Erratum: Retraction of the landmark glyphosate safety publication by Williams, Kroes and Munro (2000) should be reversed.
[This corrects the article on p. 1107 in vol. 25, PMID: 42517087.].
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to Brad Bolon.
[This corrects the article on p. 1107 in vol. 25, PMID: 42517087.].
The decision by the co-Editor-in-Chief of Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology, Prof. Martin van den Berg, to retract the 2000 review article by Williams, Kroes, and Munro has elicited widespread criticism within the scientific community. Issued in late 2025, the retraction decision cites procedural concerns including potential ghostwriting, undisclosed conflicts of interest, and omission of certain unpublished studies, invoking Committee on Publication Ethics guidelines despite lacking evidence of fraud or scientific flaws. This editorial argues that the retraction decision involves editorial overreach and misapplication of the guidelines. The alleged omissions stemmed from proprietary data access limitations that were disclosed in the original paper. Subsequent reviews by several independent expert panels and regulatory authorities with access to all glyphosate data, including the studies cited by the retracting editor, reached similar conclusions. Claims of ghostwriting were previously investigated and found lacking, including a declaration by EFSA as to the clarity of the conflict disclosures. The retraction's timing, reliance on litigation documents, and apparent biases that were not disclosed in the retraction notice raise questions of ideological interference. Absent substantive rebuttals based on scientific merit rather than speculative claims of inappropriate authorship and data access, this retraction decision sets a dangerous precedent for retroactive censorship, potentially chilling beneficial industry-academic collaborations and eroding trust in the integrity of scientific publishing. With the strongest conviction, we assert that retracting a paper without scientific flaws isn't protection-it is censorship. We therefore call for the immediate reversal of this flawed and unjustified retraction to preserve trust in peer-reviewed literature.
Conventional methods of gene transfer lead to inconsistent transgene expression within cells. This variability can be problematic, particularly in conditions like Rett syndrome (RTT), a neurological disorder caused by mutations in the MECP2 (methyl-CpG binding protein 2) gene, because overexpression of MECP2 can also cause adverse effects. To address these challenges, we devised a gene regulation system called Expression Attenuation via Construct Tuning (EXACT), which uses a self-contained, microRNA-based feed-forward loop that not only ensures more consistent transgene expression but also protects against excessive expression. Through cell-based screening assays, we demonstrated the ability of the EXACT circuit to modulate the expression of full-length human MeCP2. Compared with a conventional construct, an EXACT-MECP2 construct exhibited a narrower range of cellular protein abundance. Furthermore, the degree of regulation by the EXACT circuit increased with higher transgene doses in vitro and in wild-type mice and mice modeling RTT. On the basis of cellular and in vivo testing, we identified an optimal configuration for the adeno-associated virus serotype 9 (AAV9) construct for self-regulated MECP2 gene therapy, designated NGN-401. Delivery of NGN-401 to neonatal male Mecp2-/y hemizygous mice via intracerebroventricular injection resulted in prolonged survival and amelioration of RTT-like phenotypes compared with vehicle-treated animals. NGN-401 was also well tolerated by female Mecp2+/- mice and healthy juvenile nonhuman primates, in contrast with a conventional construct, which caused toxicity. The results from these studies underpin a first-in-human pediatric trial of NGN-401 in RTT (ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT05898620).
Mutations affecting the activity of the Wnt co-receptors LRP5 and LRP6 that cause alterations in skeletal biology confirmed the involvement of Wnt signaling in bone formation. We evaluated the potential role of Dkk1, an inhibitor of LRP5/6 activity, in bone formation by examining the normal expression pattern of Dkk1 in normal young mice and by assessing the consequences of osteoblast overexpression of Dkk1 in transgenic mice. Endogenous Dkk1 expression was detected primarily in osteoblasts and osteocytes. Transgenic over-expression of Dkk1 using two different rat collagen 1A1 promoters resulted in distinct bone phenotypes. More widespread Dkk1 expression (driven by the Col1A1 3.6 kb promoter) yielded osteopenia with forelimb deformities and hairlessness, while expression restricted to osteoblasts (driven by the Col1A1 2.3 kb promoter) induced severe osteopenia without limb defects or alopecia. The decrease in bone mass in vivo resulted from a significant 49% reduction in osteoblast numbers and was reflected in a 45% reduction in serum osteocalcin concentration; an in vitro study revealed that Dkk1 caused a dose-dependent suppression of osteoblast matrix mineralization. These data indicate that Dkk1 may directly influence bone formation and suggest that osteopenia develops in mice over-expressing Dkk1 at least in part due to diminished bone formation resulting from reduced osteoblast numbers.
