Editorial: Assessing the quality of medical organization and management.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · PubMed Health
Explore indexed PubMed citations for clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health research. Read source abstracts and follow each citation to its original PubMed record.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Healthcare boards are entering a new era of heightened accountability, scrutiny, and reform. Sarbanes-Oxley legislation, Internal Revenue Service scrutiny, pressure from creditors and bond insurers, activist state attorneys general, media attention, and other forces have sharply increased awareness of the importance of governance and have also raised the bar on what is required of boards and what is considered best-practice governance performance. Yet good governance cannot be legislated. The structure, composition, and specific required functions of boards can be legislated or mandated, but the effective function of boards cannot. At the same time that governance faces this new era of accountability, it is also being bombarded with the legions of monumental challenges in the tumultuous healthcare field. Chief executive officers and their boards must be willing to recognize the challenges and risks to the field of governance in general and to their boards in particular. Furthermore, they must be willing to implement new strategies and approaches for successful governance, including becoming compliant with Sarbanes-Oxley requirements; conducting a comprehensive audit of the structure, function, composition, and culture of the board; and seeking board members from outside the community, among many others.
It is clear from the international literature that education and training can play a crucial role in improving the quality of mental health service delivery. In the UK, post-qualification mental health education and training is not generally allied to the national policy agenda and there is a lack of service user and carer involvement in the design, development and delivery of educational curricula. The Department of Health in England has funded the development of a continuous quality improvement tool to address these important concerns and help commissioners of mental health education and training evaluate key aspects of courses. The design of the tool was informed by the literature and a series of semi-structured interviews and focus groups with key stakeholders. Subsequent drafts were refined through steering group consultation and the instrument was then piloted within a selected region in England. This has resulted in a brief, user-friendly tool that takes into account the views of all stakeholders in mental health education programmes, promotes dialogue and facilitates continuous quality improvement. The tool promotes self-assessment of: partnership arrangements; the relevance of the programme to the policy context; the extent to which service users and carers are involved in the design, delivery and evaluation of programmes; and the assessment of the impact of the programme. Results from the initial implementation project (to be reported separately) suggest that the tool is welcomed and can complement existing quality mechanisms.
Educating staff, performing billing audits, and appealing claim denials can help agencies ensure compliance with Medicare regulations and prevent loss of revenue. By preparing in advance, agencies ensure a smoother ride through (what are quite often) turbulent investigations.
Political and professional attitudes in the United Kingdom are now increasingly supportive of systematic quality assurance, particularly in the acute sector. This paper describes general progress towards organisational audit or accreditation of hospitals and outlines the structure, process and findings of two developing programmes--one based at the King's Fund Centre in London, the other in the South Western Region in Bristol.
The poor state of some hospital mattresses has been associated with the formation of pressure sores and the spread of infection. Nurses need to be aware of potential problems with old, faulty or poor-quality mattresses. Mattresses must be checked regularly.
Therapeutic drug monitoring services were investigated in a questionnaire sent to all subscribers to the United Kingdom National External Quality Assessment Scheme for Therapeutic Drug Assays. Questions were posed on assay availability and use, target ranges, and reporting procedures for digoxin, lithium, phenytoin, phenobarbitone, carbamazepine, theophylline, and valproic acid. One hundred fifty-seven laboratories replied and, except for lithium, 45% reported in mass units, 34% in molar units, and 22% a mixture of mass and molar units. Target ranges for lithium, digoxin, carbamazepine, and phenobarbitone were highly variable but ranges for phenytoin, theophylline, and valproic acid were more consistent. Immunoassay was the most popular methodology although high-performance liquid chromatography was commonly used for anticonvulsants. Paper copies of results were provided by 93% of laboratories, 40% reported by telephone, 12% by fax, and 28% by computer. Additional data, mainly dose, time of last dose, and duration of therapy were requested by 55% to 67% of laboratories. Grades of staff authorizing results ranged from nurses to senior consultants, and collaboration with pharmacists occurred in 26% of laboratories. Most laboratories provided a daily analytical service and 73% offered a 24-hour emergency service. This audit unexpectedly identified use of a wide range of target concentrations, particularly for digoxin and lithium.
Describes the clinical audit forum of anaesthetists in North Tees NHS Trust with particular reference to patients' peri-operative experience. Shows that a designated waiting room in theatre has improved the effectiveness and efficiency of the service provided.
A novel design for a solid waste audit was developed and applied to the University of British Columbia, Canada, in 1998. This audit was designed to determine the characteristics of the residual solid waste generated by the campus and provide directions for waste reduction. The methodology was constructed to address complications in solid waste sampling, including spatial and temporal variation in waste, extrapolation from the study area, and study validation. Accounting for spatial effects decreased the variation in calculating total waste loads. Additionally, collecting information on user flow provided a means to decrease daily variation in solid waste and allow extrapolation over time and space. The total annual waste estimated from the experimental design was compared to documented values and was found to differ by -18%. The majority of this discrepancy was likely attributable to the unauthorised disposal of construction and demolition waste. Several options were proposed to address waste minimisation goals. These included: enhancing the current recycling program, source reduction of plastic materials, and/or diverting organic material to composting (maximum diversion: approximately 320, approximately 270, and approximately 1510 t yr(-1), respectively). The greatest diversion by weight would be accomplished through the diversion of organic material, as it was estimated to comprise 70% of the projected waste stream. The audit methodology designed is most appropriate for facilities/regions that have a separate collection system for seasonal wastes and have a means for tracking user flow.
