Clinical controversies in oral and maxillofacial surgery. Part II: A negative view of managed health care.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to H A Israel.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
BACKGROUND: Chronic oral, facial and head pain is a common clinical problem, and appropriate diagnosis and management are a challenge for health care professionals. Patients often will first seek the care of dentists because of the pain's localization in the oral cavity and surrounding structures. This article emphasizes the importance of establishing accurate diagnoses and conducting appropriate triage of the patient with complex orofacial pain. CASE DESCRIPTIONS: The authors present two case reports illustrating the complex nature of oral, facial and head pain, and the potential and actual pitfalls in management of this condition. These representative cases demonstrate how orofacial pain--which appears to be localized in the peripheral dental and oral structures--can have extremely complex etiologies involving other anatomical structures, the central nervous system and psychological factors. The reports point to the need for the expertise of a number of specialists in such cases. CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS: If the symptoms and clinical findings do not appear to be consistent with typical oral disease, or if standard treatments do not alleviate the pain, the dental clinician must consider other, more complex orofacial pain diagnoses. The dental professional should not hesitate to make referrals to key specialists or to members of an interdisciplinary team at a pain treatment center who have the expertise to appropriately diagnose and manage chronic oral, facial and head pain.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
PURPOSE: The purpose of this investigation was to assess the relationship between parafunctional masticatory activity and arthroscopically visualized changes in patients with severe, unremitting symptoms caused by intra-articular temporomandibular joint pathology. The working hypothesis was that the presence of parafunctional activity leads to increased arthroscopically diagnosed pathology. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Temporomandibular joint arthroscopy was performed on 124 joints in 83 patients (female:male, 5.4:1; mean age, 35 years; mean duration of symptoms, 49 months) with severe symptoms unresponsive to nonsurgical management. Preoperatively, the presence of parafunctional habits (bruxism, clenching) was assessed, and joints were classified as either with or without parafunctional influences. Joints were diagnosed arthroscopically and assessed for the presence or absence of osteoarthritis, synovitis, and adhesions. Analyses were performed to determine significant relationships between parafunctional activity and the presence of osteoarthritis, synovitis, and adhesions. RESULTS: Parafunctional influences were present in 82 of 124 joints (66%). Clinically diagnosed osteoarthritis was present in 59 of 124 joints (48%) and arthroscopically diagnosed osteoarthritis was seen in 82 of 124 joints (66%). Arthroscopically, synovitis was diagnosed in 123 of 124 joints (99%) and adhesions in 93 of 124 joints (75%). Statistical analyses showed a significant relationship between parafunction and clinically diagnosed osteoarthritis, and suggested a close relationship between parafunction and arthroscopically diagnosed osteoarthritis. A significant association between clinically and arthroscopically diagnosed osteoarthritis and adhesions was also demonstrated. There also was no significant relationship detected between parafunction and the presence of synovitis or adhesions seen arthroscopically. CONCLUSIONS: It was concluded that parafunctional masticatory activity and its influence on joint loading contribute to osteoarthritis of the temporomandibular joint. Such osteoarthritis is associated with adhesions of the joint. Arthroscopically diagnosed synovitis is not specifically associated with parafunction, and it appears that numerous other causative factors may contribute to its development in the TMJ. Because abnormal joint loading is a major causative factor in cartilage degradation, biochemical and biomechanical abnormalities, and intraarticular temporomandibular pathology, clinicians must identify and address parafunctional masticatory activity during nonsurgical, surgical, and postsurgical treatment regimens.
Reconstruction of the atrophic maxilla in a young adult presents unique challenges. This article describes reconstruction in a 30-year-old patient using a two-stage procedure. Bilateral maxillary sinus augmentations with simultaneous corticocancellous grafting to the anterior maxilla and alveolar ridge were performed. Eight endosseous implant fixtures were subsequently placed into the maxilla after a five-month healing phase. Six months later the implants were uncovered, healing abutments placed and a maxillary vestibuloplasty performed. The rationale behind this treatment and a review of the literature are discussed.
