PubMed Health⌕ Search
Home/Archive/PubMed

PubMed · 15369908

Group problems in problem-based learning.

Graham D Hendry·Greg Ryan·Jennifer Harris
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Successful small-group learning in problem-based learning (PBL) educational programmes relies on functional group processes. However, there has been limited research on PBL group problems, and no studies have been conducted on problems as perceived by both students and tutors in the same educational context. The authors investigated PBL group problems in a graduate-entry medical programme, and report the most common group problems, and those that hinder students' learning the most. The possible causes of individual quietness and dominant behaviour, and potential influences that group problems may have on the tutorial process are summarized in an exploratory model of PBL group dysfunction that could be used to guide further research. Specifically, there is a need for further evidence on which to base guidelines for tutors and students to effectively manage group problems.

Explore related subjects

Adaptation, PsychologicalAttitude of Health PersonnelBoredomConflict, PsychologicalCooperative BehaviorCurriculumEducation, Medical, UndergraduateFaculty, MedicalGroup ProcessesHealth Knowledge, Attitudes, PracticeHumansInterprofessional RelationsModels, EducationalModels, PsychologicalMoraleMotivationNew South WalesPersonalityProblem SolvingProblem-Based LearningPsychology, EducationalSocial DominanceStudents, MedicalSurveys and QuestionnairesJournal Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Graham D Hendry, Greg Ryan, Jennifer Harris. 2003. Group problems in problem-based learning.. https://doi.org/10.1080/0142159031000137427

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

PubMed2007

Caregiving time in sickle cell disease: psychological effects in maternal caregivers.

BACKGROUND: Providing home care for a child with a chronic illness can be stressful for the family. The purpose of this paper is to examine patterns of caregiving and the associated psychological impact on maternal caregivers of children with sickle cell disease (SCD). PROCEDURE: Fourteen maternal caregivers of children with SCD were interviewed as part of a larger study of maternal caregivers of children with chronic illness. Forty-four caregivers of children with HIV and 36 caregivers of healthy children were included as comparison groups. Interviews included questions regarding amount of time spent providing care for the child (technical care, non-technical care, health care management), hospitalization, emergency room visits, illness stigma, and mental health of the caregiver. RESULTS: Children with SCD had significantly lower functional status and significantly more hospitalizations in the previous 3 months than children with HIV. Caregivers of children with SCD were more likely to work full-time and had higher incomes than caregivers of children with HIV. The three caregiving groups did not differ significantly on amount of total care, although caregivers of children with SCD and caregivers of children with HIV both reported significantly more time spent in technical care than caregivers of healthy children. Despite lower functional status of the children in the SCD group, when group comparisons on caregiving time variables were adjusted for child's functional status, the differences between groups increased. This appeared to be due to the fact that caregivers in the HIV group spent more time in all caregiving categories except skin, crisis, and other care. In terms of caregiver mental health, caregivers of children with HIV and SCD had significantly higher depressive mood scores than caregivers of healthy children but the groups did not differ on caregiving burden. CONCLUSIONS: The perceived care burden of caregivers of children with SCD may be related to the unpredictable nature of the crisis care they provide. Additional attention is warranted to developing adequate resources for caregivers of children with SCD to mitigate the stress of unexpected crises.

Adaptation, Psychological↗
PubMed2006

Promoting enhanced patient and family caregiver congruence on lung cancer symptom experiences.

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVES: To test the effects of different perspective-taking instructional sets, gender, caregivers' personal histories with cancer, and caregiving relationship factors on family caregiver and patient perceptual agreement of symptom experiences of patients with lung cancer. DESIGN: Counterbalanced. SETTING: Thoracic oncology outpatient clinical setting in Canada. SAMPLE: 98 dyads consisting of patients with lung cancer and their family caregivers. METHODS: Data were collected on a one-time basis by employing an abbreviated version of the Memorial Symptom Assessment Scale targeting lack of energy and worrying. Caregivers were randomized to one of six counterbalanced conditions of perspective-taking instructions. MAIN RESEARCH VARIABLES: Caregiver discrepancy scores, instructional sets (i.e., neutral, self-report, and imagine-self and imagine-patient perspective-taking), order effects, gender, caregivers' personal history with cancer, and caregiving relationship factors. FINDINGS: No order effects were found for the instructional sets. Instructions to imagine the patient's perspective over imagining how the caregiver would feel if he or she had cancer were most effective in enhancing the caregiver's ability to estimate the patient's lack of energy and worrying. Gender had no significant effects. The amount of patient-caregiver communication had a positive impact on the accuracy of caregivers' perspectives. CONCLUSIONS: The patient-oriented instructions had a limited impact on enhancing patient-caregiver congruence on patient symptoms. This likely is related to the study's convenience sample of caregivers who appear to naturally engage in empathic processes of patient-oriented perspective-taking when they assessed and reported on patient symptom conditions. IMPLICATIONS FOR NURSING: Further exploratory work should identify interpersonal conditions that negatively hamper the effects of caregiver perspective-taking on their reasonable understanding of patient symptoms.

Adaptation, Psychological↗
PubMed2006

Meaning-making and psychological adjustment to cancer: development of an intervention and pilot results.

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVES: To develop an intervention that uniquely addresses the existential impact of cancer through meaning-making coping strategies and to explore the intervention's impact on psychological adjustment. DESIGN: Descriptive, qualitative approach to develop the intervention; one-group pre- and post-test design to pilot test the intervention. SETTING: Patients' homes or ambulatory oncology clinics affiliated with a university health center in eastern Canada. SAMPLE: 18 participants who were newly diagnosed in the past three months (n = 14), had completed treatment (n = 1), or were facing recurrence (n = 3) of breast (n = 10) or colorectal (n = 8) cancer. METHODS: Data were collected during interviews using a prototype intervention for trauma patients, and content was analyzed on an ongoing basis to fit the needs of the cancer population. Pretest and post-test questionnaires were administered to determine the intervention's effect. MAIN RESEARCH VARIABLES: Meaning-making intervention (MMI), patients' background variables, disease- or treatment-related symptoms, and psychological adjustment. FINDINGS: The MMI for patients with cancer consisted of as many as four two-hour, individualized sessions and involved the acknowledgment of losses and life threat, the examination of critical past challenges, and plans to stay committed to life goals. At post-test, participants significantly improved in self-esteem and reported a greater sense of security in facing the uncertainty of cancer. CONCLUSIONS: Findings suggest that meaning-making coping can be facilitated and lead to positive psychological outcomes following a cancer diagnosis. IMPLICATIONS FOR NURSING: The MMI offers a potentially effective and structured approach to address and monitor cancer-related existential issues. Findings are useful for designing future randomized, controlled trials.

Adaptation, Psychological↗