Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to J K Lynch.
The literature purporting to demonstrate that clinical neuropsychology is of limited validity in the forensic setting is reviewed critically and alternative interpretations are discussed. The methodological, procedural, conceptual, data analytical and survey/research design limitations are evaluated.
A study was performed to determine whether magnetic resonance (MR) imaging is cost-effective and reduces the need for diagnostic arthroscopy of the knee. During a 9-month period, 103 consecutive patients with knee injury that justified diagnostic arthroscopy underwent MR imaging. The MR images were interpreted by means of consensus of three radiologists and reviewed with the referring sports medicine orthopedists. After the examination, 44 patients (42.7%) underwent immediate arthroscopy. The 59 other patients (57.3%) did not undergo arthroscopy; follow-up was performed in 55 of these 59 patients (93%) at a mean of 22 months. The outcome was successful in 49 of 55 patients (89%); 40 patients had normal function and no limitation in activity, six patients with chronic injury of the anterior cruciate ligament underwent reconstruction, and three patients underwent arthroscopy with negative findings. Without the use of MR imaging, all patients in this study would have undergone diagnostic arthroscopy. Because of the diagnoses based on MR images, 53 patients (51.4%) avoided a potentially unnecessary diagnostic arthroscopy, and, as a result, the net savings was $103,700 in the 103 patients.
The appearance and rate of healing of sutured meniscal repairs in 17 patients were evaluated using magnetic resonance scans. While prior studies in animals and humans (1-4) suggest that complete healing can occur as early as 6 wk postoperatively, we found that at 7 wk 15/15 patients demonstrated meniscal defects at the site of repair. At 6 mo, 11/11 patients showed persistent signal abnormalities. Two patients scanned at 11-12 mo also had defects at the site of repair. Therefore, complete meniscal healing appears not to occur as early as previously believed. This may affect decisions regarding the type of suture material used, the surgical treatment of associated injuries and the postoperative rehabilitation regimen. As defects may be present for relatively long periods of time following meniscal repair, caution must be exercised when attempting to diagnose new or recurrent tears in these patients.
A prospective study of grade 2 meniscal abnormalities in patients with intact anterior cruciate ligaments was done to ascertain whether such lesions progress to complete tears. A follow-up magnetic resonance (MR) image was obtained in 22 patients in whom the initial MR image showed a grade 2 lesion in one or both menisci that had been proved at arthroscopy not to be torn. On the initial images, 27 menisci contained a grade 2 lesion. At follow-up, six of the 27 lesions appeared to have decreased in size (two had completely disappeared). Eighteen lesions appeared unchanged; only three had increased in size. The mean interval between the acquisition of initial and follow-up images was 27.3 months (range, 11-41 months). The two patients whose lesion disappeared were among the youngest patients evaluated. The three patients whose abnormality increased were slightly older and more active than average. The results suggest that in most patients grade 2 lesions are stable at up to 3 years follow-up.
Osteochondritis dissecans (OCD) is a common entity in both the juvenile and adult populations, with an incidence of 3 to 6/10,000 in adults. Much of the early literature grouped juvenile and adult osteochondritis dissecans, osteochondral fracture, and accessory ossification into the same category. Conclusions were then drawn on the combined group. Nonetheless, this is a diverse group. This review discusses only OCD. There have been multiple etiological theories of OCD, ranging from trauma to ischemia to accessory centers of ossification and to genetics. It is evident that the true etiology is probably multifactorial. Bone scan, computed tomographic scan, and magnetic resonance imaging advances have enhanced the physician's ability to make the diagnosis of osteochondritis dissecans as well as to stage operative intervention. There is a vast difference between juvenile and adult OCD, as seen in the natural history, prognosis, and treatment options. In general, the juvenile patients have better results overall. The indications for operative intervention for these juvenile patients are a nonhealing attached fragment, fully or partially detached lesions of the articular surface, and loose bodies. Nonoperative treatment in the adult patient has been shown to accelerate degenerative arthritis, which involves all 3 compartments of the knee. Therefore, symptomatic lesions and loose bodies comprise the surgical indications for adult OCD. An understanding of this disease process will help the physician optimize the patient's results.
This prospective study compared 30 patients randomly assigned to either a home exercise program or supervised outpatient physical therapy following arthroscopic partial medial meniscectomy. Their knee functions were assessed at 2, 4, and 8 weeks postoperatively using isokinetic analysis and subjective questionnaires. At each evaluation, the home exercise group performed as well or better than the supervised physical therapy group. There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups. At 4 weeks postoperation, the mean percent deficit in torque (strength) between the affected and unaffected limbs was 22.1% in the supervised rehabilitation group and 22.0% in the home exercise. The percent deficit in terms of endurance was 7.7% in the supervised group and 3.6% in the home group. Similar results were noted with regard to the patients' subjective evaluations of their knee function and ability to resume work and recreational activities. We conclude that a well-planned, unsupervised home exercise knee rehabilitation program can produce equally good postoperative recovery as compared to a supervised outpatient physical therapy regimen in properly selected patients following arthroscopic partial meniscectomy of the knee.