PubMed Health⌕ Search
Home/Archive/PubMed

PubMed · 9524352

Simulating an integrated critiquing system.

M M Kuilboer·J van der Lei·J C de Jongste·S E Overbeek·B Ponsioen·J H van Bemmel
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

OBJECTIVE: To investigate factors that determine the feasibility and effectiveness of a critiquing system for asthma/COPD that will be integrated with a general practitioner's (GP's) information system. DESIGN: A simulation study. Four reviewers, playing the role of the computer, generated critiquing comments and requests for additional information on six electronic medical records of patients with asthma/COPD. Three GPs who treated the patients, playing users, assessed the comments and provided missing information when requested. The GPs were asked why requested missing information was unavailable. The reviewers reevaluated their comments after receiving requested missing information. MEASUREMENTS: Descriptions of the number and nature of critiquing comments and requests for missing information. Assessment by the GPs of the critiquing comments in terms of agreement with each comment and judgment of its relevance, both on a five-point scale. Analysis of causes for the (un-)availability of requested missing information. Assessment of the impact of missing information on the generation of critiquing comments. RESULTS: Four reviewers provided 74 critiquing comments on 87 visits in six medical records. Most were about prescriptions (n = 28) and the GPs' workplans (n = 27). The GPs valued comments about diagnostics the most. The correlation between the GPs' agreement and relevance scores was 0.65. However, the GPs' agreements with prescription comments (complete disagreement, 31.3%; disagreement, 20.0%; neutral, 13.8%; agreement, 17.5%; complete agreement, 17.5%) differed from their judgments of these comments' relevance (completely irrelevant, 9.0%; irrelevant, 24.4%; neutral, 24.4%; relevant, 32.1%; completely relevant, 10.3%). The GPs were able to provide answers to 64% of the 90 requests for missing information. Reasons available information had not been recorded were: the GPs had not recorded the information explicitly; they had assumed it to be common knowledge; it was available elsewhere in the record. Reasons information was unavailable were: the decision had been made by another; the GP had not recorded the information. The reviewers left 74% of the comments unchanged after receiving requested missing information. CONCLUSION: Human reviewers can generate comments based on information currently available in electronic medical records of patients with asthma/COPD. The GPs valued comments regarding the diagnostic process the most. Although they judged prescription comments relevant, they often strongly disagreed with them, a discrepancy that poses a challenge for the presentation of critiquing comments for the future critiquing system. Requested additional information that was provided by the GPs led to few changes. Therefore, as system developers faced with the decision to build an integrated, non-inquisitive or an inquisitive critiquing system, the authors choose the former.

Explore related subjects

AsthmaDecision Support Systems, ClinicalFamily PracticeHumansLung Diseases, ObstructiveMedical Records Systems, ComputerizedSystems IntegrationJournal ArticleResearch Support, Non-U.S. Gov't

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

M M Kuilboer, J van der Lei, J C de Jongste, S E Overbeek, B Ponsioen, J H van Bemmel. Simulating an integrated critiquing system.. https://doi.org/10.1136/jamia.1998.0050194

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

PubMed2026

Reframing the asthma microbiome: Multikingdom, multisite, and multiomic perspectives.

The field of asthma microbiome research has shifted rapidly in recent years. Advances in sequencing technology have led to an increased ability to characterize multikingdom microbial species and integration with host -omics profiling to enhance future translational applications. Traditional bacteria-centric, cross-sectional studies are giving way to mechanistic frameworks that incorporate fungi, viruses, and host-immune interactions. In this state-of-the-art review of emerging concepts in microbiome asthma research, we first propose a structured framework to consider microbiome studies across 5 major domains-microbial kingdom, site of sampling, integration with host -omics, clinical outcome domain, and translational relevance-in order to synthesize recent high-impact human microbiome studies in asthma. We highlight emerging evidence that fungal and viral communities contribute independently to asthma risk and that human microbial communities are linked to distinct inflammatory and immune pathways shaped by host genetic susceptibility.

Asthma↗
PubMed2026

H3K9ac promoter profiling and their association with gene expression in immune cells of T2-high asthma patients.

BACKGROUND: Asthma is a heterogeneous chronic inflammatory syndrome, with the T2-high endotype defined by robust type 2 immune responses and skewed T helper polarization. Although H3K9 acetylation (H3K9ac) is a key activating histone mark in T helper differentiation, its genome-wide promoter landscape in circulating immune cells of T2-high asthma remains uncharacterized. METHODS: Integrated ChIP-seq and RNA-seq profiling was performed on peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMCs) from ten T2-high asthma patients and ten healthy controls. Differential H3K9ac enrichment and gene expression were analyzed, followed by concordance and Spearman correlation analyses to identify genes under H3K9ac-linked transcriptional regulation. Findings were contextualized using publicly available H3K27ac ChIP-seq datasets from asthmatic airway tissue and glucocorticoid-treated airway epithelial cells. RESULTS: We identified 2340 differential enrichment regions (DERs), 95.9% mapping to promoters, with nearly all showing H3K9ac loss and enrichment in T cell receptor signaling and Th1/Th2/Th17 differentiation pathways. Genes encoding histone-modifying enzymes, including HATs, HDACs, and HMTs, were overrepresented, suggesting a self-reinforcing epigenetic feedback loop. Integrated analysis identified 979 genes with concordant H3K9ac and expression changes: downregulated genes were enriched in lymphocyte activation and TNF signaling, whereas upregulated genes were enriched in AKT and MAPK pathways. Locus-specific analyses showed H3K9ac loss at Th1/Th17 genes (TBX21, IFNG, CCR6) and gain at Th2 genes (IL4, TSLP). Targeted RT-qPCR provided independent experimental support for reduced expression of Th1-associated genes, with significant decreases in STAT1 and STAT4 in T2-high asthma patients. Correlation analysis identified six genes with significant H3K9ac-expression associations. CONCLUSIONS: Promoter H3K9ac remodeling is a defining epigenetic feature of T2-high asthma, reflecting coordinated alterations at T helper lineage-defining loci and inflammatory pathways.

Asthma↗
PubMed2026

Functional Variant Discovery Identifies a Novel Genetic Link between SPRY2, Wood Smoke, and Asthma.

As a consequence of climate change and land-use policies, there has been a historic rise in wildfire smoke across the United States and the world. Although the deleterious effects of wildfire smoke and associated air pollution on asthma outcomes are established epidemiologically, genetic risks and molecular mechanisms of how wildfire smoke affects asthma are unknown. This knowledge gap hinders the identification of high-risk individuals and the creation of targeted therapies or recommendations to protect these individuals. We identified 52 genetic risk variants that colocalized with genomic responses to woodsmoke particles (WSPs), a model of wildfire particulate matter, and associated with asthma in the GERA (Genetic Epidemiology Research on Adult Health and Aging) cohort. We used additional filters to prioritize variants for direct testing of allele-dependent transcriptional regulatory function in plasmid reporters. We found that the rs3861144 variant (odds ratioasthma, 1.036) changes SPRY2 responses to WSPs in airway epithelial cells, which are involved in IL-8 secretion, ERK (extracellular signal-related kinase) activation, and mechanical scratch repair in cell culture. These findings provide insights into the molecular pathways through which WSPs may influence asthma risk and propose genetic candidates that warrant further study for their potential as clinical tools for asthma.

Asthma↗