Non-right-handedness and schizophrenia.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to M Annett.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
A subgroup classification of handedness, ordered for degrees of relative hand skill, was linearly related to the probability of nonright preference for foot and eye in a volunteer sample of 263 people from the general public. Percentages of people with a nonright-handed parent also differed over groups as expected but not significantly.
This paper explains how combinations of asymmetries for pairs of laterality variables may be predicted. It shows that many pairs combine as expected by chance, plus the influence of the RS+ gene hypothesised by Annett (1978, 1985). These include: eye dominance with writing hand, with throwing hand, and with foot for kicking; nonright handedness with planum temporale asymmetry, with asymmetry of the parietal operculum, and the association between these two anatomical asymmetries. Handedness for writing and throwing, and hand and foot preferences are more strongly associated, suggesting the presence of an additional influence. The reliability of the present analyses was supported by replication, especially in findings for hand preferences for writing and throwing described by Gilbert and Wysocki (1992). The relative frequencies of discordant patterns of preference, LR (writing, throwing) versus RL, are a function of the frequencies of the two variables in the population. These differ between age groups and also with the classification of 'either' hand preferences. Patterns of preference for writing, throwing and eye-dominance (RRR, RRL etc) are related in an orderly manner to differences between the hands for peg moving time. The success of the present application of the RS theory strengthens the argument that individual differences for hand preference depend on a continuous distribution of asymmetry, not on the 'types' commonly assumed in the literature.
The reported therapeutic benefits of nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) in slowing periodontal disease progression appear intimately linked to the effective inhibition of local prostaglandin synthesis. This randomized, partially double-blind, controlled trial was conducted to evaluate the pharmacodynamic effects of the NSAID, ketoprofen (KTP), on gingival crevicular fluid (GCF) prostanoids. 42 subjects, ages 35-57 years, with moderate to advanced adult periodontitis were recruited and monitored for 22 days. On day 1, subjects were randomized for 1 of 5 treatments: i) 0.5% KTP gel; ii) 1.0% KTP gel; iii) 1.0% KTP alternate gel; iv) 2.0% KTP gel; v) 25 mg KTP capsule (positive control). Subjects applied 1 ml of gel topically to their gingiva or administered one capsule p.o., b.i.d. for 14.5 days. GCF samples were collected from posterior, interproximal sites on days 1 (pre-dosing; 1, 2, 3, 6 h), 8 (pre-dosing; 2 h), 15 (pre-dosing; 2 h) and 22 (post-treatment). GCF levels of prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and leukotriene B4 (LTB4) were determined using RIA, and expressed in ng/ml and % reduction from baseline (%Effect). Neither a significant difference among groups nor a dose response in % effect for either prostanoid was evident, both overall and among cohorts with elevated baseline mediator levels ([PGE2]>34 ng/ml; [LTB4]>300 ng/ml). When data were combined from all groups, significant (p<0.01) % reductions in GCF PGE2 were noted at 1 and 2 h post-dosing (29% and 24% respectively). In comparing topical versus systemic formulations, all topical formulations were as equipotent as systemic dosing in altering local prostaglandin levels despite lower KTP exposures with gel treatments. These data indicate that both topical and systemic KTP therapies pharmacodynamically reduce GCF PGE2 levels in adult periodontitis subjects, allowing for potential inhibition of disease progression.
The right shift (RS) theory (Annett, M., 1972. The distribution of manual asymmetry. Br. J. Psychol. 63, 343-358; Annett, M., 1985. Left, Right, Hand and Brain: The Right Shift Theory. Lawrence Erlbaum, London) suggests that the typical pattern of human cerebral and manual asymmetries depends on a single gene (RS+) which impairs speech-related cortex of the right hemisphere. The theory offers solutions to several puzzles, including the distribution of handedness in families (Annett, M., 1978. A Single Gene Explanation of Right and Left Handedness and Brainedness. Lanchester Polytechnic, Coventry; Annett, M., 1996. In defense of the right shift theory. Percept. Motor Skills 82, 115-137), relations between handedness and cerebral speech laterality (Annett, M., 1975. Hand preference and the laterality of cerebral speech. Cortex 11, 305-328; Annett, M., Alexander, M.P., 1996. Atypical cerebral dominance: predictions and tests of the right shift theory. Neuropsychologia 34, 1215-1227) and handedness and dyslexia (Annett, M. et al., 1996. Types of dyslexia and the shift to dextrality. J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry 37, 167-180). If Crow's (Crow, T.J. et al., 1989. Schizophrenia as an anomaly of development of cerebral asymmetry. A postmortem study and a proposal concerning the genetic basis of the disease. Arch. Gen. Psychiatry 46, 1145-1150; Crow, T.J., 1997. Is schizophrenia the price that Homo sapiens pays for language? Schizophr. Res. 28, 127-141) theory that schizophrenia is due to an anomaly of cerebral dominance is correct, and if the RS theory is correct, schizophrenia could be due to an anomaly of the RS+ gene. If the RS+ gene were at risk for a mutation which caused a loss of directional coding, the mutant could be described as 'agnosic' for left and right. Such a gene would impair either hemisphere at random. When paired with another RS+ gene, both hemispheres would be impaired in 50% of cases. The other 50% and people in whom the agnosic gene is paired with an RS-allele (neutral for asymmetry and not giving hemisphere impairment) would have one unaffected hemisphere and, thus, normal development. Quantitative predictions based on the RS genetic theory as previously developed, plus an agnosic mutant with frequency required to give schizophrenia in 1% of the population, are consistent with estimates of concordance for schizophrenia in relatives. Homozygotes of the agnosic mutant would occur at about the rate estimated for autism.
