PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

Jon Nicholl

Publications and source records attributed to Jon Nicholl.

17 recordsLinked to original sources

Does size matter? The relationship between volume and outcome in the care of major trauma.

OBJECTIVES: To investigate the relationship between case volume and outcome for major trauma patients. METHODS: Prospective follow-up study of all major trauma patients (with injury severity score >15) arriving alive, with no invariably fatal injury, at 14 English emergency departments between 1990 and 1993. Using the stratified W statistic, an age and severity adjusted measure of outcome, the relationship between volume of cases and outcome was initially examined using the Spearman correlation coefficient. Multiple regression analysis was used to explore further the relationship, after adjustment for hospital-level characteristics. RESULTS: The smallest department saw five major trauma cases each year, the largest saw 96. The results of the initial correlation analyses indicated that there was little evidence that outcome improved with increasing volumes for all major trauma (rho(s) = 0.12, 95% confidence interval [CI]: -0.36 to 0.55) nor for the cases presenting out-of-hours (rho(s) = 0.30, 95% CI: -0.19 to 0.67). However, there was evidence that patients with multiple injury (rho(s) = 0.65, 95% CI: 0.27 to 0.86) and those with severe head injuries (rho(s) = 0.52, 95% CI: 0.08 to 0.79) did better in high volume departments. This pattern, of a positive relationship for more complex cases was also in evidence from the results of the multiple regression analyses and, in particular, for patients with multiple injuries, was stable over time. CONCLUSIONS: While there was little evidence that all patients with major trauma do better in higher volume departments, there was evidence that patients with complex needs, such as the multiple injured or those with head injuries, had better outcomes.

Adolescent↗

Equity of access to health care. Evidence from NHS Direct in the UK.

In the UK National Health Service (NHS), NHS Direct, the national 24-h telephone helpline, has been available in England and Wales since 2000 and has been termed a 'single gateway' to health care. We conducted a population survey of 15,004 people in areas covered by the service, which included questions about NHS Direct use and socio-economic characteristics. After removing undeliverable questionnaires, the survey response rate was 60% (8750/14,516). In all, a quarter of respondents had ever used NHS Direct (26%, 95% confidence interval 25-27), ranging from 32% of the population in Preston/Chorley (888/2,794) and Newcastle and North Tyneside (515/1,621) to 17% (2,215/8,536) in Sheffield, which had introduced the service 20 months later. Logistic regression showed that those from poorer socioeconomic groups or with communication difficulties were less likely to have used the service than others. Overcoming this apparent bias against those likely to have the greatest need is an unsolved problem not confined to telemedicine.

Adolescent↗

The impact of NHS Direct on the demand for out-of-hours primary and emergency care.

In order to assess the impact of NHS Direct on out-of-hours primary and emergency care, we sought data on service demand from all GP cooperatives, ambulance services and emergency departments in England, Wales and Scotland. We analysed the impact of NHS Direct on demand, taking advantage of the fact that the service was introduced in waves over a period of 2 years. The results showed that the introduction of NHS Direct was associated with a reduction in calls to GP cooperatives, but with no evident effect on emergency services.

After-Hours Care↗

A randomised controlled trial to measure the effect of chest pain unit care upon anxiety, depression, and health-related quality of life [ISRCTN85078221].

BACKGROUND: The chest pain unit (CPU) has been developed to provide a rapid and accurate diagnostic assessment for patients attending hospital with acute, undifferentiated chest pain. We aimed to measure the effect of CPU assessment upon psychological symptoms and health-related quality of life. METHODS: We undertook a single-centre, cluster-randomised controlled trial. Days (N = 442) were randomised in equal numbers to CPU or routine care. Patients with acute chest pain, undiagnosed by clinical assessment, ECG and chest radiograph, were recruited and followed up with self-completed questionnaires (SF-36 and HADS) at two days and one month after hospital attendance. RESULTS: Patients receiving CPU assessment had significantly higher scores on the physical functioning (difference 5.1 points; 95% CI 1.1 to 9.0), vitality (4.6; 1.3 to 8.0), and general health (5.7; 2.3 to 9.2) dimensions of the SF-36 at two days, and significantly higher scores on all except the emotional role dimension at one month. They also had significantly lower depression scores on the HADS depression scale at two days (0.93; 0.34 to 1.51) and one month (1.0; 0.36 to 1.66). However, initially lower anxiety scores at two days (0.89; 0.21 to 1.56) were not maintained at one month (0.48; -0.26 to 1.23). CPU assessment was associated with reduced prevalence (OR 0.71; 95% CI 0.52 to 0.97) and severity (6.5 mm on 100 m visual analogue scale; 95% CI 2.2 to 10.8) of chest pain at one month, but no significant difference in the proportion of patients taking time off work (OR 0.82; 95% CI 0.54 to 1.04). CONCLUSION: CPU assessment is associated with improvements in nearly all dimensions of quality of life and with reduced symptoms of depression.

