PubMed1995
It has been reported that up to half of renal stones and associated urine specimens have been positive on culture, and that up to 50% of such stones contain magnesium ammonium phosphate. In a prospective study using infrared and wet chemical analysis, we found positive cultures in only 7 of 132 renal, 5 of 105 ureteral and 6 of 21 bladder stones obtained surgically and handled with sterility. Of the culture positive calculi only 43% from the kidney, none from the ureter and 50% from the bladder contained detectable magnesium ammonium phosphate. However, magnesium ammonium phosphate was detectable in 20% of renal, 2% of ureteral and 27% of bladder stones with negative cultures. Of the culture positive renal and ureteral calculi 42% were predominantly calcium phosphate and 17% were predominantly calcium oxalate. For culture negative stones 25% and 51% from the kidney, and 15% and 82% from the ureter were composed of predominantly calcium phosphate and calcium oxalate, respectively. Among the culture positive stones, related positive urine cultures were noted in 100% of the renal, 20% of the ureteral and 50% of the bladder cases, compared to 26%, 10% and 27%, respectively, of culture negative calculi. The same organism was found in the stone and urine in only 38% of the cases. The lower frequency of positive urine cultures, of stones with magnesium ammonium phosphate, and especially of culture positive renal and ureteral stones (5%) than in previous reports suggests that stone culture may be of less value than indicated previously, except for bladder calculi and large renal stones, such as the branched type.