PURPOSE: The purposes of this investigation were to determine how common osteoarthritis and synovitis are in patients with severe, recalcitrant temporomandibular joint (TMJ) symptoms using clinical diagnostic criteria as well as arthroscopic examination, and to compare the accuracy of the clinical and arthroscopic diagnoses with respect to specificity and sensitivity. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Clinical and arthroscopic diagnoses were established in 126 joints of 84 patients with severe TMJ symptoms recalcitrant to conservative therapy. All joints were classified as having osteoarthritis (OA) or no osteoarthritis (non-OA) and synovitis (syn) or no synovitis (non-syn) using clinical and arthroscopic criteria. Chi-squared analysis was used to determine whether there was a relationship between the clinical and arthroscopic diagnoses. Preoperative clinical diagnoses were compared with arthroscopic morphologic diagnoses to determine the specificity and sensitivity of the clinical diagnostic criteria for synovitis and osteoarthritis. RESULTS: A preoperative clinical diagnosis of OA was established in 59 of 126 joints (47%) compared with an arthroscopic diagnoses of OA in 82 of 126 joints (65%). Chi-squared analysis showed a significant relationship between the clinical and arthroscopic diagnosis of OA. A clinical diagnosis of OA was associated with a high specificity (.977); however, there were 23 of 82 (.293) false-negative findings and a sensitivity of only .707. A preoperative clinical diagnosis of synovitis was established in 114 of 126 joints (90%), compared with an arthroscopic diagnosis of synovitis in 112 of 126 (89%). Chi-squared analysis did not show a significant relationship between the clinical and arthroscopic diagnosis of synovitis. A clinical diagnosis of synovitis was associated with a high sensitivity (.920); however, there were 11 of 14 false-positive findings (.786) associated with a low specificity (.214). CONCLUSIONS: Although there was high specificity for the clinical diagnosis of OA, the sensitivity was very low. (Comparison of clinical and arthroscopic diagnoses showed that osteoarthritis frequently escapes clinical detection. The clinical diagnosis of synovitis showed that low specificity and symptoms may be caused by other pathoses.
PURPOSE: The specific aim of this investigation was to assess differences between primary and secondary osteoarthritis (OA) of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ) using clinical evaluation and synovial fluid analysis for proteoglycans. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Arthroscopic surgery was performed on 101 TMJs from patients with significant pain or dysfunction and who had failed to respond to treatment. Joints were assessed for primary and secondary osteoarthritis. Synovial fluid aspirates were obtained and analyzed to determine the levels of keratan sulfate (KS) epitope and a novel 3B3(-) epitope by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA). RESULTS: Fifty-four patients and 67 joints had OA diagnosed by both clinical examination and arthroscopy. Primary OA was diagnosed in 14 joints (20%), and the remaining 53 joints were regarded as having secondary OA. No differences were detected in the levels of KS in the synovial fluid from the primary and secondary OA joints. Furthermore, the 3B3(-) epitope was not detectable in the synovial fluid aspirates of any TMJ. CONCLUSION: Secondary OA is a common disorder of the TMJ. However, there is no apparent difference in the metabolism of the joints with primary and secondary OA as assessed by proteoglycans in the synovial fluid. The apparent absence of the 3b3(-) epitope, in contrast to its presence in OA of other major synovial joints, suggests that there are some differences between the cartilage metabolism of the TMJ and these other joints during OA.
Collagenase and gelatinase are matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs) which play an important role in tissue destruction in arthritic joints. Studies have demonstrated that tetracyclines can inhibit MMPs and prevent tissue destruction independent of their antimicrobial activity. The purpose of this pilot study is to assess the potential therapeutic role of Doxycycline in patients with advanced osteoarthritis of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ). This ongoing investigation includes patients with a diagnosis of osteoarthritis of the TMJ based on clinical and diagnostic imaging findings, symptoms (localized TMJ pain, limited mobility, dysfunction) for a minimum of 36 months, and failure of previous non-surgical and surgical modalities to alleviate the symptoms. A synovial fluid sample is collected by a saline injection and aspiration technique, followed by diagnostic arthroscopy. Patients are placed on Doxycycline 50 mg BID for three months and then undergo repeat diagnostic arthroscopy and synovial fluid collection. The samples are stored at -80 degrees C. Collagenase activity is determined by a combination of SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and fluorography and calculated based on the percentage of collagen alpha chains that are degraded into alphaA breakdown products. Three patients have completed the three-month course of Doxycycline thus far, and 5 joints with osteoarthritis have been analyzed. All patients were female (mean age = 35, mean duration of symptoms = 132 months) and had undergone previous bilateral arthroscopies. One patient had undergone unilateral arthroplasty. The mean collagenase activity showed 55% collagen lysis prior to Doxycycline treatment and 19% after three months of therapy. The mean gelatinase activity was 28% prior to Doxycycline treatment and 7% after three months of therapy. The mean interincisal opening was 33 mm initially and 41 mm after three months of Doxycycline. Subjectively, two of the three patients reported significant improvement in their overall symptoms, which they had not experienced over the previous three years. One patient did not experience any change in symptoms, in spite of a marked reduction in collagenase activity from 86.4% to 9.6%. Because of the very small numbers of patients enrolled in this pilot study so far, no statistically significant differences could be appreciated. However, the dramatic reduction in collagenase activity in these patients, with a long history of TMJ symptoms from osteoarthritis, suggests the potential promising role of Doxycycline in the management of osteoarthritis, and further investigation is warranted.
