PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

M Taningher

Publications and source records attributed to M Taningher.

At least 37 records · Page 2Linked to original sources

Lack of correlation between alkaline DNA fragmentation and DNA covalent binding induced by polychloroethanes after in vivo administration. Problems related to the assessment of a carcinogenic hazard.

The DNA-damaging activity of polychloroethanes was tested in mouse liver by the fluorometric assay of DNA unwinding. With the exception of 1,2-dichloroethane, all components of this chemical class had negative results. The failure of the parameter alkaline "DNA fragmentation" to detect the DNA-damaging activity of polychloroethanes is in sharp contrast with the measurement of DNA covalent binding, another short-term parameter of genotoxicity. Since covalent DNA adducts appear to be quantitatively well correlated with the oncogenic potencies of chloroethanes in liver, the negative results obtained with the present method can perhaps be explained in terms of quality of DNA adducts; these may be incapable of producing DNA breaks or alkali-labile sites detectable as alkaline DNA fragmentation. It is however worth noting that carcinogenicity of chloroethanes appears to depend not only on DNA damaging capability, but also on promoting activity during the carcinogenic process.

Alkalies↗

Mutagenic and carcinogenic potency indices and their correlation.

We have analyzed a significant number of studies existing in the literature, in which the ability of different short-term tests for predicting carcinogenicity in rodents was investigated. We have separated these studies into two groups. In the better known group of studies, qualitative predictivity was investigated (sensitivity and specificity). In the second group of studies (analyzed in greater detail), positive results were examined for the correlation between carcinogenic potency and potency of response in a given short-term test. There is substantial agreement between qualitative and quantitative predictivity; both appear to be situated between a low and moderate level. We have analyzed the interesting possibility of using the quantitative approach not only for positive data but for combined positive and negative data as well. We have stressed that short-term tests of genotoxicity should be asked to predict only initiation and irreversible alterations in the genome and not to predict a combination of these events, including promotion and modulation of differentiation. Even with regard to only initiation, genotoxicity data should be related to comparative metabolism, as well as to considerations of the significance of different end points and structure-activity relationship data. In conclusion, the information coming from short-term tests of genotoxicity is probably useful but should be used in conjunction with other types of information and only for predicting one particular class of events in the entire process of carcinogenesis.

Carcinogenicity Tests↗

Mutagenicity in V79 cells does not correlate with carcinogenity in small rodents for 12 aromatic amines.

The aim of this investigation was to study the correlation between carcinogenicity in small rodents and mutagenic potency of aromatic amines, as measured by the induction of 6-thioguanine resistance in V79 Chinese hamster cells. It has been previously shown that the carcinogenic potency of these compounds is not correlated to their ability to induce DNA breakage, SCEs, or point mutations in bacteria, but a correlation exists with autoradiographic DNA repair test (in primary hepatocyte cultures). Twelve aromatic amines were tested and the rat liver S9 fraction was routinely incorporated in the mutation assay; mouse liver and hamster liver S9 fractions were also used as metabolizing systems. The comparison of the ranks of mutagenic and oncogenic potencies by means of the Spearman test shows no correlation between carcinogenicity and V79 cell mutagenicity of the tested aromatic amines. There was a generally low mutagenicity seen for aromatic amines in V79 cells. In some cases this could be attributed to an insufficient metabolic activation by rat S9. For example, benzidine, which was inactive when assayed in the presence of rat S9, became mutagenic when in the presence of mouse S9. On the other hand, hamster S9, which has been shown to be the best activating system for 2-acetylaminofluorene in the Ames test, did not activate this compound in V79 cells. Inadequate metabolic activation of the standard system (rat S9) used in this work could explain the low mutagenicity and the lack of correlation observed between mutagenicity and carcinogenicity. A second possibility is that point mutation is not the essential end point for the initiating activity of aromatic amines during the carcinogenic process. A third possibility is that the activity of some aromatic amines is not restricted to the initiation step in carcinogenesis. Chronic treatments with the sublethal doses often result in significant promoting activities, which could mask efficiently the initiating potential of the same chemicals.

Amines↗

Negative results of short-term genotoxicity tests with 1,4-bis[2-(3,5-dichloropyridyloxy)]benzene.

