PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

P N Goering

Publications and source records attributed to P N Goering.

18 recordsLinked to original sources

Social disadvantage, mental illness and predictors of legal involvement.

The following study evaluates the complex association between legal involvement and mental illness. It describes a population of consumers of community mental health programs, comparing those with legal involvement to those without legal involvement, on a number of demographic, clinical and social indicators. It is a secondary analysis of data collected in studies making up the Community Mental Health Evaluation Initiative (CMHEI) in the province of Ontario, Canada. Legal involvement was a significant issue among community mental health program consumers; about one in five consumers had at least some contact with the legal system in the preceding nine months. Legally involved consumers were more likely to be in receipt of social assistance and be unstably housed than those legally uninvolved. However, there were no significant differences between legally involved and uninvolved consumers with respect to severity of symptomatology, current medication use or number of hospitalization days in the past 9 months. A predictive model compared the differential impact of clinical and social determinants upon legal involvement. Analyses failed to uncover a significant relationship between severity of psychiatric symptomatology and legal involvement. Significant predictors of legal involvement included gender, race, drug use as well as housing instability, and receipt of social assistance. Legal involvement was attributable to factors other than the severity of mental illness; these results challenge assumptions that the most symptomatically severe consumers are most at risk of legal involvement. Accordingly, the rate of legal involvement in a sample of community mental health program users must be considered in a broad context, with particular emphasis on social disadvantage.

Community Health Services↗

Educating the public about mental illness and homelessness: a cautionary note.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the viewing of a video depicting the successful struggles of homeless persons with mental illness in finding and maintaining housing can have a positive impact on attitudes toward homeless persons with mental illness. METHOD: Five hundred and seventy-five high school students attending a brief educational session on mental illness participated in 1 of 3 comparison versions of the 2-hour program (control, video, video plus discussion). All completed an "Attitudes toward Homelessness and Mental Illness Questionnaire." Demographic and prior exposure variables were entered as a covariates in between-group analyses of variance. RESULTS: Females and subjects who had more prior encounters with homeless persons were found to have the most positive attitudes. After controlling for these effects, the video alone had a negative impact on attitudes relative to the other groups, while the video followed by a discussion with one of the people featured in it had a largely positive impact. CONCLUSIONS: The apparent immediacy and the evocative power of video presentations cannot substitute for direct contact for the purpose of promoting positive attitude change. The findings are consistent with prior research emphasizing the importance of direct interaction with members of stigmatized groups to reduce negative attitudes. Education programs trying to destigmatize mental illness and homelessness using videos should proceed with caution.

Adolescent↗

Becoming and remaining homeless: a qualitative investigation.

This article reports the qualitative findings of a multimethod study of the homeless population in Toronto, Canada. The qualitative component sought to identify how people become homeless and why some individuals remain homeless for an extended period of time or cycle in and out of homelessness (the chronically homeless). In-depth, semistructured interviews were conducted with 29 homeless adults. The findings suggest that people both become and remain homeless due to a combination of macro level factors (poverty, lack of employment, low welfare wages, lack of affordable housing) and personal vulnerability (childhood abuse or neglect, mental health symptoms, impoverished support networks, substance abuse). Chronically homeless individuals often reported experiences of severe childhood trauma and tended to attribute their continued homelessness to a substance abuse problem. It is concluded that both macro and individual level factors must be considered in planning programs and services to address the issue of homelessness in Canada.

Adolescent↗

Personality assessment of homeless adults as a tool for service planning.

The psychiatric status of homeless adults has been described primarily in terms of Axis I disorders. By adding a subset of the Personality Assessment Inventory, this study tests the feasibility and usefulness of a brief, self-administered questionnaire to obtain scores on several dimensions of personality. Cluster analysis sorted 112 tested subjects into four groups characterized by distinct profiles. Two of these were characterized by extreme scores on pathological dimensions of personality (borderline features, antisocial traits, and aggressivity) and differed primarily on the dimension of suicidality. The third reflected moderate levels of personality dysfunction and the fourth did not deviate from adult nonclinical norms. The validity of the clusters was supported by demographic, background, and diagnostic subgroup differences. Brief personality assessment can be a cost-effective approach to matching services with clinical needs of homeless adults by attending to interpersonal dimensions that will likely affect service provision.

