PubMed HealthSearch

SEARCH · PubMed Health

Results for “genetic correlation”

Explore indexed PubMed citations for clinical trials, systematic reviews and public health research. Read source abstracts and follow each citation to its original PubMed record.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 recordsLinked to original sources

Assessment of Genetic Correlations Between Tobacco or Alcohol Use and Neurodegenerative Diseases Using East Asian Genetic Ancestry Genome-Wide Association Study Results.

Alzheimer's disease (AD) and Parkinson's disease (PD) are the most prevalent late-onset neurodegenerative diseases worldwide. Both are influenced in part by genetic factors and are currently incurable. Tobacco and alcohol, the two most common substances used among the general adult population, are potential AD/PD risk factors and are also heritable. Although important progress has been made, most existing research on the genetics of AD and PD has been carried out in individuals of European genetic ancestry. Investigations in a broad range of groups are crucial to understand disease mechanisms. Given the current availability of ancestry-specific tobacco and alcohol use as well as AD and PD genome-wide association study summary statistics, we performed global and local genetic correlation analyses using East Asian datasets. Genes within the correlated genetic regions were subsequently used to identify potentially enriched biological pathways between substance use and neurodegenerative diseases. We identified a global genetic correlation between smoking cessation and PD, which we confirmed in complementary European genetic ancestry data. Gene set enrichment analyses highlighted potentially shared genetic mechanisms between breast cancer and AD, which warrants further exploration. This work aims to promote further analyses across genetic ancestry groups.

Female

Consistent and idiosyncratic pleiotropy in shaping genetic correlations.

Pleiotropy, the phenomenon where a single mutation influences multiple phenotypic traits, creates genetic correlations that can constrain evolutionary trajectories. Yet genetic correlations differ in their persistence: some remain stable over long evolutionary timescales, whereas others change rapidly across generations or environments. One explanation is that similar values of genetic correlation, rG, can arise from different pleiotropic architectures: broadly aligned effects across many loci, or disproportionate covariance contributions from a few large effect loci. Motivated by the distinction between vertical and horizontal pleiotropy, here, we develop a bivariate marker effect framework for recombinant mapping populations that separates candidate large covariance contributors from the polygenic background correlation, rD. We define rD as the correlation among marker effects after trimming markers with unusually large covariance contributions. rD is a trait-pair summary of how consistently small and moderate effect markers align across the genome; high rD is expected when many perturbations propagate through shared developmental, physiological, causal, or geometric structure. Applying this framework to high-dimensional yeast single-cell morphology, we show that trait pairs with similar rG can differ substantially in rD, and that a small number of candidate outlier regions can strongly influence some marker effect correlations. We then test whether rD predicts the environmental stability of genetic correlations under geldanamycin-mediated Hsp90 perturbation. Trait pairs with stronger rD show smaller absolute changes in rG. These results suggest that genetic correlations supported by a strong polygenic marker effect background are more environmentally stable than correlations shaped primarily by a few large covariance contributors.

Genetic Pleiotropy

Unraveling causal links between chronic rhinosinusitis and peripheral artery diseases: insights from genetic correlations through genome-wide association studies.

OBJECTIVES: Chronic Rhinosinusitis (CRS) shares epidemiological links with Cardiovascular Diseases (CVDs), however, their shared genetic basis remains unclear. We hypothesized that pleiotropic genetic variants underlie CRS-CVDs links via distinct biological pathways. METHODS: Using large-scale GWAS data from European-ancestry individuals, we assessed global and local genetic correlations. We applied Genomic Structural Equation Modeling (Genomic SEM) to dissect shared genetic architecture, performed bidirectional Mendelian Randomization (MR) to infer causality, and conducted cis-eQTL colocalization to identify shared genetic signals. Finally, in vitro endothelial models (HUVECs) validated the functional dynamics of candidate genes under CRS-mimicking inflammatory stress. RESULTS: CRS showed significant genetic correlations with multiple CVDs. Genomic SEM revealed a latent factor structuring shared genetic risk through three pathways: artery diseases, myocardial diseases, and heart failure. Local genetic correlations identified significant local genetic correlations specifically between CRS and Peripheral Atherosclerosis (PAS)/Peripheral Artery Disease (PAD) specifically within the chr6: 31.57&#x2012;33.24 Mb locus. MR demonstrated causal effects of CRS on PAD (OR&#x2009;=&#x2009;1.23, p&#x2009;=&#x2009;0.022) and PAS (OR&#x2009;=&#x2009;1.21, p&#x2009;=&#x2009;0.011), but not vice versa. Genetically predicted HLA-DRB1, APOM, and COL11A2 expression conferred protection, while HLA-DQA2 increased risk. Crucially, in vitro validation corroborated these pathogenic trajectories, inflammatory stress significantly downregulated the protective APOM and upregulated the risk-associated HLA-DQA2 alongside pro-atherogenic VCAM-1, while HLA-DRB1 exhibited a compensatory upregulation (p&#x2009;<&#x2009;0.05). CONCLUSION: CRS shares global genetic liability with CVDs, structured through three primary etiological pathways. Causal effects of CRS on peripheral artery diseases are mediated by immune and lipid-related genes within the chr6 locus, revealing divergent pleiotropic mechanisms. Our integrated genetic and in vitro evidence provides a mechanistic framework wherein chronic mucosal inflammation contributes to systemic endothelial vulnerability, thereby highlighting candidate targets for mechanism-directed therapy.