Adult↗

Randomised controlled trial and economic evaluation of a chest pain observation unit compared with routine care.

OBJECTIVES: To measure the effectiveness and cost effectiveness of providing care in a chest pain observation unit compared with routine care for patients with acute, undifferentiated chest pain. DESIGN: Cluster randomised controlled trial, with 442 days randomised to the chest pain observation unit or routine care, and cost effectiveness analysis from a health service costing perspective. SETTING: The emergency department at the Northern General Hospital, Sheffield, United Kingdom. PARTICIPANTS: 972 patients with acute, undifferentiated chest pain (479 attending on days when care was delivered in the chest pain observation unit, 493 on days of routine care) followed up until six months after initial attendance. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The proportion of participants admitted to hospital, the proportion with acute coronary syndrome sent home inappropriately, major adverse cardiac events over six months, health utility, hospital reattendance and readmission, and costs per patient to the health service. RESULTS: Use of a chest pain observation unit reduced the proportion of patients admitted from 54% to 37% (difference 17%, odds ratio 0.50, 95% confidence interval 0.39 to 0.65, P < 0.001) and the proportion discharged with acute coronary syndrome from 14% to 6% (8%, -7% to 23%, P = 0.264). Rates of cardiac event were unchanged. Care in the chest pain observation unit was associated with improved health utility during follow up (0.0137 quality adjusted life years gained, 95% confidence interval 0.0030 to 0.0254, P = 0.022) and a saving of pound 78 per patient (- pound 56 to pound 210, P = 0.252). CONCLUSIONS: Care in a chest pain observation unit can improve outcomes and may reduce costs to the health service. It seems to be more effective and more cost effective than routine care.

Algorithms↗

Why are patients removed from their doctors' lists? A comparison of patients' and doctors' accounts of removal.

BACKGROUND: GPs in the UK may remove a patient from their list without supplying a reason to the patient or the local health authority. Little is known of the events that lead to such removal decisions, nor of patients' views of their removal. OBJECTIVE: Our aim was to describe the events that lead to a removal from both the doctor and patient perspectives. METHODS: An anonymized postal survey of 204 GPs and 319 patients with recent experience of removal was carried out. RESULTS: Violent, threatening or abusive behaviour was the most common reason for removal given by GPs (64%, 57 out of 89), with almost half of instances involving verbal abuse towards receptionists (42 out of 89). However, fewer than a fifth of patients admitted to threatening or abusive behaviour towards practice staff (15 out of 76). Although GPs reported giving patients a reason for the removal in 59% (44 out of 75) of cases, only 36% (26 out of 72) of patients reported receiving a reason. Patients often appeared not to understand why they had been removed. CONCLUSIONS: While doctors and patients frequently give differing accounts of the events which lead to removal, both emphasize relationship breakdown and loss of trust. Financial issues appear negligible. Since few removals seem preventable by policy measures, the distress of removal might best be reduced by trying to improve the removal process-probably through improved communication-rather than prevent removals.

Attitude of Health Personnel↗

Patient and primary care physician satisfaction with chest pain unit and routine care.

