PubMed Health⌕ Search

SEARCH · PubMed Health

Results for “Guidelines”

Explore indexed PubMed citations for clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health research. Read source abstracts and follow each citation to its original PubMed record.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,549 records · Page 86Linked to original sources

The implications of practice guidelines for physician medical malpractice liability.

Medical practice guidelines are increasingly coming into use, and as more and more physicians are presented with guidelines to follow in the delivery of health care, the question arises of whether these guidelines will become instruments for imposing greater medical malpractice liability on physicians. This column will briefly describe what guidelines are, how they are developed, and how they have been and may be used in litigation against physicians, hospitals, and other health care institutions. As hospitals and managed care organizations continue to implement guidelines, the role these guidelines play in malpractice cases can be expected to increase. It appears, however, that, although guidelines will contribute to the establishment of the standard of care by which a physician's actions will be measured, they are not likely to become the standard that all physician treatment decisions must meet.

Hospitals↗

Automating clinical practice guidelines: a corporate-academic partnership.

Implementation of guidelines offers one of the largest opportunities for quality improvement, utilization review, and cost control for the health-care enterprise. If guidelines could be implemented on a large scale, their adoption could result in $100 billion in annual savings as well as improve the quality of patient care. However, infrastructural barriers impede progress. Collaboration between the Laboratory Medicine Health Services Program at the University of Alabama at Birmingham, Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center, and the Cerner Corporation, funded by the National Institute of Standards and Technology as part of the Advanced Technology Program involving ¿Information Infrastructure for Healthcare,¿ is focused on developing and delivering: 1) methods for creating operational forms of guidelines; 2) an effective computer-based architecture for implementing guidelines in clinical practice; 3) methods for packaging guidelines for wide distribution; 4) methods for testing the efficacy, safety, and acceptability of guidelines; and 5) a model for collecting, aggregating, and normalizing data from disparate systems. This hypothesis-driven research program is focused on laboratory medicine-based guidelines as a tool for developing, testing, and evaluating methods that can be implemented widely.

Academic Medical Centers↗

When push comes to shove: implementing VBAC practice guidelines.

The dramatic increase in U.S. cesarean sections over the past two decades has been significantly driven by repeat C-sections. In response to this trend, clinical guidelines recommending vaginal birth after cesarean-section (VBAC) have been promulgated by national organizations. Adherence to these guidelines would reduce the number of repeat C-sections, lower the overall C-section rate, and improve both the quality and the cost of health care. While these guidelines have received professional endorsement, their implementation has been clouded by issues of patient acceptance and provider payment. To examine implementation of these guidelines by health care organizations, the authors surveyed 156 members of the American College of Physician Executives to determine their policies, practices, and attitudes toward VBAC guidelines. Those surveyed generally were medical directors in HMOs, hospitals, and other practice settings. The findings indicate that the health care organizations represented by these physician executives have not consistently implemented VBAC guideline and that they are reluctant to hold physicians, their patients, or hospitals accountable for the financial, utilization, and quality impact of the elective decision ot to pursue appropriate VBACs. We conclude that, even when widely accepted, clinical practice guidelines may be ineffective in reducing the costs or improving the quality of medical care.

Attitude of Health Personnel↗

Successful implementation of an evidence-based clinical practice guideline: acute dysuria/urgency in adult women.

This paper describes the development and successful implementation of an evidence-based clinical practice guideline dealing with uncomplicated urinary tract infection in adult women (acute dysuria guideline). This guideline was based on an evaluation and synthesis of the medical literature using the best available evidence. Following guideline implementation, clinical practice changes recommended by the guideline were observed, including a significant decrease in laboratory testing and clinic visits for acute dysuria. Successful implementation of this guideline is attributed to the use of an explicit, evidence-based guideline development process, a combination of implementation strategies including decision support for providers, and a change in the roles of registered nurses.

Acute Disease↗

[Regional implementation of guidelines as a lesson for cancer centers].

