PubMed Health⌕ Search
Home/Archive/PubMed

PubMed · 3738716

Chemonucleolysis: a note of caution.

C Watts·E Dickhaus
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

Following the approval in 1982 by the Federal Food and Drug Administration of chymopapain for public use by the medical profession in the treatment of ruptured lumbar intervertebral disk disease, chemonucleolysis has become widespread in the United States; a considerable experience has been obtained in the past 3 years, allowing for an appropriate examination of the original claims for the procedure. Chemonucleolysis is not as efficacious as surgery for simple ruptured lumbar intervertebral disk disease. Whereas the complication rates of chemonucleolysis are probably no greater than that for surgery, the incidence of unpreventable anaphylaxis and other untoward reactions makes it certainly no more safe. There is no biological basis for the belief that chemonucleolysis will result in a shorter convalescence than surgery, and it appears that chemonucleolysis has significantly increased the cost of invasive treatment of patients with ruptured lumbar intervertebral disk disease.

Explore related subjects

ChymopapainCosts and Cost AnalysisHumansIntervertebral Disc DisplacementSurgical Procedures, OperativeComparative StudyJournal Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

C Watts, E Dickhaus. 1986. Chemonucleolysis: a note of caution.. https://doi.org/10.1016/0090-3019(86)90155-2

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

PubMed2006

Hofmeister effects in protein unfolding kinetics: estimation of changes in surface area upon formation of the transition state.

We studied the effect of three electrolytes (LiCl, Na(2)SO(4), GuHCl) on the unfolding reaction of chymopapain, a two-domain protein belonging in the papain family of cysteine proteinases. Due to methodological reasons, these studies were carried out at pH 1.5 where the protein unfolds following biphasic kinetics. We have observed the presence of two different effects of electrolyte concentration on the unfolding reactions. At low ionic strength, the ionic atmosphere brought about an increase in reaction rates, regardless of the type of ions being present; this effect is attributed to a general "electrostatic screening" of charge-charge interactions in the macromolecule. At high ionic strength, each electrolyte exerted a distinctively different effect: both rate constants were largely increased by GuHCl (a well-known protein denaturant), but only slightly by LiCl; in contrast, Na(2)SO(4) (a good precipitant) decreased the value of both unfolding rates. These ion-specific (Hofmeister) effects were further used to estimate changes in accessible surface area (DeltaASA) upon formation of the transition states (TS) for unfolding. Results obtained with LiCl and Na(2)SO(4), which we analyzed by means of a parameterization derived from published solubility data of amino acid derivatives, are consistent with DeltaASA increments (for each phase) of about 8.0% of the total theoretical DeltaASA for complete unfolding of the chymopapain molecule. Results in the presence of GuHCl, which were analyzed by using a previous parameterization of protein unfolding data, gave larger DeltaASAs of activation, equivalent to 13 and 16% of the total unfolding DeltaASA.

Chymopapain↗
PubMed2006

Intradiscal therapies for discogenic pain.

Since the first injection of chymopapain in 1963, percutaneous intradiscal therapies have been used to treat discogenic back and leg pain. The percutaneous discectomy techniques treat contained disc herniations not by resecting the prolapsed disc material but rather through central decompression of the disc. By removing a small volume of tissue from the disc nucleus, a large reduction in overall disc pressure is achieved with consequent relief of neural compression. DISC Nucleoplasty and Dekompressor are the two leading percutaneous discectomy technologies currently. Although rigorous clinical testing of their efficacy is ongoing, there has now been a 40-year history confirming the concept of percutaneous disc decompression, and initial results are very promising. Discogenic low back pain can also arise from annular tears and other forms of internal disc derangement (IDD). Annuloplasty techniques, such as IntraDiscal Electrothermal Therapy (IDET) and discTRODE, have been developed over the past decade that thermally treat the lesions of IDD. Although the therapeutic mechanisms of thermal annuloplasty have yet to be fully elucidated, research studies demonstrate that the procedure can be effective for appropriately selected patients with degenerative disc disease characterized by discographically proven painful annular fissures. Other novel intradiscal therapies are emerging for percutaneous treatment of discogenic pain and await more widespread clinical evaluation.

Chymopapain↗