Changes in memory with normal aging: a functional view.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to F I Craik.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The notion that older adults fail to use optimal encoding strategies in memory tasks because of a deficit in memory monitoring was examined in a cued recall task. Participants were given different types of descriptors (initial letters, rhyme, category) for each word during encoding, and these descriptors were later given as cues at recall. Participants also predicted the likelihood of recalling each item. Age differences were found in recall performance, but there were no age differences in average predictions. However, the prediction ratings given by younger adults showed a greater difference between words recalled and words not recalled in the subsequent test than did the ratings of the older adults. Differences in recall associated with different types of processing were predicted poorly by all of the participants, but the relative recallability of specific words was well assessed by both age groups. We concluded that a memory monitoring deficit is not likely to be responsible for age differences in memory.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Previous work has shown that successful recall boosts subsequent retrieval of the recalled items. Two experiments tested the hypothesis that this benefit from prior retrieval would be less strong in older adults. Contrary to expectation, the older adults showed as great a benefit from prior retrieval as did the young adults in both experiments. It is suggested that successful cued recall may act like an orienting task at encoding, to guide retrieval processes effectively, and that the benefit obtained from a successful retrieval is a function of the information used to guide the retrieval process.
Young and old adults studied several lists of words at each of three presentation durations (1.5, 3, and 6 s/word). Under standard, intentional learning instructions the magnitude of the age-related recall deficit increased with longer presentation durations. When a semantic orienting question was used to guide the encoding of the items on each list, however, an equivalent benefit of longer study times was observed for the two age groups. In delayed recognition testing, the age groups also showed equivalent benefits from longer study times. These results were interpreted within the context of a processing deficit framework of age differences in memory, in which age differences are due to differences in the spontaneous use of organizational strategies. The results are not well described by a cognitive slowing account of age differences in memory.
The hypothesis that age deficits in long-term episodic memory tasks are due to imparied metamemorial skills was investigated in a paired-associate task that required participants to predict the likelihood of recalling individual items. Both young and old adults were able to predict their ability to recall, and both age groups were equally sensitive to the effects of differences in the degree of relatedness between word-pair members on subsequent recall. However, both old and young adults were insensitive to the beneficial effects of using interactive imagery at encoding. It was concluded that differences in metamemorial skills are not responsible for age differences in memory.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Three experiments investigated level of processing (LOP) effects on a variety of direct and indirect memory tasks, in the context of a processing theory of dissociations. Subjects studied words in five encoding conditions and received one of ten memory tests. In Experiment 1, four tests previously classified as conceptual showed a robust LOP effect, as did a direct perceptual test of graphemic cued recall. An indirect perceptual word fragment completion test was unaffected by LOP. Experiment 2 showed that a new indirect version of a graphemic cued test was not affected by LOP. In Experiment 3, guided by a generation/recognition model, we constructed three new direct tests in which subjects identified words that were graphemically, phonologically, or semantically similar to studied words. The three tests differed in their sensitivity to study conditions, but LOP had no effect in any case, despite the involvement of deliberate conscious recollection. Contemporary explanatory frameworks couched as dichotomies (e.g., implicit/explicit, perceptual/conceptual) do not provide an adequate account of the results. It seems necessary instead to specify the types of information activated by each encoding condition, the types of information required by each test, and how encoding and retrieval processes are modified by task instructions.
Young adults (N = 58) and older adults (N = 55) answered 30 questions extracted from three dimensions of the Metamemory in Adulthood (MIA) questionnaire: Capacity, Task and Strategy. The older participants scored significantly lower on the Capacity dimension, indicating that they report having greater difficulty in everyday memory situations. There was no age difference on any item in the Task dimension; both groups were equally knowledgeable about memory task demands. Responses to Strategy items varied with type of strategy: younger adults were more likely than older adults to report the use of encoding strategies, while older adults reported significantly more use of strategies which involved planning and organization. A further group of employed young adults (N = 26) was added to clarify the respective roles of aging and environmental demands on strategy use. The findings suggest that both changes in lifestyle and the effects of aging per se play some part in the use of particular memory strategies.
Salthouse (1991) suggested two methods of presenting and analyzing the data of studies in which patterns of performance for young and old participants in different tasks are compared. The first method presents the original scores in terms of the standard deviations of the distribution of the young adults group, and in the second method, the reference distribution is performance of each age group in a control or baseline condition. The authors question the arbitrariness of the baseline chosen in both methods, which might lead to misleading results, and reanalyze the results of 2 studies and show that alternative, equally legitimate methods, using different baseline conditions, yield different results. This raises a question regarding the suitability of a derived-scores methodology in presenting and analyzing summary results.