PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

D Stolke

Publications and source records attributed to D Stolke.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Olfactory groove meningiomas: functional outcome in a series treated microsurgically.

BACKGROUND: A systematic investigation of long-term follow-up results after microsurgical treatment of patients harbouring an olfactory groove meningioma, particularly with regard to postoperative olfactory and mental function, has rarely been performed. We reassessed a series of patients treated microsurgically for an olfactory groove meningioma in regard to clinical presentation, surgical approaches and long-term functional outcome. METHOD: Clinical, radiological and surgical data in a consecutive series of 56 patients suffering from olfactory groove meningioma were retrospectively reviewed. FINDINGS: Presenting symptoms of the 41 women and 15 men (mean age 51 years) were mental changes in 39.3%, visual impairment in 16.1% and anosmia in 14.3% of the patients. Preoperative neurological examination revealed deficits in olfaction in 71.7%, mental disturbances in 55.4% and reduced vision in 21.4% of the cases. The tumour was resected via a bifrontal craniotomy in 36, a pterional route in 13, a unilateral frontal approach in 4 and via a supraorbital approach in 3 patients. Extent of tumour resection according to Simpson's classification system was grade I in 42.9% and grade II in 57.1% of the cases. After a mean follow-up period of 5.6 years (range 1-13 years) by clinical examination and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), 86.8% of the patients resumed normal life activity. Olfaction was preserved in 24.4% of patients in whom pre- and postoperative data were available. Mental and visual disturbances improved in 88 and 83.3% of cases, respectively. Five recurrences (8.9%) were observed and had to be reoperated. CONCLUSIONS: Frontal approaches allowed better resection of tumours with gross infiltration of the anterior cranial base, tumours extending into the ethmoids or nasal cavity and in cases with deep olfactory grooves. Preservation of olfaction should be attempted in patients with normal or reduced smelling preoperatively.

Adult↗

Hypopituitarism following severe traumatic brain injury.

Although hypopituitarism is a known complication of traumatic head injury, it may be under-recognized due to its subtle clinical manifestations. To address this issue, we determine the prevalence of neuroendocrine abnormalities in patients rehabilitating from severe traumatic brain injury (Glasgow Coma Scale < or = 8). 76 patients (mean age 39 +/- 14 yr; range 18-65; 53 males and 23 females; BMI 25.8 +/- 4.2 kg/m2; mean +/- SD) with a severe traumatic brain injury, an average of 22 +/- 10 months before this study (median, 20 months), underwent a series of standard endocrine tests, including TSH, free T4, T4, T3, prolactin, testosterone (males), estradiol (females), cortisol, ACTH, GH, and IGF-I. All subjects also underwent GH response to GHRH + arginine. Growth hormone deficiency (GHD) was defined as a GH response < 9 microg/L to GHRH + arginine and was confirmed by ITT (< 3 microg/L). Pituitary deficiency was shown in 24% of the patients (18/76). 8% (n = 6) had GHD (GH-peak range [GHRH + arginine]: 2.8-6.3 microg/L; GH-peak range [ITT]: 1.5-2.2 microg/L; IGF-I range: 62-174 microg/L). 17% (n = 13) had hypogonadism (total testosterone < 9.5 nmol/L and low gonadotropins in 12 males; low estradiol, and low gonadotropins in 1 female). Total testosterone levels did not correlate with BMI or age. 2 males with hypogonadism also showed a mild hyperprolactinemia (33 and 41 ng/ml). 3% (n = 2) patients had partial ACTH-deficiency (cortisol-peak [ITT] 392 and 417 nmol/L) and 3% (n = 2) had TSH-deficiency. In summary, we have found hypopituitarism in one-fourth of patients with predominantly secondary hypogonadism and GHD. These findings strongly suggest that patients who suffer head trauma must routinely include neuroendocrine evaluations.