OBJECTIVES: The chest pain unit (CPU) has been developed to improve care for patients with acute, undifferentiated chest pain. The authors aimed to measure patient and primary care physician (PCP) satisfaction with CPU care and routine care and to determine whether patient satisfaction predicted PCP satisfaction. METHODS: A CPU was established, and 442 days were randomly allocated to either CPU care or routine care. Consenting patients presenting with acute, undifferentiated chest pain were recruited and followed at two days and one month. All were given a self-completed patient satisfaction questionnaire two days after attendance (N = 972). Each patient's PCP was sent a self-completed satisfaction questionnaire during days 171-442 of the trial (N = 601). Analysis determined whether CPU care was associated with improved patient or PCP satisfaction and whether patient satisfaction predicted PCP satisfaction for three questions relating to diagnosis, treatment, and overall care. RESULTS: CPU care was consistently associated with higher scores across all patient satisfaction questions, from the perceived thoroughness of examination to care received to an overall assessment of the service received. However, CPU care achieved small improvements in only two of ten PCP satisfaction questions, concerning overall management of the patient and the amount of information about investigations performed. Furthermore, patient satisfaction did not predict PCP satisfaction in relation to diagnosis (p = 0.456), treatment (p = 0.256), or overall care (p = 0.085). CONCLUSIONS: CPU care is associated with substantial improvements in all dimensions of patient satisfaction but only minimal improvements in PCP satisfaction. Patient satisfaction was not a strong predictor of PCP satisfaction with emergency care.

Adult↗

Do different types of nurses give different triage decisions in NHS Direct? A mixed methods study.

OBJECTIVES: To determine whether nurses with different clinical backgrounds make different triage decisions in NHS Direct, the 24-hour telephone helpline staffed by nurses. METHODS: Mixed methods including semistructured interviews with 24 nurses and a multilevel analysis of 60 794 calls triaged by 296 nurses. RESULTS: Nurse accounts helped to identify nurse characteristics that might affect decision-making. The proportion of calls triaged to self-care was 40% (24 049/60 794), varying by individual nurse from a 10th centile of 22% to a 90th centile of 60%, after adjustment for the age and sex of the patient and the time of the call. Variability was partly explained by the length of clinical experience of nurses and the type of software used: nurses with more than 20 years clinical experience were more likely to triage callers to self-care than those with less than ten years experience (42% versus 36%, respectively; odds ratio = 1.41, 95% confidence interval 1.13, 1.78). Proportions triaged to selfcare differed by the type of clinical decision support software used: 31%, 37% and 44%. There was no evidence that the clinical background of nurses (hospital or community), their length of experience in NHS Direct, the range of their experience, or their gender affected triage decisions. Interviews identified that nursing characteristics affected individual nurses in different ways and helped to generate a hypothesis for future research - that individual nurses' approaches to risk may influence triage decisions. CONCLUSION: There is no likely benefit in narrowing nurse recruitment to particular clinical backgrounds. The appropriateness of triage decisions still needs to be evaluated.

Adolescent↗

Acute Pain Teams in England: current provision and their role in postoperative pain management.

This survey describes the current provision of multidisciplinary Acute Pain Teams (APTs) in acute English hospitals performing adult in-patient surgery (excluding maternity). Associations between the presence of an APT and a number of organizational and clinical initiatives for the management of postoperative pain are also explored. Postal questionnaires were sent to the Clinical Director of Anaesthetics or head of the APT at every acute English hospital providing separate anaesthetic services. After written and telephone reminders, the response rate was 86% (n = 226). Eighty-four per cent (n = 190) of respondents had an APT in their hospital. The presence of an APT was associated (P</=0.05) with higher estimates of patient controlled analgesia and epidural use, regular in-service training for nurses and junior doctors, written guidelines/protocols for management of postoperative pain, routine use of postoperative pain measurement systems and audit/research in relation to postoperative pain issues. Acute Pain Teams, in which nurses play a major role, have a pivotal influence not only in relation to postoperative analgesia but also in wider service development. Since 1995, the number of hospitals offering in-patient surgery that are covered by an APT has risen. However, despite repeated endorsements from professional bodies, some acute hospitals still have no APT and recent evidence indicates that some APTs face financial problems and provide a 'token' service only. Recent policy recommendations may have little impact on the current situation.

Adult↗

Evaluation of the impact of a technology appraisal process in England: the South and West Development and Evaluation Committee.

