PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

D B Montgomery

Publications and source records attributed to D B Montgomery.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Lack of efficacy of fluoxetine in recurrent brief depression and suicidal attempts.

Recurrent brief depression (RBD) fulfills DSM-III-R symptom criteria for major depression but the episodes are of shorter duration than the 2 weeks required by DSM-III-R. The clinical importance of the disorder has been observed in prophylactic studies of suicidal behavior. The possibility that antidepressants with selective action on the reuptake of serotonin might be effective in preventing recurrences of brief depression has been investigated. Fluoxetine in a dose of 120 mg a week, administered biweekly, had no effect on the recurrence rate, which was maintained at approximately the same rate on fluoxetine (1 every 18.7 days) as with placebo (1 every 17.6 days). In a group of patients with two or more prior episodes of suicidal behavior, there were 18 attempted suicides in the 54 patients treated with fluoxetine and the same number in the 53 patients treated with placebo. Fluoxetine neither raised nor lowered the suicide attempt rate as compared with placebo, providing no evidence to support the drug's role in either suicide provocation or prevention. Since fluoxetine is clearly effective with recurrent major depression, it would appear that recurrent brief depression has a different pharmacology.

Bipolar Disorder↗

Pharmacotherapy in the prevention of suicidal behavior.

Prevention or reduction of suicide remains a serious challenge for the medical community. Psychotherapeutic and psychosocial interventions have not been shown to reduce the incidence of suicide attempts and analytic psychotherapy has been shown to increase suicidal behavior. The efficacy of pharmacotherapy in reducing suicide attempts in patients with a history of repeated suicidal behavior has been shown with low doses of the neuroleptic agent flupenthixol compared with placebo. Supporting findings have been reported with trifluoperazine. There is evidence to suggest that some antidepressants may not be neutral in their effect on suicidal behavior. Maprotiline, for example, was associated with an increase in suicide attempts compared with placebo in a large long-term treatment study despite its significant efficacy in preventing relapse of depression. Differential lethality indices taken from large community studies support the notion that noradrenergic drugs such as maprotiline, desipramine, and nortriptyline are associated with a higher than expected incidence of death from overdose, and the suicide-provoking potential may relate to some noradrenergic property. The studies of serotonergic antidepressants do not suggest that they are suicide-provoking agents; rather they appear to be neutral or protective. Prospective prophylactic studies are needed to test the ability of potential treatments for the reduction of suicidal behavior.

Antidepressive Agents↗

Brief unipolar depressions: is there a bipolar component?

Recurrent brief depression is now recognised separately in the international classification of diseases (ICD 10). The disorder is characterised by short severe bouts of depression which recur frequently but erratically. In our series of patients the median duration of the depression is 3 days, with two thirds lasting between 2 and 4 days. The severity is often marked with a mean MADRS score of 30, and the episodes recurred 20 times a year. The disorder is easily separated from major depression which lasts 2 weeks or more, although, there is an unfortunate overlap group with major depression superimposed on the recurrent brief pattern. Those with "combined depression" have a higher suicide attempt rate. There should be little overlap with dysthymia since on average only 20% of the time is spent depressed, whereas dysthymia requires a minimum of 50%. However, in practice the qualification of the time spent depressed is imprecise in dysthymia so there is potential for misdiagnosis. There is little overlap with bipolar illness. In our series with follow up of up to 15 years, the conversion rate to bipolar illness is low at 3%. Almost all of these were found to have combined depression, which suggests that the rate for pure recurrent brief depression is very low. These data suggest that pure recurrent brief depression is a unipolar depressive illness.

Bipolar Disorder↗

Early response with clomipramine in obsessive compulsive disorder--a placebo controlled study.

1. Clomipramine has been found to be effective in the treatment of obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) in nine placebo controlled studies whereas other conventional antidepressants lacking 5-HT reuptake inhibiting properties do not appear to be effective. 2. The placebo response rate in OCD is very low as is seen in the placebo controlled study of the efficacy of clomipramine 75mg in 14 patients suffering from OCD reported here. 3. Response appears early in treatment when compared with response of depression to antidepressants.

Adult↗

Profiles of antidepressant activity with the Montgomery-Asberg Depression Rating Scale.

