PubMed Health⌕ Search

SEARCH · PubMed Health

Results for “Guidelines”

Explore indexed PubMed citations for clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health research. Read source abstracts and follow each citation to its original PubMed record.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,567 records · Page 87Linked to original sources

Peril of the pox. Are primary care providers aware of varicella vaccination guidelines?

PURPOSE: To determine whether physicians providing primary care in Ontario were aware of guidelines published by Health Canada's National Advisory Committee on Immunization (NACI), their opinions about the varicella vaccine, and factors that influence use of the vaccine. METHODS: A questionnaire examining awareness, knowledge, and perceived barriers to using varicella vaccine was developed and mailed to a random sample of 500 family physicians and 400 pediatricians practising in Ontario. RESULTS: To the 900 questionnaires mailed, 284 family physicians (56.9%) and 232 pediatricians (59.2%) responded. Fifty-six percent of family physicians and 95.4% of pediatricians providing primary care were aware of the Health Canada guidelines. Physicians who were aware of the Health Canada guidelines were more knowledgeable about the vaccine and were more likely to recommend it. Both groups of physicians identified cost (not covered by the government), problems with storage and handling, and concerns about long-term immunity as barriers to use of the vaccine. CONCLUSION: While awareness of the guidelines was associated with better knowledge of and following recommendations for the vaccine, Health Canada guidelines were not widely distributed to all primary care providers. One way to encourage incorporation of varicella vaccine guidelines into practice would be to improve dissemination of the guidelines to all primary care providers.

Adult↗

Awareness of hypertension guidelines in general practice: a pilot study in Lombardy.

BACKGROUND: An adequate knowledge of hypertension guidelines by primary care physicians is a fundamental step for the improvement of the diagnosis and treatment of hypertension in the general population. The aim of this study was to evaluate, in a local survey in the northern area of Lombardy, the general practitioners' knowledge of the WHO/ISH guidelines. METHODS: A 10-item mail questionnaire based on the 1999 WHO/ISH hypertension guidelines was sent to a sample of 280 primary care physicians. The number of answers in agreement with the guidelines was used as a measure of guidelines knowledge, that was considered adequate if a correct answer to 6 out of 10 questions, in addition to an adequate definition of hypertension, was provided. RESULTS: The analysis was based on 83 returned questionnaires, that means a 29% response rate. Guidelines knowledge was adequate in 23.5% of the total study population and the mean score of correct answers was 5.5 points. A significant negative correlation (r = 0.27, p < 0.05) was observed between the mean score of knowledge and the physician's age. CONCLUSIONS: In a sample of primary care physicians from a northern region of Italy, the hypertension guidelines knowledge is inadequate; the reasons and the extent of this poor awareness will require further studies.

Adult↗

[www.evidence.de--assessment and utilization of clinical guidelines by primary care physicians and internists].

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Compared to the generation of new scientific results, implementation and utilization of evidence based knowledge is lacking far behind. Strengths and weaknesses of evidence- and HTML-based guidelines were evaluated in an academic network of primary care physicians to better understand the expectations and information needs of GPs. METHODS: Standardized survey of 72 primary care physicians (21% female, 79% male) regarding three network based issues: "frequency of guideline use", "reasons to use/not to use guidelines", "evaluation and overall judgement of guidelines". RESULTS: 62.9% of participating had used net based guidelines at least once, the percentage of more frequent users (> 2 times in two months) was 40.3%. Curiosity and non-specific interest as well as a concrete medical question were the main reasons for utilization of guidelines. The overall judgement of the guidelines was positive, however, only a minority of participating physicians viewed them as a concrete help in daily practice. CONCLUSION: Transformation of new scientific medical knowledge into daily primary care practice is only insufficiently developed. Netbased instruments of continuing medical education may serve as catalysts and should be further developed as well as evaluated.

Family Practice↗

[Practice guidelines in dentistry. An insight into the Dutch situation].