The right shift (RS) theory of handedness and cerebral dominance (Annett, 1972, 1985) suggested that individual differences for patterns of cerebral dominance may be associated with different types of risk to cognitive functions. The higher prevalence of dextrality than sinistrality in humans depends on a single gene (RS+) which facilitates left hemisphere specialisation for speech but at the expense of some right hemisphere function (Annett, 1992b; Kilshaw and Annett, 1983). RS-- genotypes have random asymmetries for hand and brain while RS++ genotypes have strong right shift. Three samples of undergraduates were given tests of phonological processing and of real word homophone discrimination. As predicted, phonology was poor in comparison with homophone discrimination toward the left of the laterality continuum while the reverse was true to the right of the continuum. When groups with specific difficulty for each type of test in comparison with the other were distinguished, those with poor phonology were less dextral and those with poor homophone discrimination were more dextral for hand preference than the rest of the sample. Siblings differed for handedness also, consistent with the argument for a genetic influence.
The right-shift (RS) theory suggests that sex differences for handedness are due to the displacement of a chance distribution of asymmetry farther to the right in females than males by about 20%. An analysis of studies in the literature shows that when handedness is assessed by self-report, paired samples of males and females differ for incidence of left-handedness as predicted, but for parents assessed by indirect-report, there are fewer left-handed mothers than expected. When handedness is assessed by self-report in both generations, the RS genetic model successfully predicts the distribution in families. It is also successful at different levels of criterion from left-writing to non-right-handedness. The RS predictions are not always consistent with the findings of studies that depended on indirect report of parental handedness. When parental incidences are low the proportion of left-handed children in the families of left-handed mothers is higher than expected. When parental incidences are high, predictions for the families of left-handed mothers are excellent, but the percentage of left-handed children in the families of left-handed fathers is lower than expected. Data for all indirect-report studies are combined to test the idea that the chief cause of poor fit is underreporting of left-handed mothers by right-handed children. Transfer of right-handed children from R x R to R x L families, thereby raising the percentage of left-handed mothers by about 1%, is sufficient to give good fits to RS predictions for both sexes.
The proportions of nonright-eyed children in families with 0, 1, or 2 nonright-eyed parents resemble those for nonright-handed children in the families of nonrighthanded parents. Both sets of proportions are consistent with the Annett right shift genetic model of human asymmetry. The suggestion that findings for eyedness in families are incompatible with genetic theories of handedness (Reiss & Reiss, 1997) is correct for the McManus theory but false for the Annett theory.
The "extreme" versus "mild" classification of handedness of Natsopoulos et al. (1998) is not comparable to that of Annett (review, 1995) because 50% of the former sample were left-handers while the samples of the latter were unselected for handedness. The 20% of the Natsopoulos sample called "extreme" right-handers represent nearly 40% of the general population. The possibility cannot be ruled out that the advantage for right-handers in this sample was due to a small excess of disabled children among left-handers because there were no controls for hand skill or for reading ability.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This clinical trial used a randomized, partially double-blind, controlled parallel design to evaluate the pharmacokinetics and safety of the NSAID, ketoprofen (KTP), in gel formulations. Forty-two subjects, ages 35 to 57 years, with generalized, moderate to advanced adult periodontitis were recruited and randomized to one of 5 treatments over a 14 1/2-day treatment period: (1) 0.5% KTP gel; (2) 1.0% KTP gel; (3) 1.0% KTP alternate gel; (4) 2.0% KTP gel; and (5) 25 mg KTP capsule (positive control). Plasma samples were obtained on days 1 (pre-dosing, 0.5, 1, 2, 3, 6 hr), 8 (pre-dosing, 2 hr), 15 (pre-dosing, 2 hr), and 22 (7 days post-treatment). Plasma KTP concentrations were determined by means of high-performance liquid chromatography. Significant differences in mean area under the plasma concentration vs. time curve (AUC(0-infinity)) among the groups were detected (p < 0.001), with the 25 mg p.o. capsule exhibiting the largest value (5054 ng-hr/mL), the 2.0% gel exhibiting an intermediate value (2244 ng-hr/mL), the 1.0% gels exhibiting lower but comparable values (1516 for the alternate formulation vs. 1461 ng-hr/mL), and the 0.5% gel showing the lowest value (736 ng-hr/mL). Significant differences in dose- and weight-adjusted maximum plasma concentration (Cmax/dose/kg) were detected overall such that the 25 mg p.o. capsule demonstrated higher values as compared with the 4 gel formulations (p = 0.001). The 5 treatments exhibited similar mean times of maximum plasma concentration (tmax) values ranging from 0.6 to 1 hr. Systemic exposures relative to dose and body weight were lower for the gel formulations than for the capsule. The relative systemic bioavailability of the gels compared with peroral administration ranged from 54% to 69%.
