PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

H Brodaty

Publications and source records attributed to H Brodaty.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources
PubMed1992

Comparison of clinician rated and family corroborative witness data for depressed patients.

There appear to be few published studies that have examined the levels of agreement between ratings of features of depression as assessed by clinicians and by corroborative witnesses. We therefore report a study of 141 depressed patients assessed by a clinical psychiatrist at a semi-structured interview, reviewing family and historical data as well as depressive symptoms, and rated on a series of designated mental state signs. A family member completed questionnaire data assessing the same features. Moderate agreement was obtained only for several historical items (e.g., previous depressive episode, response to ECT). Agreement was minimal or non-existent on numerous clinical symptoms and signs of depression. A number of sources of disagreement are considered, and it is suggested that discordance may have emerged principally from the contrasting domains and training experiences of the clinicians and the corroborative witnesses.

Adjustment Disorders↗
PubMed1992

Are there any differences between bipolar and unipolar melancholia?

Although it is now more than 30 years since Leohard originally proposed the distinction between bipolar and monopolar (unipolar) forms of affective disorder, there have been relatively few studies which have investigated clinical features which may differentiate the depressed phase of bipolar disorder from unipolar depression. In this study we examined the value of a new scale for rating depressive mental state signs (the 'core' score system), and a large series of symptoms and risk factors, in distinguishing between 27 age and sex-matched pairs of bipolar and unipolar patients diagnosed as melancholic on several diagnostic criteria. In general, we found a marked similarity between the groups on clinical features of the depressive episode when allowance was made for multiple tests. Bipolar patients, however, had shorter episodes of depression and were less likely to demonstrate 'slowed movements' than unipolar subjects. There were also consistent trends on other items for psychomotor retardation to be less common and agitation to be more likely in the bipolar patients. At the least, these findings suggest that the widely-held belief that bipolar depressed patients typically have psychomotor retardation is not as clear-cut as has been previously described.

Bipolar Disorder↗
PubMed1992

Predicting the course of melancholic and nonmelancholic depression. A naturalistic comparison study.

We assessed improvement patterns and predictors of outcome over a 1-year period, in a sample of depressed patients receiving treatment from a specialized mood disorders unit. Patients with melancholia had a differential improvement pattern from the nonmelancholics in the first 20 weeks, but case rates and severity levels were comparable at 20 weeks and at 1 year. Only three variables (older age at first episode, less severe depression and extraversion) were predictors of improvement in both groups. Improvement was predicted by less psychomotor disturbance, absence of personality disorder, and higher social functioning in the melancholic patients. A reported absence of timidity and shyness in childhood, a briefer duration of depression, and receipt of individual psychotherapy predicted a better outcome in the nonmelancholic patients. Although significant predictors were few overall, the suggested differential relevance for most of the isolated predictors argues for outcome studies that examine melancholic and nonmelancholic depressive disorders separately.

Age Factors↗
PubMed1992

Interpersonal sensitivity and the one-year outcome of a depressive episode.

Previous studies have demonstrated that abnormalities of personality can contribute to a poor prognosis following a depressive episode. In this study the relevance of a specific personality trait, interpersonal sensitivity, to poor outcome was examined. One hundred and eleven depressives completed the Interpersonal Sensitivity Measure (IPSM) twenty weeks after a baseline assessment. High scores on the IPSM were associated with a poor outcome at one year following the baseline assessment, judged according to whether they had remitted clinically or not and by the degree of change in depression severity measured using the Hamilton and Zung Depression Rating Scales. The relevance of this personality trait to the course and treatment of depression is discussed.

Adolescent↗
PubMed1991

Age and depression.

The interaction of age and depression was investigated by comparing differences between elderly (greater than or equal to 60 years old) and younger consecutive in- and out-patient referrals to a tertiary referral mood disorders unit. Older patients with unipolar major depressive episode were more likely to be psychotic and agitated regardless of depressive subtype and less likely to have personality inadequacies or a family history of affective disorder. In this sample, elderly depressives' rating of diagnosis, severity, endogeneity and social impairment were similar, irrespective of age of first onset of depression, but a positive family history and personality abnormalities were less likely in late-onset depressives.

Adjustment Disorders↗
PubMed1991

Distinguishing psychotic and non-psychotic melancholia.

To examine the necessary and sufficient status of delusions and hallucinations as clinical features of psychotic (delusional) depression, we studied a consecutive sample of 137 patients meeting DSM-III, RDC and our clinical criteria for endogenous depression/melancholia, of whom 35 had delusions and/or hallucinations, and represented our putative 'psychotic depressives' (PDs). The PDs were contrasted with the remaining 'endogenous depressives' (the EDs), and an age- and sex-matched subsample of the latter, the MEDs. Univariate and multivariate analyses of clinical features established that, in addition to the presence of delusions and/or hallucinations, the PDs could be distinguished in particular by severe psychomotor disturbance, as well as by sustained and unvarying depressive content, the absence of any diurnal mood variation and by constipation. Latent class analyses suggested that overt psychotic features (such as delusions and hallucinations) were sufficient but not necessary for a subject to be assigned to the 'psychotic' latent class, and a subsequent chart review suggested that, in some PDs actual psychotic features may not be able to be elicited because of severe psychomotor change, suggesting that clinical reliance on eliciting delusions or hallucinations may result in a number of 'masked psychotic depressives' escaping valid diagnosis.

