PubMed Health⌕ Search

SEARCH · PubMed Health

Results for “Guidelines”

Explore indexed PubMed citations for clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health research. Read source abstracts and follow each citation to its original PubMed record.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 1,585 records · Page 88Linked to original sources

Provider attitudes and beliefs about clinical practice guidelines.

The goals of clinical practice guidelines (CPG) are to improve the process and outcomes of health care, decrease practice variation, and optimize resource utilization. The objectives of this study were to (a) describe overall provider attitudes and beliefs about CPG, and (b) describe provider attitudes and acceptance of two specific spinal cord injury (SCI) CPG. A total of 152 health care providers responsible for implementation of the CPG at participating Veterans Health Administration (VHA) SCI sites responded to a survey (response rate of 35%). Overall, SCI care providers expressed positive attitudes towards CPG, including the two SCI guidelines included in this study. A comparison of responses revealed relatively few areas in which differences existed among SCI facilities and provider groups. Nurses represented the largest provider group participating in this survey and consistently expressed the most positive responses. In particular, nurses were more positive about guidelines, recognized the benefits of the guidelines, and were more willing to support the development of guidelines, compared to other providers in the study. The results of this study suggest that negative attitudes and beliefs about guidelines might be less of an obstacle to guideline implementation in VHA SCI Centers. Nurses are in a position to play a key role in their implementation.

Adult↗

[Postoperative pulmonary thromboembolism and its prevention from the perspective of the establishment of Japanese guidelines].

The incidence of venous thromboembolism (VTE) is rapidly increasing in Japan. Ideally, the guidelines for its prevention should be based on solid evidence, but there are few clinical data on the prevalence and prophylaxis of VTE in Japan. Comprehensive, standard guidelines for the prevention of VTE were recently established by applying the risk-prophylaxis relationship of the sixth American College of Chest Physicians (ACCP) consensus recommendations. Since patients undergoing cancer surgery make up a relatively homogenous, "highest-risk" group, we could precisely evaluate the difference in VTE risk between Japan and the West. The risk of clinical PE in Japanese cancer surgery was found to be one or two risk levels lower than that in the West. Therefore the Japanese risk stratification was set to be one level lower than that in the sixth ACCP guidelines. For prophylaxis, the recommendations of the Japanese guidelines are basically identical to those of the sixth ACCP guidelines. Since the present guidelines are not sufficiently based on Japanese evidence, they should be reviewed in a prospective, nationwide epidemiologic study. In this review article, the theoretical background of and future perspectives on the Japanese guidelines are discussed.

Humans↗

Pharmacologic treatment of migraine. Comparison of guidelines.

OBJECTIVE: To compare guidelines (not the primary studies) for pharmacologic treatment of migraine as to methods of guideline development; recommendations, particularly on triptans; and quality of supporting evidence (with emphasis on comparative studies of triptans versus ergot alkaloids and nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs [NSAIDs]). DATA SOURCES: We searched MEDLINE via PubMed for guidelines on migraine management published since 1990 in any language; in addition, we browsed the Internet for information. STUDY SELECTION: We found nine clinical guidelines on migraine; one guideline, not supported by references, was excluded. SYNTHESIS: Preference for triptans is not well founded and is largely based on comparisons with placebo. Too few studies compared new drugs with established ones (NSAIDs or dihydroergotamine). Guidelines that propose a hierarchy for selection of drugs are opinion-based rather than evidence-based. CONCLUSION: The current lack of evidence from comparative studies seriously limits development of evidence-based clinical practice guidelines for pharmacologic treatment of migraine.

Analgesics, Non-Narcotic↗

[Clinical guidelines: what are the viewpoints of physicians and housestaff working in hospital medical departments?].

