Biomedical subjects
J Gabbay
Publications and source records attributed to J Gabbay.
Which are the best information sources for identifying emerging health care technologies? An international Delphi survey.
The purpose of this survey was to assess potential information sources for identifying new health care technologies. A three-round Delphi study was conducted, involving 38 selected experts who suggested and assessed potential sources by applying agreed criteria. Twenty-six potential information sources were considered. Timeliness, time efficiency, and sensitivity were important criteria in determining which were the most important sources. The eight recommended sources were: pharmaceutical journals, pharmaceutical and biotechnology companies, specialist medical journals, key medical journals, medical engineering companies, private health care providers, newsletters and bulletins from other health technology assessment agencies, and groups of expert health professionals. There is a need to use a combination of sources because the most useful sources will vary according to the type of technology under consideration.
Improving health outcomes--a review of case studies from English health authorities.
We review a series of case studies from English health authorities that have tackled the assessment and improvement of health outcomes. We reflect their concerns and difficulties and the lessons they learnt. We identified case studies from a telephone survey of 91 representatives of the 100 English health authorities (61 were directors of public health). We edited 26 structured case studies which described how they had used population health outcome assessments or indicators. The health outcome assessments included service reviews, needs assessment projects, case-control studies, small area variations analyses, action research, and the use of focus groups. Many case studies highlighted inequalities in health service delivery. Health authorities chose some topics because they were outliers on national indicators, others had found unacceptable inequalities within their district, and others had been concerned that clinicians were not using the most effective interventions. Public health departments played a major role in these population-based health outcome assessments. The case studies highlighted the strengths and weakness of national population-based health outcome indicators, the difficulties of using information on effectiveness, the role of evidence-based process proxies for outcome, the need to extend information sources, the involvement of patients and carers, and the difficulty of changing clinical behaviour. We make recommendations as to how the Department of Health and NHS Executive could help health authorities improve the health outcomes of the populations they serve.
What do health authorities think of population based health outcome indicators?
OBJECTIVES: To determine the role of population based indicators of health outcome in local health outcome assessments; the constraints of using such indicators; how they could be made more useful; and whether health authorities had developed their own indicators of health outcome. DESIGN: A structured telephone interview with representatives of 91 of the 100 English health authorities. RESULTS: Interviewees, asked to give details on two clinical areas in which population health outcome assessments had been of most value, nominated 147 examples in over 30 clinical areas. They chose 50 (34%) of the examples because of an outlying national indicator, and 20 (14%) because of local variations in a national indicator. The main perceived constraints in the use of population based indicators of health outcome were: data validity and timeliness; the attributability of these health outcomes to the quality of health care; the difficulties of changing clinical behavior; and organisational change within health authorities. To make these indicators more useful interviewees wanted an increased use of process indicators as proxies for health outcome, indicator trend data, and indicator comparisons of districts with similar population structures. Some recent publications have started to consider some of these issues. 27 (30%) health authorities had developed their own indicators, mostly provider based process indicators. 10 of these used their own indicators to manage the performance of local provider units. CONCLUSIONS: Population based indicators of health outcome had an important role in prompting districts to undertake population health outcome assessments. Health authorities also used these indicators to examine local variations in health outcome. They helped to highlight areas for further investigation, initiated data validation, and enabled the monitoring of changes to services. Comparative population based indicators of health outcome may have an increasing part to play in assessing the performance of health authorities.
Britain's first minister of public health. National centre for public health is needed.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Final score in laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Cholangiogram 1207, no cholangiogram 116.
