PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

H M Proskin

Publications and source records attributed to H M Proskin.

At least 73 records · Page 4Linked to original sources
PubMed1995

Clinical anticaries efficacy of NaF and SMFP dentifrices: overview and resolution of the scientific controversy.

Since the introduction of commercially marketed fluoride-containing dentifrices in the 1950s, the evolution of these products has seen a number of formulation changes, particularly with regard to the specific types of active fluoride agents they contain. Most currently marketed dentifrices contain one of two major fluoride compounds--sodium fluoride (NaF), or sodium monofluorophosphate (SMFP)--and much research effort has gone into continued investigations geared toward determining which, if either, of these two agents provides dentifrices with greater levels of anticaries efficacy. Historically, among clinical studies, most single-investigation attempts to resolve this issue have yielded equivocal results. During the past two years, however, renewed attempts on a larger scale have been made, including scientific symposia in Toronto, London, and Stockholm sponsored by major manufacturers of dentifrices. The conflicting conclusions derived from these undertakings have resulted in a scientific controversy as to which represents the most accurate resolution to the fluoride-comparison issue. The present paper considers processes for addressing this controversy, and identifies the key points of difference among those processes by which the three symposia arrived at their respective conclusions. An objective procedure for addressing the fluoride-comparison issue is offered, and applied to the clinical data which is currently available in the literature. The results of this analysis indicate that: 1) There is no statistically significant difference between the anticaries effectiveness of dentifrices containing fluoride as SMFP, and those containing fluoride as NaF; and 2) There is no clinically meaningful difference between the anticaries effectiveness of dentifrices containing fluoride as SMFP, and those containing fluoride as NaF.

Cariostatic Agents↗
PubMed1995

Comparative attributes for the description of the relative efficacy of therapeutic agents: general concepts and definitions, and application to the American Dental Association guidelines for the comparison of the clinical anticaries efficacy of fluoride dentifrices.

Comparative attributes are terms or phrases commonly employed in the vernacular of the biomedical literature to convey the results of comparative studies. Examples are such terms as "equivalent" or "superior." Recently, there has developed an increasing tendency in certain areas of application toward the institution of guidelines which provide both a uniform set of criteria for defining such attributes and a set of requirements which must be satisfied in order to demonstrate that such attributes may hold in a particular situation. The present paper provides a general discussion of comparative attributes, from which the application of the underlying concepts to any particular context might better be understood. Second, it provides an explicit and comprehensive discussion regarding the American Dental Associations's guidelines concerning the attributions of "superiority," "equivalence," and "at least as good as," as they are applied to the comparison of the clinical anticaries efficacy of fluoride dentifrices.

American Dental Association↗
PubMed1995

A comparative clinical investigation of the safety and efficacy of an oscillating/rotating electric toothbrush and a sonic toothbrush.

This clinical study compared the ability of a sonic toothbrush to remove plaque and control gingivitis with that of an oscillating/rotating electric toothbrush. One-hundred and sixteen subjects from a general population were randomly allocated to either a sonic toothbrush group (Sonicare) or an electric toothbrush group (Braun Oral-B Plaque Remover). After 8 weeks use, there was found to be no statistically significant difference in either plaque removal or gingival index between the two groups. Both devices were found to be safe, but whereas 100% of volunteers in the Braun Oral-B Plaque Remover group expressed a wish to continue using the toothbrush, approximately 25% of the Sonicare group did not like the device and said that they would not continue to use it. The Sonicare device was found to offer no advantages in clinical terms over an established oscillating/rotating electric toothbrush (Braun Oral-B Plaque Remover) with respect to removal of supragingival plaque or improvement in gingival health.

Adult↗
PubMed1995

Serendipitous results of a pilot study: precaution indicated.