PURPOSE: The specific aims of this investigation were to determine if there is a relationship between an arthroscopic diagnosis of synovitis and osteoarthritis, and if the presence of synovitis influences the level of cartilage degradation, as evidenced by keratan sulfate levels in the synovial fluid. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Arthroscopic surgery was performed on 114 temporomandibular joints in 88 patients who had significant pain or dysfunction and whose condition had failed to improve with conservative treatment. Synovial fluid aspirates were obtained immediately before arthroscopy and used for the determination of keratan sulfate levels. Arthroscopic examination included assessment of the presence or absence of osteoarthritis and synovitis. RESULTS: Synovitis was present in 90% of joints, and osteoarthritis was present in 62% of joints examined arthroscopically. Both osteoarthritis and synovitis existed in 57% of the joints. Joints with an arthroscopic diagnosis of synovitis had significantly lower levels of keratan sulfate in the synovial fluid aspirates than joints with osteoarthritis. Synovial fluid aspirates from temporomandibular joints with osteoarthritis had significantly higher levels of keratan sulfate than synovial fluids from joints without osteoarthritis. CONCLUSIONS: Osteoarthritis and synovitis are common diagnoses and are often present concurrently in patients with symptomatic temporomandibular joints. Osteoarthritis is associated with elevated keratan sulfate levels; however, the elevation of keratan sulfate is less in patients with concomitant synovitis.
Temporomandibular disorders are a complex group of conditions which are common causes of orofacial pain and are frequently associated with headaches. Because a wide variety of diseases can ultimately cause symptoms that result in dysfunction of the masticatory system, it is important for the clinician to establish an accurate diagnosis and rule out any serious neurologic pathology. Serious extra-articular conditions often can simulate the nonspecific symptoms of a temporomandibular joint disorder. A careful history and clinical examination of the head, neck, and cranial nerves are important in establishing a differential diagnosis. Diagnostic imaging and consultation with specialists in several disciplines are often necessary to establish an accurate diagnosis and develop an appropriate therapeutic regimen.
The orthopedic literature has clearly demonstrated that the physical stimulus of motion is essential for the maintenance of the structural and functional integrity of synovial joints. As a result of this information, rehabilitation with passive motion has become an extremely important part of the rehabilitation of synovial joints throughout the body, especially when there is limited range of motion. This same biological principle must be applied to the temporomandibular joint, especially when there is limitation in mandibular mobility. The effects of limited joint mobility, as well as passive motion, on the articular and extra-articular components of synovial joints is reviewed in detail. The clinical application of these principles in the management of temporomandibular disorders is emphasized.
To understand the importance of motion on the structural and functional integrity of the temporomandibular joint (TMJ), the effects of immobilization and mobilization on synovial joints are reviewed. Impaired motion has profound deleterious effects on the synovial membrane, articular cartilage, muscles, ligaments, bone, and periarticular connective tissue. Conversely, motion has been shown to be essential to the maintenance of the structural and functional integrity of synovial joints. As in other synovial joints, the relative lack of the stimulus of mobility of the TMJ contributes to pathogenic mechanisms. Restoration of joint mobility is an important principle in the management of TMJ disorders. Illustrative cases are presented in which passive motion therapy, using a new device with a hydraulic mechanism, was successfully used for rehabilitation of TMJ function.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
A case of human papillomavirus-associated condyloma acuminatum in the oral cavity, presumed to be fulminant cyclosporine-induced gingival hyperplasia, is reported in a 55-year-old cardiac transplant patient. Approximately 47 months following the transplant, the patient developed severe hyperplasia of the uvula and oral mucosa, resulting in difficulty swallowing. The histopathologic features of the lesion were typical of those of condyloma acuminatum. In situ hybridization of the paraffin-embedded material revealed infection with human papillomavirus types 6/11. This case lends further support to the putative role of long-term cellular immunosuppression in the development of human papillomavirus-associated squamous lesions. In addition, positive staining for p53 protein raises the possibility of concomitant p53 involvement in the pathogenesis of this oral lesion.
A thorough understanding of the structure and function of diarthrodial joints is necessary for clinicians who treat individuals with temporomandibular disorders. Surgical procedures must be based on principles designed to restore and preserve joint physiology. The surgical management of patients with temporomandibular joint disorders not only requires adherence to surgical principles that make sense from a physiologic basis, but also an understanding of the disease process and continued nonsurgical management that is aimed at reducing or eliminating factors which perpetuate joint overloading.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The role of osteoarthrosis (OA) and proteoglycan degradation in the pathogenesis of temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorders has not been well established. The orthopaedic literature has demonstrated that proteoglycan degradation plays a significant role in the pathology of many joints. The purpose of this investigation was to determine if levels of immunoreactive keratan sulfate (an important component of cartilage proteoglycans) present in synovial fluid aspirates from TMJs correlated with arthroscopically demonstrated OA. Temporomandibular joint arthroscopy was performed on 25 joints in 20 patients and synovial fluid aspirates were obtained just prior to the insertion of arthroscopic cannulas. The results showed that synovial fluid aspirates from joints that arthroscopically demonstrated OA had significantly higher levels of keratan sulfate than synovial fluid aspirates from those joints that showed no evidence of OA (NON-OA). This study gives support to the theory that the pathogenesis of OA of the TMJ is similar to that of chondromalacia of other synovial joints. The combination of TMJ arthroscopy and synovial fluid analysis is an important model that can be used for investigation of the pathogenesis of TMJ disorders.