PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

S H Richards

Publications and source records attributed to S H Richards.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

A Bayesian approach to analysing the cost-effectiveness of two primary care interventions aimed at improving attendance for breast screening.

AIMS: To assess the cost-effectiveness of two primary care interventions, a letter and a flag, aimed at improving attendance for breast screening among (i) all women invited for breast screening and (ii) non-attenders. METHODS: A probabilistic decision analytic model was developed using Markov chain Monte Carlo simulation implemented in WinBUGS. The model was populated using economic and effectiveness data collected alongside two randomised controlled trials. RESULTS: For all women invited, the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) for the letter compared with no intervention is 27 pounds per additional attendance, and the ICER for the combined letter and flag intervention compared to the letter alone is 171 pounds. The corresponding ICERs for non-attenders are 41 pounds and 90 pounds. The flag intervention is an inefficient option in both settings. A large proportion of the costs fall on the practices (25-67%), depending on the intervention and target population. The total costs incurred do not, however, seem prohibitive. Expected value of perfect information suggests that there is greater value in carrying out further research on the intervention implemented among all women invited for breast screening rather than on non-attenders. CONCLUSIONS: The flag intervention alone does not appear to be an efficient option. The choice between the letter and both interventions combined is subjective, depending on the willingness to pay for an additional screening attendance.

Bayes Theorem↗

Development and testing of a questionnaire to measure patient satisfaction with intermediate care.

BACKGROUND: Individual trials have suggested high levels of general patient satisfaction with intermediate care, but this topic has not been examined in detail. AIMS: To identify the key elements of patient satisfaction with intermediate care, and to see whether these can be validly measured using a questionnaire. METHOD: A questionnaire was developed on the basis of a literature review and piloting with patients and staff on participating schemes (phase I). In phase II, the questionnaire was tested for validity and reliability in a group of patients recently discharged from two "hospital-at-home" intermediate-care schemes. In phase III, a shortened version of the questionnaire was psychometrically tested in five sites taking part in a national evaluation of intermediate care. RESULTS: 96 patients with an average age of 76.5 years took part in phase II. Test-retest reliability was evaluated by repeating the questionnaire 2 weeks later in a subsample of 42 patients. This was "moderate" (kappa 0.4-0.6) for 12 questions, "fair" (kappa 0.2-0.4) for 6 questions and "poor" (kappa 0.1-0.2) for 5 questions. Scores correlated well with the Client Satisfaction Questionnaire (Spearman's r = 0.75, p<0.001). 843 patients (57% of those eligible) from five intermediate-care schemes took part in phase III. Principal components analysis suggested six factors or subscales: general satisfaction, affective response, cognitive response, timing of discharge, coordination after discharge, and access to pain relief, although the last three factors comprised only one question each. The intraclass correlation coefficients in the first three subscales varied from 0.82 to 0.89. Scores for all subscales differed by scheme, suggesting construct validity. Only one question (on general satisfaction) was found to be redundant. CONCLUSION: The questionnaire, with some minor amendments to improve performance, could be used as a validated tool for audit and research in intermediate care. An amended version and scoring programme is available from us on request.

Aged↗

Comparison of methods for analysing cluster randomized trials: an example involving a factorial design.

BACKGROUND: Studies involving clustering effects are common, but there is little consistency in their analysis. Various analytical methods were compared for a factorial cluster randomized trial (CRT) of two primary care-based interventions designed to increase breast screening attendance. METHODS: Three cluster-level and five individual-level options were compared in respect of log odds ratios of attendance and their standard errors (SE), for the two intervention effects and their interaction. Cluster-level analyses comprised: (C1) unweighted regression of practice log odds; (C2) regression of log odds weighted by their inverse variance; (C3) random-effects meta-regression of log odds with practice as a random effect. Individual-level analyses comprised: (I1) standard logistic regression ignoring clustering; (I2) robust SE; (I3) generalized estimating equations; (I4) random-effects logistic regression; (I5) Bayesian random-effects logistic regression. Adjustments for stratification and baseline variables were investigated. RESULTS: As expected, method I1 was highly anti-conservative. The other, valid, methods exhibited considerable differences in parameter estimates and standard errors, even between the various random-effects methods based on the same statistical model. Method I4 was particularly sensitive to between-cluster variation and was computationally stable only after controlling for baseline uptake. CONCLUSIONS: Commonly used methods for the analysis of CRT can give divergent results. Simulation studies are needed to compare results from different methods in situations typical of cluster trials but when the true model parameters are known.