A key trait of developmental neurotoxicants is their ability to cause structural lesions in the immature nervous system. Thus, neuropathologic assessment is an essential element of developmental neurotoxicity (DNT) studies that are designed to evaluate chemically-induced risk to neural substrates in young humans. The guidelines for conventional DNT assays have been established by regulatory agencies to provide a flexible scaffold for conducting such studies; recent experience has launched new efforts to update these recommendations. The present document was produced by an ad hoc subcommittee of the Society of Toxicologic Pathology (STP) tasked with examining conventional methods used in DNT neuropathology in order to define the 'best practices' for dealing with the diverse requirements of both national (EPA) and international (OECD) regulatory bodies. Recommendations (including citations for relevant neurobiological and technical references) address all aspects of the DNT neuropathology examination: study design; tissue fixation, collection, processing, and staining; qualitative and quantitative evaluation; statistical analysis; proper control materials; study documentation; and personnel training. If followed, these proposals will allow pathologists to meet the need for a sound risk assessment (balanced to address both regulatory issues and scientific considerations) in this field today while providing direction for the research needed to further refine DNT neuropathology 'best practices' in the future.
Genetically engineered mice (GEM) and rats (GER) have emerged as the main mammalian models for investigating normal (physiological, or "health") and abnormal (patho-logical, or "disease") mechanisms. Regardless of the genetic manipulation, novel GEM and GER must undergo meticulous genotypic and phenotypic analyses before it is possible to predict the significance of the engineered gene with re-spect to health and disease, especially when the desire is to extrapolate the findings to humans. Numerous websites have been generated to give researchers additional tools to facilitate genotyping and phenotyping. This list of many extant sites with descriptions of their basic features provides a starting point for new and established scientists faced with the need to characterize a new GEM or GER model.
UNLABELLED: RANKL is an essential mediator of bone erosions, but the role of RANKL in systemic bone loss had not been studied in arthritis. RANKL protein was increased in rat joint extracts and serum at the earliest stages of arthritis. Osteoprotegerin (OPG) treatment reversed local and systemic bone loss, suggesting that RANKL is both a marker and mediator of bone loss in arthritis. INTRODUCTION: RANKL is well established as an essential mediator of bone erosions in inflammatory arthritis, but the role of RANKL in systemic bone loss in arthritis had not been studied. We hypothesized that serum RANKL could serve as both a mediator and as a novel biomarker for local and systemic bone loss in arthritis. We challenged this hypothesis in two established rat models of inflammatory arthritis. We sought to determine whether serum RANKL was elevated early in disease progression and whether RANKL suppression could prevent both local and systemic bone loss in these models. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Detailed time-course studies were conducted in animals with collagen-induced (CIA) or adjuvant-induced (AIA) arthritis to evaluate the onset and progression of inflammation (paw swelling), bone erosions, osteoclast numbers, and RANKL protein levels in arthritic joints and in serum. Additional CIA and AIA rats (n=8/group) received placebo (PBS) or recombinant OPG (3 mg/kg three times weekly) for 10 days beginning 4 days after disease onset (first macroscopic evidence of hind paw erythema and edema) to assess the role of RANKL in local and systemic bone loss. RESULTS: RANKL protein was significantly elevated in the joints and serum of CIA and AIA rats within 1-2 days of disease onset. Increased RANKL levels were associated with local (hind paw) and systemic (vertebral) osteopenia in both models. The RANKL inhibitor OPG prevented local and systemic osteopenia in both models of established disease. CONCLUSIONS: RANKL protein is significantly increased both locally and systemically during the earliest stages of inflammatory arthritis in rats, suggesting that serum RANKL might have prognostic value for bone erosions and systemic osteopenia in this condition. RANKL inhibition through OPG prevented local and systemic bone loss in these arthritis models, suggesting that RANKL inhibition is a promising new approach for treating bone loss in arthritis.