Sensitivity of screening sigmoidoscopy for proximal colorectal tumours.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to G Grazzini.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The trend in cervical cancer incidence in the District of Florence from 1975 to 1989 was investigated. Tuscany Cancer Registry data were available since 1985. Incidence data from 1975 to 1985 were obtained through a retrospective survey of all the Departments of Pathology and Gynaecology in the district. Cytological screening for cervical cancer has been available in the district since 1973, and since 1980 active invitation of residents aged 25 to 59 years has been in use. A significant trend in decreasing incidence was evident for the overall population (P = 0.003) and for 40-49 (P = 0.028), 50-59 (P < 0.001) and 60-69 (P = 0.002) year age groups, whereas no significant trend was observed for the age group 30-39 years. An association between attendance to screening and reduced incidence was evident, in that a greater reduction was evident for those cohorts (ages 50-59 and 60-69) who had a higher compliance to screening 10-15 years before. If the decrease in cervical cancer incidence was spontaneous, a parallel decrease of CIN3, which is commonly assumed to be the precursor of invasive carcinoma, would be expected. On the contrary, the detection rate of CIN3 at first Pap test showed a significant increase in the study period. All these findings suggest that the observed reduction in cervical cancer incidence was mostly due to the effect of screening, and stress the need for optimising the coverage of the invited population.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The performances of three faecal occult blood tests, rehydrated Hemoccult (HOR), Hemoccult sensa (HOS) and Hemeselect (HSEL) on 3 days were compared in 1,725 subjects consecutively recruited in two oncological institutions in Milan and Florence. Significant differences between the results were evident as far as HOR positivity rates (7.5% vs 4.0%, respectively) and specificity (94.3% vs 97.5%, respectively) are concerned. Overall positivity rates of HOR, HOS and HSEL were 5.9%, 5.4% and 12%, respectively; significant differences were evident between HSEL and each of the two guaiac tests. Cancer was detected in eight subjects, adenoma/s in 47. Specificity estimates were 95.8%, 90.2% and 90.5% for HOR, HOS and HSEL, respectively; significant differences were evident between HSEL and the other two tests. No significant difference between tests was evident for sensitivity or positive predictive values for cancer or adenomas. In the CSPO (Florence) population (1,223 subjects; five with cancer, 16 with adenoma/s) the performances of 1-day HSEL testing were determined on the basis of the first faecal sample only and compared with 3-day HOR, HOS and HSEL testing. The positivity rates of 1-day HSEL, 3-day HOR, HOS and HSEL testing were 7.0%, 5.0%, 5.5% and 12.9%, respectively. Only 3-day HSEL positivity rate was significantly higher than 1-day HSEL. One-day HSEL specificity (94.9%) was significantly higher than 3-day HSEL (90.0%), whereas no significant difference was seen between 1-day HSEL, HOR (96.5%), and HOS (96.1%) specificity. No significant difference between tests is evident in the CSPO population as far as positive predictive values and sensitivity for cancer and adenomas are concerned.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
The authors report on the quality control for colposcopy adopted in the Florence District screening program. The sensitivity of colposcopy was determined on all cases of CIN III recorded in the local cancer registry in a four-year period. However although this showed that a centralized colposcopic clinic employing a limited number of expert operators is superior to the performance of colposcopy in private practice, such a parameter was impractical for further routine quality control since differences among operators were too small and statistically insignificant. Other parameters for quality control were chosen, namely a) the rate of colposcopically directed biopsies performed, b) the detection rate of CIN II or more severe lesions, and c) the positive predictive value of a directed biopsy for CIN II or more severe lesions. Analysis of these indicators after stratification by cytologic report allows the identification of those operators who need additional training and provides useful information for colposcopists to optimize their diagnostic and operative criteria.
Seven hundred and eighty-six subjects spontaneously referring to our Center performed two guaiac (Rehydrated Hemoccult II (R.HO), and Hemoccult Sensa (HO S.)), and two immunochemical (OC Hemodia (Hdia) and Hemeselect (Hsel)) faecal occult blood tests on three consecutive faecal determinations. The positivity rates of 3 day R.HO, HO S., Hdia, and Hsel were 4.8%, 5.6%, 8.4% and 11.2% respectively. One hundred and thirty-five of the 150 subjects with at least one positive test completed the diagnostic work-up. Cancer was detected in three subjects and adenomas in 15. Three-day specificity estimates of R.HO, HO S., Hdia and Hsel in the overall series were 96.1%, 96.0%, 93.8% and 91.2% respectively, the differences between guaiac and immunochemical tests being significant. Corresponding values of specificity as determined on the first faecal sample only in the overall series were 98.1%, 98.3%, 96.1% and 94.9% respectively. No significant difference in specificity is evident when 3-day guaiac tests are compared to 1-day immunochemical ones. Three-day immunochemical testing is not recommended for screening purposes due to its very low specificity. Nevertheless, 1-day immunochemical testing is almost as specific as 3-day guaiac testing. A preliminary estimate of colonic neoplasms detection rates shows no difference as well. The benefit of 1-day testing on screening acceptability is evident, but the impact on sensitivity should be evaluated in a screening situation with a proper study design and a larger sample size.