Breast Neoplasms↗

Cluster randomised controlled trial comparing the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of two primary care interventions aimed at improving attendance for breast screening.

OBJECTIVES: To examine the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of two interventions based in primary care aimed at increasing uptake of breast screening. SETTING: 24 General practices with low uptake in the second round of screening (below 60%) in north west London and the West Midlands, UK. Participants were all women registered with these practices and eligible for screening in the third round. METHODS: Pragmatic factorial cluster randomised controlled trial, with practices randomised to a systematic intervention (general practitioner letter), an opportunistic intervention (flag in women's notes prompting discussion by health professionals), neither intervention, or both. Outcome measures were attendance for screening 6 months after the practices had been screened and cost-effectiveness of the interventions. RESULTS: 6,133 Women were included: 1,721 control; 1,818 letter; 1,232 flag; 1,362 both interventions. Attendance data were obtained for 5,732 (93%) women. The two interventions independently increased breast screening uptake in a logistic regression model adjusted for clustering, with the flag (odds ratio (OR) 1.43, 95% confidence interval (95% CI) 1.14 to 1.79; p=0.0019) marginally more effective than the letter (OR 1.31, 95% CI 1.05 to 1.64; p=0.015). Health service costs per additional attendance were 26 pounds (letter) and 41 pounds (flag). CONCLUSIONS: Although both interventions increased attendance for breast screening, the letter was the more cost-effective. Any decision to implement both interventions rather than just the letter will depend on whether the additional (41 pounds) costs are judged worthwhile in terms of the gains in breast screening uptake.

Breast Neoplasms↗

Improving attendance for breast screening among recent non-attenders: a randomised controlled trial of two interventions in primary care.

OBJECTIVES: To examine the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of two primary care based interventions aimed at increasing breast screening uptake for women who had recently failed to attend. SETTING: 13 General practices with low uptake in the second round of breast screening (below 60%) in north west London and the West Midlands, United Kingdom. Participants were women in these practices who were recent non-attenders for breast screening in the third round. METHODS: Pragmatic factorial randomised controlled trial, with people randomised to a systematic intervention (general practitioner letter), an opportunistic intervention (flag in women's notes prompting discussion by health professionals), neither intervention, or both. Outcome measures were attendance for screening 6 months after randomisation and cost-effectiveness of the interventions. RESULTS: 1,158 Women were individually randomised as follows: 289 control; 291 letter; 290 flag; 288 both interventions. Attendance was ascertained for 1,148 (99%) of the 1,158 women. Logistic regression adjusting for the other intervention and practice produced an odds ratio (OR) for attendance of 1.51 (95% confidence interval (95% CI 1.02 to 2.26; p=0.04) for the letter, and 1.39 (95% CI 0.93 to 2.07; p=0.10) for the flag. Health service costs/ additional attendance were 35 pounds (letter) and 65 pounds (flag). CONCLUSIONS: Among recent non-attenders, the letter was effective in increasing breast screening attendance. The flag was of equivocal effectiveness and was considerably less cost-effective than the letter.

Adult↗

How great a burden does early discharge to hospital-at-home impose on carers? A randomized controlled trial.

OBJECTIVE: to assess the effects of an early discharge hospital-at-home scheme on self-reported carer strain and quality of life. DESIGN: a randomized controlled trial SETTING: Bristol, UK. SUBJECTS: 133 carers of patients receiving either early discharge from hospital to hospital-at-home (n = 93) care or usual hospital care and discharge (n = 40). OUTCOME MEASURES: modified 12-item Carer Strain Index, COOP-WONCA charts and EuroQol EQ-5D at 4 weeks and 3 months post-randomization. RESULTS: the mean age of carers was 65 years; 56% were women. There were no marked differences between the groups in any of the outcomes used at either 4-week or 3-month follow-up. CONCLUSION: there was no evidence of increased self-reported burden imposed on carers of patients discharged early from hospital. Decisions on the implementation of hospital-at-home schemes should be influenced by considerations of cost and effectiveness rather than effects on carers. The effects on carers may, however, differ for other forms of home-based care.

Aged↗

Inter-rater reliability of the Barthel ADL index: how does a researcher compare to a nurse?

