Deep brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease: potential risk of tissue damage associated with external stimulation.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · PubMed Health
Explore indexed PubMed citations for clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health research. Read source abstracts and follow each citation to its original PubMed record.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Currently, DBS is a commonly performed surgery for treatment of movement disorders, especially Parkinson's disease. Although nonablative and minimally invasive, this procedure may give rise to many complications and side effects, some of which are neither reversible nor adaptable. This study reviews the potential complications of DBS along the entire path of this procedure, from patient selection through the postoperative period. Although intraoperative complications such as paralysis and hematoma are rare, other serious complications due to the hardware, such as lead fracture, dislocation, and infection, are not uncommon. Complications or side effects as a result of chronic stimulation itself may be the most common. It is concluded that every member of the surgical team, including the referring neurologist, has an important role in the avoidance of such complications. Proper and careful patient selection, matching each patient to the specific DBS procedure appropriate for his/her symptom profile and suitable for his/her social and cognitive condition, along with experienced and careful intraoperative surgical routine, may be the best way to prevent the complications of DBS procedures.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Eight patients with advanced PD received a unilateral STN DBS. The UPDRS III off drug-on DBS was improved by a mean 44%. Dyskinesias were ameliorated. Levodopa daily dose was reduced. Three patients required the implantation of the second electrode. Unilateral DBS may be efficacious in some patients with advanced PD.
Articles on surgery for Parkinson's disease (PD), published between 1966 and 2001, were reviewed with respect to whether the first author had a neurosurgical affiliation, and whether the papers appeared in neurosurgical or non-neurosurgical journals. Between 1966 and 1979, neurosurgeons and non-neurosurgeons published almost equally on surgery for PD in both neurosurgical and non-neurosurgical journals; between 1980 and 1995, the majority of publications were by neurosurgeons in neurosurgical journals; and after 1995, non-neurosurgeons were more often first authors of surgical publications and these were more frequent in non-neurosurgical journals. The fact that the first author of surgical publications on PD is often a non-neurosurgeon may have some bearing on the reported results of surgery.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Electrical impulses through chronically implanted electrodes in the human brain are used today in the relief of chronic crippling pain, motor movement disorders and behavior disturbances. A great number of reports from animal studies and several descriptions of the results produced by human stimulation seem to suggest that pain can often be adequately controlled. However, the perspectives of such methods raise many ethical problems and ask for caution. Nervous tissue damage after long-term stimulation, biochemical modifications, electrode migration and long-term follow-up of its clinical value are still under study and are the factors which might limit for the time being the indications. A restrictive role for this procedure is advocated for: 1. cases of chronic facial pain, 2. cases of chronic pain in other locations where other neurosurgical operations have failed and where the patient is not too young and is not suffering from pain of benign origin.
Chronic high frequency (130 Hz) stimulation (HFS) of the thalamic target Vim, first used in our group in 1987 as a treatment of tremor of various origins, has been used over the last ten years in 137 patients. Since 1993, this method has been extended to two other targets (subthalamic nucleus (STN): 137 patients and the medial pallidum (GPi): 12 patients), based on recent experimental data in rats and monkeys. STN appears to be a target of major interest, able to control the three cardinal symptoms and to allow the decrease or suppression of levodopa treatment, which then also suppresses levodopa induced dyskinesias. The stereotactic technique is based on the determination of the target using ventriculography, MRI and electrophysiology, with both microrecording of single neuron activity and microstimulation inducing therapeutic symptom suppression and side effects. Chronic electrodes are then placed bilaterally at the best physiologically defined location and then connected to implantable stimulators (either 2 Itrel II or the new double channel Kinetra), operated at 130-185 Hz, 60 ms pulse width, 2.5 to 3.5 volts. There was no operative mortality and permanent morbidity was observed in 3 patients. The mechanisms of action of HFS are not fully understood, but are definitely related to high frequency and are probably different depending on the target. Inhibition of cellular activity or of neural network functions could be induced, by jamming of a retroactive loop for tremor, or by shutdown of neurotransmitter release in STN. Mechanisms within an individual target are also probably different for tremor or for other symptom alleviation. All cardinal symptoms are alleviated from tremor to akinesia and rigidity. This strong improvement allows the decrease of the drug dosage to approximately 30% of the preoperative level, which suppresses the levodopa-induced dyskinesias. The off period dystonias are also suppressed as well as freezings and falls. The effects remain stable over more than 5 years and in the same period, the off stimulation-off medication UPDRS remains stable and does not increase at the usual rate The low rate of permanent complications, the minor side effects and their immediate reversibility, the possibility of bilateral implantation in one session and the long-term persistence of symptom relief are strong arguments which support chronic HFS of STN as the method of choice when a surgical procedure is indicated for the treatment of Parkinson's disease and even more when a bilateral procedure is necessary. Recent data show that STN stimulation could be useful in the treatment of dystonia as well as some forms of epilepsy. It is therefore possible that DBS in STN as well as in other targets could become a potent therapeutic tool in the near future for neurological disorders.
