PubMed Health⌕ Search

PubMed · 10445637

Relating clinical study design to basic research.

Abstract

Devising any research study involves careful attention to its design, as well as the development of an appropriate research question and hypothesis. Together, these attributes ensure the validity of the study in question. In most clinical or epidemiological studies, the types of research designs are often explicitly noted, whereas in papers describing basic or biological research, they are couched in different terms or, more often, are ignored, thus potentially hindering communication between basic and clinical researchers. However, given that the framework for all valid scientific research is based on sound logic, it is proposed that for each study design, a direct homology exists between clinical and basic research paradigms, despite the problem of relating epidemiological vernacular to basic research. By applying examples of basic research protocols to traditional clinical study designs, this paper shows that parallels can be drawn between the two strategies, suggesting that in the absence of a conventional nomenclature to describe basic research study designs, the use of traditional clinical design jargon is valid in describing basic research protocols.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

V Choh, S Priolo. 1999. Relating clinical study design to basic research.. https://doi.org/10.1097/00006324-199907000-00021

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

Retinoic acid receptor alpha gene variants, multivitamin use, and liver intake as risk factors for oral clefts: a population-based case-control study in Denmark, 1991-1994.

Previous studies suggest that the risks of nonsyndromic cleft lip with or without cleft palate (CL+/-P) and isolated cleft palate are influenced by variation at several loci and that these loci interact with environmental factors to determine disease risk. One putative genetic risk factor for these conditions is the retinoic acid receptor alpha (RARA) locus, which is involved in cell-specific responses to retinoic acid. Hence, RARA may influence disease risk via an interaction with vitamin A and related compounds. Data from a Danish case-control study (1991-1994) were used to evaluate the relations between oral clefts, RARA, and maternal vitamin A exposure from multivitamins and liver. Analyses provided no compelling evidence that the risks of CL+/-P or isolated cleft palate are related to the RARA variant analyzed. Consistent with several previous studies, the authors' analyses indicated that maternal multivitamin supplement use protects against CL+/-P. Within the range observed in this population, higher levels of vitamin A intake from multivitamins and liver sources also seemed to protect against CL+/-P. Exploratory analyses suggested that the latter association was not entirely explained by the association between CL+/-P and multivitamin use, indicating that adequate levels of vitamin A may be required for normal development of the primary palate.

Case-Control Studies↗

HSV-1 antigens and DNA in the corneal explant buttons of patients with non-herpetic or clinically atypical herpetic stromal keratitis.

BACKGROUND: Little is known about the role of HSV-1 in keratitis not primarily attributed to herpetic origin. This study therefore aimed to prospectively evaluate the corneal explant buttons of patients with non-herpetic or clinically atypical herpetic stromal keratitis (experimental group: non-HSK) for the presence of HSV-1 antigens and DNA, and to compare the findings with those from individuals with typical herpetic stromal keratitis (positive control group: HSK) or non-inflammatory degenerative keratopathy (negative control group). METHODS: Corneal buttons derived from 51 patients with HSK, from 72 with non-HSK and from 30 with degenerative keratopathy were prospectively collected and subjected to immunohistochemical analysis for HSV-1 antigens and to HSV-1 DNA amplification. RESULTS: In corneal buttons derived from patients with non-HSK, viral antigens were detected immunohistochemically in 8/72 cases and DNA amplified in 16/72. Corresponding values for the HSK group were 16/51 and 11/51. Taking viral antigen and DNA findings together, HSV-1 was detected in 18/72 (25%) patients with non-HSK and in 19/51 (37%) with HSK (p=0.2), but in only 2/30 (6%) individuals with non-inflammatory degenerative keratopathy. CONCLUSION: Since the detection frequencies for HSV-1 antigens and DNA were comparable in the HSK and non-HSK groups, Herpes may play an underestimated and as yet undefined role in non-herpetic and clinically atypical herpetic stromal keratitis, either as a primary trigger of the disease or as a secondary contributor to it. In this category of individuals, early anti-herpetic therapy should be considered if patients do not respond in the expected manner to treatment for non-herpetic stromal keratitis.

Case-Control Studies↗

Comparison of strategies for selecting single nucleotide polymorphisms for case/control association studies.

It is widely believed that a subset of single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) is able to capture the majority of the information for genotype-phenotype association studies that is contained in the complete compliment of genetic variations. The question remains, how does one select that particular subset of SNPs in order to maximize the power of detecting a significant association? In this study, we have used a simulation approach to compare three competing methods of site selection: random selection, selection based on pair-wise linkage disequilibrium, and selection based on maximizing haplotype diversity. The results indicate that site selection based on maximizing haplotype diversity is preferred over random selection and selection based on pair-wise linkage disequilibrium. The results also indicate that it is more prudent to increase the sample size to improve a study's power than to continuously increase the number of SNPs. These results have direct implications for designing gene-based and genome-wide association studies.

Case-Control Studies↗