PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

K A Spackman

Publications and source records attributed to K A Spackman.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Normal forms for description logic expressions of clinical concepts in SNOMED RT.

Modern clinical terminologies organize concepts into multi-hierarchy structures that are defined by logic-based expressions, enabling compositional representation of clinical statements and supporting more complete and consistent retrieval of clinical data. The Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine, Reference Terminology (SNOMED RT) gives each concept code a semantic definition stated in description logic. The process of development, testing and distribution of these definitions has highlighted the fact that a concept definition may take many different but logically equivalent forms, and has revealed a need for a set of normal forms for authoring, distribution, and other purposes. This paper describes the difference between a choice of syntax and a choice of normal form, and defines several different normal forms, including a short canonical form, a long canonical form, and a distribution normal form.

Clinical Medicine↗

SNOMED clinical terms: overview of the development process and project status.

Two large health care reference terminologies, SNOMED RT and Clinical Terms Version 3 , are in the process of being merged to form a comprehensive new work referred to as SNOMED Clinical Terms. The College of American Pathologists and the United Kingdom s National Health Service have entered into a collaborative agreement to develop this new work. Both organizations have extensive terminology development and maintenance experience. This paper discusses the process and status of SNOMED CT development and how the resources and expertise of both organizations are being used to develop this new terminological resource. The preliminary results of the merger process, including mapping, the merger of upper levels of each hierarchy, and attribute harmonization are also discussed.

Clinical Medicine↗

Mapping between SNOMED RT and Clinical terms version 3: a key component of the SNOMED CT development process.

SNOMED RT and Clinical Terms Version 3 are two large, controlled medical terminologies that are being merged to form a new work titled SNOMED Clinical Terms (SNOMED CT). One of the first steps in this process was to create maps between semantically equivalent and proximate concepts in the two terminologies. Same-as and is-a relationships were used to map the descriptions from one terminology to concepts in the other terminology. The objectives were to identify semantically equivalent concepts in the two terminologies, to find the most semantically proximate is-a relationships for non-equivalent concepts, and to evaluate the synonymy in the source terminologies. The results suggest that the rate of semantic overlap between descriptions in SNOMED RT and CTV3 is approximately 28%. This article discusses the methodology, issues, and findings of the description mapping process.

Clinical Medicine↗

Integrating sources for a clinical reference terminology: experience linking SNOMED to LOINC and drug vocabularies.

Achieving the promise of higher quality, lower cost and more available health care through electronic medical records requires the support of a comprehensive clinical reference terminology. In a previous paper we described SNOMED RT (reference terminology), and the data structures and logic syntax that support the transformation of the SNOMED III nomenclature into the SNOMED RT reference terminology. In this paper, we describe an approach to linking SNOMED RT to existing nomenclatures in the area of laboratory test names (LOINC) and therapeutic drugs (Multum's MediSource Drug Lexicon), in order to achieve an integrated whole that solves the problem of a clinical reference terminology.

Clinical Laboratory Techniques↗

Compositional concept representation using SNOMED: towards further convergence of clinical terminologies.

This paper describes several approaches to the expression and coding of clinical concepts as composites of elementary entities, and describes an approach based on SNOMED RT that may permit further convergence of clinical terminology efforts. We explain the shortcomings of previous approaches to compositional concept representation, as well as the reasons for SNOMED's current approach, which adopts a foundation based in description logics (DLs). The DL model has many advantages: it establishes a formal semantics for SNOMED assertions and suggests a syntax; it provides a basis for understanding expressiveness and computational complexity, through correspondence with known results from DLs; and it helps to clarify the relationships among existing concept representation methods in SNOMED, NHS Clinical Terms (formerly the Read Codes), and GALEN, making a path to convergence more clear.

Models, Theoretical↗

A "lexically-suggested logical closure" metric for medical terminology maturity.

