Comparison of repeat videokeratography: repeatability and accuracy.

M Jeandervin; J Barr

doi:10.1097/00006324-199809000-00021

Home/Archive/PubMed

PubMed · 9778699

Comparison of repeat videokeratography: repeatability and accuracy.

M Jeandervin·J Barr

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

PURPOSE: We compared the repeatability and accuracy of four commercially available videokeratography instruments and a manual keratometer. METHODS: Ten optometry students and two university employees who had no history of rigid contact lens wear and no soft contact lens wear within 6 months of the study were measured. Two independent measurements were taken on the right eyes only using the Alcon EyeMap EH-290 topography system (both manual and automatic focus), the EyeSys System 2000 corneal topography system, the Humphrey Mastervue topography system, the Humphrey Atlas topography system, and a Marco manual keratometer. A three-factor repeated measures analysis of variance with all factors repeated was performed using SAS and BMDP statistical software. Separate analyses were conducted for paracentral and peripheral data. To test accuracy, measurements were taken with the Alcon EyeMap automatic focus system, the EyeSys System 2000, the Humphrey Atlas system, and the Humphrey Mastervue system using four calibration spheres. RESULTS: There were no statistically significant differences in the repeatability of the instruments. The EyeSys corneal topography system had the most narrow 95% limits of agreement around the mean difference. The two Humphrey instruments performed similarly to the EyeSys. Although the Alcon EyeMap EH-290 had the widest 95% limits of agreement around the mean difference, it showed better repeatability when the manual focus was used compared with the automatic focus. The instruments varied in their level of accuracy, but the highest percentage of data points within +/- 0.37 D of the known values of the calibration spheres was found with the Humphrey Atlas. CONCLUSIONS: Although there were no statistically significant differences in repeatability, the EyeSys System 2000 had the highest repeatability, which may have clinical relevance. The accuracy measured in this study varied tremendously; however, the Humphrey Atlas was found to be the most accurate of the instruments tested.

Explore related subjects

Cornea Corneal Topography Humans Reproducibility of Results Comparative Study Journal Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

M Jeandervin, J Barr. 1998. Comparison of repeat videokeratography: repeatability and accuracy.. https://doi.org/10.1097/00006324-199809000-00021

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

PubMed2007

Differential tissue-on-tissue lubrication by ophthalmic formulations.

Tissue-on-tissue friction testing was used to determine how instillation of hydrophilic polymer-containing formulations between the "blinking" tissues would compare with lubrication by saline, alone, or an oil-emulsion preparation. Best results were obtained for a formulation that contained active demulcents polyethylene glycol (PEG 400) and propylene glycol (PG), as well as a gellable polymer hydroxypropyl guar (HP-Guar) in a borate-buffered solution, in comparison with hydroxypropylcellulose-containing and carboxymethylcellulose-containing formulations. Superior performance of all the formulations was found for lubricating tissue-on-tissue couples, compared with metal-oxide-to-metal oxide interfaces, or metal oxide-to-tissue interfaces. A reciprocating pin-on-disc type friction/wear test device articulated the intimal faces of preserved human umbilical cord vein segments under increasing loads during simulated continuous "eye-blinking" with addition of increasing weights up to 60 g/cm2, simulating maximal eyelid force on the orbital globe. The tissue-on-tissue couples moved from liquid phase lubrication to boundary lubrication. After residual formulations were rinsed away with saline, persistence of low friction at the highest loads was indicative of formulation substantivity. Human umbilical cord vein segments were utilized in saline-wetted tissue-on-tissue couples that showed variable starting coefficients of friction in the range 0.2-0.4, producing moderate tearing and disruption of the interfacial layers above the medial collagen zone. The best-performing formulations instilled to the tissues pre-wetted with saline apparently reacted separately with each tissue face to produce a lower final and persistent coefficient of friction of about 0.05. Scanning electron microscopy and light microscopy of these guar-modified tissue specimens showed only a few superficial tissue disruptions, and some interphase swelling consistent with polymer uptake. The frictional values for lubricated couples having non-tissue members were considerably higher than the coefficients of friction measured for the similarly lubricated tissue-on-tissue couples, emphasizing the requirement that appropriate simulations are critical to obtaining clinically predictive data.

Cornea↗

PubMed2006

Validated prediction model for the development of primary open-angle glaucoma in individuals with ocular hypertension.

OBJECTIVE: To test the validity and generalizability of the Ocular Hypertension Treatment Study (OHTS) prediction model for the development of primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) in a large independent sample of untreated ocular hypertensive individuals and to develop a quantitative calculator to estimate the 5-year risk that an individual with ocular hypertension will develop POAG. DESIGN: A prediction model was developed from the observation group of the OHTS and then tested on the placebo group of the European Glaucoma Prevention Study (EGPS) using a z statistic to compare hazard ratios, a c statistic for discrimination, and a calibration chi2 for systematic overestimation/underestimation of predicted risk. The 2 study samples were pooled to increase precision and generalizability of a 5-year predictive model for developing POAG. PARTICIPANTS: The OHTS observation group (n = 819; 6.6 years' median follow-up) and EGPS placebo group (n = 500; 4.8 years' median follow-up). TESTING: Data were collected on demographic characteristics, medical history, ocular examination visual fields (VFs), and optic disc photographs. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Development of reproducible VF abnormality or optic disc progression as determined by masked readers and attributed to POAG by a masked end point committee. RESULTS: The same predictors for the development of POAG were identified independently in both the OHTS observation group and the EGPS placebo group-baseline age, intraocular pressure, central corneal thickness, vertical cup-to-disc ratio, and Humphrey VF pattern standard deviation. The pooled multivariate model for the development of POAG had good discrimination (c statistic, 0.74) and accurate estimation of POAG risk (calibration chi2, 7.05). CONCLUSIONS: The OHTS prediction model was validated in the EGPS placebo group. A calculator to estimate the 5-year risk of developing POAG, based on the pooled OHTS-EGPS predictive model, has high precision and will be useful for clinicians and patients in deciding the frequency of tests and examinations during follow-up and advisability of initiating preventive treatment.

Cornea↗

PubMed2006

Corneal oxygen uptake: A review of polarographic techniques, applications, and variables.

Factors that influence the polarographic measurement of the oxygen uptake of the cornea are reviewed. These factors include the technique, electrode assembly, oxygen reservoir, membrane material and thickness, oxygen tension of the corneal environment, duration of exposure to environmental conditions and time to application of the probe all influencing measured oxygen uptake rates. Subject factors include lid position, palpebral aperture size, blinking, corneal thickness, and corneal integrity. Contact lens wear influences corneal oxygen uptake, with lens material and design parameters influencing rates obtained both under static (without blinking) and dynamic (with blinking) conditions. Measurement of corneal oxygen uptake rates remains an excellent method to quantify the oxygen supply in contact lens systems that include the contact lens, the tears, and the cornea, in which oxygen flux is influenced by the thickness and diffusion characteristics of each component.

Cornea↗