A pilot study was conducted to estimate sample size for a clinical trial in a F area. In 1992, 98 children 14 years of age living in Fall River, MA were examined for dental caries: Fall River was fluoridated in 1973. Residence histories showed that 74% lived there from birth (B), 12% were residents from kindergarten or 1st grade (K1) and 14% moved into the community at a later time (LT). Findings on caries prevalence showed an inverse relation between DMFS and initial age of residence; mean DMFS was 3.00 for Group B, 5.33 for Group K1 and 6.93 for Group LT. A one-way ANOVA indicated significant differences among the groups (p=0.05). Because residence from birth or from early life can be considered a proxy for systemic fluoride exposure, and because controversy currently surrounds the issue of topical versus systemic benefits in explaining the mechanism of action of fluoride, the results appeared to have importance. However, internal analyses of the data comparing surface-specific (pit and fissure) results among the groups for early erupting teeth with varying systemic exposure to fluoridated water and for late erupting teeth, all with appreciable systemic exposure, showed comparable relative differences in DMFS scores. Lack of internal validity, therefore, discounted a conclusion from overall results of the role of systemic fluorides in providing decay preventive benefits. If there is any conclusion that can be drawn it is that serendipitous escapades with data from a pilot study, if not rigorously analyzed and cautiously interpreted, tend to further muddy the waters (fluoridated in this case) on controversial issues and should best be avoided.

Adolescent↗
PubMed1994

Recommended revisions to American Dental Association guidelines for acceptance of chemotherapeutic products for gingivitis control. Report of the Task Force on Design and Analysis in Dental and Oral Research to the Council on Therapeutics of the American Dental Association.

This paper presents suggested revisions to the American Dental Association's 1985 guidelines for acceptance of anti-gingivitis chemotherapeutic agents. The areas of study design, choice and quality control of clinical gingivitis measurements, statistical analysis, and minimum strength of effect, are addressed. The revisions articulate certain aspects of study design which were implicit in the 1985 guidelines, clarify language on cross-over designs and independence of studies, and recommend use of a United States population in at least one trial supporting a product. Separate recording and analysis of a product's effect on gingival bleeding is proposed, and quality control of clinical measurements receives enhanced emphasis. Modestly elaborated statistical reporting guidelines and strengthened approval criteria, based on size of estimated effect as well as statistical significance, are advocated.

American Dental Association↗
PubMed1994

Proposed guidelines for American Dental Association acceptance of products for professional, non-surgical treatment of adult periodontitis. Task Force on Design and Analysis in Dental and Oral Research.

Guidelines are suggested for determining efficacy of products to supplement scaling and root planing in professional, non-surgical treatment of adult periodontitis. They result from an extended process including a conference on clinical trials in gingivitis and periodontitis, a subsequent workshop, and commentary from industrial, academic, professional and governmental members of the periodontal research community on two drafts. Recommendations are made in the broad areas of basic study design, subject and periodontal site selection, clinical management, choice of outcome variables, statistical summarization and analysis, and criteria for acceptance. Prominent dissenting views, with justifications for positions taken here, are also provided. Groundwork is laid for possible future guidelines addressing products for primary prevention or over-the-counter uses, or for determining superiority or equivalence of competing products. However, issues are identified which require further exploration before responsible and widely acceptable recommendations can be made in these areas. The guidelines suggested here are meant to form the basis of an evolving document rather than a static standard. It is suggested that they be reviewed frequently in the light of improvement in the technology available for periodontal research, and the emergence of products representing new approaches to periodontal therapy.

Adult↗
PubMed1994

Calcium fluoride formation on sound enamel using fluoride solutions with and without lactate.

