Medical competence and performance assessment. A new era.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to D G Langsley.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Specialty boards serve the function of defining qualifications and issuing credentials to assure the public of the specialist's preparation and skill. Over the past 72 years, 23 such boards have been approved and now issue 31 different types of general specialty certificates and 57 types of subspecialty credentials. For 50 years, the American Board of Medical Specialties has encouraged a system of recertification to demonstrate that the certified specialist has maintained skill and has incorporated the new knowledge associated with advancing medical science. Presently, 17 of the 23 boards are committed to time-limited certificates requiring recertification every seven to ten years, and others are currently planning such a process. New methods of performance assessment are being used for recertification processes. In addition to recertification, the other major change in specialty credentialing is the number of subspecialty certificates sought and authorized. The numbers have increased dramatically during the past 20 years and reflect the advances in science as well as new styles of practice. As a consequence, some specialties are moving toward accreditation without certification to improve training, even if there is no authorized type of certification. Another consequence of subspecialty proliferation is concern about fragmentation of medical care and its effect on the costs of health care.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
In 1980, psychiatric practitioners and educators were surveyed to determine their concepts of the knowledge and skills that define a specialist in psychiatry. The authors repeated this survey, expanding the list of skill and knowledge items and asking respondents to comment on whether particular skills or knowledge were important to a psychiatric subspecialty. Less importance was ascribed in the current survey than in the earlier survey to certain long-term and social psychotherapies, and more importance was ascribed to descriptive or biological psychiatry; brief or supportive therapies; psychopharmacological agents; consultation-liaison psychiatry; evaluation of children, the aged, and alcoholics; and certain desirable personal characteristics of the psychiatrist.
Psychiatry is likely to evolve into a number of subspecialty areas, paralleling developments in other medical specialties. These changes are impelled both from within psychiatry, where the rapid increase in knowledge and skills makes mastery of the entire field by any one practitioner less possible, and from without, related to new expectations for psychiatric services from referral sources and patients, increasing competition by other physicians and nonphysician mental health care providers, and shifting reimbursement patterns. The authors discuss the advantages and disadvantages of subspecialization as well as implications for psychiatric practitioners and training programs.
Most medical specialists who are board certified have little knowledge of, or contact with, the board that issued the certificate declaring their special knowledge and competence. Here, the executive vice president of the ABMS explains the certification process and the complex organization that has evolved to ensure that the process is relevant and that the diplomates are qualified to post their certificates for all to see.
Those who have had experience with the voluntary system of medical specialty certification will surely prefer it to an imposed bureaucratic type of control. Despite the deficiencies and problems associated with it, as Churchill noted about democracy: "It is the best that exists." Medical science and medical practice are constantly advancing and changing. With those changes it is reasonable to expect change in the specialty credentialing system. However, that change should be thoughtful, cautious, and should be made only in the best interest of the patients for whom we are responsible.
The original model for the community mental health center was a health-oriented treatment facility associated with a community hospital, operated under medical leadership, and staffed with other mental health professionals. For a variety of reasons, the number and role of psychiatrists in the centers have declined significantly. Of the psychiatrists who remain, many are employed only part time and are relegated to signing prescriptions and insurance forms. These developments have the potential for causing the neglect of acutely and chronically ill patients. Reversal of the trends requires a redefinition of the roles of professionals on the mental health team and a variety of other efforts by the centers themselves, psychiatric training programs, the psychiatric profession, and the federal government.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Specialty certification is not a static process but is developing and changing. The author reviews traditional and current patterns of examinations given in English-speaking countries and reports recent concerns and criticisms of the certification process. New developments in the United States include the audiovisual examination, changes in the neurology examination, and institution of examiner training. In Canada there is a heavy emphasis on improving multiple-choice questions and using examiner training. The United Kingdom is experimenting with audiovisual techniques. Australasia is increasing the length of its training programs. Recent research by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology includes concordance studies, the relationship between residency training and Board performance, and feedback techniques.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The original intent of community mental health centers was that they would treat the mentally ill. The more than 750 centers now operating are drifting away from that health service, however, toward a social service model offering counseling and crisis intervention for predictable problems of living. One result of the shift has been a marked decrease in medical involvement in the centers that has led to neglect of the mentally ill, especially chronic and deinstitutionalized patients. The author advocates a return to fulfilling the original mandate by giving centers clear responsibility for dealing with professionally diagnosed psychiatric illness, and by requiring that centers remain integrally involved with hospitals and hire staff that include an adequate number of psychiatrists. He also believes that scientific evaluations of community programs can and must be made in order to justify their expenditures and to attract support from funding agencies.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.