Humans

Genetic Correlation Between Brain Imaging Phenotypes and Externalizing Behavior: A Large-Scale LDSC Analysis of UK Biobank IDPs.

Externalizing has been associated with differences in brain structure and function; however, it remains unclear whether these associations reflect shared common-variant genetic influences. Cross-trait linkage disequilibrium score regression was used to estimate genome-wide genetic correlations between externalizing genome-wide association study (GWAS) results and 3,935 brain imaging-derived phenotypes from the UK Biobank BIG40 resource. The imaging phenotypes covered structural magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), diffusion MRI, susceptibility-weighted imaging, resting-state functional MRI, and task-based functional MRI. Results were included in the primary analysis when the imaging phenotype had positive single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) heritability, a heritability Z statistic of at least 1.96, a mean GWAS chi-square statistic of at least 1.02, at least 200,000 regression SNPs, and a complete LDSC result without a fatal error. Technical imaging quality-control phenotypes were excluded from biological inference. Individual results were corrected using the Benjamini-Hochberg false discovery rate procedure. Aggregated Cauchy association tests (ACATs) were used to evaluate evidence across all imaging phenotypes and within predefined imaging categories. Statistical power, simultaneous confidence bounds, and alternative quality-control definitions were examined in sensitivity analyses. Of the 3,935 imaging phenotypes, 3,716 produced estimable genetic correlations, 2,980 met the primary LDSC quality-control criteria, and 2,967 were classified as biological imaging phenotypes. No individual phenotype survived false discovery rate correction. The smallest unadjusted P value was 0.0005, and the minimum adjusted q value was 0.486. The distribution of genetic correlations was centered near zero, with a median genetic correlation of 0.0014 and a median absolute genetic correlation of 0.0338. ACAT provided no evidence of an aggregate association across all biological imaging phenotypes (P = 0.302), and no predefined imaging category survived multiple-testing correction. The median minimum detectable genetic correlation at 80% power was 0.216. Bonferroni-adjusted simultaneous confidence intervals were fully contained within the interval [-0.30, 0.30] for 80.0% of phenotypes in the primary analysis and 88.0% under the stringent heritability quality-control definition. Broad and stringent sensitivity analyses produced the same overall conclusions. In this study, no statistically robust evidence of genome-wide genetic correlations between externalizing and individual UK Biobank brain imaging phenotypes was found. Nevertheless, small, localized, mixed-direction, or developmentally specific genetic effects remain possible.

Journal Article

Investigating the causal role of smoking in gout: A triangulation approach combining NHANES data, genetic correlation, and Mendelian randomization.