Adult↗

Major depression in individuals with a history of childhood physical or sexual abuse: relationship to neurovegetative features, mania, and gender.

OBJECTIVE: Numerous studies have linked childhood trauma with depressive symptoms over the life span. However, it is not known whether particular neurovegetative symptom clusters or affective disorders are more closely linked with early abuse than are others. In a large community sample from Ontario, the authors examined whether a history of physical or sexual abuse in childhood was associated with particular neurovegetative symptom clusters of depression, with mania, or with both. METHOD: The World Health Organization Composite International Diagnostic Interview was used to assess 8,116 individuals aged 15-64 years. Each subject was asked about early physical and sexual abuse experiences on a structured supplement to the interview. Six hundred fifty-three cases of major depression were identified. Rates of physical and sexual abuse in depressive subgroups defined by typical and reversed neurovegetative symptom clusters (i.e., decreased appetite, weight loss, and insomnia versus increased appetite, weight gain, and hypersomnia, respectively) and by the presence or absence of lifetime mania were compared by gender. RESULTS: A history of physical or sexual abuse in childhood was associated with major depression with reversed neurovegetative features, whether or not manic subjects were included in the analysis. A strong relationship between mania and childhood physical abuse was found. Across analyses there was a significant main effect of female gender on risk of early sexual abuse; however, none of the group-by-gender interactions predicted early abuse. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest an association between early traumatic experiences and particular symptom clusters of depression, mania, or both in adults.

Adult↗

Epidemiologic assessment of overmet need in mental health care.

The traditional purpose of psychiatric epidemiologic surveys has been the assessment of mental illness and, by implication, the need for care. Previous research has focused on unmet need, defined as those who meet "caseness" but do not receive care, but has rarely examined the converse. Since survey respondents receiving care but not meeting caseness have been found to represent up to one-half of mental health service users, this is a significant service delivery issue. The data are drawn from the Mental Health Supplement to the Ontario Health Survey (the Supplement), a household survey of 9,953 respondents, which used the University of Michigan's version of the Composite International Diagnostic Interview (UM-CIDI) as its diagnostic instrument. Community residents who used formal mental health services in the past year but who did not have a concurrent UM-CIDI/DSM-III-R (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual 3, revised) diagnosis were defined as "treated without CIDI disorder". Their need for care was evaluated by comparing them to "treated depressed" and "healthy" respondents, using indicators of functional impairment, vulnerability to developing disorder, and risk of relapse. The match between need and care levels was examined by comparing their type and intensity of use with those of the treated depressed. Results present strong evidence for conceptualizing need as continuous, rather than discrete. The results for the group defined as "treated without CIDI disorder" were consistently between those for the other two groups (with the "treated depressed" always showing the highest need) on all indicators as well as on a summary need index. However, their type and intensity of service use appeared to be unrelated to their level of need. Although some of the "treated without CIDI disorder" group may require preventive or follow-up treatment, the need for service for others is not as convincingly demonstrated. Outcome studies are needed to provide comparative data to describe more fully the problems experienced by this group and indicate whether treatment is helpful. In an age of fiscal restraint, when resource reallocation (rather than generation of new resources) is the likely scenario, such close examination of the fit between need and care is critical if services are to be targeted appropriately.

Adolescent↗

The mental health of informal caregivers in Ontario: an epidemiological survey.