43 German Comprehensive Cancer Centers (CCC) are gathered together in a cooperative group (Arbeitsgemeinschaft Deutscher Tumorzentren e.V. = ADT). The main task of these centers is the development of interdisciplinary structures which ensure provision of the optimum facilities of diagnostic procedures, treatment modalities and follow-up management for every patient in all regions of Germany. To realize these efforts, the CCC have to establish expert groups dealing with definite tumor entities and establishing guidelines, which have to be propagated in the respective regions. The experts are responsible for the spreading of relevant information which has to be actualized periodically. The basis of this information system can be the guidelines which are developed together with the German Cancer Society (Deutsche Krebsgesellschaft e.V. = DKG). However, in some cases, the CCC have a longstanding tradition with the elaboration and use of their own guidelines. Yet, these regional guidelines should be in very close congruency with the overlaying national guidelines. Deviations from these general rules have to be explained by the citation of reliable literature from peer reviewed journals. All guidelines must be worked out sticking to the rules of "Evidence Based Medicine" (EBM). An inquiry launched by the ADT revealed different needs in several CCC for further establishment of interdisciplinary expert panels and guidelines.

Cancer Care Facilities↗

[Follow-up after melanoma resection is more extensive than recommended in the practice guidelines, primarily for reassurance of the patient].

OBJECTIVE: To determine to what extent the follow-up after resection of melanoma in practice corresponds to the relevant guidelines in the first revised version of the consensus 'Melanoma of the skin'. DESIGN: Descriptive, retrospective. METHOD: For 67 patients, who had a melanoma resected in September 1993-April 1995 in the Academic Hospital, Vrije Universiteit, Amsterdam, the Netherlands, data were collected in May-August 1997 on the first two years of follow-up from the medical records (n = 42) and through communication in writing with the referring physicians and the physicians involved in the follow-up in other hospitals in the Netherlands (n = 25). The frequency of physical examination and routine diagnostics by the doctor was evaluated. To gain insight into the reasons why in some cases the guidelines were not followed, we set up an inquiry among the 20 doctors involved in the follow-up in August 1998. RESULTS: The mean frequency of outpatient visits and physical examinations was 3-4 times per year, practically consistent with the guideline. Routine blood testing was performed in 17 patients (25%) and diagnostic imaging (X-ray or CT scan of the chest, ultrasonography of the liver) in 51 patients (76%) in deviation from the guideline. Non-compliance with the guideline could not be explained by unfamiliarity with the consensus, disagreement with the contents or existence of local protocols. Extra diagnostics were mostly meant to reassure patients. No metastases or recurrences were encountered during routine follow-up examinations, but some were found (in 8 patients) at interim visits to the outpatient clinic. CONCLUSION: The national guidelines regarding diagnostic tests in the follow-up of melanoma patients are insufficiently followed. Because redundant routine diagnostics probably have more disadvantages than benefits, a more active implementation of (future) guidelines appears necessary.

Biopsy↗

Treatment in Kenyan rural health facilities: projected drug costs using the WHO-UNICEF integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) guidelines.

Guidelines for the integrated management of childhood illness (IMCI) in peripheral health facilities have been developed by WHO and UNICEF to improve the recognition and treatment of common causes of childhood death. To evaluate the impact of the guidelines on treatment costs, we compared the cost of drugs actually prescribed to a sample of 747 sick children aged 2-59 months in rural health facilities in western Kenya with the cost of drugs had the children been managed using the IMCI guidelines. The average cost of drugs actually prescribed per child was US$ 0.44 (1996 US$). Antibiotics were the most costly component, with phenoxymethylpenicillin syrup accounting for 59% of the cost of all the drugs prescribed. Of the 295 prescriptions for phenoxymethylpenicillin syrup, 223 (76%) were for treatment of colds or cough. The cost of drugs that would have been prescribed had the same children been managed with the IMCI guidelines ranged from US$ 0.16 per patient (based on a formulary of larger-dose tablets and a home remedy for cough) to US$ 0.39 per patient (based on a formulary of syrups or paediatric-dose tablets and a commercial cough preparation). Treatment of coughs and colds with antibiotics is not recommended in the Kenyan or in the IMCI guidelines. Compliance with existing treatment guidelines for the management of acute respiratory infections would have halved the cost of the drugs prescribed. The estimated cost of the drugs needed to treat children using the IMCI guidelines was less than the cost of the drugs actually prescribed, but varied considerably depending on the dosage forms and whether a commercial cough preparation was used.

Child Health Services↗

A structured record to implement the national guidelines for diabetes and hypertension care.