OBJECTIVE: To assess the effects on motor functioning, health status and direct medical costs of high-frequency stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus (DBS-STN) in patients with idiopathic Parkinson's disease (PD). In addition, the cost-effectiveness of DBS-STN vs. drug treatment was investigated. METHODS: 16 consecutive patients with PD from two centers (Düsseldorf/Cologne; Kiel) treated by DBS-STN were prospectively evaluated. Clinical evaluations were done at baseline and 1, 3, 6, 12 months following surgery by means of the Unified Parkinson's disease Rating Scale (UPDRS). Health status of PD patients was assessed using the Sickness Impact Profile (SIP) at baseline and 6 months following surgery. Relevant economic data were taken from the medical records and costs (1999) were derived from different German medical economic resources. Costs were determined from the perspective of the health care provider. RESULTS: Following DBS-STN UPDRS scores (subscores and sum score) as well as health status improved considerably in PD patients. The overall SIP score and the physical dimension score (p < 0.009) were significantly different (p < 0.01) six month after surgery compared with baseline values. Mean costs of DM 40,020 (US dollars 20,810, EURO 20,410, GB pounds 12,810) per patient were spent during the 12 month observation period for in-patient and out-patient care. These expenses included already the costs for the electronic device for bilateral stimulation. Following DBS-STN medication was considerably reduced. Mean daily drug costs at baseline were DM 46.7+/-21.8 (US dollars 24, EURO 24, GB pounds 15) and DM 18.3+/-17.7 (US dollars 10, EURO 9, GB pounds 6) at 12 months following DBS-STN. Accounting for the decreased drug consumption, total annual costs amounted to DM 31,400 (US dollars 16,330, EURO 16,010, GB pounds 10,050). Further, we estimated the incremental cost effectiveness as DBS-STN had higher costs but was more effective than baseline treatment. The incremental total cost-effectiveness ratio for DBS-STN was DM 1.800 (US dollars 940, EURO 920, GB pounds 580) for one point decrease of the UPDRS. CONCLUSION: DBS-STN is an effective treatment that considerably alleviates the severity of signs and symptoms and improves the health status of patients with PD. Compared with drug treatment, however, the expenditures associated with DBS-STN are increased when only direct medical costs are considered in a one year horizon. However, on a long-term basis costs will decrease considerably because of the reduction of the drug expenditure and improved functioning in all activities of daily living. To adequately evaluate the cost-effectiveness of DBS-STN compared with standard drug regimen for PD it is necessary to include direct, indirect and intangible costs on a long-term basis and under standardized circumstances.
DBS of the STN is one of the most promising new therapies for the treatment of PD. However - like many other therapies for PD - the present stage of the scientific assessment does not yet suffice the rigid criteria of evidence-based medicine. Further studies should specifically address the questions of efficacy and side effects as well as the impact on quality of life.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.