The formation of calcium (Ca) fluoride (CaF2) on bovine enamel blocks during clinically relevant treatment times using neutral fluoride (F) solutions (0.26 mol/l F) with and without 0.1 mol/l lactate was investigated. Uncoated and pellicle-coated blocks were evaluated for alkali-soluble (1 mol/l KOH, three consecutive 24-hour treatments) Ca, PO4, and F after treatment by the F solutions for 0, 5, 15, 30, and 60 min. There was an overall time-related increase in F recovery, while Ca tended to remain at baseline levels. Less F was recovered from the pellicle-coated blocks. The addition of lactate to the F treatment solution did not result in an overall increase in alkali-soluble F recovery, but did result in the formation of cuboidal shaped crystals which closely approached the morphology of pure CaF2. A 1:2 stoichiometric ratio Ca:2F (mol:mol) was not established based on chemical analyses. The ultrastructural and elemental composition of surface deposits on the samples, as determined using scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, and energy-dispersive spectroscopy, established the presence of CaF2 after 24-hour F treatments; however, it was not possible to directly demonstrate the formation of CaF2 after clinically relevant treatment times.

Animals↗
PubMed1994

Evaluation of the reproducibility of rest activity of the anterior temporal and masseter muscles in asymptomatic and symptomatic temporomandibular subjects.

There is a general assumption that temporomandibular disorders and the pain and tenderness of mastication muscles may be caused by hyperactivity. Five asymptomatic men, five asymptomatic women, and five women with temporomandibular disorders participated in this study. Multiple examinations were performed to provide information concerning the reproducibility of the rest electromyographic signals. No significant differences between groups were noted. This study supports the contention that the mean rest activity in women with pain and dysfunction is less than or equal to that of sex-matched controls.

Adult↗
PubMed1994

Meta-analysis in dental research: a paradigm for performance and interpretation.

Applications of meta-analysis have begun to appear with some regularity in the dental research literature. Recently, a meta-analysis played a high-profile role in the ongoing academic debate concerning the relative anticaries efficacy of dentifrices containing fluoride as sodium fluoride and as sodium monofluorophosphate, engendering a controversy concerning the methodology employed. This has given rise to the need for a careful consideration of the principles involved in the meta-analytic process to provide a basis of understanding upon which such controversies may be resolved. The present report endeavors to meet this need by enumerating the steps involved in a meta-analysis, and contrasting them with the analogous steps in the more widely-understood "usual" inferential process, bringing to light both the similarities and differences between these two types of analyses. Within this context, the conflicting meta-analyses associated with the current controversy are discussed and compared, and the source of the difference between them is readily identified. This process reaffirms the need for close collaboration between statisticians and other scientists in the performance of a meta-analysis, and the value of such close collaboration in the evaluation and interpretation of a meta-analysis performed by others, as well.

Dental Caries↗
PubMed1993

Microbial contamination of hydrophilic contact lenses: quantitation and identification of microorganisms associated with contact lenses while on the eye.

Previous studies have demonstrated the presence of microorganisms on hydrogel contact lenses under various usage conditions. We conducted this study to quantify and identify viable bacteria and fungi associated with hydrogel contact lenses while on the eye. We removed the lenses from patients' eyes using aseptic techniques and cultured them to identify loosely adherent, as well as lens bound, microorganisms. Lenses were vortexed in a transfer medium (thereafter called the lens extract) and the lenses were then incubated in an agar sandwich separately from the transfer medium. We cultured 108 lenses (82 daily wear and 26 extended wear) from 49 patients. Bacteria were cultured from 38% (41) of the lenses; for 31 of these 41 lenses bacteria were isolated only from the lens extracts (made by vortexing lenses in a transfer medium), suggesting a transient association with the lenses. No fungi were isolated. Counts of less than 10 colony forming units (CFU)/lens were observed on 89% of the lenses. Staphylococcus epidermidis were the most frequently isolated bacteria. A statistically significant relation was observed between increased CFU/lens and increased lens age for extended wear lenses (p = 0.028).

Adult↗
PubMed1993

Comparison between mechanical cleaning and an antimicrobial rinse for the treatment and prevention of interdental gingivitis.