OBJECTIVES: To examine the influence of the English National Health Service (NHS) South and West (S&W) region Development and Evaluation Committee (DEC) technology appraisal reports on purchasing and clinical decisions in the S&W and elsewhere in the NHS, and to estimate the cost of the DEC process. METHODS: Two postal questionnaires examining issues of awareness, influence and quality of the DEC reports were sent to samples of clinical and managerial health service staff in S&W NHS region, the North West NHS region, and three other randomly selected health authorities elsewhere. Supplementary telephone interviews were undertaken with a subsample of staff. Trends in utilisation before and after the publication of four S&W DEC reports were examined using routine health service data. RESULTS: Survey response rates ranged between 73% and 85%. Within health authorities in the S&W, agreement about the impact of the DEC in informing policy and purchasing decisions was consistently high, although responses from clinicians were more equivocal. In the topic areas examined, the impact of the DEC reports could not be separated from wider influences on practice. The cost of each DEC report is estimated to have been pounds sterling 24659. CONCLUSIONS: Health service staff perceived that the S&W DEC process had had an impact on policy decisions and clinical practice locally; however, any actual impact on practice could not be identified with routine data. The approach used in this study would be valuable in evaluating the impact of the English NHS National Institute for Clinical Excellence.

Attitude of Health Personnel↗

Determining the most effective level of TRISS-derived probability of survival for use as an audit filter.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the most effective cut-off of TRISS-derived probability of survival (TRISS-PS) for the selection of trauma deaths for audit, using a large sample of trauma deaths from the United Kingdom (UK). METHODS: TRISS-PS and avoidability of death (as judged by an independent peer review panel) were compared for a sample of 222 trauma deaths. Sensitivity, specificity and predictive values were calculated for the 0.5 screening cut-off. ROC curves were derived to assess the ability of different levels of TRISS-PS to identify avoidable deaths. Calculations were made for both the raw sample and the sample adjusted for the sampling method used. RESULTS: For the weight-adjusted sample, the sensitivity of TRISS-PS greater than 0.5 for the detection of avoidable death is 80% (95% CI 61-91%), the specificity is 86% (95% CI 80-90%), PPV 42% (95% CI 29-56%) and NPV 97% (95% CI 93-99%). Twenty percent of avoidable deaths would have been 'missed' if the 0.5 level of audit filter had been used. Based on the same sample, the best cut-off is at TRISS-PS 0.33, with a sensitivity of 90% and specificity of 80%. It is estimated that this cut-off would have selected 62 deaths for audit and failed to identify 2 out of 25 avoidable deaths. CONCLUSION: The previously accepted audit filter of TRISS-PS of greater than 0.5 fails to identify a significant proportion of avoidable deaths. This study suggests that the most effective level of audit filter cut-off of TRISS-PS for the trauma system studied is 0.33. This level would identify 90% of avoidable deaths with 80% specificity. Similar ROC curve analysis could be used to determine appropriate TRISS-PS cut-offs for institutions or other trauma systems.

Aged↗

Women's perceptions of informed choice in maternity care.

OBJECTIVE: to describe the extent to which women using maternity services perceive that they have exercised informed choice. SETTING: twelve maternity units in Wales. DESIGN: postal survey of women using maternity services, covering women's views of the extent to which they exercised informed choice overall, and at eight decision points during their care. PARTICIPANTS: 1386 women at approximately 28 weeks gestation (antenatal sample) and 1741 women at approximately 8 weeks post delivery (postnatal sample). MEASUREMENTS AND FINDINGS: 54% of women perceived that they exercised informed choice overall in the antenatal sample (95% CI: 51-57%) and 54% overall in the postnatal sample (95% CI: 52-56%). Perceptions of informed choice differed by decision point, varying between 31% for fetal heart monitoring during labour and 73% for the screening test for Down's syndrome and spina bifida in the baby. There were differences by maternity unit, even when the characteristics of women attending these units were taken into account. Multiparous women, women from manual occupations and women with lower educational status were more likely to feel that they exercised informed choice during antenatal care. These sub-groups of women were also more likely to report a preference for not sharing decision-making with health professionals. CONCLUSIONS: a large minority of women felt that they had not exercised informed choice overall in their maternity care. The perception of informed choice differed by decision point, maternity unit and characteristics of the woman. IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: attaining informed choice is more of a challenge for some decision points in maternity care than others, particularly fetal monitoring. The difference in levels of informed choice between maternity units highlights the importance of maternity unit policy in the promotion of informed choice.

Adult↗