Medical Terminologies are becoming increasingly expressive secondary to their increase in size, and are becoming increasingly difficult to analyze secondary to inconsistencies in their use and complex interrelationships that are often not explicitly defined. To address these problems, SNOMED-RT is being developed to allow consistent use, and to define explicitly interrelationships between terms. Ensuring the quality of a terminology system like SNOMED-RT presents new challenges which we are trying to address with theoretically-grounded methodologies for quality management. Here we describe an initial metric toward achieving this goal called "lexically-suggested logical closure." We explain how this metric can be useful for tracking the maturity and quality of a terminology, and apply this metric to track the progress of SNOMED-RT development over a portion of its life-cycle.

Algorithms↗

Reproducibility of interpreting "and" and "or" in terminology systems.

High quality terminologies are a fundamental requirement in a range of health care applications. To ensure high quality terminologies we should reflect about the understandability, reproducibility and utility criteria within a terminology. This paper describes efforts to improve the understandability of SNOMED. We describe the problem related to the grammatical conjunctions "and" and "or" and how we applied basic semantic rules defined by the SNOMED Editorial Board. The results show that the meaning of "and" and "or" in SNOMED can be made explicit in almost all cases and can be done in a reasonable, reliable, and reproducible manner.

Semantics↗

Computer-facilitated collaboration: experiences building SNOMED-RT.

Collaborative development involving both individuals and groups is often less efficient than independent development because of communication overhead and integration costs. Despite the decreased development efficiency, collaborations promise more general-purpose products because of the opportunity for integration, with negotiation and reconciliation of diverse perspectives. Collaborations are also perhaps less costly when considered in contexts where there is significant duplication of effort. Computer-facilitated collaboration can reduce the communication and integration burden such that the increased effort required to manage a successful collaboration focuses primarily on the development of shared conceptual model among the developers by requiring that the work product be independently reproducible. This reproducibility requirement incorporates formal quality assurance processes into the development process. In this paper, we describe our initial experiences developing SNOMED-RT using such a computer-facilitated collaborative process. We quantify the extra costs incurred to achieve consistency in our efforts and reproducibility of our results.

Cooperative Behavior↗

SNOMED RT: a reference terminology for health care.

We describe the framework for SNOMED RT (Reference Terminology), designed to complement the broad coverage of medical concepts in SNOMED with a set of enhanced features that significantly increases its value as a reference terminology for representing clinical data. We describe what is meant by a reference terminology, and differentiate SNOMED RT from specialized terminologies that enable user interfaces, electronic messaging, or natural language processing, as well as from other specialized reference terminologies whose primary purpose is for representing data that is not primarily clinical in nature. We then describe how SNOMED RT represents multiple hierarchies and incorporates description logic. We believe that such a comprehensive set of concepts at multiple levels of granularity, with multiple logic-based subsumption hierarchies can meet the requirements of a reference terminology for health care.

Terminology as Topic↗

An expert system to diagnose anemia and report results directly on hematology forms.

An attempt was made to create an expert system with sufficient accuracy to diagnose classes of anemia and report presumptive diagnoses directly on the hematology form. The system should simulate the processes of human experts who can reliably achieve diagnostic separability by pattern analysis. A hybrid expert system combining rule-based and artificial neural network (ANN) models was constructed to evaluate microcytic anemia in a 3-layered program using hematocrit (HCT), mean corpuscular volume (MCV), and coefficient of variation of cell distribution width (RDWcv) as inputs. These measurements are available as standard output on most hematology analyzers. Three categories of microcytic anemia were considered, iron deficiency (IDA), hemoglobinopathy (HEM), and anemia of chronic disease (ACD). A novel feature of the model is its construction and training using human expert input alone. Model construction is described in detail. The model's performance was evaluated with actual case data. It was successful in correctly classifying 96.5% of 473 documented cases of microcytic anemia and anemia of chronic disease. It thus exhibits sufficient accuracy for it to be considered for use in reporting microcytic anemia diagnoses on hematology forms.

Anemia↗

Recognizing noun phrases in medical discharge summaries: an evaluation of two natural language parsers.