OBJECTIVES: To investigate whether a nonclinical research assistant, using standardized scoring criteria, can reliably administer the Barthel Activities of Daily Living (ADL) Index in a sample of elderly inpatients. DESIGN: Paired comparison of nurse and nonclinical research assistant Barthel Index assessments. SETTING: Acute hospital wards from two hospitals in a UK Healthcare Trust, with a catchment population of approximately 224,000 people. METHODS: A consecutive sample of 94 elderly patients with a variety of medical problems. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Barthel ADL Index, Folstein Mini-Mental Status Examination. RESULTS: Whilst the inter-rater reliability of the Barthel Index was within acceptable boundaries, two items out of ten had only fair agreement and low crude agreement (transfer and dressing) on Cohen's kappa scores. CONCLUSIONS: Depending on the differences observed in any particular context, the Barthel Index can be applied with reasonable reliability by nonclinical staff applying the standardized scoring criteria. It should be noted, however, that the kappa coefficients between clinical and nonclinical assessors tend to be lower than those found when comparing two clinically trained assessors in previous research.

Activities of Daily Living↗

Randomised controlled trial comparing effectiveness and acceptability of an early discharge, hospital at home scheme with acute hospital care.

OBJECTIVE: To compare effectiveness and acceptability of early discharge to a hospital at home scheme with that of routine discharge from acute hospital. DESIGN: Pragmatic randomised controlled trial. SETTING: Acute hospital wards and community in north of Bristol, with a catchment population of about 224 000 people. SUBJECTS: 241 hospitalised but medically stable elderly patients who fulfilled criteria for early discharge to hospital at home scheme and who consented to participate. INTERVENTIONS: Patients' received hospital at home care or routine hospital care. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Patients' quality of life, satisfaction, and physical functioning assessed at 4 weeks and 3 months after randomisation to treatment; length of stay in hospital and in hospital at home scheme after randomisation; mortality at 3 months. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in patient mortality, quality of life, and physical functioning between the two arms of the trial at 4 weeks or 3 months. Only one of 11 measures of patient satisfaction was significantly different: hospital at home patients perceived higher levels of involvement in decisions. Length of stay for those receiving routine hospital care was 62% (95% confidence interval 51% to 75%) of length of stay in hospital at home scheme. CONCLUSIONS: The early discharge hospital at home scheme was similar to routine hospital discharge in terms of effectiveness and acceptability. Increased length of stay associated with the scheme must be interpreted with caution because of different organisational characteristics of the services.

Activities of Daily Living↗

Hospital at home or acute hospital care? A cost minimisation analysis.

OBJECTIVE: To compare, from the viewpoints of the NHS and social services and of patients, the costs associated with early discharge to a hospital at home scheme and those associated with continued care in an acute hospital. DESIGN: Cost minimisation analysis. SETTING: Acute hospital wards and the community in the north of Bristol (population about 224 000). SUBJECTS: 241 hospitalised but medically stable elderly patients who fulfilled the criteria for early discharge to a hospital at home scheme and who consented to participate. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Costs to the NHS, social services, and patients over the 3 months after randomisation. RESULTS: The mean cost for hospital at home patients over the 3 months was 2516 pounds, whereas that for hospital patients was 3292 pounds. Under all the assumptions used in the sensitivity analysis, the cost of hospital at home care was less than that of hospital care. Only when hospital costs were assumed to be less than 50% of those used in the initial analysis was the difference equivocal. CONCLUSIONS: The hospital at home scheme is less costly than care in the acute hospital. These results may be generalisable to schemes of similar size and scope, operating in a similar context of rising acute admissions.

Aged↗

Use of the EuroQoL among elderly acute care patients.

The assessment of the validity and reliability of generic quality of life (QoL) instruments among elderly patient groups has tended to lag behind such assessments in general populations, yet it is an important methodological issue. This paper presents the findings from a study of the use of the EuroQoL among an elderly acute care patient group, focusing particularly on the ability to self-complete, construct validity and sensitivity to change. Two hundred and fourteen UK patients aged 65 years and over, participating in a randomized controlled trial comparing hospital at home and routine hospital care were asked to complete the EuroQoL and a number of other instruments at randomization and at 4 week and 3 month follow-ups. The inability to self-complete the EuroQol was found to be strongly related to both increased age and reduced cognitive function (p < 0.0001). From logistic regression, the expected probability of an acute care patient requiring interview administration at age 65 years is 11%, at age 75 years is 37% and at age 85 years is 73%. The relationships with age and limiting long-standing illness/disability were weaker than expected, but the results obtained from the EuroQoL were highly correlated with those from both the Barthel Index and the COOP-WONCA charts where this was anticipated. Preliminary evidence of sensitivity to change was found from descriptive statistics of the changes in scores for four specific subgroups of patients, but the small numbers and high variability in each sub-sample means that this should be interpreted with caution. The most important issue arising from the research concerns the impact of age on the ability to self-complete the EuroQoL questionnaire. It is argued that this research points to the need for rigorous studies (such as randomized controlled trials) to assess the impact of the format of administration of the EuroQoL on the scores obtained.

