Developmental biology: Ignoratio elenchi: red herrings in stem cell research.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Animals↗
Biomedical subjects
Mark Dooner
Publications and source records attributed to Mark Dooner.
The stem cell continuum.
Hematopoietic stem cells have been felt to exist in a hierarchical structure with a relatively fixed phenotype at each stage of differentiation. Recent studies on the phenotype of the marrow hematopoietic stem cell indicate that it is not a fixed entity, but rather that it fluctuates and shows marked heterogeneity. Past studies have shown that stem cell engraftment characteristics, adhesion protein, and gene expression varies with the phase of the cell cycle. More recently, we demonstrated that progenitor numbers and differentiation potential also vary reversibly during one cytokine-induced cell cycle transit. We have also shown high levels of conversion of marrow cells to skeletal muscle and lung cells, indicating a different level of plasticity. Recently, we demonstrated that homing to lung and conversion to lung cells in a mouse transplant model also fluctuates reversibly with cell cycle transit. This could be considered plasticity squared. These data indicate that marrow stem cells are regulated on a continuum related to the cell cycle both as to hematopoietic and to nonhematopoietic differentiation.
Cell Cycle↗
Circadian variations of bone marrow engraftability.
Circadian rhythms exist for hematopoiesis, but little is known about circadian variation of bone marrow engraftability and host "acceptability". Using a B6.SJL to C57BL/6J congenic transplant model, we chose 3-times with light on: Hours After Light Onset (HALO) 4, 8, and 12 and 3-times with light off: HALO 16, 20, and 24. The mice were conditioned on a 12-h light/dark cycles. Recipient mice (100 cGy) received 40 million cells. We demonstrated a significant variation of bone marrow engraftability into bone marrow, spleen, and thymus when donor animals were subjected to changes in their light/dark cycles. Two statistically significant nadirs in all three organs were observed at HALO 8 and 24 in experiments carried out in July, while an identical set of experiments in February analyzing engraftment in marrow and spleen showed nadirs at HALO 8, but not at HALO 24. Marrow progenitors from the July experiments showed nadirs at HALO 12 and 24. The percentage of progenitors in S phase peaked at HALO 8 and 24. Interestingly, there were no changes in the ability of host to accept grafts with changes in the light/dark cycles of host animals. Circadian variations of bone marrow engraftability are important and should be considered in bone marrow transplant strategies.
Animals↗
Marrow stem cells shift gene expression and engraftment phenotype with cell cycle transit.
We studied the genetic and engraftment phenotype of highly purified murine hematopoietic stem cells (lineage negative, rhodamine-low, Hoechst-low) through cytokine-stimulated cell cycle. Cells were cultured in interleukin (IL)-3, IL-6, IL-11, and steel factor for 0 to 48 h and tested for engraftment capacity in a lethally irradiated murine competitive transplant model. Engraftment showed major fluctuations with nadirs at 36 and 48 h of culture and recovery during the next G1. Gene expression of quiescent (0 h) or cycling (48 h) stem cells was compared with lineage positive cells by 3' end PCR differential display analysis. Individual PCR bands were quantified using a 0 to 9 scale and results were visually compared using color-coded matrices. We defined a set of 637 transcripts expressed in stem cells and not expressed in lineage positive cells. Gene expression analyzed at 0 and 48 h showed a major shift from "stem cell genes" being highly expressed at 0 h and turned off at 48 h, while "cell division" genes were turned on at 48 h. These observations suggest stem cell gene expression shifts through cell cycle in relation to cell cycle related alterations of stem cell phenotype. The engraftment defect is related to a major phenotypic change of the stem cell.
Animals↗
A method for clonal analysis of epidermal growth factor-responsive neural progenitors.
Epidermal growth factor (EGF) responsive neural progenitors are defined by clonal growth from single cells. In previous studies we were unable to obtain clones at single cell densities using trypsinized cells and trituration alone always gave cellular aggregates. Here we report on single cell derived clones using a technique involving trituration of EGF responsive neurospheres, cell filtration, and single cell sorting using a MoFlo high speed fluorescence activated cell sorter. Single cell deposition was confirmed by labeling cells with Hoechst 33342 and Flow-check Fluorospheres, and visualization by fluorescence microscopy. The cells were deposited into liquid medium and grown from single cells in 10-20 ng/ml EGF for 12-14 days. This gave a cloning efficiency of 2.12%+/-0.37. New colonies occurred as late as day 18 post-sort. Tritiated thymidine suicide indicates that a percentage of these cells are cycling. Immunohistochemical analysis for oligodendrocytes, astroglia, and neuronal lineages performed on colonies at 10-14 and 21-28 days gave 39% uni-lineage, 36% bi-lineage, and 25% tri-lineage colonies. A total of five different types of progenitor cells were observed. In individual colonies, oligodendrons predominated with a lesser presence of astroglial or neuronal cell types. This approach establishes a reliable and reproducible method for single cell cloning of neurosphere cells.