Adolescent↗

Endovascular treatment of middle cerebral artery aneurysms with electrolytically detachable coils.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Middle cerebral artery (MCA) aneurysms often have an unfavorable aneurysm geometry that might limit endovascular therapy. Our purpose was to analyze the feasibility, safety, and efficacy of coil embolization in a consecutive series of MCA aneurysms chosen for endovascular treatment. PATIENTS AND TECHNIQUES: Of 235 MCA aneurysms seen at our institution during the past 5 years, 36 patients harboring 38 MCA aneurysms were primarily selected for coil embolization: 18 patients had an acute subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH), 16 of which were due to a ruptured MCA aneurysm. SAH was classified according to Hunt and Hess grade: I (5), II (7), III (5), IV (0), and V (1). RESULTS: Complete occlusion could be achieved in 33 of 38 aneurysms. In 5 aneurysms, coil embolization was not performed because of an unfavorable aneurysm geometry with a wide neck or incorporation of adjacent branches (3) or failed because of insecure coil placement (1) or severe vasospasm (1). Procedural complications included coil protrusion into the parent artery (1), and thromboembolic M2 occlusion (5), with recanalization in 4 of 5 cases. Of 8 aneurysms with initial subtotal occlusion, 3 progressed to total occlusion during follow-up. Three aneurysms had to be retreated, and no patient rebled. Glasgow Outcome Scale at 6 months for the patients with SAH (17/18) was good recovery (12), moderate disability (4), severe disability (0), persistent vegetative state (0), and death (1); outcomes for patients with an incidental aneurysm (17/18) were good recovery (16) and moderate disability (1). CONCLUSION: Endovascular coil embolization can be performed safely and effectively in selected MCA aneurysms. Initial subtotal aneurysm occlusion might progress to total occlusion.

Adult↗

Malignant meningioma as a second malignancy after therapy for acute lymphatic leukemia without cranial radiation.

RATIONALE: Meningiomas in the pediatric age group are very rare tumors, comprising about 1-4.2% of all primary pediatric intracranial tumors. CASE REPORT: We present a 17-year-old patient who suffered from an intraventricular malignant meningioma. At the age of 2 years, acute lymphatic leukemia (common ALL [cALL]) was diagnosed and successfully treated with chemotherapy. There was no cranial radiation therapy. In December 2001, 13 years after diagnosis of cALL, he complained of headache, vomiting, and walking difficulties. Magnetic resonance imaging showed an enhancing mass with cystic components in the trigone of the right lateral ventricle. The tumor was removed completely. Histological diagnosis revealed a malignant papillary meningioma. After removal of a recurrent meningioma 16 months later, he received local radiotherapy. CONCLUSION: Pathogenetic mechanisms, treatment options, and prognosis of meningiomas and secondary malignancies of this age group are discussed.

Adolescent↗

[Epidural haematoma after operative evacuation of an acute subdural haematoma. Discussion of primary treatment illustrated by an unusual case].

Subdural haematomas as a consequence of severe head injury often constitute the indication for operative evacuation. Despite intensive care management postoperative computed tomography scans are essential. This is illustrated by an unusual case report of a patient suffering from an epidural haematoma after operation of an subdural haematoma. In addition, the importance of the skull X-ray in the emergency setting and intracranial pressure monitoring are discussed.

Adult↗

Surgical treatment of intramedullary spinal cord metastases of systemic cancer: functional outcome and prognosis.

OBJECTIVE: Intramedullary spinal cord metastases (ISCM) of systemic cancer are rare. To date, patients with ISCM tend to benefit only to a limited extend from surgery and adjuvant therapy. Subject of this investigation is to assess predictive factors for surgical outcome and survival and to evaluate the value of surgical radicality in the treatment of ISCM. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between 1990 and 2004, a series of 146 patients with intramedullary tumors underwent surgical treatment in our institution. Among these, 13 patients with intramedullary cancer metastases (7 adenocarcinomas, 3 poorly differentiated carcinomas, 3 sarcomas) were identified. Standard microsurgical removal of the ISCM was performed. Functional outcome was graded according to a standardized scale and factors influencing outcome and survival were statistically analyzed. RESULTS: Median progression-free survival was 13 weeks and median overall survival was 31 weeks. In 5 patients (38) the intramedullary lesion was the initial manifestation of the malignant disease. All poorly differentiated carcinomas and all sarcomas were resected incompletely. Surgical radicality presented a negative predictive factor for functional outcome, increasing radicality leading to functional deterioration. Age, sex, tumor localization, surgical radicality and the presence of neoplastic meningeosis did not affect survival. CONCLUSION: Surgery of ISCM can be performed with an acceptable operative morbidity. Radicality depended on tumor histology. However, radical tumor removal did not affect survival and was correlated with a poor functional outcome. Therefore, complete surgical removal of ISCM should only be intended in patients in whom an unproblematic excision is feasible.

Adenocarcinoma↗

Functional outcome after surgical treatment of intramedullary spinal cord tumors: experience with 78 patients.