The relationship between smoking and the development of gout is not well understood. To address this, we adopted a triangulation framework that integrates observational analysis, genetic correlation estimation, and two-sample Mendelian randomization (MR) to examine whether smoking confers a causal risk for gout. We first performed a cross-sectional analysis using information for 13,626 participants from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey between 2013 and 2018. The association of smoking with gout was subsequently assessed through logistic regression models. We next investigated the extent of shared genetic factors between smoking phenotypes and gout. We were able to demonstrate this using the linkage disequilibrium score regression applied to genome-wide association study data of European ancestry. Finally, to verify the causality of our relationship, we carried out a two-sample MR analysis. We selected the inverse-variance weighted (IVW) method and confirmed the consistency of using the IVW method with other statistical methods, including weighted median, weighted mode, and simple mode, as well as MR-Egger regression. We performed sensitivity analyses to investigate the heterogeneity of the hypothesis and stability of the data. Our findings based on National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey data reveal that there is a strong positive association between smoking and the risk of gout (odds ratio [OR]&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.94, 95% confidence interval [CI]&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.48-2.55, P&#x2005;<&#x2005;.001). This association persisted after confounding adjustments (OR&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.41, 95% CI&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.04-1.91, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;.027). In the subgroup analyses, former smokers and current smokers of 10 to 20 cigarettes per day had a substantially increased risk. Post-linkage disequilibrium score regression analysis revealed that the significantly positive genetic correlations of smoking initiation and lifetime smoking index with gout risk were both significantly positive. Additional evidence for causality is presented by MR. Genetic prediction of smoking initiation statistically increases gout risk (IVW OR&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.55, 95% CI&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.26-1.90, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;3.17&#x2005;&#xd7;&#x2005;10-5). A much stronger association is evident for lifetime smoking index (IVW OR&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.99, 95% CI&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.44-2.76, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;3.24&#x2005;&#xd7;&#x2005;10-5). These findings are the same with or without heterogeneity by sensitivity analysis. In light of our integrated analysis, smoking is a causative factor for gout. This suggests that public health interventions like anti-smoking campaigns might reduce gout incidence.

Humans

Multi-ancestral genome-wide association study of chronic pain reveals widespread genetic correlations with mental and physical health traits.

Chronic pain (CP) is common and debilitating, affecting 12-40% of people worldwide. In this study, we conducted a genome-wide association study (GWAS) of CP in the All of Us Research Program across six genetic ancestries (Ntotal = 313 931, Ncase = 64 894, Ncontrol = 249 037). In the cross-ancestral meta-analysis, one locus on chromosome 3 reached genome-wide (GW) significance (&#x3b1; = 5E-08; lead SNP: rs3849410, p = 2.64E-08,). This same lead SNP, rs3849410, also reached GW significance in the European subsample (p = 7.45E-10) and in European females (p = 4.25E-08). Two additional loci, with lead SNPs rs7652179 and rs4760489, reached GW significance (p = 8.57E-09, and 3.07E-08, respectively) in European ancestry. Sex-stratified analyses revealed one locus on chromosome 11 (lead SNP: rs77607049) in males (p = 1.13E-08); in females, two other loci on chromosomes 11 (lead SNP: rs368001205) and 12 were also identified (lead SNP: rs80043169; p = 1.58E-08, 9.14E-09, respectively; p < 2.5E-08). CP was genetically correlated with psychiatric, physical, and immune traits, including anxiety (rg = 0.72, p = 2.00E-46), generalized addiction risk (rg = 0.38, p = 2.08E-17), higher C-reactive protein levels (rg = 0.36, p = 6.38E-22) and greater body mass index (rg = 0.43, p = 8.03E-47). This study represents one of the largest cross-ancestral investigations of the genetics of CP to date and demonstrates shared genetic effects between CP and multiple health conditions. PERSPECTIVE: This article presents multi-ancestral cross-sex and sex-stratified GWAS of chronic pain (CP). One significant cross-ancestral locus and 3 sex-specific loci were identified; a previously published locus for multisite CP met traditional genome-wide significance in the current European ancestry GWAS. This study identifies 4 novel genetic loci associated with CP.

Chronic pain

aPhyloGeo: a Python application for correlating genetic and climatic conditions.

MOTIVATION: Environmental variation and its influence on genetic diversity is a central topic in evolutionary biology and phylogeography. Accurate correlations between genetic and climatic datasets to understand the genetic adaptations of different species to specific environments. It requires integrated and reproducible workflows. RESULTS: We developed aPhyloGeo, an open-source and multiplatform application implemented in Python, for investigating correlations between genetic variation and environmental data within a phylogenetic framework. The workflow integrates multiple analytical steps, including sequence alignment, sliding window phylogenetic inference, and statistical approaches such as the Mantel test and the Procrustean randomization test. These analyses enable the identification of mutation hotspots that exhibit strong associations with environmental variables. In addition, aPhyloGeo supports multicore data processing and provides a fully reproducible pipeline for evaluating localized relationships between genomic variation and climatic distributions. AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION: aPhyloGeo is freely available on GitHub at: https://github.com/tahiri-lab/aPhyloGeo, as both a PyPI package and as Python scripts for Linux, macOS, and Windows.

