PubMed Health⌕ Search

SEARCH · PubMed Health

Results for “Prospective Payment System”

Explore indexed PubMed citations for clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health research. Read source abstracts and follow each citation to its original PubMed record.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 847 records · Page 47Linked to original sources

Pricing Medicare's diagnosis-related groups: charges versus estimated costs.

Hospital payments under Medicare's prospective payment system (PPS) are based on prices established for 474 diagnosis-related groups (DRG's). Previous analyses using 1981 data demonstrated that DRG prices based on charges alone were not that different from prices calculated from estimated costs. Data for 1986 were used in this study to show that the differences between the two sets of DRG prices are much larger than previously reported. If DRG prices were once again based on estimated costs instead of the current charge-based prices, payments would be significantly redistributed.

Abstracting and Indexing↗

Disease staging and PMCs. Can they improve DRGs?

Since the adoption of Medicare's Prospective Payment System (PPS), critics have raised concerns about the degree of variation in cost per case due to variability in severity of illness within DRGs. Using hospital (Part A) costs for all Medicare beneficiaries hospitalized in Michigan during 1982, this paper applies multivariate techniques to test the ability of two state-of-the-art case-mix measures to either replace or act as a severity modifier to DRGs. When compared with DRGs, neither Patient Management Categories (PMCs) nor Disease Staging explains any more of the variation in costs. Results show that DRGs explain 33%, while PMCs and Disease Staging explain 26% and 17%, respectively. The use of either alternative in tandem with DRGs explains only 1-2% more of the observed variation; however, both PMCs and Disease Staging identify subgroups of patients with significantly different costs. These findings suggest that the alternatives may prove modestly useful as DRG modifiers by identifying classes of patients that do not belong. More importantly, they offer a measure of "unrelated comorbidity" that may improve the performance of DRGs.

Costs and Cost Analysis↗

Sources of hospital cost variation by urban-rural location.

Under current law, Medicare's Prospective Payment System (PPS) recognizes a 25% differential in standardized average costs per admission between rural and urban areas. Using Medicare Part A and B claims data from four states across the country, this paper employs descriptive and multivariate techniques to explain the underlying sources of cost variation. DRG mix and within-DRG severity differences were found to contribute only 10-15% to the overall urban-rural variation compared to about one third for wage differences. Differences in procedure intensity for basically similar patients explained another 25-50% of the urban-rural difference depending on illness. Evidence was also found for systematic cost and procedure differences between core city versus suburban hospitals. If the urban-rural rate differential were eliminated, the impact on urban hospitals could have major effects on the intensive way in which physicians treat patients. Whether this would have demonstrable outcome effects is unknown, but initial severity differences alone do not justify the observed procedural differences.

Aged↗

Hospital response to DRG refinements: the impact of multiple reimbursement incentives on inpatient length of stay.

Recent research has warned that the introduction of Diagnosis Related Groups (DRGs) based on hospital treatment decisions will lead to an increase in the rate of marginal procedures and to a resumption of high medical expenditure growth rates. This paper explores the often contradictory effects of the multiple reimbursement incentives created by refinements to the Prospective Payment System (PPS) (principally, the introduction of procedure-based DRGs) on hospital resource allocation. Three effects are examined in the paper: (i) the change in primary or payment-related procedures owing to marginal reimbursement incentives; (ii) the change in secondary or non-payment-related services owing to average price incentives; and (iii) the change in average severity of both medical and surgical admissions. The model suggests that the anticipated positive effect of marginal reimbursement incentives on overall hospital resource use may be offset by several factors, most notably the lower average payment incentives of non-procedural DRGs.

Diagnosis-Related Groups↗

Should Medicare compensate hospitals for administratively necessary days?

Days that a patient remains in a hospital due to inability to secure nursing home placement are termed administratively necessary days (ANDs). Some hospitals under Medicare's prospective payment system have incurred discharge delays of this kind. Nursing home bed supply is one major problematic factor; others include adequacy of Medicare nursing home reimbursement rates relative to nursing home costs in an area, the willingness of facilities in an area to serve those needing skilled care, and stringency of relevant Medicaid reimbursement policy. Two promising approaches for dealing with ANDs are increasing nursing home reimbursement rates, and adjusting Medicare payments for exceptionally long-staying patients or those requiring exceptionally intensive care in hospitals.

