Kidney preservation with University of Wisconsin or Euro-Collins solution? An economic analysis.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to F F Rutten.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Despite the considerable burden and costs of illness and despite the increasing need to set priorities on the basis of efficiency considerations, only 20 economic appraisals of asthma and COPD care have been published during the past 11 years. This paper provides a detailed summary of the cost-effectiveness 'evidence' given by these studies and a discussion of relevant methodological issues. The studies comparing programme costs of delivery methods for oxygen and for aerosol bronchodilator drugs, provide the most straightforward evidence in favour of the concentrator and the metered dose inhaler respectively. There also seems to be evidence in favour of hospital-based home care programmes as compared to community-based home care programs. Health education, especially directed at asthmatic children seems to reduce health care costs and improve attitude, compliance behaviour and self-management skills. Information on the cost-effectiveness of pharmacotherapy and diagnostic technologies, both important interventions in asthma and COPD, was found to be totally lacking.
The influence of high cost technology goes beyond its consequences for the selected patient groups that benefit from its application. Past and future technological developments have a variety of social, economic and ethical implications which have to be taken into account when balancing its costs and benefits to society. Departing from an economic perspective we describe a number of mechanisms underlying the emergence of high cost technology which help us to understand some of the characteristics of high cost technology, such as its focus on quality enhancement rather than on economy. To assess the actual performance of high cost technology in terms of efficiency and equity is difficult as there may be debate about the perspective guiding such assessment and as there still is scarce information on high cost technology in terms of these economic indicators. The increasing technological opportunities have triggered a wider debate on the desired evolution of our health care systems. In some countries there is a tendency to diminish government involvement in health care and emphasize private (for profit) enterprise as a reaction to not being able to finance all new high cost technology. The risks of such strategies are discussed briefly. We conclude that the main actors in health care should adjust their behaviour in order to accomplish the introduction of more cost-effective technologies and to achieve a more socially efficient distribution of their benefits.
With use of a model of the costs and effects of cholesterol lowering therapy in the primary prevention of coronary heart disease, the cost-effectiveness of simvastatin and cholestyramine in the Netherlands have been estimated. Costs per year of life saved by cholestyramine therapy are several times greater than those of simvastatin therapy and compared unfavorably with those of generally accepted health care programs in the Netherlands. Cholesterol-lowering with simvastatin in men can be cost-effective when therapy is initiated at an early age. At cholesterol levels between 6.5 and 8 mmol/l, however, therapy should be restricted to men with at least one, preferably two additional risk factors such as hypertension or diabetes mellitus. Among women, cholesterol lowering can only be cost-effective when therapy is limited to women with diabetes mellitus or severely elevated serum cholesterol levels.
To assess the cost-effectiveness of cholesterol-reducing therapy with cholestyramine and simvastatin in the primary prevention of coronary artery disease in The Netherlands, a model of coronary artery disease incidence was used based on multivariate logistic risk functions from the Framingham study. For men with initial cholesterol levels of 8 mmol/liter, the cost per year of life saved of cholestyramine, expressed in Dutch guilders (NLG; 1 NLG = $0.50), ranges from approximately NLG 208,000 to NLG 483,000, depending on the patient's age at initiation of therapy. For simvastatin, cost-effectiveness ranges from NLG 46,000 to NLG 98,000 per year of life saved among this group of men. Similar differences between simvastatin and cholestyramine therapy prevail among women, although the costs per year of life saved for both agents are considerably higher. These results suggest that (1) simvastatin is substantially more cost effective than is cholestyramine; (2) simvastatin therapy compares favorably with other generally accepted medical practices, especially if treatment is initiated at an early age; and (3) as its long-term safety record becomes more established, simvastatin may become accepted as a drug of first choice in the treatment of persons with elevated serum cholesterol levels.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Using a model of coronary heart disease incidence based on multivariate logistic regression functions from the Framingham Heart Study, the cost effectiveness of simvastatin was compared with that of cholestyramine in preventing such disease. For men with initial cholesterol levels of 310 mg/dl, the cost effectiveness of cholestyramine, expressed in Dutch guilders, ranges from approximately 220,000 to 510,000 guilders per year of life saved, depending on age at initiation of therapy. For simvastatin, cost-effectiveness ratios range from 50,000 to 110,000 guilders per year of life saved among this group of men. Results are similar for women, although the cost effectiveness of both agents is considerably less. These results suggest that simvastatin is substantially more cost effective than cholestyramine; that it compares well with other generally accepted medical practices, especially if therapy is initiated at an early age; and that simvastatin should become accepted as a drug of first choice in the treatment of persons with elevated serum cholesterol levels as its long-term safety record becomes more established.