BACKGROUND: Guidelines to improve standards of care for hypertension and diabetes were disseminated by the National Department of Health in 1996 but have generally not been implemented by health professional in local primary care. A strategy for the adoption and implementation of the Guidelines was developed in collaboration with health professionals in primary care. OBJECTIVES: The development of a structured record, with prompts for the management of diabetes and hypertension according to the Guidelines. SETTING: Three community health centres (CHCs) in the Western Cape. PARTICIPANTS: Doctors and nurses managing patients with diabetes and hypertension. METHODS: A draft of the structured record was developed at a single-pilot CHC in the Western Cape. Focus group discussions established the core requirements for a structured record. Process, result and structural indicators in line with the national Guidelines were considered for inclusion in the draft record. This draft record was then piloted at two other CHCs. Comments from semi-structured interviews and pre- and post-test evaluation questionnaires were used to compile the final instrument. RESULTS: Eleven doctors and 8 nurses participated in the development of the final instrument. Important considerations in the design were a single-page, user-friendly format, tick-boxes to reduce writing, prompts, provision for sequential recording, target setting, and compatibility with the Guidelines. The final instrument was piloted and elicited a favourable overall response. CONCLUSION: The structured record simplifies the application of the Guidelines and the systematic recording of processes of care. The effectiveness of the Guidelines will be evaluated further in a randomised control trial using the structured record.

Diabetes Mellitus↗

[Methodological standards of the evidence-based approach of clinical guidelines development in Germany. Consensus between the scientific community, self-governed bodies and practice].

The most appropriate method of clinical guidelines development has been the subject of controversial debates in Germany during the last few years. The German Guidelines Clearinghouse at the Society for Quality in Medicine (Cologne) provided a discussion forum where clinicians, methodologists, the Association of the Scientific Medical Societies, and the corporate self-governed bodies (the health insurances, physicians' associations, and the hospital associations) agreed on the most important methods of an evidence-based approach for guidelines development. It was generally agreed that rigorous methodological standards should be followed to ensure both the scientific quality and the consensus quality in the development or revision of clinical practice guidelines. The agreement draws on the following topics: Scientifically valid guidelines: (1) are based on a comprehensive and systematic review of the best available evidence, (2) derive the recommendations from the best available evidence, and (3) demonstrate explicitly how the recommendations are linked to the evidence. The quality of consensus is ensured through (1) the participation of all relevant stakeholders in the guideline panel and (2) the application of formal consensus development methods. This type of an "evidence-based consensus guideline" is assumed to possess the highest level of scientific and political legitimacy.

Evidence-Based Medicine↗

Guideline classification to assist modeling, authoring, implementation and retrieval.

The National Guideline Clearinghouse (NGC) and its guideline classification system are significant contributions to the study of clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) and their incorporation into routine clinical care. The NGC classification system is primarily designed to support guideline retrieval. We believe that a guideline classification system should also support identification of features that relate to incorporation of executable CPGs into computer-based applications for sharing and delivering guideline-based advice. We have developed a proposed expansion of the NGC guideline classification for this purpose. The axes of the proposed scheme have implications for designing formal models and structures for representing and authoring CPGs. This scheme also has implications for future research.

Classification↗

Conceptual integration of guidelines and workflow into the electronic health record.

Even though computerized practice guidelines and workflow management (WfM) are proven effective techniques to improving quality of care and reducing costs, they are not widely deployed today. One reason for this is the impedance mismatch between guideline systems and electronic heath record (EHR) systems. This paper presents the Unified Service Action Model (USAM) that has been developed for the HL7 Reference Information Model and that conceptually integrates guidelines and workflow management into the EHR. We argue that the information items recorded in the EHR are logically similar to guideline and WfM definition. Therefore, guidelines and EHR reuse the same information structure in the USAM. This reuse is possible through a technique borrowed from natural language grammar and modal logic. The conceptual alignment of guidelines, WfM and the EHR could facilitate the sharing and deployment of guidelines in routine health care.

Efficiency↗

Neonatal skin care: clinical outcomes of the AWHONN/NANN evidence-based clinical practice guideline. Association of Women's Health, Obstetric and Neonatal Nurses and the National Association of Neonatal Nurses.