Aged↗

Estimating the hospital-wide cost differentials warranted for teaching hospitals. An alternative to regression approaches.

Under Medicare's Prospective Payment System, teaching hospitals receive additional reimbursements, vis-à-vis nonteaching hospitals, for both "direct" teaching expenses and for "indirect" expenses. They totaled $3.1 billion in fiscal year 1989. The authors propose and illustrate a non-regression-based, nonparametric method for viewing the total hospital-wide reimbursement differential warranted for teaching hospitals, a method utilizing a peer grouping of like hospitals to estimate two different "best practices" cost frontiers. The hospital's efficiently delivered cost to meet all of the hospital's actual service outputs, including its teaching mission, and delivered level of quality of care, is compared to the corresponding cost when only the teaching mission is excluded. The difference in these costs for a particular hospital can be used to estimate a suggested lump sum Medicare reimbursement add-on, in recognition of the hospital's teaching mission. The approach is illustrated using a subset of the Health Care Financing Administration's 1988 hospital data set, with comparisons of actual and suggested reimbursements provided.

Cost Allocation↗

Differences in quality of care for hospitalized elderly men and women.

OBJECTIVE: To analyze whether important gender differences exist in the quality of hospital care provided to patients with four major medical conditions. DESIGN: Bivariate and multivariate comparisons of clinically detailed sickness at admission, quality, utilization, and outcome measures. SETTING: Acute care hospitals located in five states. PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS: A total of 11,242 patients 65 years or older who were hospitalized with one of four diseases: congestive heart failure, acute myocardial infarction, pneumonia, and cerebrovascular accident. We derived our data from the nationally representative sample used to study the quality of hospital care for Medicare patients before and after the implementation of the prospective payment system. A hierarchical (nested) cluster sampling design was used to draw disease-specific samples of patients hospitalized in 1981, 1982, 1985, or 1986 in one of 297 hospitals located in 30 areas within five states. INTERVENTIONS: This was an observational study. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Sickness at admission, process, use rates, length of stay, discharge status, discharge destination, and mortality. RESULTS: Sex differences in sickness at admission varied by disease. There was some evidence that women received worse process of care, but the difference was very small. We found many similarities in the process and outcomes of care for male and female patients. CONCLUSIONS: After controlling for sickness at admission, age, and other important covariates, the in-hospital experiences of elderly men and women showed greater similarities than differences. The concern that sex bias enters into clinical decision making during hospitalization is eased, although not entirely eliminated.

Aged↗

Impact of prospective payment and discharge location on the outcome of hip fracture.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the impact of prospective payment by diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) on length of stay in the hospital, ambulatory status, and level of post-hospital care needed for patients hospitalized with hip fracture. DESIGN: Retrospective chart review of a consecutive series of cases before and after the reference date of implementation of the prospective payment system (PPS). SETTING: Academic, tertiary-care hospital. PATIENTS/PARTICIPANTS: 181 patients 69 years of age or older admitted with International Classification of Diseases (ICD) or DRG codes for hip fracture. RESULTS: Length of stay was shorter by 1.37 days in the post-PPS era (p = 0.05). Poorer discharge ambulation was found in the post-PPS group (p = 0.089). At one year, differences in ambulation and nursing home residence were found to be related not to the implementation of PPS, but rather to the nursing home to which the patient was discharged. Patients discharged to a facility with active physical rehabilitation were less likely to remain institutionalized (p = 0.0025) than those in "ordinary" nursing homes and ambulated more independently (p = 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: The PPS did not have a significant long-term impact on hip fracture outcome. Post-hospital care may be of crucial importance to the future quality of life of hip fracture patients.

Aftercare↗

Measuring hospital input price increases: the rebased hospital market basket.

The input prices indexes used in part to set payment rates for Medicare inpatient hospital services in both prospective payment system (PPS) and PPS-excluded hospitals were rebased from 1982 to 1987 beginning with payments for fiscal year 1991. In this article, the issues and evidence used to determine the composition of the revised hospital input price indexes are discussed. One issue is the need for a separate market basket for PPS-excluded hospitals. Also, the payment implications of using hospital-industry versus economywide measures of wage rates as price proxies for the growth in hospital wage rates are addressed.