A proactive approach will help avoid Medicare claims denials related to medical necessity requirements. Providers should familiarize themselves with applicable local medical review policies. A self-audit should target areas where the most money is lost to medical necessity denials. Educational tools and a letter that highlights the provider's approach to medical necessity can encourage physicians to comply with Medicare requirements when providing a diagnosis.
Over the past three years, those who work in HIV prevention have come under increased political scrutiny. HIV-prevention programs first came under fire in the fall of 2001 from the Office of Inspector General and later the Department of Health and Human Services.
Seven enterprises that have had recent Cleaner Production (CP) audits in Beijing were interviewed to identify whether these enterprises implemented the audit recommendations. If enterprises did implement the recommendations, their reasons and the results were analyzed. Finally, some suggestions on how to promote enterprise-wide CP were given.
A four-part study assessing cleanliness in up to 113 environmental surfaces in an operating theatre and a hospital ward is reported. Surfaces were assessed visually, using microbiological methods and ATP bioluminescence. Results from a preliminary random survey indicated variability in cleanliness. These results were then used to select sites for monitoring before and after routine cleaning, over a 14-day period. Using published microbiological and ATP specifications 70 and 76% of these sites were unacceptable after cleaning. Visual assessment was a poor indicator of cleaning efficacy with only 18% considered unacceptable. Sites most likely to fail in the ward were in the toilet and kitchen, areas which are frequently implicated in the spread of infectious intestinal disease. Operating theatre sites had lower ATP results but 61% of sites would be considered unacceptable. There was no significant difference in general microbiological or ATP results overall before and after routine cleaning. Although some important hand contact sites showed no significant difference, overall there was a significant decrease in staphylococcal and enterobacteria counts in the ward but not in the operating theatre after cleaning. The routine cleaning programmes used did not include a biocide and cleaning using a hypochlorite based sanitizer gave much lower values. The results are discussed in relation to infection control, cleaning audits and cleaning schedules: an integrated cleaning monitoring programme using ATP bioluminescence in conjunction with visual and microbiological assessments is recommended.
Although medical and nursing audit is attaining a high profile in UK hospitals, the development of objective measures remains a challenge. The availability and storage or urinary catheters was recorded by a point prevalence survey in a District General Hospital. A "long-term" and "short-term" catheter were provided in all areas, but seven further brands of catheter were found. Female length catheters were rarely available. With some limited exceptions there were no written or verbal policies concerning selection of catheters in the wards. Excess numbers of catheters were stored by wards responsible for their own ordering. Damage of catheters during storage was noted. The survey provided a simple, rapid and inexpensive method of audit to rationalise and improve the provision of catheters. The implementation of a policy incorporating the selection, ordering, storage and use of such equipment will both optimise patient care and maximise efficient budgeting.
This is the second in a series of three articles regarding steel can recycling from foodservice operations of healthcare facilities. This article highlights the basic methods of recycling steel cans, and includes information on conducting a waste audit and negotiating with a hauler regarding the benefits of recycling. The previous article discussed how steel is recycled across the country. The next article will convey a case history of actual foodservice recycling practice from a healthcare facility.
Auditing a gamma radiography program is required as part of the authorizing license. Checklists and cursory reviews are the typical approach to addressing program requirements. A more proactive approach is recommended. The audit program described was prepared for a specific set of operating conditions but can be applied to any given program. Improvements in the effectiveness of the radiography safety program can be made with additional examination and emphasis on direct observation of licensed activities.
OBJECTIVE: To identify patients receiving albumin, develop guidelines for albumin use, and examine distribution and billing procedures. DESIGN: Case series. SETTING: Tertiary care center. PATIENTS: All patients received albumin in a four-week period. Patients were identified concurrently using intensive care unit surveys and the pharmacy computer system, and retrospectively using billing statements. Data were analyzed from 73 of 79 patients (92.4 percent); 6 (7.6 percent) had no record of albumin being ordered or administered. Pediatric patient data were used only in the financial calculations. DATA COLLECTION: Demographics and albumin dosages were recorded for all patients. Prescribing service and indications for use were recorded in adults. Albumin administered was compared with the amount billed to each patient. MAIN RESULTS: Sixty adult patients aged 14-91 y (median 62) received 1-69 units (median 4 units [1 unit = 12.5 g albumin]) and 470 total units. Surgical services prescribed albumin in 73 percent and medical services in 27 percent of the patients. Common indications for albumin included volume expansion (65 percent), as intraoperative fluid (13 percent), and to increase urine output (10 percent). The pharmacy computer system identified 63 percent of the patients. Of these, 13 percent were not billed for albumin they received. Examinations of patient billing statements found that up to $17,740 a year (15 percent) of albumin administered is not billed. The floor-stock distribution system used in the intensive care units contributed to most errors. CONCLUSIONS: Recommendations addressing the problems identified in this audit were made to the pharmacy, medical, nursing, and billing departments. Guidelines for albumin use were formulated and approved by the hospital's pharmacy and therapeutics committee.
OBJECTIVE: Assess the quality of information contained in the medical files of patients with cancer pathology. PATIENTS AND METHODS: Eighty medical files from patients cared for in the cancerology units of the Lyons civil hospices were retrospectively analyzed to determine information quality. Prior to the audit, the health care teams established a set of consensus standards to compared with observed procedures. After data collection and analysis of the results, observed departures from the standards led to propositions for guidelines designed to improve points where significant deviations were observed. RESULTS: For certain items, the medical files did not always contain the expected data. Significant deviations were observed for important data such as postal code of birth, pTNM classification, presence of pathology report, codified evaluation of general status. CONCLUSION: Management of these patients requires more rigorous record keeping and classing of appropriate data. A unique data sheet is proposed for all cancer. This should be a computerized sheet with a cancerology reference in each medical unit.