Affective Disorders, Psychotic↗
PubMed1991

Growth hormone and other hormonal responses to clonidine in melancholic and nonmelancholic depressed subjects and controls.

To study putative differences in central neurotransmitter function in depressive subtypes, growth hormone, adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH), cortisol, and prolactin responses to the alpha 2-noradrenergic receptor agonist clonidine (1.3 micrograms/kg i.v.) were examined in 26 subjects with major depression, 13 of whom had melancholia. The responses of 10 of these endogenous/melancholic subjects were compared with those of 10 controls who were matched to the patients on age, sex, and menopausal status. In 15 of the depressed subjects, prolactin and cortisol responses to the putative serotonergic agonist fenfluramine were also examined to test for associations between these challenges. There were no significant differences in any of the responses between melancholic and nonmelancholic depressive subgroups after controlling for age and sex. With the exception of a greater reduction in ACTH in the endogenous/melancholic subjects, there were also no significant differences in hormonal responses between these patients and controls. There was, however, a significantly greater reduction in systolic blood pressure in the control subjects. There were no significant correlations between the responses to clonidine and fenfluramine. The findings suggest that clonidine at a dosage of 1.3 micrograms/kg is neither able to differentiate reliably between depressive subtypes nor to differentiate reliably between depressed and control subjects.

Adrenocorticotropic Hormone↗
PubMed1991

Psychosocial risk factors distinguishing melancholic and nonmelancholic depression: a comparison of six systems.

We examined six systems or scales designed to distinguish melancholia from residual nonmelancholic depressive disorders in a sample of 305 patients. A count of the number of significant psychosocial risk factors showed that a clinical diagnosis was the most differentiating (19 significant risk factors), followed by the Newcastle index (13), DSM-III (10), and the CORE system (10)--the last essentially assessing psychomotor change; Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC) (7) and an endogeneity symptom scale (2) were the least differentiating. A subsample of "composite melancholics" was derived, comprising 138 who met "melancholia" criteria for DSM-III, RDC, and CORE, and they were contrasted with residual depressives. The composite melancholics were older, had had a briefer depressive episode, and differed significantly on 12 risk factors, essentially being less likely to report deprivational experiences such as deficient parenting and dysfunctional marital relationships. We suggest that such a risk factor strategy is of potential use in refining the clinical definition of melancholia.

Adaptation, Psychological↗
PubMed1991

Cost effectiveness of a training program for dementia carers.

An intensive 10-day residential training program for dementia carers has previously been shown to be associated with increased patient survival at home and decreased psychological morbidity in carers (Brodaty & Gresham, 1989). Results from a further follow-up, about 39 months after entry into the trial, were even more impressive. Patients whose carers had trained in the program had much higher adjusted rates of survival at home (53% versus 13%) and, unexpectedly, fewer deaths (20% versus 41%) than those whose carers did not have training. Patients whose carers had delayed training achieved intermediate results (31% surviving at home and 21% dying). These results were achieved with an average saving of $A7,967 ($U.S.5975) per patient over the first 39 months.

Aged↗
PubMed1991

Psychotic depression: a review and clinical experience.

We review research literature on psychotic (delusional) depression, including demographic, illness pattern, clinical, biological marker and treatment issues. Secondly, we report a study of a consecutive sample of 137 patients meeting criteria for DSM-III melancholia, RDC definite endogenous depression and our "clinical" criteria for endogenous depression, of whom there were 35 "psychotic depressives" (PDs). The PDs were contrasted with the remaining 76 depressives (EDs) and with an age and sex-matched subset (MEDs). The PDs were distinctly older than the EDs at assessment and at initial onset of any affective disorder. Compared to the MEDs, they tended to have longer illnesses, were more likely to be hospitalised (and to have longer stays), to receive (in the past and for the current episode) combination antipsychotic/antidepressant medication and/or ECT, and to have a poorer course over the following year. They were no more likely to have a bipolar pattern, a family history of depressive disorder, schizophrenia or alcoholism, or vegetative depressive features. Developmental psychosocial stressors and antecedent life event stressors were not over-represented. Most of the PDs had delusions, one-fifth reported hallucinations and psychomotor disturbance was marked. Other differential clinical findings were sustained mood disturbance, constipation, and the absence of a diurnal variation in mood and energy.