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate whether the bone-preserving effects of a RANKL antagonist or a tumor necrosis factor (TNF) antagonist could be further improved by the addition of a bone anabolic agent in inflammatory arthritis. METHODS: Lewis rats with either adjuvant-induced arthritis (AIA) or collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) were treated for 10 days with PEGylated soluble tumor necrosis factor receptor type I (PEG sTNFRI), interleukin-1 receptor antagonist (IL-1Ra), osteoprotegerin (OPG), parathyroid hormone (PTH), or combinations of these agents starting on day 4 after disease onset. Treatment effects were assessed clinically, radiologically, and histologically, and by morphometry for the extent of paw swelling, bone erosive changes, and synovial inflammation. RESULTS: Paw swelling and synovial inflammation were significantly inhibited by PEG sTNFRI in AIA and CIA, and by IL-1Ra in CIA. OPG and PTH had no significant effect on these parameters. Analysis of bone erosion revealed a significant bone-sparing effect of monotherapy with PEG sTNFRI or OPG in both models, whereas IL-1Ra was only effective in CIA. PTH treatment alone did not show a bone-protective effect in either model. With the combination of PEG sTNFRI and PTH, erosion scores (-74% in AIA and -61% in CIA versus controls) were significantly lower than those elicited by PEG sTNFRI alone (-41% and -29%, respectively, versus controls). Similar results were also obtained with the combination of OPG and PTH (-88% in AIA and -73% in CIA, compared with -70% and -55%, respectively, with OPG monotherapy). Coadministration of IL-1Ra and PTH had no synergistic bone-sparing effect. Morphometric analysis revealed that the addition of PTH to PEG sTNFRI or OPG resulted in higher bone volume and higher osteoblast numbers in both AIA and CIA. CONCLUSION: The bone-protective effects resulting from RANKL or TNF antagonism can be further improved by the addition of a bone anabolic agent.
OBJECTIVE: To analyze the kinetics of osteoclastogenesis in 2 models of chronic immune-mediated arthritis and 1 model of acute arthritis. METHODS: Adjuvant-induced arthritis (AIA) and collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) in Lewis rats were used as models of chronic arthritis. Acute arthritis was induced in Lewis rats by injecting carrageenan into the hind paw. Osteoclasts were identified by cathepsin K immunohistochemistry at various time points after the onset of arthritis. The location, size, and nucleation of osteoclasts were also analyzed. RESULTS: In both AIA and CIA, multinucleated and cathepsin K-positive osteoclasts first were observed on the day of disease onset. Initially, osteoclasts were localized at the periosteum next to the synovial membrane and in subchondral bone channels. The number, size, and nucleation of osteoclasts rapidly increased, leading to severe bone loss within days after disease onset. In addition, numerous mononucleated cathepsin K-positive osteoclast precursor cells emerged in the synovial membrane. All osteoclasts (cathepsin K-positive, multinucleated, attached to bone) and osteoclast precursors (cathepsin K-positive, mononucleated or multinucleated, within synovial tissue) were also positive for a macrophage-specific marker. Upon induction of acute arthritis with carrageenan, osteoclasts formed transiently in subchondral bone, but regressed 7 days after disease onset. CONCLUSION: Functional osteoclasts are generated at the earliest stage of arthritis, and new precursors are continuously formed in the synovial membrane to replenish the osteoclast pool. These data indicate that anti-resorptive therapies may provide the most effective bone protection, when treatment is started soon after the onset of arthritis.
Chronic exposure to the chloracetanilide herbicide alachlor has been shown to cause olfactory mucosal neoplasms. Genomic analysis of olfactory mucosa from rats given alachlor (126 mg/kg/d) for from 1 day to 18 mo suggested that matrix metalloproteinases MMP-2 and MMP-9 were upregulated in the month following initiation of treatment. The present studies were designed to confirm this latter finding and to explore the potential role of MMPs in alachlor-induced olfactory carcinogenesis. Zymographic analysis of olfactory mucosal extracts confirmed that MMP-2 activity is higher in the olfactory mucosa of alachlor-treated rats. Therefore, rats were fed alachlor (126 mg/kg/d in the diet for 1 year) either with or without the MMP-2/MMP-9 inhibitor Ro 28-2653 (100 mg/kg daily by gavage for the first 2 months of alachlor treatment). The number of olfactory mucosal neoplasms was reduced by 25% after 1 year of alachlor treatment in rats that received both alachlor and Ro 28-2653. The morphology of alachlor-induced olfactory tumors was similar whether or not Ro 28-2653 had been given; the MMP inhibitor itself had no impact on olfactory mucosal histology. These data confirm that olfactory mucosal MMP-2 activity is increased following short-term alachlor exposure and show that administration of an MMP-2/9 inhibitor reduced the incidence of olfactory neoplasms in alachlor-treated rats, thereby implicating MMP-2 activity as a mediator of alachlor-induced carcinogenicity.
