PubMed HealthSearch

PubMed · 3772549

Ethical concerns in occupational screening programs.

Abstract

Preventive and anticipatory programs for identifying workers at higher-than-normal risk for occupational injury and/or disease can now draw on an expanding net of sophisticated diagnostic tests. New genetic screening tests may use reagents developed through recombinant DNA technologies, including cDNA probes for genetic variants such as HLA B27 associated with late-appearing disability. Assessments of the readiness of these technologies to be incorporated into standard occupational policy turn on their predictive value, applications, and the locus of control of the data which they generate. The question of responsibility for health protection and obligations accruing to those who uncover genetically fixed risk status has major ethical implications. Issues of potential stigmatization, discrimination, and protection of equal employment opportunity must be resolved before these tests are put into practice. The possible use of genetic testing to assure minimal risk and its equitable distribution among workers is highlighted as a possible benefit of this new applied technology.

Explore related subjects

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

M A Lappé. 1986. Ethical concerns in occupational screening programs.. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3772549/

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

Protecting the privacy of patient information in clinical networks: regulatory effectiveness analysis.

Patient privacy is one of the major issues in the development of modern clinical information system networks. Such networks will have to demonstrate an appropriate concern for privacy as a precondition of operation. Regulatory effectiveness analysis is a novel technique for measuring compliance with a technological regulatory system. By examining the public policies, legal structures, and technical tools involved in the regulatory system, it is possible to discover discontinuities that may result in noncompliance with the regulatory system.

Civil Rights

The problem of discrimination in health care priority setting.

Increasingly stringent fiscal restrictions on the scope of medical services available to patients have resulted in calls for explicit health care priority setting. Several commentators have called for the application of decision-analytic principles to such efforts, which would assign services priority based on the extent to which they produce preferred health outcomes. The Oregon Medicaid exercise is an example of such a process. An important challenge to these utilitarian efforts is the need to avoid discrimination against people with medical disabilities. Both of the key elements entailed by decision-analytic approaches to priority setting--estimation of outcomes and assignment of values to those outcomes--are vulnerable to charges of discrimination, primarily because both the medical outcomes expected in disabled individuals and the values they place on those outcomes may differ from the general public. Priority-setting efforts must proceed carefully to avoid the appearance (and reality) of discrimination.

Civil Rights