A rare and atypical case of long-distance indirect DNA transfer: Contamination from an investigator never present at the scene.

Abstract

To maximize the usefulness of DNA obtained from biological samples in forensic genetics, it is crucial to avoid DNA contamination throughout all procedures, from sample collection at crime scenes to STR profile generation in DNA laboratories. This study reports a rare and atypical case of DNA contamination in a forensic setting. During the analysis of biological evidence from a cold case preserved for 18 years, the STR profile obtained from the surface of a plastic bag matched that of an investigator, identified through the DNA elimination database. Case reconstruction confirmed that the investigator-who was located 80 km from the DNA laboratory and had never entered the crime scene or the sample storage room-was not a suspect and that the obtained STR profile originated from contamination. The most plausible explanation for the contamination was indirect transfer: investigator's DNA had adhered to a colleague's clothing and was subsequently dislodged and deposited onto the surface of the plastic bag as the colleague approached the sample pretreatment area. This study integrates trace DNA profiling of challenged samples with rapid contamination investigation and proposes prevention and control measures. This case underscores that, although DNA is widely regarded as the "gold standard" in forensic genetics, its interpretation must be considered within the context of the entire case. Conclusions should not be drawn based solely on a single DNA result.