The phenobarbital-like enzyme inducer and tumor promoter of murine hepatocarcinogenesis, 1,4-bis[2-(3,5-dichloropyridyloxy)]benzene has been assayed in short-term genotoxicity tests, i.e. the Salmonella mutagenicity test, micronucleus and chromosomal aberrations analysis in mouse bone marrow cells in vivo, DNA alkaline elution and DNA unwinding assays in mouse liver in vivo. All the assays performed proved negative.

Animals↗

In vitro transformation of BALB/c 3T3 cells by 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane.

1,1,2,2-Tetrachloroethane (1,1,2,2-TTCE) was shown to be capable of inducing in vitro transformation of BALB/c 3T3 cells (clone A-31) either in the presence or in the absence of S9 activating system using an amplification-transformation (level-II) assay by reseeding confluent cells from each treatment and allowing additional rounds of cell replication. In the absence of metabolic activation, the highest assayed dose (1000 micrograms/ml), exerting the highest toxicity, was the only transforming dose. Lower doses of 1,1,2,2-TTCE were capable of transforming BALB/c cells in the presence of S9 activating system, the dose of 500 micrograms/ml exerting the highest transforming activity. The number and size of transformed foci recognized in the level-II plates were a function of the number of cells reseeded in the amplification assay. Foci obtained in the presence of S9 activating systems were larger in size, more deeply basophilic, and exhibited denser multilayering of constituent cells than foci recognized in the absence of exogenous metabolic activation.

Animals↗

Quantitative predictability of carcinogenicity of the covalent binding index of chemicals to DNA: comparison of the in vivo and in vitro assays.

The capability of covalent binding to DNA to predict the initiating potential of chemical carcinogens was compared for the assays performed in vivo (rodent liver DNA) and in vitro (purified DNA incubated in the presence of mouse and rat liver microsomes). A quantitative correlation between DNA adducts and carcinogenic potency was investigated. The in vivo assay appeared slightly, but not significantly, more predictive than the in vitro assay. Also predictivity was slightly higher both in vivo and in vitro when we referred to liver carcinogenicity instead of overall carcinogenicity. The predictive ability found for DNA covalent binding (both in vivo and in vitro) was similar to that of many short-term tests (such as mutagenicity, DNA damage/repair, SCEs, and cell transformation tests). The covalent DNA binding, measured after incubation with DNA in vitro in the presence of liver microsomes, could therefore be a reasonable short-term test offering greater rapidity of execution and requiring the sacrifice of fewer animals than the corresponding in vivo test.

Animals↗

Lack of DNA alterations induced by orotic acid in rat liver as evaluated with two DNA unwinding methods.

One percent orotic acid supplemented diet is a promoting treatment in the rat model of liver carcinogenesis. After treatment with this type of diet, DNA alterations were observed using alkaline sucrose gradients and alkaline elution methods. In this work we have utilized two unwinding methods for the detection of DNA fragmentation. One method is a viscosimetric method in which the rate of increase in DNA viscosity with time is related to the rate of alkaline DNA unwinding. The second method measures fluorimetrically the amount of renatured and denatured DNA after different times allowed for alkaline DNA unwinding. These two methods are very sensitive in detecting DNA breaks induced by typical alkylating agents, X-rays and H2O2. The two unwinding methods were clearly negative for the orotic acid supplemented diet. We suggest that the DNA alterations detected with alkaline sucrose gradients and alkaline elution methods, after promoting treatment with orotic acid, are probably different from the DNA breaks induced by typical alkylating agents, X-rays and H2O2.

Animals↗

The problem of carcinogenic hazard evaluation for new chemicals: general considerations about the carcinogenic process.

We discuss the problem of oncogenic hazard evaluation for new chemicals. In the recent past, assessment of global carcinogenicity in rodents was considered the most significant type of information. It has recently emerged that this type of information is not adequate to distinguish initiation and genotoxicity from promotion-like effects. In this report we suggest that hazards from initiating agents and hazards from promoting agents should be treated separately. In this perspective, longterm experiments for carcinogenicity in rodents should still play an important role but a less central one. Initiation-promotion experiments in different target organs are recommended. We suggest a strategy of hazard evaluation related to the initiating potential as distinct from overall carcinogenicity. The problem of utilizing not only the qualitative component of the available information, but also the quantitative component, is considered. Finally, we discuss a possible hazard evaluation for promoting effects, but conclude that this area is very much in its infancy. Possible contributions of computer science technology to the problem of oncogenic hazard evaluation are briefly introduced.

Animals↗

DNA damage in mouse and rat liver by caprolactam and benzoin, evaluated with three different methods.