OBJECTIVE: To test the effectiveness of an evidence-based clinical practice guideline for neonatal skin care on selected clinical outcomes for newborns in neonatal intensive-care units (NICU), special-care units (SCU), and well-baby nurseries. DESIGN: Prospective evaluation of the collaborative neonatal skin care research-based practice project of the Association of Women's Health, Obstetric and Neonatal Nurses and the National Association of Neonatal Nurses. SETTING: NICU and well-baby units in 51 hospitals located throughout the United States. PARTICIPANTS: Member site coordinators (N = 51) and the neonates (N= 2,820) observed during both the pre- and postimplementation phases of the project. METHOD: Site coordinators received specialized education in neonatal skin care and implemented an evidence-based clinical practice guideline addressing 10 aspects of neonatal skin care. Baseline observations of skin condition, care practices, and environment of newly admitted neonates were collected by site coordinators. Postimplementation observations were then completed. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Skin condition was assessed with the Neonatal Skin Condition Score (NSCS), which ranges from a score of three (best condition) to a score of nine (worst condition), based on dryness, erythema, and skin breakdown. Changes in frequency of selected skin care practices were used to assess the effectiveness and feasibility of using the practice guideline in everyday clinical practice. Aspects of the care environment with potential effect on skin integrity were monitored to determine risk factors. RESULTS: Fifty-one site coordinators made 11,468 systematic assessments of 2,464 NICU and SCU newborns and 356 well newborns. Baseline skin scores were better in well newborns compared with premature newborns. After implementation of the guideline, skin condition was improved, as reflected by less visible dryness, redness, and skin breakdown in both the NICU/SCU and well newborns. The guideline was integrated into care, as evidenced by increased use of emollients, particularly with premature infants, and decreased frequency of bathing. A relationship was shown between selected aspects of the environment and alterations in skin integrity. CONCLUSIONS: Use of the AWHONN/NANN Neonatal Skin Care Research-Based Clinical Practice Guideline was successfully implemented at 51 sites, and effectiveness was demonstrated by changed care practices and improved skin condition in premature and full-term newborns. The results of this project support a wider dissemination of the project's practice guideline for neonatal skin care.

Clinical Nursing Research↗

[The guideline for the treatment of mood disorders in USA and Japan].

Recently, the number of available antidepressants has increased dramatically and psychopharmacological treatment is becoming complex. It is important to present some guideline for supporting clinical decision making. Three different kinds of guideline for the treatment of mood disorders, that is, the APA style guideline, the algorithm and the consensus guideline, have been developed in our country. The APA style guideline and the algorithm are basically evidence based and the consensus guideline is developed through the consensus panel format. These guidelines should be used as 'a starting point' for specifying decisions that will be modified occasionally.

Algorithms↗

Sharable computer-based clinical practice guidelines: rationale, obstacles, approaches, and prospects.

Clinical practice guideline automation at the point of care is of growing interest, yet most guidelines are authored in unstructured narrative form. Computer-based execution depends on a formal structured representation, and also faces a number of other challenges at all stages of the guideline lifecycle: modeling, authoring, dissemination, implementation, and update. This is because of the multiplicity of conceptual models, authoring tools, authoring approaches, intended applications, implementation platforms, and local interface requirements and operational constraints. Complexity and time required for development and structure are also huge obstacles. These factors argue for convergence on a common shared model for representation that can be the basis of dissemination. A common model would facilitate direct interpretation or mapping to multiple implementation environments. GLIF (GuideLine Interchange Format) is a formal representation model for guidelines, created by the InterMed Collaboratory as a proposed basis for a shared representation. GLIF currently addresses the process of authoring and dissemination; the InterMed team's major focus now is on tools to facilitate these tasks and the mapping to clinical information system environments. Because of limitations in what can be done by a single team with finite resources, however, and the variety of additional perspectives that need to be accommodated, the InterMed team has determined that further development of a shared representation would be best served as an open process in which the world community is engaged. Under the auspices of the HL7 Decision Support Technical Committee, a GLIF Special Interest Group has been established, which is intended to be a forum for collaborative refinement and extension of a standard representation that can support the needs of the guideline lifecycle. Significant areas for future work will need to include demonstrations of effective means for incorporating guide-lines at point of care, reconciliation of functional requirements of different models and identification of those most important for supporting practical implementation, im-proved means for authoring and management of complexity, and methods for automatically analyzing and validating syntax, semantics, and logical consistency of guidelines.

Artificial Intelligence↗

An approach to guideline implementation with GEM.