Abstracting and Indexing↗

Functional status outcomes in rehabilitation. Implications for prospective payment.

Previous studies have demonstrated that functional status is a significant predictor of resource utilization for rehabilitation patients. Before implementing a prospective payment system (PPS) for rehabilitation, it is important to first: 1) develop an underlying conceptual framework of rehabilitation resource use; and 2) understand how the role of functional status may vary by rehabilitation condition. In this study, a theoretical model of rehabilitation is presented that proposes relationships between patient and provider characteristics, rehabilitation treatment, costs, and clinical outcomes of rehabilitation. Also presented are regression analyses based on this model for a key outcome of rehabilitation, change in functional status, for nine rehabilitation conditions using variables that minimize adverse incentives by providers in selecting patients for admission to rehabilitation. The change-in-functional-status model explained the most variance for back injury, cardiopulmonary, and arthritis, and less variance for stroke, spinal cord injury, and neurologic impairment. The significant predictors of change in functional status varied by condition. Results support the use of functional status measurements in a PPS for rehabilitation services, the need to refine the measurement of functional status, and the use of condition-specific activities of daily living (ADL) items to include in summary indices.

Activities of Daily Living↗

Good quality care increases hospital profits under prospective payment.

This study shows that, contrary to popular belief, the prospective payment system discourages skimping on medically indicated care. The quality of care on a nationally representative sample of Medicare discharges underwent judgmental review using implicit criteria. The reviewing physicians identified hospitalizations that omitted medically indicated services and diagnoses overlooked because of this skimping. After deduction for the cost of the omitted services and probability of negative diagnostic tests, good quality care would have increased hospital profits a significant 7.9 percent. As the specificity of diagnosis and intensity of treatment increase, the DRG payment rises faster than the cost of providing medically indicated services.

Data Collection↗

How recalibration method, pricing, and coding affect DRG weights.

We compared diagnosis-related group (DRG) weights calculated using the hospital-specific relative-value (HSRV) methodology with those calculated using the standard methodology for each year from 1985 through 1989 and analyzed differences between the two methods in detail for 1989. We provide evidence suggesting that classification error and subsidies of higher weighted cases by lower weighted cases caused compression in the weights used for payment as late as the fifth year of the prospective payment system. However, later weights calculated by the standard method are not compressed because a statistical correlation between high markups and high case-mix indexes offsets the cross-subsidization. HSRV weights from the same files are compressed because this methodology is more sensitive to cross-subsidies. However, both sets of weights produce equally good estimates of hospital-level costs net of those expenses that are paid by outlier payments. The greater compression of the HSRV weights is counterbalanced by the fact that more high-weight cases qualify as outliers.

Costs and Cost Analysis↗

Toward an international case mix index for comparisons in OCED countries. Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development.

During the last 20 years, a number of studies have examined the effect of Diagnosis Related Group (DRG)-based health care prospective payment systems on the cost and quality of services. To examine these issues, it is necessary to control for variations in patient mix and the related resources needed by incorporating some form of a case mix index. As part of our ongoing research on comparative DRG-based health care payment systems, we develop a preliminary, international case mix index using the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) health care database. We illustrate the application of our case mix index and use it to devise a standardized cost per case and a standardized cost per day for several countries. We also provide some preliminary analysis of the data demonstrating the observable and predictable effects of DRG-based payments on case m ix index, length of stay,cost per day, and cost per case.

Benchmarking↗

Regulation, retrenchment--the DRG experience: problems from changing reimbursement practice.