Benzoin and caprolactam were examined for their capability of inducing alkaline DNA fragmentation in mouse and rat liver DNA after treatment in vivo. Three different methods were used. With the alkaline elution technique we measured an effect presumably related to the conformation of the DNA coil. With a viscometric and a fluorometric unwinding method we measured an effect presumably related to the number of unwinding points in DNA. For both compounds only the alkaline elution technique was clearly positive. The results suggest that both caprolactam and benzoin can induce an important change in the conformation of the DNA coil without inducing true breaks in DNA.

Animals↗

Chemical composition and genotoxic activity of petroleum derivatives collected in two working environments.

Pitch and bitumen, two complex petroleum derivative mixtures, were studied for both their chemical composition and their mutagenic/DNA damaging activity. While bitumen revealed no genotoxic effect and low polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) concentration, petroleum pitch showed a high concentration of mutagenic/carcinogenic PAHs, and also an elevated mutagenic activity when assayed by the Ames test, in the presence of postmitochondrial rat liver fractions. The in vitro mutagenic activity was detectable as frameshift mutation by assaying the pitch both as an in toto mixture and after HPLC fractionation, the most polar fractions being the most active. In contrast, both derivatives showed no in vivo DNA damage in rat liver, using the DNA alkaline elution technique and the fluorometric assay of DNA unwinding.

Animals↗

Results of animal studies suggest a nonlinear dose-response relationship for benzene effects.

Considering the very large industrial usage of benzene, studies in risk assessment aimed at the evaluation of carcinogenic risk at low levels of exposure are important. Animal data can offer indications about what could happen in humans and provide more diverse information than epidemiological data with respect to dose-response consideration. We have considered experiments investigating metabolism, short-term genotoxicity tests, DNA adduct formation, and carcinogenicity long-term tests. According to the different experiments, a saturation of benzene metabolism and benzene effects in terms of genotoxicity seems evident above 30 to 100 ppm. Below 30 to 60 ppm the initiating effect of benzene seems to be linear for a large interval of dosages, at least judging from DNA adduct formation. Potential lack of a promoting effect of benzene (below 10 ppm) could generate a sublinear response at nontoxic levels of exposure. This possibility was suggested by epidemiological data in humans and is not confirmed or excluded by our observations with animals.

Animals↗

Binding of hexachloroethane to biological macromolecules from rat and mouse organs.

Hexachloroethane (HCE) binds to macromolecules of rat and mouse both in vivo and in vitro after metabolic activation. The covalent binding index (CBI) to liver DNA in vivo is comparable to that of compounds classified as weak-moderate initiators and is of approximately the same order of magnitude as those of other halocompounds such as 1,2-dichloroethane. HCE is bioactivated in vitro by microsomal enzymatic systems from murine liver and kidney and, to a greater extent, by cytosolic fractions from all assayed organs. HCE is less reactive than 1,1,2,2-tetrachloroethane, which is more toxic and oncogenic. The ability of hexachloroethane and five other chloroethanes to react covalently with mouse liver DNA both in vivo and in vitro parallels the relative oncogenic potency of these hepatocarcinogenic chemicals in mouse liver.

Animals↗

Characterization of the effects induced on DNA in mouse and hamster cells by lithocholic acid.

Lithocholic acid (LCA) is a promoting agent in colon carcinogenesis. In this work we have tried to characterize the DNA alteration induced by LCA in cells grown in vitro and in nuclei. Confirming previous findings, a clear increase in elution rate was observed at both alkaline and neutral pH. The extent of the increase was very similar at the two pHs. However, an increased elution rate could be observed only when lysing the nuclei at high ionic strength and low detergent concentration (2 M NaCl + 0.2% N-lauroylsarcosine sodium salt). No effect could be observed when the nuclei were lysed with a high detergent concentration (2% sodium dodecyl sulfate). In addition, a slight effect could be observed using a method for the evaluation of DNA unwinding in alkali. After termination of the incubation with LCA, the DNA alteration observed with DNA elution disappeared very rapidly both in intact cells and nuclei, even when the incubation buffer was totally unsuitable for the repair of the type of DNA damage induced by typical genotoxic agents. The effect of LCA on DNA was apparently not mediated through an inhibition of topoisomerase II. Only the intact chromatin of nuclei was responsive, not the quasinaked DNA of nuclei lysed at high ionic strength. We advance the hypothesis that the increased alkaline and neutral elution rate observed with LCA could be independent of DNA fragmentation and related to changes in chromatin structure.