OBJECTIVE: To analyze factors with impact on the functional outcome for patients with surgically treated intramedullary spinal cord tumors (IMSCT) and to point out characteristics of the different histological entities. SETTING: Neurosurgical Department, University of Essen, Germany. METHODS: Between 1990 and 2000, a consecutive series of 78 patients were referred to our institution and underwent surgical treatment. There were 46 (59%) male and 32 (41%) female patients. Mean age was 43.3 years. Functional outcome was analyzed depending on histological features, age, tumor localization and the extension of involved spinal segments. The mean follow-up period was 34.4 months. Operative removal of the IMSCT was performed under standard microsurgical conditions with intraoperative monitoring of somatosensory-evoked potentials (SSEP). RESULTS: The most frequently involved localization was the cervical and cervicothoracic region (55%) followed by the thoracic region (32%) and the medullar conus (13%). The most frequent IMSCTs were neuroepithelial tumors in 44 patients (56.5%) including 32 patients with ependymomas, 15 astrocytomas, and two lesions without further histological classification. Non-neuroepithelial tumors included 10 metastases, nine cavernomas, eight hemangioblastomas, one dermoidal cyst and one enterogenetic cyst. Complete tumor removal was achieved in 65 cases (83.3%) and subtotal resection in nine cases. In four cases a biopsy was performed only. The overall postoperative neurological state was improved or unchanged in 51 patients (65.4%) and worsened in 27 patients (34.6%). A favorable functional outcome was observed in 94.1% of patients with vascular tumors, in 61.3% of patients with low-grade neuroepithelial tumors and in 53.3% of patients with malignant tumors. CONCLUSIONS: The strongest predicting factor of functional outcome was the preoperative neurological condition beyond the histological differentiation of the IMSCT. Although there was no outcome difference with respect to the age and tumor extension, thoracically located IMSCTs proved to harbor an increased risk of postoperative surgical morbidity.

Adolescent↗

Endovascularly or surgically treated vertebral artery and posterior inferior cerebellar artery aneurysms: clinical analysis and results.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the clinical results in patients with aneurysms of the vertebral artery and posterior inferior cerebellar artery complex (VA-PICA) treated by endovascular embolization or surgically in cases considered untreatable by endovascular methods. PATIENTS AND METHODS: During a 5-year-period a total of 28 patients with a VA-PICA complex aneurysm out of 600 patients received definitive treatment, 19 patients by endovascular embolization and 9 patients surgically. Mean age was 54 years (range 9-75 years). Clinical data, intraoperative observations and procedural complications were evaluated. The mean follow-up was 9 months. RESULTS: Hunt-Hess (HH) grades were HH 0-II in 10 patients (35.7 %), HH III in 6 patients (21.4 %) and HH IV + V in 12 patients (42.9 %). Aneurysm size ranged from 2 to 40 mm (mean size 5.5 mm). Aneurysm configuration was saccular 18, fusiform 7 and multilobed 3. Complete occlusion was achieved in all cases. Overall 67.9 % (n = 19) showed a favorable outcome (Glasgow Outcome Score IV + V). Overall procedure-related rate for permanent morbidity and mortality was 3.6 % (n = 1) and 3.6 % (n = 1), respectively. Predictive factors of clinical outcome were the initial clinical HH grade and the Fisher grade. CONCLUSION: Endovascular embolization is an effective method for the treatment of VA-PICA aneurysms. Surgical clipping is still an alternative and should be considered for "uncoilable" lesions. Outcomes showed a close correlation to the initial clinical state and were not dependent on the treatment modality.

Adolescent↗

Treatment of wide-necked intracranial aneurysms with a self-expanding stent: mid-term results.

PURPOSE: To evaluate mid-term clinical and angiographic results after using a self-expanding neurovascular stent and coils for the management of broad-based intracranial aneurysms. METHODS: During the period from August 2001 to October 2004 we treated a total of 42 patients with 44 aneurysms using a self-expandable stent. To date we have data on more than 6 months of follow-up in 25 patients with 26 aneurysms. Aneurysm occlusion was divided into the following categories: 100 % (complete), 95-99 % (subtotal), and < 95 % (incomplete). RESULTS: In 15 aneurysms complete occlusion, in 11 aneurysms subtotal occlusion was initially achieved. Control DSA showed progressive thrombosis in seven aneurysms leading to total occlusion in another 4 aneurysms. Three recanalizations were observed in one large and two giant ICA aneurysms. No vessel occlusion occurred. One vessel stenosis of the stented segment was noted, but it was not clinically relevant. One patient experienced a small embolic infarction after stopping antiplatelet medication. No persistent deterioration of the clinical status occurred. CONCLUSION: Combining a stent with coils seems to be an acceptable treatment option for broad-based intracranial aneurysms. As this special subgroup of treated aneurysms includes only those with an unfavourable geometry, the results are extremely promising.