Practice guidelines provide opportunities for monitoring and improving dental health care. A survey was conducted among 78 departments at dental societies, scientific dental associations and health care insurance companies in the Netherlands to obtain insight into the number and quality of practice guidelines available. The response rate was 67%. Written materials were analysed and 21 practice guidelines were identified as such. The results of the analysis indicate that many initiatives to construct and implement practice guidelines have been taken. However, these initiatives were insufficiently coordinated and existing guidelines may be subject to improvement. Main improvement would be to demonstrate the validity and reliability of the existing guidelines and, more in general, to provide a sound scientific basis to the development and implementation of practice guidelines.

Data Collection↗

Support for guideline development through error classification and constraint checking.

Clinical guidelines aim to eliminate clinician errors, reduce practice variation, and promote best medical practices. Computer-interpretable guidelines (CIGs) can deliver patient-specific advice during clinical encounters, which makes them more likely to affect clinician behavior than narrative guidelines. To reduce the number of errors that are introduced while developing narrative guidelines and CIGs, we studied the process used by the ACP-ASIM to develop clinical algorithms from narrative guidelines. We analyzed how changes progressed between subsequent versions of an algorithm and between a narrative guideline and its derived clinical algorithm. We recommend procedures that could limit the number of errors produced when generating clinical algorithms. In addition, we developed a tool for authoring CIGs in GLIF3 format and validating their syntax, data type matches, cardinality constraints, and structural integrity constraints. We used this tool to author guidelines and to check them for errors.

Algorithms↗

[Dutch Institute for Healthcare Improvement guideline, "Treatment of breast carcinoma": important document but an open attitude to new "evidence" is necessary].

In addition to the many international guidelines on the treatment of breast cancer, the Dutch Institute for Healthcare Improvement [Dutch acronym: CBO] has issued a Dutch national guideline on this subject, aided by representatives from the various medical professions involved and the patient advocacy group. A potential problem in reaching consensus on a practice guideline is the masking of controversies, which may hamper participation in new and innovative studies. Examples are the manner in which local and systemic treatments are combined and the consequences of new diagnostic modalities, for example the histopathologic presence of micrometastases in the sentinel node. The abridged version of the guideline published in this issue of the journal, scarcely allows space for specific problems such as the very young or old, pregnancy, hormonal substitution, male breast cancer and the patient with hereditary breast cancer. The authors of this guideline propose a nationwide registration of all patients plus follow-up to monitor the adherence to the guideline. The best way to study the quality of care and compliance with guidelines is still being debated in the medical literature. The money required for a nationwide registration of data on all patients including follow-up, might be better spent on measuring a number of indicators in a limited group of patients on the one hand and on devising new (randomised) trials on the other. This would result in the collection of better evidence for the many unanswered questions in the treatment of this common malignancy.

Breast Neoplasms↗

[Results of survey of adult community-acquired pneumonia utilizing flow chart of diagnostic guideline for management of respiratory infections].

We performed a nationwide survey of 1,258 patients to assess the treatment of community-acquired pneumonia in Japan. Cases were classified as bacterial pneumonia in which the causal organism was unknown (Type A) or presumed (Type B), atypical pneumonia (Type C), severe pneumonia (Type D), or pneumonia in certain specific morbid states (Type E). Our objectives were to assess the actual use of antimicrobials and to determine the usefulness of the "Guidelines on Respiratory Infections--Basic Concepts in the Medical Care of Community-Acquired Pneumonia in Adults", developed by the Guideline-Drafting Committee of the Japanese Respiratory Society (JRS), in differentiating these categories of patients. We also hoped to elicit constructive opinions that would contribute to future revisions of these guidelines. The findings showed that pneumonia was classified as "bacterial pneumonia in which the causal organism was unknown" in approximately half (50.2%) of the patients studied. The next most common classification was "severe pneumonia", followed by "atypical pneumonia", "bacterial pneumonia in which the causal organism was presumed", and "pneumonia in certain specific morbid states", in that order. Our results suggest that the JSR guidelines, including the methods for differentiating between bacterial pneumonia and atypical pneumonia, are useful and appropriate, and that antimicrobial agents were generally selected in accordance with the guidelines. We also identified a number of issues to be addressed in future updates of the guidelines, including criteria for physiological assessment, handling of cases in which physical findings and laboratory test results are not in agreement, age-related issues (especially the treatment of patients 65 years of age and older), the differentiation between bacterial pneumonia and atypical pneumonia, the weighing of underlying diseases and complications, and guidelines regarding the use of adjuvant therapy.