OBJECTIVES: This study describes the mental health status, disability, physical health, and mental health service utilization of informal care-givers under the age of 65 in the province of Ontario. METHODS: The study analyzed data collected in the 1991 province-wide, population-based mental health supplement to the Ontario Health Survey. Diagnoses from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3rd edition, revised, were generated on the basis of a structured diagnostic interview. Caregivers and noncaregivers are compared here on past-year prevalence of psychiatric disorder, physical illness, disability, and utilization of mental health services. The possible confounding effects of age, sex, employment status, and economic disadvantage are explored. RESULTS: Informal caregivers (n = 1219) constituted 15.0% of the sample. Caregivers had higher rates of affective (6.3% vs 4.2%) and anxiety (17.5% vs 10.9%) disorders than noncaregivers and used health services for mental health problems at nearly twice the rate. CONCLUSIONS: Documentation of the prevalence of caregiving and the increased prevalence of psychiatric disorders, disability, and service utilization among caregivers is of critical importance as governments continue to move toward community-based care. To accomplish this goal, the needs of caregivers must be acknowledged and met by the establishment of appropriate and readily accessible support services.

Adolescent↗

Response to Mitchell and Radford's rethinking research relationships in qualitative research: further thoughts and suggested training strategies.

This paper expands an important discussion initiated in an earlier publication of this journal (Mitchell & Radford, 1996). These authors point to a discrepancy between the ability of qualitative interviewers to elicit disclosures of personal information and the corresponding training of interviewers to respond appropriately to such disclosures. They suggest that high levels of disclosure may be attributable to the nature and duration of the qualitative research relationship. We propose that additional factors may be at play including, for example, the fact that research participants are sometimes paid for their participation. Based on our experience, we suggest strategies for training qualitative researchers.

Ethics, Professional↗

Reconcilable differences: the marriage of qualitative and quantitative methods.

Qualitative research consists of methods that allow for a more in-depth understanding of phenomena and encompasses techniques such as focus groups, in-depth interviews, and participant observation. The guidelines that pertain to sampling and analysis are different from those which govern quantitative techniques, but they can be applied just as rigorously to ensure the validity of the results. This article introduces these methods and criteria and illustrates how qualitative and quantitative methods can be combined in order to improve what is learned from each.

Data Collection↗

The role of research in systems reform.

Knowledge concerning the care of people with severe and persistent mental illness has grown dramatically, but that knowledge is seldom translated into improvements in care. The authors describe their involvement in three service delivery projects in Ontario and discuss how, by assuming multiple roles, they were able to ensure that planning and policy development were informed by current knowledge. In addition to being an investigator, such roles may include being an administrator, planner, consultant and advocate. The redevelopment of Whitby Psychiatric Hospital resulted in an innovative plan for a comprehensive, integrated service delivery system based upon community support services research. Implementation of the Graham Report in Ontario provided an array of district mental health plans which incorporate current knowledge with regard to service delivery. Ontario's mental health reform strategy represents a close connection between public policy and scientific information. The authors recommend that researchers be prepared to assume multiple roles in the service delivery field so as to reduce the gap between science and practice.

Comprehensive Health Care↗

Intensive studies of patients and the experiences of investigators and clinicians.

Mental processes, normal or abnormal, are complex and multifaceted, needing to be viewed from diverse perspectives. But our field has split increasingly into two discrete groups. One group includes those investigators and clinicians who are often seen as most scientific and have restricted themselves more and more exclusively to directly observable, generally superficial phenomena and patients as classified according to those phenomena. Such variables can be reliably rated, a crucial aspect of any scientific endeavor. But in this group there has been a tendency to be like the person who lost the keys in the middle of the block but looked for them at the corner because "the light is better here." Those of us in this group have tended to act as though, if we can't measure a phenomenon with relative ease, it doesn't exist--potentially the antithesis of an adequate science. Others, and they have become rarer, have focused on understanding the psychological processes of individuals with mental disorder in great depth, while paying less attention to questions of scientific approaches to proof.

Female↗

The hostel outreach program: assertive case management for homeless mentally ill persons.