A study of 227,771 discharge abstracts from one U.S. state's short-term, acute care hospitals compares changes in the inpatient market available to the oldest old Medicare patients (85 and older) with those less than 70 and those 70-84 between 1981, the last year when all hospitals were under cost-based reimbursement, and 1984, the first year in which all hospitals were under a prospective payment system based on diagnosis related groups (DRGs). All three populations experienced retrenchment in services as hospitals pursued practice changes to enhance revenue potential. An older, sicker client was admitted as hospitals implemented changes in admission patterns to avoid denial of reimbursement for an admission deemed inappropriate by the Peer Review Organization (PRO). Evidence demonstrates compression in service markets and retrenchment in services for less profitable DRGs and/or cohorts. Inpatient services were reduced the most for the oldest old population although this cohort was the sickest. Changes were observed in utilization of special care units, such as in coronary and intensive care units. Large increases in readmissions in all three cohorts suggests that DRG incentives to reduce length of hospital stay may have promoted premature discharge. Or, perhaps these readmissions resulted from 'unbundling', a practice of splitting patient problems into multiple admissions, as hospitals sought ways to enhance revenue instead of practicing cost-containment. Policy, perceived to be economically stringent, can affect hospital practice and produce undesired results with long-reaching untoward effects on certain segments of the population.

Aged↗

Prospective payment and the utilization of physical therapy service in the hospitalized elderly.

We studied the effect, in a university teaching hospital, of the prospective payment system (PPS) on utilization of physical therapy (PT), a non-reimbursable service; subjects were hospitalized patients aged 75 or older with non-PT-related diagnoses (myocardial infarction, pneumonia, congestive heart failure, and colectomy) and PT-related diagnoses (cerebrovascular accident and hip fracture). The proportion of patients referred for PT increased from 68 percent pre-PPS to 85 percent post-PPS for those with PT-related diagnoses and from 13 percent pre-PPS to 19 percent post-PPS for those with non-PT-related diagnoses. The mean number of sessions of PT decreased slightly for both groups: from 8.5 to 7.6 sessions for those with PT-related diagnoses and from 5.2 to 4.5 for those with non-PT-related diagnoses. In patients with PT-related diagnoses whose ambulatory status worsened during hospitalization, referrals for PT increased from 76 percent pre-PPS to 98 percent post-PPS. Referrals of comparable patients with non-PT-related diagnoses did not increase. Changes in provider education and efforts to reduce length of stay may account for these findings.

Aged↗

Effect of locale on health status and direct care time of rural versus urban home health patients.

OBJECTIVE: The study purpose was to determine if health status differed between rural versus urban home health patients and to identify if locale was a significant predictor of home health direct care time. BACKGROUND: Implemented in October 2000, the Medicare home health prospective payment system (PPS) made only temporary allowance for differences in cost of delivering home health services in rural versus urban environments. However, past research documented differences in health status and service utilization between rural and urban home health patients. METHODS: Data were collected retrospectively on a convenience sample of 2,788 patient episodes of care. Patient health status was measured using items form the Outcome Assessment and Information Set (OASIS). Obtained from itinerary records, direct care time was the time clinicians spent in the home. RESULTS: The results showed significant differences in rural versus urban patients health status, with urban patients being healthier than rural patients. Consistent with poorer health status, rural patients received more RN direct care time. Other study factors being equal, living in a rural locale increased total direct care time by 150 minutes over living in an urban environment. CONCLUSIONS: Given the poorer health status and increased time requirements for rural patients, the results support assertions that Medicare per episode reimbursement should be higher for rural than for urban home health patients.

Adult↗

Are PPS payments adequate? Issues for updating and assessing rates.

Declining operating margins under Medicare's prospective payment system (PPS) have focused attention on the adequacy of payment rates. The question of whether annual updates to the rates have been too low or cost increases too high has become important. In this article we discuss issues relevant to updating PPS rates and judging their adequacy. We describe a modification to the current framework for recommending annual update factors. This framework is then used to retrospectively assess PPS payment and cost growth since 1985. The preliminary results suggest that current rates are more than adequate to support the cost of efficient care. Also discussed are why using financial margins to evaluate rates is problematic and alternative methods that might be employed.

Diagnosis-Related Groups↗

DRG "creep". Pitfalls and sanctions to avoid.

In 1983, with the advent of the Medicare prospective payment system, the physician's role became crucial in determining a hospital's reimbursement for treatment of a Medicare patient. The correct diagnosis-related group assignment depends upon the physician's accurate designation of the primary and secondary discharge diagnoses. Manipulation of this information can result in an inaccurate payment, and the physician is ultimately responsible for the misrepresentation. Physicians' recognition of the importance of their responsibility to designate complete and accurate diagnostic and procedural information can help avoid problems, including the potential for sanctions against physicians who unwittingly contribute to fraud and abuse.

Crime↗