BACKGROUND: The role of intraoperative fluorocholangiography (IOC) in laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) is controversial. We evaluated the use of IOC at an institution where the study is performed routinely. METHODS: Records of all patients undergoing LC during a 3-year period ending January 1, 1996 were reviewed. RESULTS: A total of 1207 patients received IOC, whereas 116 patients did not. IOC findings were categorized as follows: normal, 1016 cases (84%); CBD stone, 149 cases (12.3%); anomalies, 23 cases (1.9%); duodenal diverticula, 10 cases (0.8%); ductal strictures, four cases (0.3%); and CBD diverticula, 5 cases (0.4%). In the 116 patients who did not receive IOC, 35 of the procedures could not be performed, whereas 81 were not attempted. Of the 149 IOC that showed CBD stones, two were false positives. Anomalies included accessory right hepatic ducts (11 cases), cystic ducts joining the right hepatic duct (seven cases), and abnormal cystic duct entries (five cases). Duct injuries occurred in 5 cases (0.4%), three before and two after IOC. Four injuries were minor; IOC prevented CBD transection. CONCLUSIONS: Routine IOC is feasible, safe, accurate, and provides critical information of immediate use during LC. By treating ductal stones at operation and identifying patients without CBD stones, IOC minimizes need for postoperative studies, including endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (ERC).
Identifying new health care technologies in the United Kingdom.
We aimed to establish a 1996 baseline of new health care technologies that are predicted to have an impact on the United Kingdom's National Health Service in the next five years. One thousand and ninety-nine health care technologies were identified from a variety of sources. Further work will attempt to determine the most efficient method of identifying and monitoring new health care technologies.
Safe laparoendoscopic approach to biliary pancreatitis in older patients.
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate management strategies for biliary pancreatitis in different age groups. DESIGN: Retrospective review. SETTING: Large private metropolitan teaching hospital. PATIENTS: Patients seen between January 1991 and December 1994 with a diagnosis of biliary pancreatitis (N = 136) divided into 2 groups (group 1, aged < 65 years; group 2, aged > or = 65 years). INTERVENTIONS: Primary treatments included endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (n = 36) alone or with endoscopic sphincterotomy (n = 27); operative procedures, including cholecystectomy by laparoscopic (n = 54) or open (n = 16) approaches; or no definitive therapy (n = 22). Secondary treatments of common bile duct stones included laparoscopic transcystic bile duct exploration (n = 5), open common bile duct exploration (n = 4), or postoperative endoscopic retrograde cholangiography (n = 10). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Success of interventions, incidence and treatment of common bile duct stones, morbidity and mortality rates, frequency of retained stones, and length of hospitalization. RESULTS: Numbers of Ranson criteria were higher for older patients (group 1, 0.83 +/- 0.12 vs group 2, 1.57 +/- 0.11 [mean +/- SEM]; P < .001). Primary endoscopic retrograde cholangiography with or without endoscopic sphincterotomy was performed earlier than operative procedures, with a significantly higher incidence of common bile duct stones (72% vs 19%; P < .001). Number of primary procedures and complication and mortality rates for endoscopic retrograde cholangiography with or without endoscopic sphincterotomy were 36, 8%, and 3%, respectively; for laparoscopic cholecystectomy, 54, 9%, and 2%, respectively; and for open cholecystectomy, 16, 6%, and 19%, respectively. For complication and mortality rates, there were no statistical differences between groups or among treatments. Deferred therapy was used in 30 patients, with 20% readmitted for recurrence of biliary pancreatitis. Length of intensive care unit and total hospital stay were similar for all groups and treatments. CONCLUSIONS: Older patients with biliary pancreatitis may be safely treated with a combined laparoendoscopic approach. Management of common bile duct stones depends on age, with laparoscopic transcystic duct exploration or open common bile duct exploration preferred for younger patients and laparoscopic transcystic duct exploration or postoperative endoscopic sphincterotomy for older ones. Deferred therapy has a substantial relapse rate.
The Health Authorities Bill.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Identifying the missing link in the audit cycle.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Self-estimation of oral malodor.