Osteoporosis is a chronic condition that is typically treated by the long-term repeated administration of antiresorptive agents. Gene therapy has the potential to deliver protein-based antiresorptive agents without the need for repeated administration. Osteoprotegerin (OPG) is a naturally occuring protein that prevents bone resorption by inhibiting osteoclast formation, function and survival. We tested whether adeno-associated virus (AAV) could deliver OPG at levels that are sufficient to reverse established osteopenia in ovariectomized (OVX) mice without causing liver toxicity. Tibial bone mineral density (BMD) was measured by peripheral quantitative computed tomography (pQCT) in 12-week-old CDF1 mice prior to OVX or sham surgery. Six weeks later, BMD was significantly reduced in OVX mice compared to sham controls or pre-surgery values. Sham and OVX mice were then injected once IV with an AAV vector carrying cDNA for recombinant hOPG (AAV-OPG) or beta-galactosidase (AAV-betaGal). BMD and bone histomorphometry were assessed 10 weeks after treatment. A single injection of AAV-OPG led to the appearance of human OPG (hOPG) in the serum of mice within 7 days, and high serum levels of hOPG were maintained for the duration of the 10-week study. At the end of the study, OVX mice given AAV-OPG had significantly greater tibial BMD compared to age-matched OVX animals given AAV-betaGal. In sham-operated mice, AAV-OPG also significantly increased tibial BMD compared to AAV-betaGal. The increased BMD in AAV-OPG animals was accompanied by significantly increased bone volume and significantly reduced osteoclast surfaces in the proximal tibial metaphysis. Liver histology was normal, and circulating activities of hepatocyte cytosolic enzymes were unaffected by AAV exposure. In an accompanying experiment, young (3-4 weeks) C57BL/6 mice treated once IV with AAV-OPG maintained pharmacologically active levels of OPG in serum for at least 16 months. In summary, a single AAV-OPG treatment reversed established osteopenia in OVX mice without evidence of liver toxicity. AAV delivery appears to be a safe and effective method for producing sustained systemic exposure to OPG.
Genetically engineered mice that either over-express a foreign gene (transgenic) or in which the activity of a specific gene has been removed ("knock-out") or replaced ("knock-in") will be used increasingly to investigate molecular mechanisms of disease, to evaluate innovative therapeutic targets, and to screen novel agents for efficacy and/or toxicity. Recent innovations of relevance to toxicologic researchers include the construction of genetically engineered mice with (1) multiple engineered genes, (2) mutations that can be induced at specific sites and times throughout life, and (3) the substitution of human genes for their mouse counterparts ("humanized" mice) to allow in vivo investigation of xenobiotic toxicity. Contemporary applications of genetically engineered mice in toxicology include basic mechanistic research exploiting newly engineered mouse lines as well as applied screening for genotoxicity and carcinogenicity using commercially available animals. Many caveats must be considered when interpreting genetically engineered mice-derived toxicity data, the chief of which will be the extent to which the model's phenotype has been fully characterized, the type and incidence of background lesions for the given mouse strain and engineered gene, and the possibility of misinterpreting the presence or absence of a phenotype due to compensatory physiologic processes that mask the outcome produced by the engineering event. Toxicity data acquired using genetically engineered mice currently supplements and in time likely will supplant those gathered using the present "gold standard" bioassays, as genetically engineered mice typically develop more lesions after a shorter latency period than do age- and strain-matched, wild-type mice.