Adolescent↗

[Agreement between clinical practice guidelines for management of community-acquired pneumonia. A retrospective study of 101 hospitalized patients].

INTRODUCTION: Management guidelines for acute community acquired pneumonia vary considerably. The objective is to estimate by a retrospective study the uniformity of the recommendations for the management of patients and the choice of initial empirical antibiotic therapy. METHODS: Eight English and French language guidelines published between 1998 and 2001 were identified by a search of the literature. They were applied retrospectively to a sample of 101 patients admitted to a university hospital in 2000 with a diagnosis of pneumonia. RESULTS: Hospital admission was advocated for between 61% and 95% and admission to intensive care for between 8% and 35% of the patients, depending on the guidelines under consideration. The actual management conformed to that advocated for between 34% and 94% of the patients (kappa=0.27 [0,19; 0,34]). Compliance of the empirical antibiotic therapy (drug, dose, mode of administration) with the recommendations varied from 0% to 68% of the patients depending on the guidelines considered (kappa=0.01 [-0,10; 0,12]). CONCLUSIONS: The heterogeneity of the guidelines is manifest by important variations in the recommendations for management and initial empirical therapy. These differences are due, in part, to a paucity of evidence based data upon which to base the guidelines. It would appear essential to harmonise the guidelines in a way that is appropriate for the country of their intended use.

Acute Disease↗

Assessment of the possibility to classify patients according to cholesterol guideline screening criteria using routinely recorded electronic patient record data.

BACKGROUND: Computerised decision support systems (CDSS) can be categorised as either being inquisitive or non-inquisitive. The non-inquisitive system uses routinely entered electronic patient data, to generate patient specific feedback based on guidelines. The Dutch College of General Practitioners' (DCGP) cholesterol guideline classifies patients into risk groups, eligible for screening. The availability of sufficient routinely recorded electronic patient data to classify patients according to the DCGP cholesterol guideline is unknown. OBJECTIVE: To assess whether it is possible to classify patients according to the screening criteria of the DCGP cholesterol guideline, using data routinely recorded by general practitioners. METHODS: We analysed the DCGP cholesterol guideline to identify selection criteria for screening. These selection criteria were subsequently used to create a cohort of patient records eligible for screening in the Integrated Primary Care Information (IPCI) Database. We calculated incidence and prevalence of risk factors and selected patient records for active management according to the identified screening selection criteria. RESULTS: 145866 valid patient records were selected for classification. In the retrieved records 9741 (13.6%) males and 5756 (7.8%) females were identified for active management according to the selection criteria of the DCGP cholesterol guideline. CONCLUSION: The classification of patients into risk groups, eligible for screening, according to the criteria of the DCGP cholesterol guideline using routinely recorded electronic patient data is feasible. Care should be taken when using only diagnostic codes, as it gives higher than expected incidence and prevalence of risk factors. Based on these findings we are currently building Cholgate, a non-inquisitive decision support system for cholesterol management.

Adolescent↗

Current awareness in Canada of clinical practice guidelines for colorectal cancer screening.

INTRODUCTION: The Canadian Task Force on Preventive Health Care (CTF-PHC) recently revised its screening recommendations for colorectal cancer (CRC). We wished to assess the effect of this change on the screening beliefs and clinical practice of primary care physicians. METHODS: We surveyed 160 primary-care physicians, quasi-randomly sampled, in June-July 2001 and again in April-July 2002, 9 months after publication of the guidelines. Descriptive statistics and McNemar chi2 analyses were carried out on data from physicians who responded to both surveys. RESULTS: Of the those sampled, 47% responded to both surveys. After the publication of the CTF-PHC guidelines, the proportion reporting that they recommend CRC screening to their patients at average risk increased from 43% to 60% (p = 0.02). Before publication of the revised guidelines 48% stated that the CTF-PHC did not support screening, compared with 24% afterward (p = 0.01). CTF-PHC guidelines were acknowledged by 30% to be a source of CRC screening information. Around 9 months post-publication, 24% of the physicians stated their awareness of the revised screening guidelines. The most commonly cited reasons for not recommending CRC screening to average-risk patients were that the evidence is inconclusive and that CTF-PHC guidelines do not support screening. CONCLUSIONS: After publication of the revised CTF-PHC guidelines more primary-care physicians reported that they recommend CRC screening to their average-risk patients. The belief that the evidence is inconclusive nevertheless remains a considerable barrier to implementation. To increase the use of screening for CRC, additional strategies are required.