The Montgomery and Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS) is a 10 item severity scale constructed to be sensitive to change with treatment. It was designed to be sensitive for individual items and is therefore useful for measuring differential profiles of action. The MADRS profiles of activity were examined in a six-week double-blind comparative group study of depressed patients treated with mianserin or zimeldine. Three of the ten items on the MADRS showed individual significant advantages for mianserin, reduced sleep (weeks 1 and 3), concentration difficulties (week 1), and reduced appetite (week 3). These findings are in agreement with earlier reports of poor sleep and gastrointestinal upset associated with the 5-HT uptake inhibitor zimeldine. The selective improvement in concentration difficulties and in the other items support the view that mianserin is particularly useful in alleviating the anxiety associated with depression. The sedative effect of mianserin did not appear to interfere with concentration. There were significant improvements in the mianserin-treated group at 1, 2, 3, and 4 weeks for the MADRS, Hamilton Depression Rating Scale and Clinicians Global Impression scale. There was no significant advantage for mianserin at 5 and 6 weeks. The differential clinical effects were apparent early in the study but any selectivity of action appeared to be overwhelmed by the general antidepressant effect later in treatment.

Adult↗

The prevention of recurrent suicidal acts.

1 There have been few controlled prospective investigations into the prevention of suicidal behaviour and by and large they have failed to demonstrate the efficacy of social work, psychotherapy or psychiatric treatment. 2 A group of 58 high-risk patients with multiple episodes of suicidal behaviour was treated with mianserin 30 mg at night or placebo in a six month double-blind trial of the efficacy of an antidepressant in reducing suicidal behaviour. 3 Patients were screened for depression, schizophrenia and organic disease. Patients were diagnosed as suffering from personality disorders according to DSM-III criteria mainly borderline or histrionic. 4 There was no significant difference in outcome between the mianserin and placebo treated group at any point in the six month study. 5 An item analysis of the MADRS showed that at entry the item 'reduced appetite' predicted subsequent suicidal attempt. The total MADRS score did not predict further suicidal acts at entry but was highly significant at four weeks. At four weeks the items 'reduced sleep' and 'reduced appetite' were highly significant predictors of further suicidal acts and the items 'lassitude', 'suicidal thoughts', 'inability to feel' and 'pessimistic thoughts' were significant predictors.

Adult↗

Plasma levels and clinical response with imipramine in a study comparing efficacy with mianserin and nomifensine.

1 The comparative antidepressant efficacy of 150 mg imipramine, 60 mg mianserin and 150 mg nomifensine was studied in 45 depressed patients in a six week double-blind investigation. 2 In the efficacy analysis of 41 patients completing the study there was no overall significant difference in efficacy between the groups. Individual group comparisons showed no significant difference in response between mianserin and nomifensine, and mianserin and imipramine. There was a significant (z = 1.99, P less than 0.05) improved response in the imipramine compared with the nomifensine treated group. The imipramine treated group were significantly older. 3 No significant plasma concentration/clinical response relationships were demonstrated with nomifensine, mianserin, imipramine or desipramine. 4 Plasma level monitoring of imipramine recommended by some investigators does not seem to be appropriate.

Adult↗

The antidepressant efficacy of zimelidine and maprotiline.

In a double-blind group comparison study of 39 patients with primary depressive illness zimelidine in a dose of 200 mg at night demonstrated the same order of antidepressant efficacy as maprotiline in a dose of 150 mg at night after either two or four weeks treatment measured by the amelioration or final score on the Hamilton Rating Scale (HRS) and on the Montgomery & Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS). Both zimelidine and maprotiline demonstrated significant antidepressant activity at 2 weeks compared with 2 weeks prior treatment with placebo measured by amelioration on HRS (paired t 4.1 P less than 0.001, t 2.7 P less than 0.02) or MADRS (paired t 3.5 P less than 0.005, t 5.1 P less than 0.001). An item analysis of the MADRS showed significantly better sleep and appetite in the maprotiline-treated group compared with the zimelidine-treated group which is in accord with the pharmacology of the two compounds.

Adult↗

A double blind comparison of zimelidine and amitriptyline in endogenous depression.

In a randomized double-blind group comparison study of 40 patients with endogenous depression zimelidine appeared to be as effective an antidepressant as amitriptyline at 4 and 6 weeks using the Hamilton Rating Scale (HRS) and the Montgomery and Asberg Depression Rating Scale (MADRS). At 2 weeks there was a significantly better response (P less than 0.05) on zimelidine compared to amitriptyline on the clinician's global scale and 4 out of 10 items on the MADRS suggesting an early onset of action. A significant better response to zimelidine was seen on the item somatic anxiety (HRS) while the effect on sleep and appetite was better in the amitriptyline group. There were significantly more side effects, raw and corrected, in the amitriptyline-treated group. High steady state plasma concentrations of norzimelidine (greater than 800 nmol/l) which were significantly correlated with age (r = 0.8) were associated with a significantly poorer response suggesting that a lower dose than 200 mg in older patients may be appropriate.

Adult↗