Aged↗

Effect of varying the time frame for COOP-WONCA functional health status charts: a nested randomised controlled trial in Bristol, UK.

STUDY OBJECTIVES: To investigate whether changing the stated time frame for COOP-WONCA charts has any effect on responses. Specifically, to assess the effect of attempting to avoid the situation where the time frame crosses the onset of an acute episode. DESIGN: A randomised controlled trial of two time frames, nested within a main trial comparing early discharge with a hospital at home scheme against routine discharge policy. The time frames compared were the standard two weeks (four for the pain chart) and a shorter period of 48 hours for all seven charts. SETTING: Acute hospital wards in Frenchay Healthcare Trust and the Avon Orthopaedic Centre in Bristol. PARTICIPANTS: Patients entered into the main trial, who were medically stable, in need of continued rehabilitative care but suitable for discharge to hospital at home. MAIN RESULTS: A total of 200 patients were randomised, 106 to the shorter time frame, 94 to the standard charts. No clear differences were observed between the two groups for the proportion failing to self complete the charts. For the (seven) chart scores, only pain was statistically significantly different between the time frames (Mann-Whitney p = 0.0085; proportion reporting moderate or severe pain 19% higher in the standard group, 95% confidence intervals 5% to 33%). For both this chart and that for change in health, however, there was evidence of greater differences between the versions of the chart among those admitted more recently (p values for relevant interactions 0.004 and < or = 0.001 respectively). CONCLUSIONS: While the present findings give some support for the wide applicability of the standard version, there is sufficient evidence here to indicate that the time frame may influence the results, particularly for patients with a recent acute episode. In the absence of further data, then, it would seem prudent to consider a shorter time frame for such patients, especially if the aim is to assess current health status or to measure changes over a comparatively short period of time, or both.

Activities of Daily Living↗

Voice changes in acromegaly.

The fundamental frequency of 14 patients undergoing hypophysectomy was studied. Eight patients had acromegaly, 3 had a prolactinoma, and 3 had nonfunctioning adenomas. The fundamental frequency of 22 normal, healthy volunteers was measured for comparison. In addition, the external size of the larynx of all patients and volunteers was measured and a relationship between external laryngeal size and the mean fundamental frequency was identified in the volunteers. The mean fundamental frequency in patients with acromegaly was significantly lower than the other 6 patients undergoing hypophysectomy and, in addition, was also lower than the 22 normal volunteers. Postoperatively the fundamental frequency of the acromegalic patients increased rapidly to within the expected normal range. Patients with acromegaly have a lowered fundamental frequency which is most likely due to altered vocal cord mass and elasticity, which is a reversible change. Patients with acromegaly can expect a rapid and complete return of normal fundamental frequency within 2 weeks of surgery to remove the pituitary adenoma.

Acromegaly↗

Finding the means to carry on. Suicidal feelings in cancer patients.

People suffering from advanced cancer may question the point of carrying on. It is essential that nurses are sensitive to patients' suicidal feelings at such times, and that a multidisciplinary assessment is made of the patient's key concerns. By bringing such problems into the open, these concerns may begin to be addressed.