OBJECTIVE: To estimate the disagreement between the histologic reports at colposcopically directed punch biopsy of the cervix and subsequent loop excision of the transformation zone, and to assess the indications for loop excision in current practice. METHODS: The histologic diagnoses from loop electrosurgical excision procedures and concurrent colposcopically directed punch biopsies were compared in 337 consecutive women undergoing loop excision in a 5-year period. RESULTS: Disagreement between punch biopsy and loop excision was recorded in 190 cases (56.4%). The undercall and overcall rates for punch biopsy were 14 and 42.4%, respectively. Undercall at punch biopsy occurred in 24 of 46 cases of cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) III and in one microinvasive cancer diagnosed at loop excision, and disagreement was within one grade of CIN in 16 cases. CONCLUSIONS: Loop electrosurgical excision allows further and more accurate histologic examination of the transformation zone and should be the standard assessment procedure in all cases of CIN II detected at punch biopsy and whenever cytology or colposcopy suggests the risk of punch biopsy undercall. Immediate treatment by local destruction should not be performed, to avoid underestimation of the severity of the lesion.
The authors report on a consecutive series of 62 evaluable, elderly (age greater than 69 years) women with primary operable breast cancer treated only with tamoxifen. The treatment schedule was 160 mg on day 1 followed by a daily maintenance dose of 20 mg. Compliance to treatment was excellent, and subjective side effects were minimal. The best response achieved after at least 6 months of treatment was complete in 7, partial in 22 and minor in 3, whereas stable disease or progression was observed in 28 and 2 patients, respectively. The response rate decreased and progressions increased with time. At 6, 12, 24, 36 and 48 months of treatment, the complete + partial response rates were 30.6%, 45%, 45.6%, 38.7% and 25% and the progressive disease rates 4.8%, 19.6%, 34.8%, 45.2% and 66.6%, respectively. These results do not confirm some previous reports of a high response to tamoxifen. This difference is only partially explained by the use of mammography, which is more sensitive than palpation, to assess tumor size and treatment response. The present study does not support primary hormone therapy as a current alternative to surgery, which should be the standard treatment in otherwise healthy elderly patients with operable breast cancer.
The sensitivity of Hemoccult testing (HO) in a population-based screening for colorectal cancer was evaluated. HO sensitivity estimates were calculated as the ratio of screen-detected HO-positives to total screen or interval-detected cancers. Sensitivity was estimated according to 1, 2, and 3-year rescreening intervals. Corresponding estimates are 69.4%, 61.8% and 57.7%, respectively. No significant correlation was observed between HO sensitivity and other variables, such as calendar period, tumor stage or site, or patient age or sex. HO sensitivity as estimated in the present experience is consistent with other reports of population-based screenings. Screening every year would achieve too limited an increase in sensitivity, compared to biennal screening, to be worth the difficulties of doubling organizational efforts and costs.
Eighty-eight cases of subclinical human papillomavirus (HPV) vulvar infection were detected in a consecutive colposcopic series of 968 women. Three patterns of acetowhite lesions had a 72% predictive value (88/122) for histologically assessed HPV. The prevalence of subclinical vulvar HPV in self-referred patients was 7.9% (73/918); it was 9% (88/968) in the overall series and significantly higher in younger patients (age less than 25 years: 21/106, or 19.8%) or in those with cervical HPV or cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) (40/100, or 40%). Routine inspection of the vulva after acetic acid lavage in association with a Papanicolaou test might help identify Papanicolaou-test-negative patients at high risk of developing cervical HPV or CIN. Treatment with beta-interferon (2,000,000 IU daily intramuscularly for 10 days) was given to 30 consecutive patients, but the results were poor: regression was observed in only 2 cases.
The authors report on 228 cases of suspected breast cancer local recurrences studied by fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC). The nature (malignant = 133, benign = 95) of suspected lesions was assessed on histology (no. = 46) or according to unequivocal follow-up (no. = 182). Inadequacy rate was 0.20, 0.09 or 0.35 in total, cancer or benign cases, respectively, and was particularly high (0.50) for benign chest wall lesions. Accuracy was determined on adequate smears; dubious reports were assumed as positive. Sensitivity and specificity were 0.96 and 0.97, respectively. The routine use of FNAC is recommended since it helps in the differential diagnosis of suspicious cases and may bypass surgical biopsy of positive cases not eligible for surgical treatment.
