Exploring differences across pangenome-graph representations using Escherichia coli O157:H7 as a model.
Pangenome graphs are increasingly used to represent population-scale bacterial diversity, yet construction methods span fundamentally different representation paradigms whose outputs and sensitivities to assembly quality remain poorly quantified. We systematically reviewed microbial pangenome graph tools and benchmarked seven representative methods spanning gene-cluster, compacted coloured de Bruijn graph, one hybrid approach and one multiple sequence alignment method. Using a repeat-rich Escherichia coli O157:H7 dataset with complete genomes and matched short-read data, we constructed graphs from identical inputs and observed orders-of-magnitude differences in graph size and fragmentation, indicating that global topology is driven by representation strategy. Varying completeness composition revealed that assembly fragmentation is a first-order determinant of graph structure: gene-cluster graphs contracted as draft assemblies replaced complete genomes, whereas compacted coloured de Bruijn graphs expanded, with distinct degree-prevalence fingerprints across tools. In contrast, the multiple sequence alignment method could not be evaluated across fragmented inputs because it did not run reliably on draft-assembly datasets. Computational cost mirrored these shifts and depended strongly on completeness composition, including a pronounced runtime penalty for one compacted coloured de Bruijn graph implementation on all-draft inputs. Finally, analysis of Shiga toxin loci showed that pangenome-level reconciliation by gene-cluster-based tools does not reliably correct assembly artefacts at challenging multi-copy genes and that performance varies by locus. Together, these findings show that pangenome graphs are representation-dependent models of bacterial diversity, and that, in this repeat-rich O157:H7 benchmark dataset, assembly completeness is a primary determinant of their topology, scalability, and locus-level accuracy.