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Most West European countries have health care systems financed by social insurance funds. In these pluralistic systems, decision-making processes are complex and involve many factors. The present paper focuses on the decision-making behavior of public authorities in health care. It is stressed that understanding the functioning of the political market is essential for explaining the development and performance of health care systems. This political market receives relatively little attention from economists. Specific mechanisms as they can be observed in this market are discussed, and the paper concludes with a plea for reducing the role of government in planning and price-setting in health care.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Following a short outline of the structure of the Dutch health care system and the regulatory activities of the government, budgeting in health care is being considered at three levels: the national level, the level of the health care institution and the intermediate level of the region. The authors foresee that regional budgeting and regional policy-making will become more important. Instead of a nation-wide introduction of the Health Services Act, which means more government interference at regional and local levels in health care, the authors believe that a re-orientation on market-principles as the dominating mechanism in resource allocation in health care will take place in the coming years. This will coincide with strengthening the position of sickness funds and private insurers at the cost of that of provincial and local government.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The ethical aspects of the distribution of resources for health care at the macro level deserve more study than they hitherto received. The socio-medical and economic policy implications of four distribution principles are reviewed: the utilitarian, the egalitarian, the equal access and the libertarian. Policy in welfare states is primarily based on the equal access principle. Economic factors have led to policy proposals in libertarian and utilitarian directions; competition, cost-sharing, cost-effectiveness and individual responsibility are central to the discussion. The authors conclude that it remains to be seen whether these alternatives produce the results expected. They recommend more comprehensive examination of the practical and political feasibilities of a more egalitarian policy.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Three independent sets of data are analyzed to investigate the determinants of referrals from general practitioners to specialists, the demand for specialist care, and the rapid increase in referrals and use of specialists in the Netherlands. Individual determinants of demand are examined with data from a three-man group practice; macroanalyses are conducted on cross-section data from all service areas of the Dutch Sickness Fund Organization for 1971 and 1973 and cross-section time-series data from all provinces for the period from 1960 to 1972. Regression coefficients are estimated for the number of referrals to specialists and the amount of care given by specialists, with respect to explanatory variables that induce both socioeconomic and care-supply factors. Results are discussed in light of M. Feldstein's classification of three types of care, in which for some types the physician is seen as generating the demand for care. The authors conclude that demand for specialist outpatient care is in large part supply-determined and that general practitioners substitute for specialists; they also suggest that the dual physician-payment system in the Netherlands (capitation for legally insured patients and fee-for-service for privately insured patients) contributes to increased use of specialist care.
Hospital use in the Netherlands is examined in a cross-section analysis of 1969 and 1971 data for 120 service regions. Elasticities of admissions with respect to bed supply and supply of general practitioners are calculated, and the substitutability of first level care (by general practitioners) for hospital care is considered. Substitution effects found indicate that the Dutch government's plan to reduce the ratio of hospital beds to population is feasible.
The cost-effectiveness of various diagnostic strategies in patients with clinically suspected pulmonary embolism (PE) was analysed using a modelling approach. In 451 consecutive patients with clinically suspected PE data on the performance of diagnostic tests were collected prospectively in two large teaching hospitals in Amsterdam, The Netherlands. The ventilation-perfusion lung scan was used as the primary diagnostic test in all patients. In patients with a non-diagnostic lung scan result the performance of a clinical decision rule, a D-dimer test, and ultrasonography of the leg veins was evaluated with pulmonary angiography as the gold standard. It was estimated that the strategy recommended by a 1992 Dutch consensus meeting costs about Dfl 4400 per patient and that 97.02% of the patients can be expected to survive the first 6 months after the primary PE. The nation-wide annual costs for the diagnosis and treatment of patients by this strategy were estimated at 163 million Dutch Guilders. Subsequently, the costs and effects of alternative strategies were evaluated in a modelling approach, and compared with those of the consensus strategy. One strategy was selected that produces the best results in terms of survival and leads to considerable savings as compared with the consensus strategy. In this strategy subsequently a ventilation-perfusion scan, a clinical decision rule, a D-dimer test, a pulmonary angiography and leg ultrasonography are performed. Patients with a high probability ventilation-perfusion scan, an abnormal angiography or leg ultrasound test are treated, whereas treatment is withheld in patients with a normal ventilation-perfusion scan, a normal clinical decision rule, a negative D-dimer test, a normal angiography, or a normal leg ultrasound test. This strategy will have to prove its value and usefulness in clinical practice in a subsequent prospective validation phase.