Implementation of practice guidelines refers to the creation of strategies and systems to operationalize the knowledge and recommendations set forth by guideline developers. We describe an approach to guideline implementation that makes direct use of the guideline document as a knowledge base. The Guideline Elements Model (GEM) provides an XML-based guideline document model that facilitates implementation of guidelines. Knowledge extraction using GEM requires document markup rather than programming and can promote authenticity and consistent knowledge encoding. Knowledge customization for the local enterprise requires addition of meta-information to pertinent components of the GEM hierarchy in a design database. GEM provides an audit trail to track local adaptation. Knowledge integration with patient data can be promoted using information management services. A design goal is to devise a system that can be applied by local clinical domain experts, quality assurance experts, and information systems programmers without requiring trained informaticians and knowledge engineers to serve as intermediaries

Artificial Intelligence↗

[Japanese guideline for treatment and management of childhood asthma and its originality].

Japanese guideline for treatment and management of childhood asthma was published in April, 2000. This is the Japan original guideline. The general and practical asthma treatment in Japan is described. We compared with this guideline and GINA. There is not a difference in the diagnosis and concept of bronchial asthma. This guideline for several Japan original therapies are described. The originality of this guideline is the early use of theophylline. There is not the entry of the use of oral steroid. There are many Japan original therapies such as the isoproterenol continuous inhalation therapy. Also, as for this guideline the education, vaccination and exercise of the patient are written in detail. We hope that this guideline is translated to English and be published.

Adolescent↗

An implementation framework for GEM encoded guidelines.

Access to timely decision support information is critical for delivery of high-quality medical care. Transformation of clinical knowledge that is originally expressed in the form of a guideline to a computable format is one of the main obstacles to the integration of knowledge sharing functionality into computerized clinical systems. The Guideline Element Model (GEM) provides a methodology for such a transformation. Although the model has been used to store heterogeneous guideline knowledge, it is important to demonstrate that GEM markup facilitates guideline implementation. This report demonstrates the feasibility of implementation of GEM-encoded guideline recommendations using Apache Group s Cocoon Web Publishing Framework. We further demonstrate how XML-based programming allows for maintaining the separation of guideline content from processing logic and from presentation format. Finally, we analyze whether the guideline authors original intent has been sufficiently captured and conveyed to the end user.

Artificial Intelligence↗

Rheumatologists' adherence to guidelines for misoprostol use in patients at high risk for nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug gastropathy.

OBJECTIVE: To determine the extent of evidence based practice among rheumatologists in the prevention of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drug (NSAID) associated peptic ulcer disease and to seek ways to improve the management of high risk NSAID users. METHODS: In March 1996 all 7 rheumatologists from Saskatoon participated in a consensus conference to develop local guidelines for the prophylaxis of NSAID associated peptic ulcer disease. We performed a retrospective chart review for September/October 1995 (baseline) and for June/July 1996 (post-consensus guideline) of all patients from Saskatoon rheumatologists who were being treated with NSAID for either rheumatoid arthritis (RA) or undifferentiated inflammatory polyarthritis (IP). A prospective crossover intervention study was performed from January to April 1997 in which 2 subgroups of rheumatologists (university or private practice) had a reminder sheet of gastrointestinal (GI) bleeding risk assessment placed into the front of each patient's chart prior to each office visit. The GI bleeding risk for each patient at time of visit was later determined by chart review. The primary outcome was the proportion of adherence to guidelines for high risk NSAID users in the combined intervention group (reminder sheet) compared to the combined control group (no reminder sheet) in the prospective controlled crossover study. RESULTS: A total of 484 patients with RA or IP received NSAID during the 4 study periods. Of these, 82 patients (16.9%) were at high risk of GI bleed. In 1995, the proportion of high risk patients taking misoprostol was 29% for university and 33% for private practice rheumatologists. The establishment of local consensus guidelines in 1996 temporarily increased adherence to guidelines to 43%, but only for private practice rheumatologists. During the prospective study, adherence to guidelines was significantly greater in the intervention (reminder sheets) group compared to the control (no reminder sheets) group (53% vs 15%; p = 0.014). CONCLUSION: The simple intervention of reminder sheets for GI bleeding risk assessment resulted in a significant increase in rheumatologists' adherence to guidelines, although a substantial number of patients remained untreated with misoprostol. This study illustrates the difficulty of incorporating new knowledge and recommendations into clinical practice. Additional strategies should be investigated to more effectively incorporate new knowledge in the practice of rheumatology.

Adolescent↗