Adult↗
PubMed1991

Depression sub-typing: unitary, binary or arbitrary?

The strongest statistical support for the binary view of depression has been provided by factor (principal components) analytic studies which delineate a bipolar factor with features interpreted as reflecting "endogenous depression" and "neurotic depression" at opposing poles. We review the seminal studies to suggest instead that the bipolar factor has generally polarised depression and anxiety, and that no such entity or symptom complex of "neurotic depression" has been isolated. Instead "neurotic depression" has been defined principally by features of anxiety and personality style. We argue that the suggested entity is, in fact, a pseudo-entity, being no more than a residual group of non-depressive features without any significant intrinsic depressive characteristics. We support our interpretation by showing comparable solutions in published studies of depressives alone, contrasted with separate analyses of anxious and depressed patients. We also report two studies in which the "neurotic depressive" pole is made to appear and disappear by the inclusion and exclusion of anxiety items. As factor analytic studies have defined the "residual" pole so variably, we argue that some features held to distinguish neurotic depression are of no utility and that such a diagnosis is meaningless. We suggest that the clinician should not proceed (after excluding endogenous depression) to conclude that the default option is necessarily an entity "neurotic depression" and that instead a heterogeneous group of options (e.g. anxiety, personality disorder) require review. If the "neurotic depressive" type of the multivariate analytic studies is a pseudo-entity, then a modified unitary view of depression may be valid.

Adult↗
PubMed1991

Carbamazepine for treatment-resistant melancholia.

BACKGROUND: There have only been a few studies of the role of carbamazepine in the management of treatment-resistant depression. METHOD: The response to carbamazepine of 16 melancholic patients, who had been depressed for an extended period despite a number of standard treatments, was studied retrospectively. RESULTS: Seven patients (44%) had a moderate or marked improvement. The responders included both psychotic and nonpsychotic depressives, and patients with concurrent organic brain disease. There was, however, a high rate of complications, with 5 of these 7 responders (71%) having to discontinue carbamazepine because of adverse effects. This high rate of complications may have reflected the older age of our sample. CONCLUSION: These findings suggest the efficacy of carbamazepine in melancholic patients who have not responded to conventional treatments, but indicate that the high rate of significant side effects may limit its long-term usefulness.

Adult↗
PubMed1990

Perceived dysfunctional intimate relationships: a specific association with the non-melancholic depressive subtype.

Associations between perceptions of dysfunctional current intimate relationships and subtypes of depressive disorders were quantified in a sample of 136 patients, using the Intimate Bond Measure (IBM). Deficient care was two to three times more likely to be reported by patients with non-melancholic disorders than by matched subjects, but was no more likely to be reported by patients with melancholic disorders, suggesting a risk factor selective for depressive type. Patients who reported markedly deficient care in childhood were more likely to report very poor current intimate relationships. For the remaining patients, however, no evidence of continuity between a dysfunctional parental relationship and a current dysfunctional intimate relationship was found.

Adult↗
PubMed1990

Low diagnostic yield in a memory disorders clinic.

A review of the first 144 patients to attend a Memory Disorders Clinic found not one case of treatable dementia. The use of a routine comprehensive battery of investigations was not supported: however, computerized tomographic brain scans and electroencephalograms were moderately useful in diagnosing dementia. Clinical features and historical data did not discriminate early- from late-onset Alzheimer's disease or Alzheimer's disease from multi-infarct dementia.

Activities of Daily Living↗
PubMed1990

Depressive type and state effects on personality measures.

We examine the hypothesis that the effect of mood state on personality questionnaire scores is more a function of diagnosis than of depression severity. Sixteen endogenous and 83 neurotic depressives completed a battery of personality questionnaires at a baseline assessment and again 20 weeks later. Scores on the personality measures changed significantly. Endogenous depressives were found to have more pronounced changes on measures of dependence and timidity, but when change in mood state was partialed out only one of the dependence measures and timidity remained significant. Thus the hypothesis only received partial support--change in mood state appears to be the major factor in elevating personality questionnaire scores.

Adolescent↗
PubMed1990

Personality differences between patients with remitted melancholic and nonmelancholic depression.

Seventy-five patients with remitted depression were categorized as having melancholic-endogenous or non-melancholic-nonendogenous depression according to DSM-III criteria, Research Diagnostic Criteria, and the Newcastle endogeneity scale. The patients' scores on four personality scales--the Eysenck Personality Inventory, the Interpersonal Dependency Inventory, locus of control, and the Interpersonal Sensitivity Measure--were then compared. Patients with nonmelancholic-nonendogenous depression were generally rated as having more vulnerable personality styles, but the differences were dependent on the particular diagnostic system used. A principal components analysis isolated three underlying personality constructs--dependency, introversion, and timidity. Patients with nonmelancholic-nonendogenous depression scored as significantly more dependent.

Adult↗