PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

M F Festing

Publications and source records attributed to M F Festing.

At least 55 records · Page 3Linked to original sources

Genetic factors in toxicology: implications for toxicological screening.

Methods of assessing the toxicity of xenobiotics have improved substantially during the last decade. However, as compounds become generally safer, the problem of individual variation in response assumes increasing relative importance. Environmental factors such as age, health and nutritional status, and interactions with other xenobiotics account for some of this variation, but genetic differences between individuals and races have important implications. In a few cases, Mendelian loci which control drug susceptibility (e.g., to isoniazid) have been described. However, in most cases the exact mode of inheritance has not yet been determined due to the problems of carrying out genetic studies in man. It is well established that many loci that are polymorphic in man are also so in laboratory animals, so much of this genetic variation should be picked up in preclinical screening, and could be used to more accurately predict potential variation in toxicity in man. Unfortunately, most toxicologists use only a single stock of laboratory animals, which does not show whether the response to a given xenobiotic is under genetic control. The design of animal tests would be improved by using more than one strain of genetically defined animals, and by paying more attention to genetic variation in responses to xenobiotics, both in animals and man.

Animals↗

The case for isogenic strains in toxicological screening.

The fundamental principle of the controlled experiment is that treated and control groups should be identical, with minimal within-group variability. Toxicologists recognise this and control age, body weight, disease and the physical environment of the test animals. However most toxicological screening in done with genetically variable outbred stocks, even though isogenic inbred strains, F1 hybrids or identical siblings are usually available. The result is poor experiments with the inevitable genetic differences between groups resulting in increased false positive and negative results, and no indication that the response is under genetic control. It is also illogical to treat genetic variation differently from other types of variation. The argument that it is essential to use outbred animals to model outbred man is illogical. If bacteria can be used to model man (as in the Ames test), so can inbred animals. The uncontrolled variation present in an outbred stock can not be used efficiently to increase the range of phenotypes tested because it also introduces "noise" which obscures experimental effects. The use of two or more isogenic strains gives a much more efficient experimental design with low "noise" and an indication of whether the response is under genetic control. Inbred and F1 hybrid strains (but not identical siblings) have the added advantage of an immortal genotype which outlives any individual animal. Such immortal genotypes may be studied in detail to gather background information. Toxicologists should treat genetics like every other variable and control it, using several isogenic strains in cases where testing needs to be done on more than one genotype.

Animals↗

NIH/Ola: a highly productive inbred strain of laboratory mouse.

According to historical records the NIH/Ola strain was developed from outbred 'Swiss' mice imported into the USA by Dr C. Lynch in 1926. A comparison of biochemical markers in strain NIH/Ola and other strains such as SJL and SWR derived from the same foundation stock supports the historical records. Data on litter size, length of gestation, bodyweight to 70 days of age, and reproductive performance when housed in polygamous groups of up to 10 females per male were compared with similar data on inbred CBA/CaOla and C57BL/10ScSnOla mice. NIH/Ola inbred mice had an exceptional reproductive performance, producing about 1.8 young weaned/female/week when housed as monogamous pairs over a period of 20 weeks, compared with less than 1.0 young/female/week with the other 2 strains. NIH/Ola mice were also extremely tolerant to mating in polygamous groups of up to about 8 females per male. Mating ratios of over 2-3 females per male resulted in a marked decline in the total number of litters produced per female in C57BL/10ScSnOla and CBA/CaOla, but this reduction was not nearly so marked in NIH/Ola. It is concluded that the NIH/Ola inbred strain may be particularly useful in studies such as teratology where a high reproductive performance needs to be combined with the advantages of a fully inbred strain.

Animals↗

An allelic difference determines reciprocal patterns of expression of binding sites for Dolichos biflorus lectin in inbred strains of mice.

We used staining of tissue sections by lectin conjugates to screen inbred strains of mice for polymorphisms which could be used as histological markers of chimaerism. We found one polymorphism, which involves reciprocal patterns of expression of binding sites for the N-acetyl-galactosamine-binding lectins from Dolichos biflorus (DBA), Helix pomatia (HPA) and Wisteria floribunda (WFA) on intestinal epithelium and vascular endothelium. The polymorphism is due to alleles at a single locus, designated D1b-1 (for Dolichos lectin binding). Of 29 inbred strains examined, 3 are D1b-1a (type strain RIII-ro; gut epithelium-ve, vascular endothelium + ve), and 26 are D1b-1b (type strain C57BL/6J; gut epithelium + ve, vascular endothelium-ve). In RIII-ro and C57BL/6J embryos, the polymorphic difference is not clearly present until day 11 of gestation. Before then, embryos of both strains express binding sites on gut epithelium and on endothelium. The temporal and tissue-specific patterns of expression of lectin-binding sites may result from differences in expression of an N-acetyl galactosaminosyl transferase. If so, elucidation of the genetic basis of the polymorphism might provide an insight into the mechanisms of developmental regulation of glycosyltransferase activity.