Aneurysm, Ruptured↗

[Stenting plus coiling: dangerous or helpful?].

PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to evaluate the procedural risk of treating acute ruptured aneurysms with a stent-coil combination. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Between August 2001 and January 2004 we treated nine acute subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) patients with a combination of stents and platinum coils. RESULTS: Six aneurysms were 100% eliminated; the residual three aneurysms had a 95% to 99% occlusion. A transient thrombosis in the stent in one patient could be recanalized by intravenous application of ReoPro. In another patient an occlusive vasospasm at the distal end of the stent was successfully treated with intraarterial Nimotop. Neurological complications occurred in none of the patients. CONCLUSION: In broad-based aneurysms which cannot be clipped or in which any neurosurgical treatment presents an unacceptably high risk (posterior circulation and paraophthalmic aneurysms), treatment using a combination of stent and platinum coils might be an option even in the acute phase of an SAH. Platelet aggregation can be treated with Aspirin and Plavix after placement of the first coil, vasospasms with intraarterial Nimotop, and acute stent thrombosis with GP IIa/IIIb-antagonists.

Acute Disease↗

Does intraoperative aneurysm rupture influence outcome? Analysis of 169 patients.

OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate the prognostic value of intraoperative aneurysm rupture (IAR) in patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) undergoing surgery for cerebral aneurysms. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Between July 1997 and April 2000, 292 consecutive patients were admitted to our institution with SAH due to ruptured intracranial aneurysms. Of these, 169 patients were treated surgically according to standard microsurgical procedures and were included in this study. Mean age was 47 years. Initial clinical state was graded according to the classification of Hunt and Hess (HH). Outcome was classified according to the Glasgow Outcome Scale as favorable (grades IV and V) and unfavorable (grades I-III). Outcome of patients with intraoperative ruptured and non-ruptured aneurysms was analyzed in correlation to the preoperative clinical state and with respect to the time of surgery and to aneurysm localization. RESULTS: Different rupture rates were observed with respect to the localization of the aneurysm: anterior circulation (n=69) 39.1%, middle cerebral artery (n=46) 34.8%, internal carotid artery (n=48) 31.2%, and posterior circulation (n=6) 16.7%. Patients with HH-grades I-III showed a favorable outcome in 72.2% (61 of 84 patients) without intraoperative rupture and in 71.7% (33 of 46 patients) with intraoperative aneurysm rupture. The corresponding values for patients with HH-grades IV/V were: favorable outcome in 34.6% (9 of 26 patients) and 23.1% (3 of 13 patients), respectively. Poor initial clinical condition (HH IV and V) as well as the initial Fisher grades III and IV were strongly associated with poor clinical outcome. CONCLUSIONS: Intraoperative aneurysm rupture has no impact on the outcome, neither in patients with good initial condition nor for poor grades patients.

Adolescent↗

Observations on intraoperative monitoring of visual pathways using steady-state visual evoked potentials.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Former studies revealed conflicting information on the usefulness of intraoperative monitoring of visual evoked potentials. This study was designed to evaluate the characteristics of visual evoked potential recording in surgically anaesthetized patients using the modality of steady-state visual evoked potentials. METHODS: In 30 cases with non-cranial surgery steady-state visual evoked potentials were recorded in the awake and surgically anaesthetized patient using total intravenous anaesthesia. For stimulation, goggles with red light-emitting diodes at a frequency of 8.5 Hz were used. A two-channel recording with silver cup electrodes at Oz to Fz and Oz to earlobe was used. All traces were analysed for the presence of the characteristically sinusoidal waveform and amplitudes and latencies of the main peaks were measured. RESULTS: Recordings during surgery demonstrated a minor latency prolongation of 16% and a more pronounced amplitude attenuation of 67% compared to the recordings in the awake patients. These differences were statistically significant (paired t-test, P < 0.001). In surgically anaesthetized patients steady-state visual evoked potentials showed a relatively high intra- and interindividual variability. In four of 30 patients completely stable recordings were obtained, whereas in 14 patients identifiable waves were recordable in only less than 50% of the intraoperative traces. Of the total 1360 traces recorded intraoperatively clearly identifiable steady-state visual evoked potentials patterns were present in 56% of the traces. There was no correlation between the magnitude of the evoked potential amplitude and its stability in intraoperative recordings. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude from this study, that steady-state visual evoked potential recordings in the surgically anaesthetized patient appeared to be more stable compared to our earlier findings using transient visual evoked potentials. However, further efforts are necessary to improve the stability of the recordings during surgery and thus allow for a more reliable intraoperative monitoring of visual pathways in routine clinical practice.