Bad breath (halitosis, oral malodor) is a common condition, usually the result of microbial putrefaction within the oral cavity. Often, people suffering from bad breath remain unaware of it, whereas others remain convinced that they suffer from foul oral malodor, although there is no evidence for such. The purpose of the present investigation was to determine whether objective self-measurement of oral malodors is possible. Each of 52 volunteers was asked to sample the odor from his/her mouth, tongue, and saliva. Results were compared with (i) self-assessments prior to (preconception) and following (post-measurement) self-measurements; (ii) odor judge scores; (iii) dental-measurements (plaque index, gingival index, and probing depth); (iv) volatile sulphide levels; (v) salivary cadaverine levels; and (vi) intra-oral trypsin-like activity. Among the self-measurements, only saliva self-scores yielded significant correlations with objective parameters. Despite the partial objectivity of saliva self-estimates, subsequent post-measurement self-assessments failed to correlate with objective parameters. The results suggest that (i) preconceived notions confound the ability to score one's own oral malodors in an objective fashion; and (ii) partial objectivity can be obtained in the case of saliva self-measurement, presumably because the stimulus is removed from the body proper.
'Quick and clean': authoritative health technology assessment for local health care contracting.
Commissioners of health care require rapid, accurate and usable information on health technology effectiveness to help them to decide on the content of contracts. Despite major strides in the national initiatives in health technology assessment, such information is still in short supply at the local level. In 1991 the former Wessex region (now in the new South and West Region) established a mechanism which continues to provide carefully established recommendations on new technologies. Its features include: identification of locally important topics for evaluation by the purchasers and the providers; an evaluation team, working to a well-defined format in a service-led academic institute; an arbitration committee to deliver recommendations to purchasers on the basis of both the cost-utility of proposals and the quality of the evidence; and implicit obligations for purchasers to respond to strong recommendations.
Towards investing in health gain.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Surgical anatomy of the hepatic arteries in 1000 cases.
OBJECTIVE: Anatomic variations in the hepatic arteries were studied in donor livers that were used for orthotopic transplantation. SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA: Variations have occurred in 25% to 75% of cases. Donor livers represent an appropriate model for study because extrahepatic arterial anatomy must be defined precisely to ensure complete arterialization of the graft at time of transplantation. METHODS: Records of 1000 patients who underwent liver harvesting for orthotopic transplantation between 1984 and 1993 were reviewed. RESULTS: Arterial patterns in order of frequency included the normal Type 1 anatomy (n = 757), with the common hepatic artery arising from the celiac axis to form the gastroduodenal and proper hepatic arteries and the proper hepatic dividing distally into right and left branches; Type 3 (n = 106), with a replaced or accessory right hepatic artery originating from the superior mesenteric artery; Type 2 (n = 97), with a replaced or accessory left hepatic artery arising from the left gastric artery; Type 4 (n = 23), with both right and left hepatic arteries arising from the superior mesenteric and left gastric arteries, respectively; Type 5 (n = 15), with the entire common hepatic artery arising as a branch of the superior mesenteric; and Type 6 (n = 2), with the common hepatic artery originating directly from the aorta. CONCLUSIONS: These data are useful for the planning and conduct of surgical and radiological procedures of the upper abdomen, including laparoscopic operations of the biliary tract.
Evaluation of patients' knowledge about anticoagulant treatment.
OBJECTIVE: To develop a questionnaire to evaluate patients' knowledge of anticoagulation. DESIGN: Anonymous self completed questionnaire study based on hospital anticoagulant guidelines. SETTING: Anticoagulant clinic in a 580 bed district general hospital in London. SUBJECTS: 70 consecutive patients newly referred to the anticoagulant clinic over six months. MAIN MEASURES: Information received by patients on six items of anticoagulation counselling (mode of action of warfarin, adverse effects of over or under anticoagulation, drugs to avoid, action if bleeding or bruising occurs, and alcohol consumption), the source of such information, and patients' knowledge about anticoagulation. RESULTS: Of the recruits, 36 (51%) were male; 38(54%) were aged below 46 years, 22(31%) 46-60, and 10(14%) over 75. 50 (71%) questionnaires were returned. In all, 40 respondents spoke English at home and six another language. Most patients reported being clearly advised on five of the six items, but knowledge about anticoagulation was poor. Few patients could correctly identify adverse conditions associated with poor control of anticoagulation: bleeding was identified by only 30(60%), bruising by 23(56%), and thrombosis by 18(36%). Only 26(52%) patients could identify an excessive level of alcohol consumption, and only seven (14%) could identify three or more self prescribed agents which may interfere with warfarin. CONCLUSION: The questionnaire provided a simple method of determining patients' knowledge of anticoagulation, and its results indicated that this requires improvement. IMPLICATIONS: Patients' responses suggested that advice was not always given by medical staff, and use of counselling checklists is recommended. Reinforcement of advice by non-medical counsellors and with educational guides such as posters or leaflets should be considered. Such initiatives are currently being evaluated in a repeat survey.