BACKGROUND: Factors facilitating use of clinical guidelines by physicians working in French public hospitals are unknown. We wanted to ascertain the desires of physicians and housestaff working in medical departments. METHODS: A cross-sectional survey using a self-administered questionnaire with closed-ended questions and free comment was conducted in the two academic regional hospitals and the 20 district hospitals of Brittany. The following items were noted: individual and professional characteristics, use of and opinion about clinical guidelines, perceived usefulness of specific attributes of guidelines or implementation efforts. The results are shown separately for physicians and housestaff. The statistical significance of associations between physician characteristics and their opinions was tested by using the chi-square test. RESULTS: 390 out of 783 responded (50%). Nine housestaff and eight physicians out of ten responders found more positive than negative points to guidelines (decision making tool, standardization of practices, versus rigidity, lack of freedom in practice). One out of three reported using them regularly. Guidelines focusing on general medicine, covering both diagnosis and treatment, developed at the national level with local adaptation, synthetic and pocket-sized guide-book given directly to the housestaff by the department's physicians, were more likely to be used. One physician out of two would use more guidelines from specialty organizations, or would use them as a self-training tool in practices evaluation. CONCLUSION: Implementation of guidelines in hospital medical departments should take into account the housestaff demands as well as the need for the physicians' implication.

Adult↗

[The practice guideline 'Urinary-tract infections' (second revision) from the Dutch College of General Practitioners; a response from the perspective of general practice].

The Dutch College of General Practitioners recently published an update of the practice guideline on urinary-tract infections. This guideline provides a clear overview of the medical history, the diagnostic methods and the treatment options. Sixteen management modalities are presented in relation to specific patient characteristics. However, this revised guideline warrants some minor comments. According to the guideline, the dipstick (nitrite) test and dipslide form the two cornerstones of the diagnosis of urinary-tract infections. The value of the dipslide, however, seems to have been overestimated and that of microscopic examination of the urine by skilled physicians to have been underestimated. New in this guideline compared to that of 1999 is that nitrofurantoin (the treatment of first choice in uncomplicated infections) should be given for five instead of three days. The guideline motivates this change in policy on the basis of the numerous treatment failures seen in practice. The most convincing type of evidence, however, is not available due to the lack of relevant randomised clinical trials. The introduction of the prescription of phosphomycin, which is unusual in the Netherlands, as an alternative treatment for uncomplicated infections requires supportive evidence before it will be accepted by general practitioners. This well-documented guideline provides clear guidance for the general practitioner faced with patients with urinary-tract symptoms that could be caused by infection.

Anti-Bacterial Agents↗

Computer-interpretable clinical practice guidelines. Where are we and where are we going ?

OBJECTIVES: To provide a comprehensive overview of computer-interpretable guideline (CIG) systems aimed at non-experts. The overview includes the history of efforts to develop CIGs, features of and relationships among current major CIG systems, current status of standards developments pertinent to CIGs and identification of unsolved problems and needs for future research. METHODS: Literature review based on PubMed, AMIA conference proceedings and key references from publications identified. Search terms included practice guidelines, decision support, controlled vocabulary and medical record systems. Papers were reviewed by both authors and summarized narratively. RESULTS: There is a consensus that guideline delivery systems must be integrated with electronic health records (EHRs) to be most effective. Several evolving CIG formalisms have in common, use of a task network model. There is currently no dominant CIG system. The major challenge in development of interoperable CIGs, is agreement on a standard controlled vocabulary. Such standards are under development, but not widely used, particularly in commercial EHR systems. The Virtual Medical Record (VMR) concept has been proposed as a standard that would serve as an intermediary between guideline vocabulary and that used in EHR implementation. CONCLUSION: CIG systems are in a state of evolution. Standards efforts promise to improve interoperability without compromising innovation. The VMR concept can assist guideline development even before clinical systems routinely adhere to standards. Frontiers for future work include using the principles learned by computer implementation of guidelines to improve the guideline development process and evaluation methods that isolate the effects of specific CIG features.

Decision Making, Computer-Assisted↗

Clinical guidelines: their implementation in general practice.