During our initial attempts to produce transgenic rats, we found that an anaesthetic combination typically used for embryo transfer (intramuscular injection of ketamine [90 mg/kg] with xylazine [10 mg/kg]) yielded extensive variation in both the depth and length of anaesthesia. In the present prospective study, we compared the reproductive outcomes afforded by using either isoflurane (5% for induction, 2% for maintenance, carried in 2 l/min of oxygen) with morphine (5 mg/kg s.c., given immediately after isoflurane induction) or ketamine/xylazine in adult (250-300 g), pseudopregnant Sprague-Dawley rats. Each animal was anaesthetized with either isoflurane/morphine or ketamine/xylazine, after which 30 microinjected eggs were transferred into the left uterine horn. The mean pregnancy rate for isoflurane/morphine (15%) was 50% greater than that achieved with ketamine/xylazine (10%). The mean number of live pups (just over five per litter) was comparable for both regimens. All rats given isoflurane/morphine quickly achieved a surgical depth of anaesthesia and experienced a rapid postoperative recovery (3-5 min). In contrast, 25% of rats injected with ketamine/xylazine did not reach a depth of anaesthesia within 10 min that was sufficient for laparotomy, and all that were anaesthetized successfully required an extended postoperative recovery period (60-90 min). These data show that isoflurane/morphine is well tolerated by microinjected embryos and suggest that its use during embryo transfer may provide a means for both reducing the number of pseudopregnant females used and increasing the speed with which rat transgenic projects are completed.
In this study, we compared two endotracheal tubes (cuffed [Murphy Eye type] and uncuffed [Cole type]) and a pediatric laryngeal mask airway (LMA) with respect to their ease of use in rabbits and their capacities to limit waste isoflurane emissions. Animals (New Zealand White, 3.3 to 5.0 kg, n = 8) were sedated with intramuscular ketamine (50 mg/kg) and xylazine (10 mg/kg). After 5 min, the larynx was numbed with cetocaine, an intubation device was positioned, and anesthesia was maintained with isoflurane (2%) in oxygen (1 liter/min). Real-time atmospheric isoflurane emissions were assessed at the rabbit's oral commissure and in the operator's breathing zone (45 cm from the rabbit's nose) by using a portable infrared spectrophotometer. The LMA was placed more easily than was either endotracheal tube, especially by novices. The cuffed tube was positioned more readily than was the uncuffed variant. All three devices emitted isoflurane. The concentrations measured at the oral commissure for the LMA (mean +/- standard error, 8.4 +/- 0.6 ppm) were modestly higher than those acquired for the cuffed (6.7 +/- 0.5 ppm) and uncuffed (6.3 +/- 0.4 ppm) endotracheal tubes; the difference between the LMA and uncuffed tube was significant (P = 0.012). Isoflurane was not detected in the operator's breathing zone. These data show that the uncuffed endotracheal tube (usually used to anesthetize birds and reptiles) and the pediatric LMA can be used in rabbits as readily as a cuffed tube. In addition, our findings indicate that tradeoffs will be required in selecting a delivery system for this species, as the easiest apparatus (the LMA) also emits the most isoflurane waste.
We have identified a novel chordin-like protein, CHL2, which is structurally most homologous to CHL/neuralin/ventroptin. When injected into Xenopus embryos, CHL2 RNA induced a secondary axis. Recombinant CHL2 protein interacted directly with BMPs in a competitive manner to prevent binding to the type I BMP receptor ectodomain, and inhibited BMP-dependent induction of alkaline phosphatase in C2C12 cells. Thus, CHL2 behaves as a secreted BMP-binding inhibitor. In situ hybridization revealed that CHL2 expression is restricted to chondrocytes of various developing joint cartilage surfaces and connective tissues in reproductive organs. Adult mesenchymal progenitor cells expressed CHL2, and its levels decreased during chondrogenic differentiation. Addition of CHL2 protein to a chondrogenic culture system reduced cartilage matrix deposition. Consistently, CHL2 transcripts were weakly detected in normal adult joint cartilage. However, CHL2 expression was upregulated in middle zone chondrocytes in osteoarthritic joint cartilage (where hypertrophic markers are induced). CHL2 depressed chondrocyte mineralization when added during the hypertrophic differentiation of cultured hyaline cartilage particles. Thus, CHL2 may play negative roles in the (re)generation and maturation of articular chondrocytes in the hyaline cartilage of both developing and degenerated joints.