Alleles↗

Principal components analysis of haematological data from F344 rats with bladder cancer fed N-(ethyl)-all-trans-retinamide.

Several multivariate statistical methods are available which can alleviate the problems of analysing the large volumes of data generated from toxicological experiments. One such technique, principal components analysis, provides a method for exploring the relationships between a number of variables (such as blood parameters) and for eliminating redundant data if strong correlations exist between the characters. It also provides a method for clustering individuals, which may reveal similarities between animals in a treatment group or highlight individual 'outliers'. The application of principal components analysis to a set of haematological data from a trial evaluating the efficacy of a synthetic retinoid against carcinogen-induced bladder cancer in the rat has clearly shown, in two bivariate plots, that while some animals in the carcinogen-treated groups were normal, others were anaemic and that animals fed the synthetic retinoid and killed at 1 year had a microcytic anaemia. A full exploration of the data using conventional univariate statistical analysis would have involved at least 28 graphic representations of the data, as well as the interpretation of more than 130 means and SDs. Principal components analysis provides a valuable additional tool for the statistical analysis and exploration of toxicological data, but it must be used in conjunction with univariate or other multivariate methods if hypothesis testing is required. The use of multivariate techniques in toxicology may best be assessed by their practical application to toxicological data, and this paper presents such an evaluation with the aim of encouraging further exploration of the usefulness of principal components analysis. The raw data on which most analyses have been carried out are given.

Analysis of Variance↗

An investigation of genetic variation within a series of congenic strains of mice.

2 congenic strains of mice, B6N.AKN-Ahk and D2N.B6N-Ahb, imported from the USA, were found to be either segregating or fixed for an incorrect allele at a number of biochemical loci. B6N.AKN-Ahk, supposedly congenic with C57BL/6N, had the wrong genotype at 6 out of 12 biochemical loci; D2N.B6N-Ahb, supposedly congenic with DBA/2N, was segregating at 3 out of 9 loci. There was genetic variation in mandible shape within the 2 strains but no abnormal coat colours were found and no hybrid vigour in breeding performance was detected. Analyses in the USA confirmed these results and showed that 2 other congenic strains, C3N.D2N-Ahd and AKN.B6J-Ahb, were also segregating at a number of loci. Some of the alleles found in the C3N.D2N-Ahd mice must be the result of a genetic contamination. The simplest explanation for this breakdown in the backcrossing programme is genetic contamination with other congenic strains or recombinant inbred lines under development in the same laboratory. These findings emphasize the importance of continual genetic monitoring of all genetic stocks at regular intervals and in particular during the development of congenic and recombinant lines.

Alleles↗

Haematological findings in healthy and diseased rabbits, a multivariate analysis.

Haematological data from 94 diseased rabbits and 23 healthy adult rabbits were analysed statistically using principal components analysis and multiple discriminant function analysis. The 1st principal component accounted for 32% of the variation and was interpreted as showing total blood cellularity. This was decreased in the majority of diseased rabbits, principally due to anaemia, although in a few it was slightly increased possibly as a result of dehydration. The 2nd principal component (22% of the variation) had high positive loadings on monocyte and heterophil counts and weak negative loadings on the red cell characters. This component was interpreted as the response of the white blood cells to disease. When classification analysis was used to decide whether or not an animal was 'normal' the heterophil and lymphocyte counts alone provided almost as accurate an assessment as when all the blood parameters were taken into account. The role of these analyses in the diagnosis of disease is discussed.

Analysis of Variance↗

Whisker trimming in mice.

Whisker trimming is extremely common in strain A2G mice, with an incidence which progresses with age. Over 75% of cages containing 2-3 mice have 1 or more active trimmers by the time the mice are about 60 days old. When male A2G mice were housed with mice of other strains there was a tendency for trimming to occur most in cages where the A2G male was socially dominant (as judged by a tube test). The number of animals per cage did not seem to influence this behaviour. In groups of male mice there was usually I with untrimmed whiskers, presumably because he was socially dominant. However, with females there were always several active trimmers. There was some evidence that when females became pregnant they were able to resist whisker trimming by their mates.

Age Factors↗

Polyvalent strain-specific alloantisera as tools for routine genetic quality control of inbred and congenic strains of rats and mice.

Strain-specific polyvalent alloantisera may be obtained by injecting lymphocytes pooled from several different strains into an inbred recipient. 6 sera of this type were produced in rats and 23 in mice. A dye-exclusion microcytotoxic test was used to evaluate the strain specificity of such sera. A total of 663 out of 713 (93.0%) of the tests conformed with expectation, but there were 58 (6.7%) false negative results in which the test failed to detect non-authentic animals. There were also 2 (0.3%) false positive results, in which authentic animals were shown as non-authentic. These were attributed to technical errors. Most false negative results occurred when serum and test cell suspensions matched at the major histocompatibility complex. It was concluded that the use of strain-specific polyvalent immune sera, coupled with a simple immunological test such as the microcytotoxic test, offers a sensitive and quick new method for routine genetic quality control.

Animals↗