In recent years the development of clinical guidelines has received increasing attention from medical educators and those involved in standard setting, and has been initiated at both central and local levels. This review article outlines the current state of knowledge with regard to clinical guideline implementation in medical practice. It deals with the main aspects of the current guideline debate, such as, clinical freedom and doctor autonomy, the importance of ownership in guideline implementation, the effectiveness of guidelines in changing practice and, in particular, the strategies needed to implement clinical guidelines in general practice. Mechanisms of behavioural change that have been recognized as being important for implementation are also discussed. If implementation strategies are not treated as an integral part of the development process then clinical guidelines may fail to achieve their potential in changing clinical practice.

Family Practice↗

Identifying adults at increased risk of coronary disease. How well do the current cholesterol guidelines work?

OBJECTIVE: To assess the accuracy of lipid screening strategies to identify individuals at increased risk of coronary heart disease mortality. PATIENTS: The 15% random sample of adults recruited into the Lipid Research Clinic Prevalence and Follow-up Studies, which included 3678 men and women aged 35 to 74 years. Total plasma cholesterol levels, lipoprotein fractions, and other coronary risk factors at study entry were compared with subsequent coronary heart disease mortality (mean follow-up, 12.2 years). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The areas under receiver operating characteristic curves for blood lipids, lipid ratios, the screening guidelines proposed by the National National Cholesterol Education Program, those of the Canadian Consensus Conference on Cholesterol, and a coronary risk model that used Framingham data. MAIN RESULTS: The current National Cholesterol Education Program guidelines (area under the curve, 0.74) were significantly (P = .03) more accurate than the old National Cholesterol Education Program guidelines (area, 0.72). The ratio of total plasma cholesterol level to high-density lipoprotein cholesterol level (area, 0.72) was as accurate as current National Cholesterol Education Program guidelines. The coronary risk model (area, 0.85) was superior (P < .003) to all other screening maneuvers. Compared with the current National Cholesterol Education Program guidelines, the risk model demonstrated superior test sensitivity (70% vs 45%) with only slightly reduced specificity (82% vs 86%). CONCLUSION: The ratio of total plasma cholesterol level to high-density lipoprotein cholesterol level is as accurate as current American screening guidelines. Future guidelines should better incorporate high-density lipoprotein cholesterol levels and nonlipid risk factors to target high-risk individuals accurately.

Adult↗

Practice guidelines: what the family physician should know.

Practice guidelines that specify how to treat medical conditions and perform procedures are appearing with greater frequency in the medical literature. Their use by managed care plans, hospitals and government programs is expected to affect the practice of medicine substantially in the coming years. This article reviews the key information that family physicians should have in order to evaluate and use practice guidelines effectively: how they are developed; how they differ from textbooks, review articles and other sources of expert consultation; whether they promote "cookbook medicine"; when to modify one's clinical practice in response to new guidelines, and how to cope with conflicting recommendations. Practice guidelines can improve the quality of care by summarizing current evidence and expert opinion, but they can also reduce the quality of care if the recommendations are poorly supported by scientific evidence and clinical reasoning. Economic and medicolegal concerns can also influence the potential benefits and harms of practice guidelines. Since hundreds of practice guidelines are anticipated to be developed in the coming years, family physicians should become informed consumers of guidelines, avoid accepting them on face value, and ask specific questions to judge their quality.

Family Practice↗

Implementation of guidelines for prevention of deep vein thrombosis in a managed care environment.

Implementation strategies are key factors in determining the overall success of clinical guidelines. They are important for changing physician practices and expected to result in clinical improvement or cost savings. Within an organization, the method of implementation should be a major component of the development of the guideline itself. In a group practice system, clinical guidelines must be clear and provide numeric thresholds or explicit criteria for decision points and subsequent action. Assessing the overall impact of a clinical practice guideline provides excellent feedback in determining whether goals are being met and provides guidance for fine-tuning strategic approaches. With regard to the prevention of deep vein thrombosis (DVT) monitoring, the overall results of a clinical practice guideline would assess guideline compliance, complications of the guideline interventions, as well as the incidence of DVT, pulmonary embolism, hospital readmissions, and mortality.

