Limited Impact of Column Chemistry and Length on Proteome Coverage Under High-Speed DIA.

Abstract

The evolution of mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics has been driven by continuous technological advances in sample preparation, liquid-phase separations, instrumentation, and data acquisition. Chromatographic performance has been recognized as a contributing factor to identification depth, particularly on earlier-generation MS platforms. Recent advances in MS sampling speed and sensitivity now raise the question of how strongly chromatographic quality continues to determine overall proteome coverage. We investigate how column chemistry and length influence proteome coverage and chromatographic selectivity under modern data-independent acquisition conditions, and whether traditional optimization priorities still apply. Spanning a matrix of experiments with five distinct stationary phases, including C18 chemistries, C8, and Phenyl-Hexyl, across eight column lengths (40-140 mm), we evaluate protein identification performance using data-independent acquisition on the Orbitrap Astral mass spectrometer. Despite differences in stationary-phase chemistry and column length, we observed remarkably convergent proteome coverage metrics. All C18 and C8 phases consistently achieved over 150,000 precursor- and approximately 9000 protein group identifications, regardless of column length variations. While retention fingerprints persisted across chemistries, these chromatographic differences did not translate into meaningful variations in proteome coverage under high-speed acquisition conditions at 200 Hz. Within the range of modern sub-2 μm reversed-phase materials tested, identification depth showed limited dependence on column chemistry and length, suggesting that for state-of-the-art stationary phases, method development priorities may increasingly favor operational robustness, throughput, and reproducibility over traditional separation optimization.