Adult↗

The supraorbital keyhole approach via an eyebrow incision for resection of tumors around the sella and the anterior skull base.

OBJECTIVE: This study evaluates the technique, indications, advantages and limitations of the minimal invasive supraorbital keyhole approach via an eyebrow skin incision for resection of tumors around the sella and the anterior skull base. METHODS AND RESULTS: In 9 patients (5 males, 4 females) different tumors (6 meningiomas, 1 craniopharyngioma, 1 Rathke's cleft cyst and 1 hypophysitis) with a maximum diameter of 30 millimeters were resected via a small eyebrow incision and a supraorbital keyhole craniotomy. Details of the operative procedure include the use of a high-speed drill, a microsaw, bayonet-shaped instruments, careful microsurgical dissection, the use of a neuroendoscope and miniplates for closure. In all patients complete tumor removal was achieved. Mean duration of surgery was 01 h 51 min and mean hospital stay was 8.9 days. There were no significant postoperative complications. Clinical examination and MR imaging after a mean follow-up of 313 days revealed no tumor recurrence and a very satisfying overall functional and cosmetic result in all patients. CONCLUSION: The eyebrow incision supraorbital keyhole approach proved to be safe, effective and time-sparing. The authors recommend this approach for resection of small tumors around the sella and the anterior skull base in selected cases as a valuable alternative to standard skull base approaches.

Adult↗

False negative findings in intraoperative SEP monitoring: analysis of 658 consecutive neurosurgical cases and review of published reports.

OBJECTIVES: To determine the sensitivity of intraoperative monitoring in neurosurgical operations using somatosensory evoked potentials and to identify reasons for false negative findings and possible settings with an increased risk for monitoring failure. METHODS: SEP monitoring of 658 neurosurgical operations was analysed. The target of monitoring was the function of a hemisphere in 251 cases, the brain stem in 198 cases, and the spinal cord in 209 cases. RESULTS: In 27 cases (4.1%), monitoring was classified as false negative. Further analysis showed that five of these patients had experienced delayed neurological damage. Among the remaining 22 false negative cases, 14 had a minor neurological deficit and eight had severe neurological damage. Overall sensitivity and negative predictive value of SEP monitoring was 79% and 96%, respectively. For the detection of severe neurological damage the corresponding figures were 91% and 98%. Sensitivity of monitoring varied depending on the target of monitoring and the type of lesion. Monitoring was less likely to detect neurological damage in surgery for infratentorial tumours with brain stem compression, small lesions of the motor cortex, and small vessel damage during aneurysm surgery. CONCLUSIONS: SEP monitoring has acceptable sensitivity for detecting neurological damage during different neurosurgical procedures. Distinct settings with an increased risk of monitoring failure can be identified. In these cases measures to enhance the sensitivity of monitoring should be considered.

Adolescent↗

Intra-operative characterization of gliomas by near-infrared spectroscopy: possible association with prognosis.