Humans↗

The Investigators' Brochure: a comparison of the draft international conference on harmonisation guideline with current Food and Drug Administration requirements.

For several years, the United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has participated in a collaborative effort to harmonize the technical procedures for development and regulatory approval of human pharmaceuticals in multiple countries. This harmonization effort is the work of the International Conference on Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Registration of Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH). At this point, ICH focuses on achieving harmonization of technical requirements in three major regions of the world, i.e., the United States, European Union, and Japan. One area for which harmonization is being sought is the format and content of the Investigators' Brochure. On October 27, 1993, the ICH Steering Committee agreed that the ICH draft guideline on the Investigators' Brochure should be made available for public comment. On August 9, 1994, the FDA published the draft guideline for the format and content of the Investigators' Brochure. This draft guideline was prepared by the Efficacy Expert Working Group of the ICH. FDA solicited written comments on this draft guideline until October 11, 1994. Ultimately, FDA intends to adopt the ICH Steering Committee's final guidelines on Investigators' Brochures as part of a larger document on good clinical practices. Therefore, the content of this draft guideline warrants careful attention. In this paper, ICH's proposed information for inclusion in the Investigators' Brochure is reviewed and compared with current regulatory requirements of FDA. The expanded contents of the Investigators' Brochure proposed by ICH, which represent potential new requirements beyond current FDA regulations, are highlighted. The major controversial elements of this draft guideline are summarized.

Drug Approval↗

Current status of practice guidelines in oncology.

A large number of organizations are currently developing practice guidelines in oncology. These include federal agencies; medical societies and groups, including both oncologic and nononcologic specialty societies; and informal and formal groups of oncologists at the national, regional, and local level. Despite this marked increase in guideline activity, the science of guideline development must still be considered embryonic. Several general principles appear to be important for the generation of sound practice guidelines: (1) selection of suitable topics; (2) appropriate composition of the panel; (3) objectivity of the process used to arrive at recommendations; and (4) specific provisions for review and revision. Like the science of guideline development, the science of guideline implementation is still in its infancy. The factors facilitating physician acceptance of guideline recommendations have yet to be identified. Also, systematic evaluation of the effectiveness of different implementation strategies is needed.

Government Agencies↗

The Ontario Cancer Treatment Practice Guidelines Initiative.

The Ontario Cancer Treatment Practice Guidelines Initiative was established in 1993 to develop clinical practice guidelines for cancer treatment in Ontario, Canada. First, an organizational structure, consisting of a coordinating committee, a methods resource group, and disease site groups, was put in place. Central to the development of guidelines are the 10 provincial site groups, which use a methodologic framework, the practice guidelines development cycle, to formulate the guidelines. When a preliminary evidence-based recommendation is developed by a site group, it is sent out to a sample of community practitioners for input and is modified based on their feedback. The final product is the practice guideline. Further research is required to determine optimal dissemination strategies and evaluate the impact of these guidelines.

Evidence-Based Medicine↗

[Implementation of guidelines for clinical practice in a surgical department].

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate implementation of clinical practice guidelines. DESIGN: Prospective evaluation study. SETTING: Department of Surgery. Academic Medical Center. University of Amsterdam, the Netherlands. METHODS: Clinical practice guidelines on patient care were developed by physicians working in the department of surgery. Six months after their introduction a selected, representative group of consecutive patients, admitted during 4 months, was followed by an independent investigator who determined compliance with a large number of guidelines. After this study period all physicians of the department were given oral and written feedback. This was followed by a period of two months during which compliance was determined again. RESULTS: In the first study period 226 patients were included. Compliance with most of the guidelines evaluated was over 70%. Compliance with the guidelines described in this article (antibiotic and thrombosis prophylaxis, use of urinary tract catheters and wound drains, diagnostics and therapy in symptomatic gallstones and distal obstruction icterus) ranged from 49% for the use of urinary tract catheters to 94% for thrombosis prophylaxis. In the second study period 106 patients were studied and no differences in compliance were found, except for the use of urinary tract catheters (from 49% to 73%). CONCLUSION: This study demonstrates that it is possible to introduce clinical practice guidelines in a surgical ward successfully and to reduce variation in patient care. Providing aggregated feedback is not sufficient to improve compliance with guidelines.