Adaptation, Psychological↗

Low recurrence rate after partial hypophysectomy for prolactinoma: the predictive value of dynamic prolactin function tests.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the factors influencing the outcome of transethmoidal partial hypophysectomy for suspected prolactinoma and the predictive value of pre and post-operative dynamic PRL function tests. DESIGN: A retrospective study of patients undergoing surgery for a suspected prolactinoma in Cardiff between 1979 and 1989. PATIENTS: Eighty-two hyperprolactinaemic patients (75 women, seven men) diagnosed as having a prolactinoma on the basis of dynamic PRL function tests, radiological investigation and exclusion of other causes. MEASUREMENTS: TSH and PRL responses to domperidone (10 mg i.v.) and TRH (200 micrograms i.v.) measured preoperatively, 2 months post-operatively, and annually thereafter. CT scan performed preoperatively in 58 patients. Operative findings, including adenoma size, documented in each case. RESULTS: Forty-two patients (51%) had microadenomas (less than 10 mm), 37 (46%) had macroadenomas and in three no tumour was found at operation. Preoperatively, normal responses of both TSH (incremental rise less than 2.0 mU/l) and PRL (greater than 100% rise) to domperidone were observed in two patients only: both had an abnormal vascular supply to the pituitary rather than an adenoma. Serum PRL was normalized in the early post-operative period (less than 72 h; 'early cure') in 65 patients (79%). The highest early cure rate (96%, n = 26) was in patients with adenomas of 5-9 mm, lower rates being achieved for lesions of 10-19 mm (80%, n = 30), less than 5 mm (63%, n = 19) or greater than or equal to 20 mm (57%, n = 7). The early cure rate was strongly correlated with preoperative PRL, ranging from 100% in patients with PRL less than 1000 mU/l (n = 13) to zero in those with PRL greater than 10,000 mU/l. Dopamine agonist therapy of between 5 weeks and 4 years duration prior to surgery was associated with a significantly reduced early cure rate (60 vs 94%, P less than 0.02) in macroadenoma but not microadenoma patients. Recurrent hyperprolactinaemia during mean follow-up of 51.7 months occurred in eight patients (12%), in five cases within 2 months of surgery and in the others at 26, 48 and 50 months. Recurrence could not be predicted from any preoperative parameter, but a serum PRL greater than 150 mU/l 1-3 days following microadenomectomy was associated with early recurrence and probably indicates failed surgery. An abnormal response of TSH to domperidone was documented 2 months post-operatively in 11/60 patients with normal basal PRL, and preceded all three late recurrences. Of four patients with abnormal responses of both PRL and TSH at this time, two have relapsed to date. CONCLUSIONS: In carefully selected patients, partial hypophysectomy is an acceptable alternative to medical treatment for prolactinoma. Preoperatively, dynamic tests accurately identified those patients whose hyperprolactinaemia was non-adenomatous in origin and, post-operatively, identified a subgroup of patients at increased risk of late recurrence.

Adult↗

Non-secretory adenomas of the pituitary treated by trans-ethmoidal sellotomy.

A consecutive series of 35 clinically non-secretory pituitary adenomas treated surgically by the transethmodial approach is presented. Mean age at presentation was 60 years, with a male-to-female ratio of 2:1. These tumours present later than hormone secreting tumours: 90% were over 2 cm in diameter at operation. Seventy-one per cent of patients had impaired vision and 89% had hypopituitarism. Surgical treatment relieved or significantly improved visual fields in 79% of patients with impaired vision. Ninety-one per cent required permanent hormone replacement. Mean follow-up was for 4.4 years. Five tumours recurred, causing recurrent visual symptoms. No tumours recurred in those patients treated with postoperative radiotherapy, but follow-up in this group was only for a mean of 2.7 years.

Adenoma↗

Discontinuous DNA synthesis by purified mammalian proteins.

Five proteins purified from mouse cells acting together efficiently convert a single-stranded circular DNA template to covalently closed duplex circle by a discontinuous mechanism. DNA polymerase alpha/primase with the assistance of alpha accessory factor covers the single-stranded circle with RNA-primed DNA fragments. Primers are removed by a combination of RNase H-1 and a 5'-exonuclease that was identified by its ability to complete this in vitro system. The 5'-exonuclease is required to remove residual one or two ribonucleotides at the primer/DNA junction that are resistant to RNase H-1. Gap filling is by the DNA polymerase alpha/primase, and DNA ligase I converts the DNA fragments to continuous strand. The concerted action of the five proteins emulates synthesis of the staging strand at the replication fork.

Animals↗

Acromegaly--the mucosal changes within the nose and paranasal sinuses.

The presence of upper respiratory tract obstruction in patients with acromegaly has been described. The main sites for obstruction were previously thought to be laryngeal and oropharyngeal. This study reviews 65 patients with acromegaly and 27 patients with a prolactinoma treated by trans-ethmoidal hypophysectomy. The results confirmed a very high incidence of polyp formation and mucosal hypertrophy within both the sphenoid (88 per cent) and ethmoidal (62 per cent) sinuses of the acromegalic patients. The histological appearances of the mucosal hypertrophy and polyposis confirmed no specific features attributable to acromegaly. Patient age and serum H.G.H. level do not appear to be significant factors. These findings within the para-nasal sinuses have never previously been reported.

Acromegaly↗