This study compared the efficacy of an antimicrobial mouthrinse (0.12% chlorhexidine gluconate) plus toothbrushing (mouthrinse group), mechanical interdental cleaning plus toothbrushing (mechanical group), and toothbrushing alone (control group), at reducing and preventing interdental gingival inflammation. 92 male subjects were examined for interdental inflammation using the Eastman interdental bleeding index at baseline, then monthly for 3 months after using one of the above oral hygiene regimens. The mechanical cleaning group had significant reductions in bleeding sites compared to baseline at 1 month (56.90% versus 13.17%) that persisted throughout the study (2 months = 6.65%, 3 months = 5.70%). The other regimens showed no significant bleeding reduction at any time point in the study. The mechanical interdental cleaning group showed improvement over baseline at 1 month with the full benefit apparent after 2 months. The effect of location in the mouth on bleeding reduction was also assessed. The % of posterior sites which bled was always higher than anterior sites. Analysis of maxillary versus mandibular, and buccal versus lingual sites showed no significant differences. Additional observations of the data demonstrated that sites which bled at baseline were more likely to stop bleeding in the mechanical cleaning group. Also, sites which did not bleed at baseline were unlikely to bleed subsequently when mechanical cleaning was used. Neither of these observations were true for the other cleaning regimens. These data show that only mechanical interdental plaque removal combined with toothbrushing is effective at reducing or preventing interdental inflammation. This underscores the importance of instituting mechanical interdental cleaning to eliminate interdental inflammation.

Adolescent↗
PubMed1993

Effect of chewing xylitol chewing gum on salivary flow rate and the acidogenic potential of dental plaque.

Ten adults participated in the study which consisted of four experimental periods each lasting 2 weeks, during each of which subjects were assigned to one of four gum-chewing regimens: no gum, sucrose gum, sorbitol gum and xylitol gum. At the start and end of each test period unstimulated and stimulated salivary flow rates were determined. At the end of each test period the acidogenic potential of 48-hour dental plaque was measured using a Beetrode pH microelectrode. No statistically significant (p < 0.05) effect on salivary flow rate was observed. The xylitol chewing gum regimen resulted in significantly higher plaque pH than no gum, sucrose gum and sorbitol gum at 2, 10, 20, 30 and 60 min following a 10% sucrose rinse. In addition, xylitol gum regimen exhibited a significantly higher minimum pH and smaller area of the curve below pH 6. The results suggest that the regular use of xylitol-sweetened gum may serve to reduce the acidogenic potential of dental plaque.

Adult↗
PubMed1993

Caries risk assessment by a cross-sectional discrimination model.

Although the prevalence of dental caries is continuing to decline, it still affects a majority of the US population and can be a serious problem for those afflicted. The objective of this project was to develop and perfect a model for assessment of risk of dental caries onset in children. In the first study, reported herein, a set of clinical, microbiological, biochemical, and socio-demographic variables was identified that distinguished, with an acceptable level of sensitivity and specificity, between children who had no previous caries experience and children who had high caries levels. A total of 313 children--age 12-15 years, 140 from a fluoridated community and 173 from a fluoride-deficient community--was selected on the basis of previous caries experience, either zero DMFS or high DMFS (> or = 6 in the fluoridated or > or = 8 in the fluoride-deficient community). Clinical exams for DMFS, dental fluorosis, and plaque were conducted. Stimulated whole saliva was collected for analysis of mutans streptococci, lactobacilli, total viable flora, and fluoride concentration. A questionnaire was used for collection of demographic data as well as information on prior fluoride exposure, dietary habits, and oral hygiene practices. By means of discriminant analyses, with use of seven key clinical and laboratory variables, it was possible for zero-DMFS subjects to e classified correctly (specificity) in 77.6% of cases in the fluoridated community and in 86.1% of cases in the fluoride-deficient community. High-caries subjects were classified as such (sensitivity) in 79.3% and 88.1% of cases, respectively.

Adolescent↗
PubMed1993

Caries risk assessment in a longitudinal discrimination study.