Algorithms↗

Practice guidelines in acute pancreatitis.

Guidelines for clinical practice are intended to suggest preferable approaches to particular medical problems as established by interpretation and collation of scientifically valid research, derived from extensive review of published literature. When data are not available that will withstand objective scrutiny, a recommendation may be made based on a consensus of experts. Guidelines are intended to apply to the clinical situation for all physicians without regard to specialty. Guidelines are intended to be flexible, not necessarily indicating the only acceptable approach, and should be distinguished from standards of care that are inflexible and rarely violated. Given the wide range of choices in any health care problem, the physician should select the course best suited to the individual patient and the clinical situation presented. These guidelines are developed under the auspices of the American College of Gastroenterology and its practice parameters committee. These guidelines are also approved by the governing boards of the American Gastroenterological Association, American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy, and American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases. Expert opinion is solicited from the outset for the document. Guidelines are reviewed in depth by the committee, with participation from experienced clinicians and others in related fields. The final recommendations are based on the data available at the time of the production of the document and may be updated with pertinent scientific developments at a later time. The following guidelines are intended for adults and not for pediatric patients.

APACHE↗

[A concept for a clearing procedure for guidelines in Germany].

Guidelines are efficient tools for the maintenance and improvement of the quality of care and contribute to the increase of the efficacy of care. However, the quality of guidelines has not been investigated or improved much in Germany. This is especially true for the formal assessment of guidelines regarding the collection and evaluation of evidence, their feasibility and their effects on health economy. There is an internationally recognized method available to examine and evaluate current and new guidelines with respect to these three categories. This paper proposes a clearing procedure for guidelines in Germany to systematically improve the quality of guidelines and to offer authors as well as users of guidelines valuable informations.

Germany↗

Breast cancer practice guidelines: evaluation and quality improvement.

The utility of practice guidelines in breast cancer management remains unproved. This paper examines the scope and goals of published guidelines and their utility in the process of breast cancer treatment quality improvement. Although existing breast cancer guidelines vary widely in scope and intent, they provide a framework for meaningful quality-of-care evaluation. Among the few comprehensive breast cancer guideline programs are those developed by the Ontario Cancer Treatment Practice Guidelines Initiative, the Revlon/UCLA Breast Center, the Association of Community Cancer Centers (ACCC), the Society of Surgical Oncology (SSO), and the National Comprehensive Cancer Network (NCCN). Ultimately, guidelines will prove useful only if they are utilized as part of a comprehensive program to improve quality, cost-effectiveness, and outcomes. To accomplish this, they must include mechanisms for revision and evaluation. The evaluation of guideline utility in quality improvement, particularly in breast cancer care, is a complex long-term process, which should include input from practitioners, institutions, payors, and government.

Breast Neoplasms↗

[Guidelines in trauma surgery--direction or hindrance?].

The German Society of Trauma Surgery decided in November 1995 to pass a resolution on trauma diagnosis and therapy guidelines. The first eight guidelines, dealing with the Diagnosis Related groups relevant for trauma patients, have now been completed by the scientific committee of the society and is published as a pocket book in July 1997. The content is clearly classified, and each guideline is described shortly. This book does not serve as a substitute for textbooks and surgical manuals. Guidelines have to be open to new innovative trends and should not compel certain diagnostic or therapeutic procedures to be used. Instructions may help to reduce costs and to establish necessary procedures. Legally these guidelines describe the medical standard and, therefore, can not be ignored. They do not replace the medical expert. Guidelines require a high degree of expert knowledge. Therefore, they should only be published and modified by a scientific society. As guidelines may endanger the medical freedom of treatment and development of innovative trends, they need to be carefully defined for a wide range of application.

Cost-Benefit Analysis↗