PubMed Health⌕ Search
Home/Archive/PubMed

PubMed · 15964766

A resolution criterion for electron tomography based on cross-validation.

Giovanni Cardone·Kay Grünewald·Alasdair C Steven
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Despite much progress in electron tomography, quantitative assessment of resolution has remained a problematic issue. The criteria that are used in single particle analysis, based on gauging the consistency between density maps calculated from half data sets, are not directly applicable because of the uniqueness of a tomographic volume. Here, we propose two criteria based on a cross-validation approach. One, called FSC(e/o), is based on a Fourier shell correlation comparison between tomograms calculated from the even and odd members of a tilt series. The other, called noise-compensated leave-one-out (NLOO), is based on Fourier ring correlation comparisons between an original projection and the corresponding reprojection of the tomogram calculated from all the other projections, taking into account the differing noise statistics. Plotted as a function of tilt angle, they allow assessment of the angular dependence of resolution and quality control over the series of projections. Integrated over all projections, the results give a global figure for resolution. Tests on simulated tomograms established consistency between these criteria and the FSC(ref), a correlation coefficient calculated between a known reference structure and the corresponding portion of a tomogram containing that structure. The two criteria-FSC(e/o) and NLOO-are mutually consistent when residual noise is the major resolution-limiting factor. When the size of the tilt increment becomes a significant factor, NLOO provides a more reliable criterion, as expected, although it is computationally intensive. Applicable to entire tomograms or selected structures, NLOO has also been tested on experimental tomographic data.

Explore related subjects

CapsidComputer SimulationCryoelectron MicroscopyElectronsHepatitis B virusMathematicsModels, TheoreticalReproducibility of ResultsSimplexvirusTomographyJournal Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

Giovanni Cardone, Kay Grünewald, Alasdair C Steven. 2005. A resolution criterion for electron tomography based on cross-validation.. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsb.2005.04.006

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

PubMed2017

A directed evolution approach to select for novel Adeno-associated virus capsids on an HIV-1 producer T cell line.

A directed evolution approach was used to select for Adeno-associated virus (AAV) capsids that would exhibit more tropism toward an HIV-1 producer T cell line with the long-term goal of developing improved gene transfer vectors. A library of AAV variants was used to infect H9 T cells previously infected or uninfected by HIV-1 followed by AAV amplification with wild-type adenovirus. Six rounds of biological selection were performed, including negative selection and diversification after round three. The H9 T cells were successfully infected with all three wild-type viruses (AAV, adenovirus, and HIV-1). Four AAV cap mutants best representing the small number of variants emerging after six rounds of selection were chosen for further study. These mutant capsids were used to package an AAV vector and subsequently used to infect H9 cells that were previously infected or uninfected by HIV-1. A quantitative polymerase chain reaction assay was performed to measure cell-associated AAV genomes. Two of the four cap mutants showed a significant increase in the amount of cell-associated genomes as compared to wild-type AAV2. This study shows that directed evolution can be performed successfully to select for mutants with improved tropism for a T cell line in the presence of HIV-1.

Capsid↗
PubMed2014

Engineering adeno-associated viruses for clinical gene therapy.

Clinical gene therapy has been increasingly successful owing both to an enhanced molecular understanding of human disease and to progressively improving gene delivery technologies. Among these technologies, delivery vectors based on adeno-associated viruses (AAVs) have emerged as safe and effective and, in one recent case, have led to regulatory approval. Although shortcomings in viral vector properties will render extension of such successes to many other human diseases challenging, new approaches to engineer and improve AAV vectors and their genetic cargo are increasingly helping to overcome these barriers.

Capsid↗
PubMed2007

A precise packing sequence for self-assembled convex structures.

Molecular simulations of the self-assembly of cone-shaped particles with specific, attractive interactions are performed. Upon cooling from random initial conditions, we find that the cones self-assemble into clusters and that clusters comprised of particular numbers of cones (e.g., 4-17, 20, 27, 32, and 42) have a unique and precisely packed structure that is robust over a range of cone angles. These precise clusters form a sequence of structures at specific cluster sizes (a "precise packing sequence") that for small sizes is identical to that observed in evaporation-driven assembly of colloidal spheres. We further show that this sequence is reproduced and extended in simulations of two simple models of spheres self-assembling from random initial conditions subject to convexity constraints, including an initial spherical convexity constraint for moderate- and large-sized clusters. This sequence contains six of the most common virus capsid structures obtained in vivo, including large chiral clusters and a cluster that may correspond to several non-icosahedral, spherical virus capsids obtained in vivo. Our findings suggest that this precise packing sequence results from free energy minimization subject to convexity constraints and is applicable to a broad range of assembly processes.

Capsid↗