Animals↗

Utilization of the quantitative component of the information obtained from short term tests.

We are referring in this paper to traditional tests of genotoxicity that are essentially detecting properties correlated with the initiating activity of chemical and physical agents. In classical initiation-promotion experiments, promotion is changing dramatically tumor frequency, but a better correlation between initiation and tumor frequency may exist when carcinogenesis experiments in rodents utilize only an initiator agent. End points, metabolism and target organs of short term test may be not optimal in respect to the real initiation process. In conclusion, we have to expect a very high level of statistical noise in the correlation between short term tests and carcinogenicity in rodents. Correlations of this type are not unique in science. For instance, the input data for weather forecasting and the real weather are often related with a high level of statistical noise. But this is not considered a good reason for throwing away the quantitative component of the input information. Similarly, in this context the utilization of the quantitative component of the information improves in a moderate, but not negligible way the predictive value of the information offered from short term tests, especially when they are used in a battery. In this review we discuss the possibility that, when studying correlations between genotoxicity tests and carcinogenicity in rodents, a quantitative approach could replace with important advantages the qualitative approach generally adopted up to the present time. The qualitative approach appeared as a more modest but realistic approach to the complexities of these correlation studies. What we suggest is that a quantitative approach mathematically not less correct than the qualitative approach is feasible. More precise and useful information for risk assessment evaluations can be obtained.

Animals↗

A choline-devoid diet, carcinogenic in the rat, induces DNA damage and repair.

A diet deficient in choline when fed to rats for as few as 3 days resulted in liver DNA damage. The damage could be monitored as alkali-labile lesions using alkaline-sucrose gradients as well as alkaline elution technique. The DNA damage disappeared when the choline-deficient diet was replaced by a choline-supplemented diet suggesting the alkali-labile lesions were repairable. The DNA damage was detected at a time when no liver cell death was detectable. The induction of DNA damage in a proliferating liver by the choline-deficient diet may be an early important event leading to initiation of liver carcinogenesis.

Animals↗

Quantitative predictivity of carcinogenicity of the autoradiographic repair test (primary hepatocyte cultures) for a group of 80 chemicals belonging to different chemical classes.

In this work we have investigated the correlation existing between a short-term genotoxicity test (DNA repair in rat liver cells) and carcinogenicity in rodents. The work is in the framework of a line of thinking that considers as a possibility the utilization of the quantitative component of the information obtained from genotoxicity tests. In a preliminary report for 25 compounds belonging to different chemical classes, a correlation coefficient of 0.36 was found between carcinogenic potency in small rodents and potency in autoradiographic repair. This level of correlation is comparable with similar levels found for many other short-term tests: Ames test, alkaline DNA fragmentation in vivo, DNA adducts in vivo, morphological transformation in vitro and SCE induction in vivo. Obviously, since only 25 compounds were examined, assessment was rather uncertain, and the subdivision of the set into subsets for different chemical classes would have generated groups too small for a meaningful statistical analysis. With a much larger set (80 compounds) we hoped to be able to discriminate different predictivities for different chemical classes. This seems important because the test could be much more suitable for one given class than for another. Previous investigations with different short-term tests have shown that these differences can indeed exist and be very great. In this respect it is potentially very encouraging that the test considered here showed a fair correlation with carcinogenic potency for aromatic amines. Many other tests that we have examined so far have shown little or no predictivity for this important class of chemicals.

Animals↗

Quantitative correlation with carcinogenic potency of different short term tests.

The following short term parameters evaluating essentially genotoxic effects were considered: liver DNA alkaline fragmentation (DFI), morphological transformation in hamster embryo cells (TPI), and mutagenicity in the Ames' test (MPI). The internal consistency of the carcinogenicity data (OPI) was rather high (r approximately or equal to 0.8). The correlation with OPI of DFI and MPI was statistically significant but rather modest, about 0.4-0.5. The best correlation between OPI and TPI was 0.65. This level of correlation was observed only when some kind of dose-response relationship for transformation could be established. When comparisons were attempted for exactly the same 27 compounds for all three tests, a general decrease in predictability was observed. This could be mainly due to problems of representation of the ideal population of chemicals using small samples. The more general problem of the quantitative approach to the predictability of short term tests was also discussed.

Animals↗