PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

G Neale

Publications and source records attributed to G Neale.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Case record review of adverse events: a new approach.

OBJECTIVES: To redesign the existing clinical review form (RF2) used in previous retrospective case record review studies in order to clarify the review process and provide a more powerful analysis of adverse events; and then to ask clinicians to pilot and evaluate the new modular review form (MRF2). The review form is divided into five sections, each with a defined purpose, providing a modular structure. DESIGN: Design and testing of the MRF2 on a sample of medical and nursing records, and evaluation of the reviewers' responses regarding the new review form. SETTING: Hospital based teams from eight countries. RESULTS: The modular review form was reported to be comprehensive, well structured, and clear. Most of the reviewers agreed with the positive statements regarding the review form. Overall, the modular structure was thought to be helpful. Several modifications have been made to the final version to take account of criticisms and suggestions. CONCLUSIONS: The full potential of case record review has yet to be explored. The benefits of this review form include a modular format which enables reviewers or project leaders to select the focus of their review based on resources and the purpose of the review, and to identify contributory factors which indicate areas for improvement and prevention. The training of reviewers is of vital importance for record review. Record review remains one of the primary methods for assessing the incidence of adverse events and the new format is suitable for both prospective and retrospective review.

Attitude of Health Personnel↗

Adverse events in British hospitals: preliminary retrospective record review.

OBJECTIVES: To examine the feasibility of detecting adverse events through record review in British hospitals and to make preliminary estimates of the incidence and costs of adverse events. DESIGN: Retrospective review of 1014 medical and nursing records. SETTING: Two acute hospitals in Greater London area. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Number of adverse events. RESULTS: 110 (10.8%) patients experienced an adverse event, with an overall rate of adverse events of 11.7% when multiple adverse events were included. About half of these events were judged preventable with ordinary standards of care. A third of adverse events led to moderate or greater disability or death. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that adverse events are a serious source of harm to patients and a large drain on NHS resources. Some are major events; others are frequent, minor events that go unnoticed in routine clinical care but together have massive economic consequences.

Costs and Cost Analysis↗

Exploring the causes of adverse events in NHS hospital practice.

In a previous paper we reported that 10.8% of patients admitted to two large hospitals in Greater London experienced one or more adverse events, of which half were deemed preventable. Here we examine the underlying causes of errors in clinical practice. Rather than identifying specific errors made by individuals, we have looked at possible faults in the organization of care. Adverse events were grouped according to stages in the care process: diagnosis, preoperative assessment and care, operative or invasive procedure (including anaesthesia), ward management, use of drugs and intravenous fluids and discharge from hospital. Less than 20% of preventable adverse events were directly related to surgical operations or invasive procedures and less than 10% to misdiagnoses. 53% of preventable adverse events occurred in general ward care (including initial assessment and the use of drugs and intravenous fluids) and 18% in care at the time of discharge. Probable contributory factors in these errors included dependence on diagnoses made by inexperienced clinicians, poor records, poor communication between professional carers, inadequate input by consultants into day-to-day care, and lack of detailed assessment of patients before discharge.

Aged↗

Informed consent.

Explore the source record for details and available documents.

Endoscopy, Gastrointestinal↗

A case of kwashiorkor in the UK.

A case of kwashiorkor in a British child of Caucasian origin is described. The 5-year-old boy was referred to hospital for investigation of a persistent anaemia, but on examination was found to have classical features of kwashiorkor. He was stunted with both height and weight below the fifth centile and had mild pitting oedema in both legs. His hair was pale and easily pluckable and a soft liver edge was palpable. Plasma albumin concentration was 16 g/l and the plasma amino acid pattern, which revealed markedly reduced levels of essential but normal to high non-essential amino acids, was similar to that described in kwashiorkor in Uganda. A dietary history revealed that for about 2 years the child's diet had contained very little protein but adequate energy and had been supplemented with multivitamin pills. There was no evidence of other pathology, neglect or abuse and the child responded rapidly to refeeding with a balanced diet.

Amino Acids↗

Reducing risks in gastroenterological practice.

Eighty five malpractice claims against gastroenterologists have been analysed. Thirty seven (44%) arose from adverse events as a result of endoscopy and 48 (56%) from clinical practice. In 31 (84%) of the endoscopy cases (including all 13 endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatographies) there seemed to be significant fault. In nine cases the procedure was not clearly indicated and in 10 recognition and treatment of the adverse event was delayed. In no case had the patient given adequate informed consent. Diagnostic error was responsible for most of the claims related to clinical practice (31 of 48) of which 13 were indefensible. Failure to obtain an adequate history (17 cases) and insufficient awareness of disorders of the small intense (12 cases) were major factors. In 26 cases a key investigation was not performed. Seventeen claims were related to management or treatment but only one of these cases was difficult to defend. Overall, there was evidence of serious fault in 50% of claims. Greater care in selecting patients for endoscopic procedures and in providing postprocedural care would have eliminated the basis of more than half the claims arising from endoscopy. There would have been few claims if properly informed consent had been obtained. Over-ready acceptance of the diagnosis of a functional disorder (for example, irritable bowel, dyspepsia) was the usual cause of delays in diagnosis.

Clinical Competence↗

Nutritional aspects of dissimilatory sulfate reduction in the human large intestine.