Metanephric kidney development requires an inductive interaction between the ureteric bud and progenitor mesenchyme, where the early expression of two genes, Wilms' tumour 1 (WT1) and paired box 2 (Pax2), establishes critical but unknown developmental pathways. Indeed, transgenic mice with deregulated overexpression of Pax2 exhibit structural kidney defects and impaired renal function, as do mice harboring targeted disruptions and/or spontaneous mutations of either the Pax2 or WT1 genes. WT1 and Pax2 are thought to regulate each other's expression during renal development. To better define the relationship between WT1 and Pax2, we generated mouse embryos containing heterozygous mutations in both genes. WT1(+/-)/Pax2(1Neu/+) kidneys were 50% smaller than wild-type kidneys. They were characterized by severe attenuation of the renal medulla, and reduced development of calyces and the renal pelvis. Renal cortex development in compound heterozygotes culminated in fewer nephrons than in WT1(+/-), Pax2(1Neu/+) or wild-type mice. Only minor variations in the mesenchymal expression pattern of Pax2 protein, and the mRNA expression levels of Pax2 and WT1, were noted in mutant kidneys. We show that WT1 and Pax2 proteins interact in vitro and in vivo, demonstrating that WT1 and Pax2 can form a molecular complex. Our data suggest that WT1 is a modifier of the Pax2 mutant phenotype.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the role of tumor necrosis factor (TNF) in systemic bone loss of chronic inflammatory conditions, such as rheumatoid arthritis (RA), and to address the therapeutic potential of osteoclast blockade. METHODS: We investigated systemic bone changes in human TNF transgenic (hTNFtg) mice, which spontaneously developed severe inflammatory arthritis. RESULTS: Osteodensitometry revealed a significant decrease in trabecular bone mineral density (BMD) (-37%) in hTNFtg mice, and histomorphometry revealed a dramatic loss of bone volume (-85%) compared with wild-type controls. Osteoclast-covered bone surface and serum levels of deoxypyridinoline crosslinks were significantly elevated, suggesting increased osteoclast-mediated bone resorption in hTNFtg mice. Osteoprotegerin (OPG) completely blocked TNF-mediated bone loss by increasing BMD (+89%) and bone volume (+647%). Most strikingly, formation of primary spongiosa was dramatically increased (+563%) in hTNFtg mice after OPG treatment. Osteoclast-covered bone surface and serum levels of deoxypyridinoline crosslinks were significantly decreased by OPG, suggesting effective blockade of osteoclast-mediated bone resorption. OPG did not influence levels of hTNF, TNF receptor I (TNFRI), interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta), and IL-6. However, OPG decreased bone formation parameters (osteoblast-covered bone surface and serum osteocalcin levels), which were elevated in hTNFtg mice. In contrast to OPG, bisphosphonates and anti-TNF treatment did not affect generalized bone loss in hTNFtg mice. Anti-TNF, however, did not affect levels of TNF and TNFRI at the concentrations tested. These data indicate that generalized bone loss due to increased TNF can be blocked by OPG. CONCLUSION: OPG may represent a potent tool for preventing generalized loss of bone mass in chronic inflammatory disorders, especially RA.
The formation of Alzheimer's Abeta peptide is initiated when the amyloid precursor protein (APP) is cleaved by the enzyme beta-secretase (BACE1); inhibition of this cleavage has been proposed as a means of treating Alzheimer's disease. (AD) We have previously shown that young BACE1 knockout mice (BACE1 KO) do not generate Abeta but in other respects appear normal. Here we have extended this analysis to include both gene expression profiling and phenotypic assessment of older BACE1 KO animals to evaluate the impact of chronic Abeta deficiency. We did not detect global compensatory changes in neural gene expression in young BACE1 KO mice. In particular, expression of the beta-secretase homolog BACE2 was not upregulated. Furthermore, we found no structural alterations in any organ, including all central and peripheral neural tissues, of BACE1 KO mice up to 14 months of age. Aged BACE1 KO mice engineered to overexpress human APP (BACE1 KO/APPtg) did not develop amyloid plaques. These data provide evidence that neither beta-secretase nor Abeta plays a vital role in mouse physiology and that chronic beta-secretase inhibition could be a useful approach in treating AD.