The authors evaluate the referral rates and the predictive value (PV) of call for diagnostic work up or biopsy in a population based breast cancer screening program in the 1979-1986 period. The presence of mammographic abnormalities either benign or suspicious proved to be the only reliable referral criterion (recall rate = 7.9%, recall PV = 3.8%, biopsy call PV = 39%). When mammography was normal the presence of breast complaints other than pain or of a radiologically dense breast were aspecific referral criteria, and since the latter was abandoned, (a) referral rates dropped especially in younger women, (b) referral or biopsy PV improved, whereas (c) cancer detection rate was almost unaffected. Younger age was associated with higher referral rates and with lower PV of both referral or biopsy. Whenever comparison with previous examination was possible, mammography accuracy was higher; this explains the decrease in referral rates and the increased predictivity observed at further rounds with respect to first screening round.
We report on 156 consecutive cases of in situ ductal carcinoma (DCIS) of the breast observed from 1968 to 1988. The relative frequency of DCIS was much higher in screened, with respect to self-referred, women and a significant association of DCIS with younger age was observed. The combined use of mammography and physical examination identified 138 of 156 total DCIS cases as suspicious. Mammography, physical examination or cytology (of nipple discharge or needle aspirate) were the only tests to provide suspicious evidence in 35, 22 and four cases respectively. DCIS was a relatively unexpected surgical finding in 13 apparently benign cases. Different surgical options were recorded in the study period but a temporal trend in favour of conservative surgery was evident. Subsequent ipsilateral or contralateral breast cancer was recorded in seven and six cases respectively. Death from breast cancer occurred in five cases, all of whom had contralateral or subsequent ipsilateral infiltrating cancer. This figure confirms the high curability of DCIS if local control is achieved.
A consecutive series of 185 instances of histologically confirmed nonpalpable infiltrating carcinoma of the breast is presented. Histologic nodal involvement was found in 12 per cent and was dependent on the size of the tumor. Conservative surgical treatment was the predominant method used during the study period. The ten year over-all survival was studied and compared with that of 4,217 instances of palpable carcinoma of the breast observed during the same period. The ten year survival rates were, by far, better for nonpalpable (94 per cent) than for palpable carcinomas (65 per cent). A better prognosis for nonpalpable carcinomas was confirmed also by multivariate analysis (Cox) with adjustment for potential confounders, such as age, stage or nodal involvement. The possible confounding effect of over diagnosis and length or lead time bias is discussed. Although this difference in survival might be partially explained by the aforementioned confounders, the chance of increasing life expectancy and conservative surgical treatment encourages preclinical detection of carcinoma of the breast.
A report on 1877 consecutive node negative (N-) breast cancer cases is presented in which the prognostic value of the main clinico-pathologic features is evaluated. Tumor size (and UICC-TNM T category) and lobular infiltrating histologic type were significantly associated with a more favorable prognosis whereas no association was found for patient age, tumor site and number of examined axillary nodes. However tumor size (and T category) is not a very accurate prognostic predictor (71% of all recurrences observed occurred in cases with tumor diameter of more than 20 mm, which represented 58% of the total series), although its efficiency seems almost as good as that of other more recent prognostic predictors such as estrogen receptor content or labeling index. None of the prognostic predictors currently available, including tumor size, seems sufficiently specific and they do not allow for a reliable selection of high risk N-patients for adjuvant treatment.
The authors report the results of a campaign aimed at increasing compliance to cervical cancer screening by promoting general practitioners' (GPs) cooperation. Different types of intervention were tested, namely mailing lists of non responders to the GP, visiting the GP at the office, or both. No active intervention was made in a sample of GPs who served as a control group. Overall 288 GPs assisting 75,853 women aged 25 to 59 were enrolled in the study. Compliance before and after the campaign was studied and the association between compliance and different variables such as age, residence and type of intervention was tested by univariate and multivariate analysis. The proportion of previous non responders who performed a Pap test after the campaign was 6.7%, the response being dependent on age (25-29 = 11.5%, 30-39 = 8.8%, 40-49 = 6.5%, 50-59 = 4.2%) and place of residence (urban = 7.2%, suburban = 5.9%, rural = 4.0%). Compliance was better in the case of the active campaign (list mailing = 8.3%, visit = 7.0%, list + visit = 7.2%) with respect to controls (2.9%) although no significant differences were detected between different types of active intervention. Compliance to cervical cancer screening may be increased by promoting GPs cooperation but the benefit is limited. Mailing lists of non responders was found the most cost effective policy in this study.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.