BACKGROUND: Growth and expansion of gliomas are highly dependent on vascular neogenesis. An association of microvascular density and tumour energy metabolism is assumed in most human gliomas. The purpose of this investigation was to characterize a series of gliomas by intra-operative near-infrared spectroscopy (NIRS), and to elucidate the relationship between microvascular blood volume (BV), oxygen saturation (SaO(2)), histology and patient survival. METHOD: The study included 13 patients with gliomas, in whom complete tumour resection according to postoperative magnetic resonance imaging criteria was achieved. Intra-operatively, one low grade astrocytoma, five anaplastic astrocytomas and seven glioblastomas with the ipsilateral cortex were investigated by NIRS revealing capillary BV (total haemoglobin) and SaO(2). Intratumoural BV (tBV) and SaO(2) (tSaO(2)) were additionally used in relation to histology and survival. FINDINGS: The mean tBV of the astrocytomas was 4.96 mg/ml compared to 18.40 mg/ml in the glioblastoma group. Mean tSaO(2) was 36% in the astrocytoma group and 52% in the glioblastomas, respectively. Both tBV and tSaO(2) were significantly higher (p<0.01) in the glioblastoma group. Median survival time was shortest for patients with glioblastoma (12.5 months), with tBV >10/mg/ml (10 months), and tSaO(2) >50% (10 months). Longest median survival times were observed in the astrocytoma group (32.5 months), in patients with Tbv <10/mg/ml (30 months), and tSaO(2) <50% (27.5 months). The differences were highly significant (p<0.01). INTERPRETATION: Intra-operative characterization of gliomas by NIRS is feasible. High tBV represents extensive angiogenetic activity of the tumour, whereas high tSaO(2) may be result of non-oxidative glucose metabolism with less oxygen extraction from the capillary bed of the tumour. However, the extent of tBV and tSaO(2) are both of possible prognostic value thus resulting in additional information about the tumour.

Adult↗

Surgical prognosis in hindbrain related syringomyelia.

OBJECTIVES: The recommended operative treatment against hindbrain related syringomyelia is suboccipital decompression. The aim of the study was to define prognostic factors for surgical outcome in this disease. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Between 1990 and 1997, 31 patients with hindbrain related syringomyelia were treated. All patients underwent craniovertebral decompression by suboccipital craniectomy and laminectomy of C1 or C1 and C2, respectively. Additionally, in nearly half of the cases, the tonsils were treated by bipolar coagulation. Mean post-operative observation period was 35 months including clinical and radiological (MRI) examination. RESULTS: Neither there was correlation between clinical outcome and age nor correlation between clinical outcome and duration of preoperative symptoms. There was good correlation between clinical outcome and result of post-operative MRI: 63% of patients with a sufficient post-operative MRI demonstrated a significant clinical improvement, whereby only 17% of patients with insufficient MRI did so (P < 0.05). None of the patients with coagulation of the tonsils showed clinical improvement. In contrast, 77% of patients without tonsillar manipulation demonstrated clinical improvement (P < 0.01). Additionally, 88% of the patients with dorsal-tenting duraplasty experienced neurological improvement (P < 0.01), too. CONCLUSIONS: The results give evidence for the prognostic importance of creating an adequate artificial cisterna magna. Dorsal-tenting of the duraplasty is an advantageous means against scarring and adhesions, whereby intradural applications such as extensive bipolar coagulation of the cerebellar tonsils should be avoided.

Adult↗

German Society of Neurosurgery Section on Vascular Neurosurgery: Position Statement on the International Subarachnoid Hemorrhage Trial (ISAT).

The outcome after a specific treatment (clipping or coiling) of ruptured intracranial aneurysms is determined by both the periprocedural complication rate and the success of preventing re-bleeding from the treated aneurysm. The latter is associated with a cumulative risk over many years, particularly in incompletely treated aneurysms. Incomplete occlusion of the aneurysm is not infrequently seen after endovascular coiling, even in cases with a perfect anatomical configuration. Therefore, we believe that the 1-year outcome as reported in the ISAT is not an appropriate endpoint for the comparison of both methods. There has also been a tendency to apply the 1-year ISAT data to all patients harbouring intracranial aneurysms. It is inappropriate and dangerous to be less critical when selecting the endovascular approach as the method of choice for treating an aneurysm. This will ultimately result in a higher complication rate of coiling. Another striking finding is the poor surgical outcome in the ISAT. This good-grade patient population (94 % were WFNS grade 1-3 and 89 % were WFNS grade 1-2) had an almost 10 % higher rate of poor outcome compared to other good-grade patients in large prospective surgical studies or the same outcome as trials that included up to 20 % poor-grade patients.[nl]Neurosurgeons should acknowledge that endovascular coiling is a safe method associated with less complications than clipping in experienced hands (Fig. ). Endovascular radiologists should acknowledge that the success of complete obliteration is higher after surgery, that incompletely occluded aneurysms have a higher rate of re-rupture and that the definitive long-term re-rupture rate still remains unknown. Therefore, we await with interest the angiographic and clinical follow-up data that will provide evidence about the final patient outcome.

Germany↗