Animals↗
Homing of purified murine lymphohematopoietic stem cells: a cytokine-induced defect.
This study was designed to establish a direct homing assay using purified lineage-negative Sca-1-positive (Lin(-) Sca(+)) murine bone marrow cells and to evaluate the effects of cytokines on homing. C57BL/6 Lin(-) Sca(+) marrow stem cells were labeled with 5-(and 6)-carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester (CFDA-SE) and then injected by tail vein into untreated C57BL/6 mice. Marrow was harvested at various times after cell infusion and analyzed on a high-speed MoFlo cell sorter for fluorescent positive events, using a large event analysis, with at least 16 million total events analyzed. We have shown that homing of Lin(-) Sca(+) cells plateaus by 1 h, and at 3 h post-infusion is linear between 50,000 and 1,000,000 infused cells. This forms a base for a homing assay in which 250,000 CFDA-SE labeled Lin(-) Sca(+) marrow cells are infused and then recovered from marrow 3 h later, followed by a large-event fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) analysis. We found that 7.45-9.32% of infused cells homed and that homing of stem cells cultured for 48 h in interleukin-3 (IL-3), IL-6, IL-11, and steel factor cultured cells was defective when compared to noncultured cells. Exposure of marrow stem cells to IL-3, IL-6, IL-11, and steel factor induces a stem cell homing defect, which probably underlies the engraftment defect previously characterized under these conditions.
Animals↗
Stem cell plasticity: an overview.
The capacity of adult bone marrow cells to convert to cells of other tissues, referred to by many as stem cell plasticity, was the focus of the meeting in Providence entitled "Challenges in the Era of Stem Cell Plasticity". The meeting provided a showcase for the many impressive positive results on tissue restoration including the capacity of purified marrow stem cells to restore heart, skin, and liver function in impaired mice or humans. This area of research has become a center of controversy, although it is not clear why. Calls for clonality, robustness, and function have been shown to be erroneous or premature. A call for clonality (which has been shown nicely in one study) is meaningless on a predefined stem cell population which is intrinsically heterogeneous, as they all are. Robustness means nothing; it all depends on the details of the situation. Function on an organ level is, of course, the goal of many investigators and should not be raised as a limiting consideration. Lastly, fusion has been highlighted as undermining studies with adult stem cells. It, of course, does not. Fusion is simply a means to a final goal, which occurs in certain settings of marrow conversions (transdifferentiation) and not in others. We hypothesize that the conversion phenomena may, in fact, be due to one or several marrow stem cells with broad differentiation potential which can be expressed when the cell is placed in an environment with the appropriate inductive signals. Furthermore, initial events may be relatively rare and significant conversion numbers may be obtained with massive or ongoing selection. Fusion appears in an initial mechanism in some cases and not in others. Overall, the therapeutic potential of adult marrow stem cells is very intriguing, and successful use therapeutically will probably depend on definition of the most appropriate transplant model and tissue injury.
Animals↗
Homing and conversion of murine hematopoietic stem cells to lung.
The hematopoietic stem cell population, lineage negative-Sca positive (HSC), displays a homing defect into bone marrow (BM) after 48-h exposure to interleukin (IL)-3, IL-6, IL-11, and steel factor [J. Hematother. Stem Cell Res. 11 (2002) 913]. Cytokine treatment of murine marrow leads to reversible alterations in adhesion protein expression, which may explain the changes in homing. We evaluated 3 h homing to nonhematopoietic organs of marrow cells exposed to cytokines for 0, 18, 24, 40 and 48 h. HSC cells from C57BL/6J mice were cultured and labeled with the cytoplasmic fluorescent dye CFSE. We found homed events from uncultured cells in spleen, liver and lung, but no events were seen in duodenum or anterior tibialis muscle. Culture in cytokines led to decreased homing to marrow at 24 and 48 h with parallel changes in spleen homing. There was little variability of homing to liver, however the number, of homed events in lung was markedly increased when 24-h cultured cells were assessed. This was approximately a 10-fold increase compared to the 0 h time point (flow cytometry). Homing was determined by evaluation of frozen section (8 microm) by fluorescent microscopy for spleen, liver, duodenum, anterior tibialis and lung. Data were confirmed by flow cytometry from each organ including marrow. These data indicate the presence of a lung homing "hotspot" at 24 h of cytokine culture; this is a time when the stem progenitors cells are in mid S-phase. Altogether these data suggest that homing of marrow cell to nonmarrow organs may fluctuate with cell cycle transit and that there is a lung homing hotspot in mid-S.
Animals↗