In contrast to other anaerobic ecosystems, such as marine and estuarine sediments, there is a lack of information on the nutritional requirements of human gut sulfate-reducing bacteria (SRB). Various substrates stimulated sulfate reduction in mixed culture, including short-chain fatty acids and other organic acids, alcohols, and amino acids (but not sugars or aromatic compounds). However, the use of sodium molybdate as a specific inhibitor of sulfate reduction caused an accumulation of ethanol and malonate only, and reduced the rate of utilization of lactate. This indicates the importance of these electron donors for sulfate reduction. Since ethanol and lactate are primarily utilized by members of the Desulfovibrio genus, the results suggest a physiologically important role for this group. Experiments with two strains of Desulfovibrio desulfuricans isolated from human feces demonstrated that both were able to reduce sulfite, thiosulfate or nitrate in the absence of sulfate. In addition, one strain (DsvUC1) was able to grow by fermentative metabolism, although the second strain (DsvFD1) showed more restricted fermentative growth. The data indicate that desulfovibrios are ecologically the most significant group of SRB in the human colon, and that colonic isolates belonging to this genus are versatile, in terms of both the electron acceptors and donors that they are able to utilize.

Acetates↗

Acquired intestinal aganglionosis and circulating autoantibodies without neoplasia or other neural involvement.

The clinical course, diagnosis, and treatment of 2 patients with acquired intestinal aganglionosis without other neurological involvement or neoplasia are described. They initially presented with constipation and abdominal pain in late childhood. They were found to have enteric ganglionitis with a loss of neurons together with vacuolated nerve cells surrounded by CD3- and CD4-positive T lymphocytes. This process initially affected only the colon but later the entire gastrointestinal tract was involved in 1 patient. Associated with this process there were circulating immunoglobulin G class enteric neuronal antibodies in high titer (1:5000-8000). The staining of central nervous system neuronal nuclei and Western blotting indicated the presence of antineuronal nuclear protein antibodies of the ANNA-1 (anti-Hu) type usually associated with paraneoplastic sensory neuropathy. However, the reaction pattern in enteric neurons was quite different with strong reaction to perikarya and only weak staining of nuclear antigens.

Adolescent↗

Radionuclide studies in intestinal transplantation. Diagnosis of rejection and assessment of permeability.

Three patients who received intestinal allografts were studied using two distinct radionuclide investigations. In the first, 111In or 99mTc-labeled leukocyte scanning was performed to assist in the diagnosis of rejection. It was able to demonstrate the occurrence of rejection in the transplanted intestine, and the response to antirejection therapy. In 1 case, the abnormality on the scan preceded the histological confirmation of rejection. The second technique studied mucosal integrity by serial 51Cr-EDTA/14C-mannitol permeability tests. These studies demonstrated the initial marked impairment and the slow return to normal function of the intestinal mucosal barrier. In 1 patient, this occurred by 91 days; in another, it took 232 days. A single assay performed in the third patient at the time of allograft rejection was also abnormal. Both radionuclide tests were helpful in the care of these complicated cases.

Adult↗

Home enteral tube feeding in East Anglia.

OBJECTIVE: To establish the profile of patients receiving home enteral tube feeding (HETF) in East Anglia, to assess the adequacy of care, and to consider the causes and implications of differences in the geographic prevalence of HETF. DESIGN: A 1-year prospective study. SETTING: Eight independently funded districts within East Anglia. SUBJECTS: Basic clinical data were available from 234 patients, 191 of which were tube-fed in the same district as that which initiated treatment, with detailed data obtained from 126. OUTCOME MEASURES: Prevalence, complications in relation to the dietetic support available, and standards of care in relation to those set in the reports of the King's Fund and the British Association of Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition. RESULTS: The patients, who were usually elderly subjects or children, had severe disabilities: 40% were unable to walk: 39% were unable to speak; and 20% were housebound. In all cases enteral tube feeding had been initiated in hospital but in this survey we found inadequate training for home care in 23%, inadequate support and follow-up in 20%, inadequate equipment in 41%, uncertainties regarding organisation, and various clinical problems such as feed regurgitation, in 22%, aspiration pneumonia in 13% , which occasionally led to hospitalization (4%), and frequent but usually minor peristomal problems in patients with gastrostomies. There was a direct correlation between the prevalence of HETF (which varied fourfold between districts) and the number of NHS dieticians per head of population; and in inverse correlation with respect to requests by patients for more support (r = 0.97), complaints of blocked tubes (r = 0.82) and the need for hospital help. CONCLUSION: HETF provides an important form of support to a small group of severely disabled patients. There are important differences between districts in the prevalence of HETF which may be related to variation in local expertise and available support staff. The standards of care did not always conform to those set in the King's Fund report and BAPEN report on Enteral and Parenteral Nutrition in the community.

Adolescent↗

Clinical analysis of 100 medicolegal cases.

OBJECTIVE: To find the reasons for legal claims against hospital doctors. DESIGN: Prospective analysis of requests for medical opinion submitted by solicitors during 1984-93 on legal claims against hospital doctors. SUBJECTS: 100 successive cases: 98 from the United Kingdom and two from the Republic of Ireland. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Principal underlying causes of claims. RESULTS: In 44 cases there was no serious clinical error. Of the 56 cases of clinical fault, seven were a failure of communication by doctors, 15 were an isolated error in otherwise good clinical management, 21 were errors that might not have occurred with better control of clinical practice (doctors exceeding their competence, poor clinical judgment, and poor teamwork), and 13 were major errors due to carelessness or incompetence. In 34 cases there was evidence of clinical fault that might escape clinical audit and medicolegal processes. Most of these legal claims have been or are likely to be withdrawn: only five plaintiffs have settled out of court, and 11 are pursuing their actions. CONCLUSIONS: To reduce the incidence of errors, hospital doctors should consult colleagues about difficult cases and specialists should maintain a broad interest in disease. The NHS clinical complaints procedure should be extended to cover potential claims, and serious cases should be subject to independent external assessment by experienced consultants.

Clinical Competence↗