We evaluated the ability of two natural language parsers, CLARIT and the Xerox Tagger, to identify simple, noun phrases in medical discharge summaries. In twenty randomly selected discharge summaries, there were 1909 unique simple noun phrases. CLARIT and the Xerox Tagger exactly identified 77.0% and 68.7% of the phrases, respectively, and partially identified 85.7% and 80.8% of the phrases. Neither system had been specially modified or tuned to the medical domain. These results suggest that it is possible to apply existing natural language processing (NLP) techniques to large bodies of medical text, in order to empirically identify the terminology used in medicine. Virtually all the noun phrases could be regarded as having special medical connotation and would be candidates for entry into a controlled medical vocabulary.

Medical Records↗

The CIO and the medical informaticist: alliance for progress.

To achieve the full potential of information technology, health care institutions must overcome organizational and political barriers that often overshadow scientific and technical barriers. The time has come for an alliance between the Chief Information Officer (CIO) and medical informatics specialists, or informaticists. Organizations that successfully accomplish this alliance will position themselves to take advantage of the enormous potential of information technology to manage today's cost-quality pressures. This article first reviews some of the recent developments in the way health care organizations manage information technology. It then describes the traditional, perhaps the natural state of affairs, in which there may be tension and conflict between medical informaticists and line managers of information systems (IS). Finally, the article makes a case for closer collaboration and cooperation between these groups, and provides a case study that illustrates one example of such an alliance.

Academic Medical Centers↗

Combining logistic regression and neural networks to create predictive models.

Neural networks are being used widely in medicine and other areas to create predictive models from data. The statistical method that most closely parallels neural networks is logistic regression. This paper outlines some ways in which neural networks and logistic regression are similar, shows how a small modification of logistic regression can be used in the training of neural network models, and illustrates the use of this modification for variable selection and predictive model building with neural networks.

Algorithms↗

Maximum likelihood training of connectionist models: comparison with least squares back-propagation and logistic regression.

This paper presents maximum likelihood back-propagation (ML-BP), an approach to training neural networks. The widely reported original approach uses least squares back-propagation (LS-BP), minimizing the sum of squared errors (SSE). Unfortunately, least squares estimation does not give a maximum likelihood (ML) estimate of the weights in the network. Logistic regression, on the other hand, gives ML estimates for single layer linear models only. This report describes how to obtain ML estimates of the weights in a multi-layer model, and compares LS-BP to ML-BP using several examples. It shows that in many neural networks, least squares estimation gives inferior results and should be abandoned in favor of maximum likelihood estimation. Questions remain about the potential uses of multi-level connectionist models in such areas as diagnostic systems and risk-stratification in outcomes research.

Diagnosis, Computer-Assisted↗

Information workstations in clinical pathology.

Multitasking operating systems and expanding networks now permit smooth access to remote computers, peripherals, data, and information resources. Graphic user interfaces and productivity-enhancing software packages reduce the need for training and memorization of commands. New models of desktop computers based on "data-centered" software architecture can enhance workstation usefulness even more. Pathologists need to consider how these tools might improve access to and management of information and knowledge.

Computer Systems↗

A knowledge-based system for transfusion advice.

A knowledge-based system has been designed for evaluating the appropriateness of transfusion of non-red blood cell blood components. The goal of the system is to assist the blood bank physician in quality assurance efforts by automatically identifying cases of inappropriate transfusion before the blood is issued. Evaluation of a working prototype system shows that it is indeed capable of serving this function. The system identifies and summarizes cases, but it leaves consultation, education, and decision making to the blood bank physician. Small "expert systems" such as this may find use in quality assurance activities throughout the laboratory.

Blood Transfusion↗

Knowledge-based systems in laboratory medicine and pathology. A review and survey of the field.

Knowledge-based systems are computer systems designed to handle knowledge-intensive tasks, usually involving reasoning and inference. They are increasingly being applied to problems in laboratory medicine and pathology. In this article we provide a brief introduction to the basic concepts of knowledge-based systems, review some of their published applications, and report on an informal survey of specialists in laboratory medicine and pathology. The survey, sent to 102 individuals, indicated that 24% were involved in developing knowledge-based systems, with most systems at an early stage of development. Recent advances in knowledge-based systems research as well as survey responses suggest that this technology will have increasing value in laboratory medicine and pathology.

Artificial Intelligence↗