PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

F L Bedford

Publications and source records attributed to F L Bedford.

5 recordsLinked to original sources
PubMed1997

False categories in cognition: the Not-the-Liver fallacy.

This paper reports on an increasingly frequent error committed in cognition research that at best slows progress, and at worse leads to self-perpetuating false claims and misguided research. The error involves how we identify meaningful processes and categories on the basis of data. Examples are given from three areas of cognition: (1) memory, where the misconception has fueled the popular implicit/explicit categories, (2) perception, where the misconception is used to re-evaluate the classic what/where division, and (3) motor skills, where it is used to draw conclusions from patients with Huntington's disease. Reasons for the prevalence of this error, how it relates to double dissociations, and what it suggests about scientific reasoning are offered.

Cognition↗
PubMed1995

Constraints on perceptual learning: objects and dimensions.

The article addresses two questions about perceptual learning: What are the circumstances which produce learning? What is the content of learning? For each question, a critical principle is suggested: (1) Objects are constrained to behave in certain ways. If a violation is detected, an internal malfunction is assumed and subsequently corrected. (2) Learning involves mappings between entire perceptual dimensions rather than associations between individual stimuli. The principles are applied to two phenomena: the classic adaptation to prism distorted vision and the more recent, but equally elusive, McCollough effect. The view suggests a new interpretation of the McCollough effect and accounts for findings difficult to account for in other interpretations including which stimuli can successfully lead to contingent after-effects, the outcome of correlation manipulations, and why the effect exists at all. In addition, the phenomenon is linked to prism adaptation, usually regarded as a distinct type of plasticity. In general, the view advanced is that the two principles help distinguish perceptual learning from other types of learning processes.

Adaptation, Psychological↗
PubMed1993

Perceptual and cognitive spatial learning.

Ss were taught novel mappings between visual space and motor space with either a variant on a prism adaptation paradigm (Experiments 1 and 2) or a nonperceptual cognitive task (Experiments 3 and 4). First, discrimination training specified that 1 visual location required a new pointing response but another location did not. This led to unusual generalization unlike typical generalization decrement. Second, training at 9 locations specified that 1 location required a new response but that the remaining 8 did not. This simple isolation mapping was unlearnable and instead a flat function fit through all of space. In contrast, for the cognitive paradigm, not only was isolation of one region of space easily learned, it was the preferred pattern of generalization. Implications for perceptual learning, as well as the qualitative distinctions between perceptual and cognitive learning, are discussed.

Adult↗
PubMed1993

The McCollough effect: dissociating retinal from spatial coordinates.

Three experiments were conducted to dissociate the perceived orientation of a stimulus from its orientation on the retina while inducing the McCollough effect. In the first experiment, the typical contingency between color and retinal orientation was eliminated by having subjects tilt their head 90 degrees for half of the induction trials while the stimuli remained the same. The only relation remaining was that between color and the perceived or spatial orientation, which led to only a small contingent aftereffect. In contrast, when the spatial contingency was eliminated in the second experiment, the aftereffect was as large as when both contingencies were present. Finally, a third experiment determined that part of the small spatial effect obtained in the first experiment could be traced to hidden higher order retinal contingencies. The study suggested that even under optimal conditions the McCollough effect is not concerned with real-world properties of objects or events. Implications for several classes of theories are discussed.

Adult↗