PubMed Health⌕ Search

PubMed · 12548478

[Model project on coding accuracy].

Abstract

First experiences with the external evaluation of coding accuracy in view of the German DRG-System are reported. 387 randomised inpatient cases of three departments of a municipal hospital were evaluated. 1.648 diagnosis codes and 946 procedure codes were evaluated with complete clinical data. Before and after correction by the reviewers the cases were grouped (AR-DRG 4.1) and the casemix index of the sample was calculated. 45.9% to 56.7% of primary diagnosis in the department samples were rated as correct. 25.2% to 37.5% of secondary diagnosis were rated as correct, 8.3% to 14.2% were corrected and 49.2% to 60.5% were rated as not relevant with regard to the German coding standards. 7.2% to 22.7% of secondary diagnosis had to be completed in the data. Evaluation of procedure codes resulted in 54.2% to 65.7% accepted codes, 5.9% to 12.1% corrected codes and 23.1% to 39.9% not accepted with regard to the German coding standards. 30.8% to 37.0% of procedure codes had to be completed in the data. After review, remarkable shift in DRGs was seen and casemix index increased 6.9% in average (0.25-12.1%). General and department-specific implications for improvement of coding accuracy could be evaluated. Consequences of potential coding errors in a prospective payment system on DRG basis were seen under conditions of daily hospital practice. External evaluation of coding accuracy used in this study could be the methodological basis for further investigations on this topic.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

P Dirschedl, M Reichle, M Röther. 2003. [Model project on coding accuracy].. https://doi.org/10.1055/s-2003-36914

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

Reliability of diagnoses coding with ICD-10.

OBJECTIVE: Reliability of diagnoses coding is essential for the use of routine data in a national health care system. The present investigation compares reliability of diagnoses coding with ICD-10 between three groups of coding subjects. METHOD: One hundred and eighteen students coded 15 diagnoses lists, 27 medical managers from hospitals 34 discharge letters, and 13 coding specialists 12 discharge letters. Agreement in principal diagnosis was assessed using Cohen's Kappa and the fraction of coincidences over the number of pairs, agreement for the full set of diagnoses with a previously developed measure p(om). RESULTS: Kappa values were fair (managers) or moderate (coders) for terminal codes with 0.27 and 0.42 (agreement 29.2% versus 46.8%), substantial for the chapter level with 0.71 and 0.72 (agreement 78.3% versus 80.8%). p(om) was lower for the full set of diagnoses than for principal diagnoses, for example in case of managers with 0.21 versus 0.29 for terminal codes. Best results were achieved by students coding diagnoses lists. In summary, the results are remarkably lower than in earlier publications. CONCLUSION: The refinement of the ICD-10 accompanied by innumerous coding rules has established a complex environment that leads to significant uncertainties even for experts. Use of coded data for quality management, health care financing, and health care policy requires a remarkable simplification of ICD-10 to receive a valid image of health care reality.

Diagnosis-Related Groups↗