Role of users of health care in achieving a quality service.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Piccadilly Circus legionnaires' disease outbreak.
BACKGROUND: An outbreak of legionnaires' disease occurred in central London in January and February 1989. An Infection Control Committee was established to investigate the outbreak and institute control measures. The objective of this paper is to describe the investigation and control of the outbreak. METHODS: An epidemiological survey and case-control study were carried out. The subjects were cases of community acquired pneumonia associated with central London with onset of illness in January and February 1989. RESULTS: Thirty-three confirmed cases, including five deaths, and ten suspected cases, including three deaths, were identified with dates of onset from 1 January to 11 February. A clustering of visits by cases to the vicinity of Piccadilly Circus was noted, and a case-control study demonstrated a strong association between illness and visits to this area in the two weeks before onset of symptoms. The causative organism, Legionella pneumophila serogroup 1, was isolated from six patients. Legionella pneumophila of the same serogroup was isolated from water samples from five wet cooling systems (cooling towers) in the area under investigation, but in only two systems was the organism indistinguishable by subtyping from the patients' strains. Many of the cooling towers examined were inadequately maintained, including one of the two above a building adjacent to Piccadilly Circus from which a strain indistinguishable from the outbreak strain was isolated. All cooling towers in the area were shut down until inspected, and only allowed to restart after appropriate maintenance had been instigated. CONCLUSIONS: This outbreak showed the continuing risk of legionnaires' disease posed by wet cooling systems, including cooling towers, and highlighted the need to assess this risk so that appropriate maintenance is carried out. Regulations have recently been introduced, under the Health and Safety at Work Act, requiring notification of all wet cooling systems to the local authority to facilitate the investigation of outbreaks of legionnaires' disease.
Referral of patients to an anticoagulant clinic: implications for better management.
The quality of anticoagulant treatment of ambulatory patients is affected by the content of referral letters and administrative processes. To assess these influences a method was developed to audit against the hospital standard the referral of patients to one hospital anticoagulant clinic in a prospective study of all (80) new patients referred to the clinic over eight months. Administrative information was provided by the clinic coordinator, and the referral letters were audited by the researchers. Referral letters were not received by the clinic for 10% (8/80) of patients. Among the 72 referral letters received, indication for anticoagulation and anticipated duration of treatment were specified in most (99%, 71 and 81%, 58 respectively), but only 3% (two) to 46% (33) reported other important clinical information (objective investigations, date of starting anticoagulation, current anticoagulant dose, date and result of latest international normalised ratio, whether it should be the anticoagulant clinic that was eventually to stop anticoagulation, patients' other medical problems and concurrent treatment. Twenty two per cent (16/80) of new attenders were unexpected at the anticoagulant clinic. Most patients' case notes were obtained for the appointment (61%, 47/77 beforehand and 30% 23/77 on the day), but case notes were not obtained for 9% (7/77). The authors conclude that health professionals should better appreciate the administrative and organisational influences that affect team work and quality of care. Compliance with a well documented protocol remained below the acceptable standard. The quality of the referral process may be improved by using a more comprehensive and helpful referral form, which has been drawn up, and by educating referring doctors. Measures to increase the efficiency of the administrative process include telephoning the clinic coordinator directly, direct referrals through a computerised referral system, and telephone reminders by haematology office staff to ward staff to ensure availability of the hospital notes. The effect of these changes will be assessed in a repeat audit.