Our objective was to develop and perfect a model for the assessment of risk of dental caries onset in children. Even though dental caries prevalence in children is continuing to decline, there is still a significant minority for whom it is a problem. In this study, we sought to ascertain whether a set of variables selected in a previous cross-sectional study could be used to differentiate between caries-free six-year-olds who would or would not subsequently present with clinically-detectable caries. A total of 472 caries-free six-year-olds--286 from a fluoridated community and 186 from a fluoride-deficient community--was selected. Clinical examinations for DMFS, dental fluorosis, and plaque were conducted. Stimulated whole saliva was collected for analysis of mutants streptococci, lactobacilli, total viable flora, and fluoride, calcium, and phosphate concentrations. A questionnaire was used for collection of demographic data as well as information on prior fluoride exposure, dietary habits, and oral hygiene practices. By means of linear discriminant analyses, it was possible to predict correctly which children would develop caries within six to 12 months (sensitivity) in 82.8% of cases and which children would not develop caries during that period (specificity) in 82.4% of cases.

Apatites↗
PubMed1993

Statistical considerations related to a meta-analytic evaluation of published caries clinical studies comparing the anticaries efficacy of dentifrices containing sodium fluoride and sodium monofluorophosphate.

The comparison of the anticaries efficacy of dentifrices containing sodium fluoride (NaF) and sodium monofluorophosphate (SMFP) has recently been addressed through a meta-analysis of published head-to-head clinical trials. Such an analysis is used to provide an omnibus conclusion on the basis of summary information obtained from several individual studies. An important aspect of a meta-analysis is the determination of which studies from among those available in the relevant literature are to be incorporated into the calculations. The statistical literature provides several perspectives with respect to this issue. A recently-published meta-analysis by Johnson (1993) resulted in the conclusion that dentifrices containing NaF provide significantly lower caries increments than do those containing SMFP. However, a similar analysis utilizing studies identified by Volpe, Petrone & Davies (1993) suggests that no such significant difference exists. The resolution of such conflicting results rests on clinical judgment concerning the issue of study inclusion. The clinical significance of the results of both of these analyses was considered. Despite the differences in the analyses, both support the conclusion that dentifrices containing SMFP provide equivalent anticaries protection as do those containing NaF, in accordance with the standards established in the current American Dental Association Guidelines for the comparison of fluoride dentifrices.

American Dental Association↗
PubMed1992

Examiner reliability for an invasive gingival bleeding index.

This investigation was undertaken to determine the intra- and inter-examiner reliability of the method of stimulation for bleeding used in the Eastman interdental bleeding index. 26 subjects were examined twice, 1 h apart, by either a single examiner or 2 examiners in each half of their mouths, for the presence bleeding after stimulation with a wooden interdental cleaner. Scores were tabulated and intra- and inter-examiner % agreements and kappa-coefficients calculated. Z-tests were performed on the pairs of agreement statistics to check for significant differences. Overall, intra-examiner agreement statistics were high (91.3% to 93.1% agreement; 0.79 to 0.86 kappa-coefficient). Further breakdowns of the data into facial and lingual sites by arch and location (anterior or posterior) resulted in similar levels of reliability, with no significant differences within examiners. The overall inter-examiner agreement statistics were good (82.8% to 87.6% agreement; 0.62-0.75 kappa coefficient). When inter-examiner data were analyzed at facial or lingual sites by arch and location, a significant difference existed in reliability for mandibular posterior lingual sites, but reliability was high in all other areas. These data demonstrate a high level of reproducibility for this method, which suggests that the Eastman interdental bleeding index is suitable for clinical trials and epidemiologic studies of interdental gingivitis.

Adult↗
PubMed1992

Some thoughts on the measurement of gingivitis.

The selection of a method for measurement is of critical importance in the planning of a study. Despite the great strides afforded by research of gingivitis, a "gold standard" for its measurement has yet to be clearly established. Traditional clinical indices continue to serve as "gold standards" in many investigations. There is a need for some caution and tentativity in interpreting the results of such studies. Additionally, those studies which yield data on an ordinal scale should make more use of statistical methodologies specifically geared toward the analysis of such data.

Diagnosis, Oral↗