Adult↗

[Prophylactic antibiotics in urological surgery: compliance of prescriptions in Franche-Comté with national guidelines].

STUDY OBJECTIVE: To evaluate prophylactic antibiotic practices in urological surgery in Franche-Comté. MATERIAL AND METHODS: Six urological surgery teams participated in data collection. Practices were evaluated in comparison with national guidelines by means of five questions: Did the surgical operation justify prophylactic antibiotics and was this treatment administered? Was the antibiotic selected that recommended by national guidelines? Was the total duration appropriate? Was the time of the first injection appropriate? Was the dosage appropriate? The Société Française d'Anesthésie et de Réanimation (SFAR) guidelines, revised in 1999, constituted the reference. RESULTS: Of the 213 operations included in the study, 134 corresponded to Altemeier class 1 and 2 operations for which the SFAR has issued guidelines. The overall compliance rate was 22.6%. Among the 56 patients who did not receive the recommended molecule, 45 received a molecule with a broader spectrum of activity than that of the recommended molecule. The duration of prophylactic antibiotics was longer for 10 of the 11 patients in whom the duration of prophylaxis did not comply with guidelines. Finally, for more than one third of operations, the time of injection of the first dose was not optimal. CONCLUSION: This study demonstrated the high frequency of non-compliance with prophylactic antibiotic prescription guidelines in urological surgery in Franche-Comté. These guidelines must be reinforced and applied to ensure the efficacy of prophylactic antibiotics and to avoid the emergence of resistant strains.

Antibiotic Prophylaxis↗

[Present state of guidelines for perioperative management of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism in Japan].

To clarify the present state of local institutional guideline for perioperative deep thrombosis and pulmonary embolism in individual hospitals, a questionnaire was sent to anesthesia departments in Japan. According to the replies, 82 hospitals have original guidelines. Forty of them reported the contents of their guidelines. However, 37 hospitals have some problems regarding their guidelines. Cost for these perioperative managements and application of spinal or epidural anesthesia for heparinized patients appears to be commonly recognized as pending questions in their guideline. It seems to be difficult to make a stereotyped standard guideline in Japan because each local guideline has a specific strategy according to their situations. However, it is needless to say that a further nationwide survey and collaboration, and governmental support for these diseases would be required.

Anesthesia Department, Hospital↗

[The impact of guidelines, standards and economic restrictions on clinical decision-making processes].

Guidelines aim at improving clinical decision-making. Contrary to textbooks and reviews that want to improve medical knowledge, guidelines try to influence medical behaviour. Scientific models of clinical decision-making such as the action theory and empirical data on the effects of guidelines suggest that guidelines will not always reach their goals but can instead even lead to a deterioration in the quality of medical care. Therefore there is a need for controlled clinical trials to investigate whether guideline-exposed physicians yield better patient outcomes than guideline-naïve physicians. Guidelines should only be regarded as evidence-based if their positive effects have been empirically demonstrated.

Costs and Cost Analysis↗

[The practice guideline 'Hormonal contraception' (second revision) from the Dutch College of General Practitioners; a response from the perspective of obstetrics & gynaecology].

