PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

A L Caplan

Publications and source records attributed to A L Caplan.

At least 73 records · Page 4Linked to original sources

Informed consent and provider-patient relationships in rehabilitation medicine.

The legitimacy of paternalism in health care relationships has been severely criticized by those in the field of medical ethics. Critics have argued that paternalism has no place in physician/patient encounters. Patients must always be treated as autonomous agents, capable of directing the course of their medical care. Informed consent has come to represent the mechanism through which autonomy can best be assured in medical relationships. If provider/patient interactions are viewed as a contract between consenting agents, then providers are obligated to obtain informed consent for all interventions they wish to undertake. This view, however, relies upon examples of care provided to those with acute medical problems. In rehabilitation, it can be argued that for some patients at some times during their care, a contractual model would be inappropriate. Especially when patients have undergone a sudden and unexpected course of severe impairment, it is difficult to conceptualize provider/patient relationships in the context of a contract. Providers are more accurately seen as acting in educational roles toward those in their care. If this is so, then there may be instances in which paternalistic behavior toward rehabilitation patients is ethically justified. Informed consent must be carefully examined if it is to be a useful doctrine in the context of rehabilitative care.

Contracts↗

Social and health policy issues in total joint replacement surgery.

Total joint replacement has restored function and provided comfort to many patients who would otherwise have suffered. However, success and widespread diffusion of this procedure pose a number of important questions. The patient's and the doctor's criteria of success may not be the same: Which are to be used? Health resources are becoming limited: Should money be spent to restore function and for pain relief to those late in life or past their work life? Who makes this choice? A medical technology is tested in the best of settings but routinely practiced in many: How should society and health care professionals monitor the results of surgery? Who should do surgery and where should it be done?

Health Resources↗

Organ transplant rationing: a window to the future?

Those who advocate rationing access to health care to control escalating costs must adequately examine the field of organ transplantation, where rationing has been a harsh fact of life for many years. In our society, two paradigmatic cases illustrate rationing: a lifeboat with too many passengers aboard for the supply of food and water to keep alive, and battlefield triage with more wounded soldiers than medical personnel available to treat them. Examination of these cases reveals four criteria that must be fulfilled for rationing to be the only possible response to a resource shortage: Nothing can be done to stretch or divide the available resource to meet the needs of all seeking access to it. Those who seek access to the scarce resource need it to survive. Nothing can be done to increase the supply of the resource that is available. The resource is recognized as a benefit by both those who seek it and those who can provide it. For the most part, transplant decisions are surrounded by secrecy, and public input is minimal. Although many centers use psychosocial as well as medical criteria in deciding whom to admit to transplant programs, no consistent criteria have been developed among transplant centers. This secrecy and inconsistency could damage public support of organ transplant programs. If rationing is instituted in other areas of health care, public input must be sought in establishing equitable standards. The scarcity of organs for transplant cannot be changed, but this is not true in other areas of health care, where we can choose to build more facilities, eliminate waste, and dispense with unnecessary services.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Decision Making↗

Informed consent.

Explore the source record for details and available documents.

Control Groups↗

Exemplary reasoning? A comment on theory structure in biomedicine.

The contributions that the philosophy of medicine can make to both the philosophy of science and the practice of science have been obscured in recent years by an overemphasis on personalities rather than critical themes. Two themes have dominated general discussion within contemporary philosophy of science: methodological essentialism and dynamic gradualism. These themes are defined and considered in light of Kenneth Schaffner's argument that theories in biomedicine have a structure and logic unlike that found in theories of the natural sciences. Schaffner's arguments are suggestive but not definitive as a refutation of methodological essentialism. I argue that a primary reason for differences in the logic and structure of theories in biomedicine is not, as some philosophers have suggested, a product of ontological differences, but rather a product of the practical and pragmatic concerns of scientific theorizing in many areas of science, such as medicine.

Concept Formation↗

The ethics of in vitro fertilization.

Advances in medicine's ability to assist reproduction in those afflicted with infertility raise numerous ethical questions both for potential recipients of the techniques and for society as a whole. Society must decide what level of resources should be committed to the treatment of infertility in light of the fact that many children are not readily placed in adoptive or foster homes and the increasing competition that exists for scarce health care resources. The ethical uncertainty about the moral status of embryos and the moral acceptability of nonstandard techniques of in vitro fertilization raise further troubling questions about the adequacy of consent, committee review, and other protections for the welfare of families. Although it may not yet be appropriate to call for legislation or regulation in this area, there is a very real need to increase professional and public discussion of the ethical and policy questions raised by assisted reproduction.

Adoption↗