PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

John Turnbull

Publications and source records attributed to John Turnbull.

7 recordsLinked to original sources

Competence and cognitive difficulty in physicians: a follow-up study.

PURPOSE: Remediation of incompetent physicians has proven difficult and sometimes impossible. The authors wished to determine whether such physicians had neuropsychological impairment sufficient to explain their incompetence and their failure to improve after remedial continuing medical education (CME). METHOD: Between 1997 and 2001, the authors undertook neuropsychological screening of 45 participants of a physician competency assessment program. For those physicians reassessed after a period of remediation, the authors relate the findings of the physicians' competence reassessments to their neuropsychological scores. RESULTS: Nearly all physicians performing well on competency assessment had no or mild cognitive impairment. Conversely, a significant number of physicians performing poorly on competency assessment had sufficient neuropsychological difficulty to explain their poor performance. The cognitive impairment was more marked in elderly physicians, and referencing the neuropsychological scores to an age-matched normative population underestimates the impairment. No physician with moderate or severe neuropsychological dysfunction had successful competency reassessment. Increasing age was associated with poor performance on competency testing, but was less strongly associated with unsuccessful reassessment. CONCLUSION: A large minority of the physicians who fell significantly below desired levels of competence had cognitive impairment sufficient to explain their lack of competence and their failure to improve with remedial CME.

Adult↗

Contextual considerations in summative competency examinations: relevance to the long case.

Long-case patient-based examinations previously formed the basis of summative competency testing in physician certification examinations. These exams were found to be unreliable and have fallen from favor. During the authors' deliberation of the long case in the neurology certification examinations of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada, they considered the examination context and concluded that the appropriate psychometric analysis of the exams is highly contingent on the context. The examination context underlying certification examinations has evolved considerably; within a different context, a more cohesive test system based on a quality assurance framework could better manage substantive psychometric issues around case specificity, comprehensiveness, reliability, and compensability. These arguments are in small part psychometric, but are mostly philosophical and have relevance to the profession and the public.

Certification↗

Automated state analyses: proposed applications to neonatal neurointensive care.

The two principal challenges of neonatal physiologic monitoring device are: (1) the development of computational strategies that consider the rudimentary forms of neonatal sleep state especially for preterm infants and (2) any physiologic monitoring device for clinical applications in a neonatal intensive care setting must be small, portable, and user-friendly. Our multicenter neonatal sleep consortium has acquired more than 1,100 multihour EEG-sleep recordings on over 370 neonates, ranging from 24 to 44 weeks gestation. Each recording was visually-scored for state, arousals, movements, and rapid eye movements, which were used as templates when applying spectral analyses. The authors have defined a brain dysmaturity index to represent functional brain reorganization as the prenate matures to a full-term age; delayed or accelerated physiologic behaviors have been described for the preterm cohort when compared to the full-term group at the same postmenstrual age. Seven EEG-sleep measures comprise this index: quiet sleep percentage, sleep cycle length, rapid eye movements, arousals, spectral beta EEG energies, spectral EEG correlations, and a spectral measure of respiratory regularity. Linear and nonlinear computational algorithms are being developed to automate the computation of the dysmaturity index and to identify new feature types that correlate with dysmaturity. Automated neonatal sleep monitoring system can potentially improve neonatal neurointensive care by facilitating analyses of pervasive neonatal brain disorders expressed primarily as altered sleep state organization, and help predict altered developmental trajectories of children at higher risk for neurologic sequelae.

Brain↗

Severe acute respiratory syndrome: developing a research response.

When severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS) first came to world attention in March 2003, it was immediately perceived to be a global threat with a pandemic potential. To help coordinate international research efforts, the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases convened a colloquium entitled SARS: Developing a Research Response on 30 May 2003. Breakout sessions intended to identify unmet research needs in 5 areas of SARS research--clinical research, epidemiology, diagnostics, therapeutics, and vaccines--are summarized here. Since this meeting, however, the identified research needs have been only partially met. Needs that have yet to be realized include reliable methods for early identification of individuals with SARS, a full description of SARS pathogenesis and immune response, and animal models that faithfully mimic SARS respiratory symptoms. It is also of the utmost importance that the global scientific community enhance mechanisms for international cooperation and planning for SARS research, as well as for other emerging infectious disease threats that are certain to arise in the future.

Humans↗

Addressing areas of common concern.

John Turnbull FREng introduces, in this article, three reports on various aspects of risk and engineering. The reports were produced by a number of working groups consisting of Fellows of The Royal Academy of Engineering and social scientists. Each addressed areas of common concern arising from a series of seminars on risk. The reports are titled "The Societal Aspects of Risk", "Common Methodologies for Risk Assessment & Management", and "Risks Posed by Humans in the Control Loop". The reports can be downloaded from The Royal Academy of Engineering's web site--www.raeng.org.uk Feedback on the reports is welcomed, and suggestions for addressing other areas of risk will be considered. Many of the recommendations considered in the reports are forming part of an ongoing work programme in this area.

Engineering↗

Dear CNO.

Explore the source record for details and available documents.

Humans↗