The Dutch College of General Practitioners' (NHG) guideline on hormonal contraception does not follow the WHO criteria for the use of oral contraceptives in contrast to the guideline of the Dutch Society of Obstetrics and Gynaecology. Contrary to the WHO criteria, the NHG guideline considers a blood-pressure measurement before starting with an oral contraceptive to be unnecessary. It also considers no form of migraine to be a contraindication for oral contraceptives. The NHG guideline further disclaims the (slightly) increased risk of developing breast cancer in women using oral contraceptives. It advises initiation of oral-contraceptive use two weeks postpartum in non-breastfeeding women and six weeks postpartum in breastfeeding women, instead of the three weeks and six months, respectively, indicated in the WHO guideline. Lastly, the NHG guideline is too optimistic as to the reliability of oral-contraceptive use, as no distinction is made between efficacy and effectiveness. Such discrepancies between two Dutch guidelines can be detrimental to women's health care. The WHO criteria for contraceptive use may be a valuable tool to overcome differences of opinion so as to achieve a badly needed full consensus.

Contraception↗

Toward improved guideline quality: using the COGS statement with GEM.

The Conference on Guideline Standardization (COGS) was convened to create a standardized documentation checklist for clinical practice guidelines in an effort to promote guideline quality and facilitate implementation. The statement was created by a multidisciplinary panel using a rigorous consensus development methodology. The Guideline Elements Model (GEM) provides a standardized approach to representing guideline documents using XML. In this work, we demonstrate the sufficiency of GEM for describing COGS components. Using the mapping between COGS and GEM elements we built an XSLT application to examine a guideline's adherence (or non-adherence) to the COGS checklist. Once a guideline has been marked up according to the GEM hierarchy, its knowledge content can be reused in multiple ways.

Congresses as Topic↗

Executing clinical practice guidelines using the SAGE execution engine.

We report the first successful test of an interoperable guideline execution engine that interprets encoded clinical guideline content and executes that content via functions of a target clinical information system (CIS). For this test, an exemplar immunization guideline was encoded in the SAGE guideline model using standards-based information models and terminologies. This guideline content was subsequently executed using the prototype SAGE guideline execution engine, which interacts through standards-based VMR/Action services to instantiate real-time guideline recommendations via existing functions of the target CIS. In this paper, we describe our test implementation and highlight the significance and implications of each component of our deployment architecture

Decision Making, Computer-Assisted↗

[The practice guideline 'Peripheral vascular disease' (first revision) from the Dutch College of General Practitioners: a response from the perspective of surgery].

The practice guideline 'Peripheral vascular disease' is well written and based on evidence-based principles. In comparison with the previous guideline considerable attention is given to secondary prevention. In this guideline general practitioners are more diffident about prescribing statins than vascular specialists. This is probably related to the fact that this guideline refers to another guideline of the College concerning the treatment of patients with high-cholesterol concentrations and not to recently-published large studies. The guideline advises making a distinction between intermittent claudication stage 2a and 2b. This is impractical as the choice of therapy depends on the subjective feelings of disability. Some controversy remains with respect to the detection of asymptomatic abdominal aneurysms: should there routinely be only physical examination or ultrasonographic screening as well? The guideline advises against routine ultrasonic screening, which is in line with the view held by the author of this commentary.

Anticholesteremic Agents↗

[A concept for the implementation and evaluation of the guideline "Early Detection of Breast Cancer in Germany"].

Systematically developed, evidence- and consensus-based guidelines are important tools for improving health care services. The effectiveness of a guideline does not only relate to its methodological quality but also to the implementation strategy used. The following paper describes the systematic development of a strategy for implementing and evaluating the guideline "Early Detection of Breast Cancer in Germany" as part of a national project. A multi-faceted systematic implementation strategy has been developed addressing existing barriers and building on projects that have recently been introduced in Germany to improve the early detection and management of breast cancer. The aim is to induce behavioural changes in women as healthcare recipients and physicians as healthcare providers, both involved in the medical decision-making process within the scope of the guideline. Furthermore, it supports organisational changes to assure compliance with the guideline by means of quality assurance and quality management. To ensure evaluation of the implementation process a set of quality indicators have been identified for the baseline assessment of structures, provider performance and outcomes. Both the effectiveness of the implementation process and the effectiveness of the guideline itself will be measured by using the same set of indicators for reevaluation within a pre-defined time interval of 18 months. The quasi-experimental design of this uncontrolled before and after implementation study outlined in the present paper allows the assessment of clinically relevant changes using quality indicators that measure the effectiveness of the guideline on a national level.

Breast Neoplasms↗