Crow (1995a) has argued that schizophrenia is caused by a gene associated with the evolution of human language and cerebral specialisation. This paper suggests a mechanism for Crow's theory which requires only one new assumption for the right shift genetic model of handedness and cerebral dominance (Annett, 1978). The proposal is that the RS+ allele, whose normal function is to induce the left hemisphere to serve speech by impairing speech-related cortex in the right hemisphere, tends to lose its directional coding. It becomes agnosic (RS+ a) for right versus left and impairs the left or right hemisphere at random. Schizophrenia is likely to develop when the RS+ a gene is paired with a normal RS+ gene but only in the 50% of cases where both hemispheres are affected. In the 50% where RS+ a affects the right hemisphere, development is normal as in the RS+ RS+ genotype. The risks for schizophrenia in monozygotic and dizygotic twins and other relatives are as expected for 50% expression of a Mendelian gene which is paired with a particular allele, but not alternative alleles at the same locus. The frequency of homozygotes for the agnosic gene is about 4 in 10,000, the rate observed for autism. A random pattern of double hemisphere deficits would give scope for a range of developmental strengths and weaknesses as observed within the spectrum of autistic disorders. Tests of the model require brain-imaging studies sensitive to individual differences in hemisphere lateralisation and a search for a genetic locus with human and nonhuman primate alleles, together with a mutant of the human form with a frequency of about 2%.
Anomalous lateralization of cognitive functions is observed in a small percentage of right-handed patients with unilateral brain damage, either crossed aphasia (aphasia after right brain damage) or "crossed nonaphasia" (left brain damage without aphasia but with visuospatial and other deficits typical of right brain damage). No comprehensive theory of these anomalous cases has been proposed. Nine new right-handed cases (plus one left-handed case) were analyzed and the literature was reviewed. The dramatically anomalous organization of cognitive functions is best explained by random lateralization of all cognitive functions in a small subset of the population. The RS theory of cerebral dominance can account for this pattern of anomalies in right-handers and may account for the most common patterns of dominance observed in left-handers.
Alexander and Annett (Brain and Language, in press) described new cases of atypical cerebral specialization, and suggested that these observations and others in the literature could be explained by the right shift (RS) theory. The theory generates specific predictions as to the prevalence of different patterns of cerebral dominance and their distribution among right-handers and left-handers. Predictions differ between strict and generous criteria of sinistrality, as between left writers and non-right-handers. Tests of the predictions against reports in the literature reveal good fits for most data. New studies will test the RS theory if their design permits examination of the present predictions.
The right shift theory of handedness and cerebral specialization suggests that there is an underlying substrate of random lateral asymmetries in all higher animals and a specific factor in humans which increases the probability of left hemisphere advantage. The specific factor displaces the random distribution along a continuum of asymmetry in favour of the left hemisphere and the right hand. The distribution of handedness in families can be explained if the shift to dextrality depends on a single gene, rs +, when the frequency of the gene is estimated from the proportion of dysphasics with unilateral lesions of the left versus the right hemisphere. The gentoype proportions suggested a genetic balanced polymorphism with heterozygote advantage for laterality and ability. Application of the model to developmental dyslexia led to the hypothesis that both homozygotes (rs -- and rs ++ genotypes) are at risk for reading. The critical question was whether the type of cognitive problem differs as expected, speech based processing for the rs -- and non-speech based for the rs ++. The former should include more left and mixed handers, while the latter should be more strongly dextral than controls. Evidence for this double dissociation between type of cognitive disability and type of handedness has been found in poor readers and in other samples.
The prediction of the right shift theory that there are two types of dyslexia with different distributions of handedness was examined in a large cohort of school children. Dyslexics with poor phonology were less biased to dextrality than controls, while dyslexics without poor phonology tended to be more dextral than controls on measures of hand preference and hand skill. Relatives also differed for handedness, as expected if phonological dyslexics were less likely than nonphonological dyslexics and controls to carry the hypothesized rs + gene.
The right shift (RS) theory of a gene for left-cerebral dominance which increases the probability of right-handedness is outlined, together with two proposed alternatives, the 1985a genetic theory of McManus and the 1993 developmental instability theory of Yeo and Gangestad. Similarities and differences among the three theories are reviewed. Both of the genetic theories can predict the distribution of handedness in families and in twins more efficiently than the developmental instability theory, and the RS theory better than the McManus theory.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.