Biomedical subjects
N Jehl
Publications and source records attributed to N Jehl.
Problems to anticipate in treating difficult patients in a long-term psychiatric hospital.
In a previous report, the authors identified four dimensions of patient pathology associated with treatment difficulty: withdrawn psychoticism, character pathology, violence-agitation and suicidal-depressed behavior. In a subsequent study, they linked these dimensions to patterns of countertransference. The present research extends the two prior reports by examining the relations of the patient pathology dimensions to staff members' dissatisfaction with four areas of treatment: interpersonal approaches, structure and control, quality of teamwork, and medication. The major findings are: withdrawn psychoticism primarily relates to dissatisfaction with interpersonal treatment approaches; character pathology entails dissatisfaction with the level of structure and control; violence-agitation poses particular problems for teamwork; and suicidal-depressed behavior is unrelated to dissatisfaction with any dimension of treatment. The authors propose that these various problems in treatment are, in part, mediated by patterns of countertransference which they described in the prior paper. These findings should help staff members to focus their attention on areas of treatment in which problems are bound to arise in work with different types of difficult patients.
Profiles of difficult psychiatric hospital patients.
In a study of 127 long-term psychiatric hospital patients perceived as difficult to treat, investigators used hierarchical grouping analysis to differentiate ten profile groups of patients. The groups are based on four dimensions or clusters of characteristics previously derived by factor analysis: withdrawn psychoticism, severe character pathology, suicidal-depressed behavior, and violence-agitation. The ten profile groups are described and are related to staff ratings of overall treatment difficulty, prognosis, sex, diagnosis, and other variables. The main conclusion is that treatment difficulty stems in large part from the compounding of different dimensions of severe psychopathology. Thus a pan-symptomatic group, with high scores on all four dimensions, ranks highest in overall treatment difficulty.
An anatomy of countertransference: staff reactions to difficult psychiatric hospital patients.
Countertransference among hospital staff was investigated as part of ongoing research on difficult-to-treat psychiatric hospital patients. Staff's ratings of their emotional reactions to 127 patients on long-term units were analyzed by factor analysis, and the resulting factors were correlated by discipline with patient problem behaviors. Among the conclusions were that different forms of psychopathology elicit characteristic patterns of emotional reaction from staff; that some dimensions of psychopathology, particularly suicidal-depressed behavior and violence-agitation, elicit different emotional reactions among different disciplines, thus laying the groundwork for division among staff; and that the more difficult the process of hospital treatment, the more likely staff will experience a variety of emotions.
Patterns of staff perception of difficult patients in a long-term psychiatric hospital.
In a study to determine which psychiatric patients are perceived by staff as most difficult to treat, clinical staff from several disciplines rated problem behaviors of 127 long-term inpatients in a private psychiatric hospital; staff also rated overall treatment difficulty, progress, and prognosis. No single patient characteristic determined staff's perception of patients as difficult to treat. Instead, four clusters of patient characteristics contributed to this perception; in decreasing order of influence, they are withdrawn psychoticism, severe character pathology, suicidal-depressed behavior, and violence-agitation. The study also showed that the patients who are considered particularly difficult are perceived as improving less and as having a poor prognosis.