OBJECTIVE: This study measured the impact of an assertive case management program for psychiatrically disabled homeless persons in metropolitan Toronto. It was hypothesized that the program would improve residential stability, reduce psychiatric symptoms, improve social functioning, improve social networks, and increase use of appropriate services. METHOD: For 59 clients admitted to the program, assessments for the nine-month period before program entry were completed and were repeated nine months later. The Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale and a version of the Scale for Level of Functioning were the main measures of outcome. RESULTS: At follow-up significant improvements in residential stability and reductions in psychopathology were demonstrated. Improvements in social functioning and increases in social network size were significant. Although no baseline data about service use were collected, clients used basic support services during their first nine months in the program. CONCLUSIONS: The success of the program demonstrates that a difficult-to-treat patient population can be helped in a humane fashion if trained personnel are available.

Activities of Daily Living↗

Marital support and recovery from depression.

A prospective study of 47 married women who met RDC for major depressive disorder investigated the relationship between the social support provided by the husbands and the post-hospital symptom course of the women. Separate taped semistructured interviews were held with the patient and husband at the time of admission. Six months later, symptom course was rated using the LIFE psychiatric status schedule. Only 51% of the sample recovered in the six months. Few demographic or clinical factors were related to symptom course. Recovery was predicted by the depressed woman's ratings of the current marital relationship and by the husband's rating of the pre-morbid relationship but not by the husband's level of expressed criticism or his ratings of the current relationship.

Adult↗

Components of care for patients with schizophrenia.

To assist in the planning of mental health services for Metropolitan Toronto, the Mental Health Care Committee of the Metropolitan Toronto District Health Council convened a Task Force on Mental Health Epidemiology to help determine the need for services for patients suffering from schizophrenia. As part of its work, the Task Force described components of care which comprise a comprehensive treatment model. Underlying this approach was the recognition that many efficient, effective interventions for the treatment of schizophrenia have been developed and evaluated, but few attempts have been made to apply these various interventions in a systematic, comprehensive manner. This report presents an inventory of state-of-the-art approaches to dealing with schizophrenia which should be of interest both to practicing clinicians and health care planners.

Adult↗

What difference does case management make?

The outcomes of 82 patients in a rehabilitation-oriented case management program six months and two years after they were discharged from an inpatient setting to join the program were compared with those of 82 matched control patients who had been discharged from the same inpatient settings before the case management program was established. At the two-year follow-up, the patients in the case management program were significantly more likely than the control patients to have better occupational functioning, to live in a residence requiring more independence than they did at the six-month follow-up, and to be less socially isolated; in contrast, at the six-month follow-up only their occupational functioning was better than the control group's. The two groups did not differ in number of hospitalizations at either follow-up. The authors believe the study supplies much-needed documentation of the effectiveness of rehabilitation-oriented case management.

Chronic Disease↗

Impact of a case manager program on psychiatric aftercare.

Shifting the locus of aftercare planning from hospital to community can enhance continuity of care. The authors compared chronically mentally ill patients assessed and managed by community-based practitioners trained in psychiatric rehabilitation with patients whose discharge planning was arranged by inpatient staff members. They found significant differences between the two groups in aftercare needs identified, aftercare referrals made, and use of aftercare services. The authors conclude that this approach to psychiatric aftercare is superior to more traditional models if practitioners are carefully trained.

Adult↗

Depression in Ontario: under-treatment and factors related to antidepressant use.

Our study examines how depression is treated in Ontario, with particular examination of the correlates of antidepressant utilization using a broad model of individual (clinical), demographic, and health system determinants of treatment. From a community epidemiologic survey, a sample of 333 individuals with major depression in the past year was identified. More than half received no treatment (untreated n = 170, 51.1%), while 74 (22.2%) received treatment without medication, 29 (8.7%) received treatment mainly with anxiolytics, and only 60 (18.0%) were treated with antidepressants. All four groups had similar rates of alcohol and substance abuse. Disability and comorbid anxiety were common, with the least in the untreated group and the most in the antidepressant group. Increased use of antidepressants was associated with psychiatrist contact, while family physicians treated a substantial minority primarily with anxiolytics. Under a universal health care system, no differential access to antidepressants was found in terms of demographic characteristics. Clinical severity and contact with a psychiatrist correlate with antidepressant treatment of depression.

Adolescent↗