Software

Refining the link between REM sleep behavior disorder and neurodegeneration: Genetic correlation, Mendelian randomization, and colocalization evidence.

Observational studies have proposed a link between isolated rapid eye movement sleep behavior disorder (iRBD) and several neurodegenerative diseases. We employed genome-wide linkage disequilibrium score regression (LDSC), standard two-sample Mendelian randomization (MR), and colocalization analysis to assess the causal links between iRBD and these neurodegenerative conditions. iRBD demonstrated a positive causal association with Alzheimer disease (odds ratio [OR]&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.02, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.00-1.03, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.10E-02), Parkinson disease (OR&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.10, 95% CI: 1.03-1.16, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;2.96E-03), and multiple sclerosis (OR&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.09, 95% CI: 1.02-1.17, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.61E-02). A strong positive genetic correlation with dementia with Lewy bodies was observed (rg&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.6313, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;.0002), along with a causal association (OR&#x2005;=&#x2005;1.45, 95% CI: 1.03-2.06, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;3.53E-02), further supported by colocalization analysis. No significant causal relationship was identified between iRBD and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (all P&#x2005;>&#x2005;.05). Additionally, reverse Mendelian randomization analyses did not reveal any causal relationships between the neurodegenerative diseases studied and iRBD. Our findings provide robust genetic evidence supporting a causal relationship between iRBD and the risk of multiple neurodegenerative diseases, highlighting the potential for shared pathophysiological mechanisms.

Humans

Estimates of genetic correlations among clinical measures of the eye.

In a quantitative genetic investigation of seven clinical tests, five pairs were significantly correlated: (1) cover test measures and corneal power, (2) corneal power and divergence recovery points, (3) convergence and divergence recovery points, (4) divergence break and recovery points, and (5) convergence break and recovery points. Common genes may account entirely for the gene influence on cover test measure; thus, parents who are above the population mean for corneal power will have offspring with a tendency toward an exodeviation (phoria). The two convergence amplitudes may depend on the same gene differences, whereas the two divergence amplitudes only partly reflect a common function, suggesting that they may be indexing somewhat different underlying physiologic mechanisms.

Accommodation, Ocular

Is there a genetic correlation between tinnitus and temporomandibular joint disorder?: A two-sample Mendelian randomization study.

Tinnitus and temporomandibular disorder (TMD) are frequent coexistence of clinical symptoms caused by some systemic diseases in all humans. The observational research results on the correlation between tinnitus and TMD are inconsistent with the reported findings. The purpose of the study was to explore the bidirectional causal relationship between tinnitus and TMD. This study adopts a two-sample Mendelian randomization (MR) methodology. Single-nucleotide polymorphisms from the genome-wide association study were used as instrumental variables to elucidate the bidirectional causal relationship between tinnitus and TMD. The quality of our study was evaluated in accordance with the STROBE-MR guidelines. The MR analysis results showed that tinnitus (yes, most or all of the time now) could be significantly reduced TMD muscular pain linked with fibromyalgia (OR&#x2005;=&#x2005;0.239, 95% CI: 0.087-0.66, P&#x2005;=&#x2005;.0057), but there was no correlation between other frequencies of tinnitus and the increased risk of TMD in genetic predisposition (all P&#x2005;>&#x2005;.05). The reverse MR analysis revealed no causal relationship and correlation between TMD exposure and increased risk of tinnitus. Sensitivity analysis indicated no horizontal pleiotropy and insignificant heterogeneity. This MR study supports evidence of a correlation between high-frequency tinnitus and reduced risk of TMD muscle pain associated with fibromyalgia. Further research on disease mechanisms are needed to explore the correlation between tinnitus and TMD.

Humans

Interstrain Recombinants of Human Cytomegalovirus Reveal Complex Genetic Correlates and Epistasis Influencing Glycoprotein Display, Virion Infectivity and Spread Characteristics.

Most of the nucleotide diversity in the human cytomegalovirus (HCMV) genome is due to approximately 17 genes with 2-14 alleles each. These allelic genes are interspersed among longer stretches of highly conserved sequences with signatures of extensive recombination that would shuffle the allelic genes into a vast number of allelic haplotypes. Bacterial artificial chromosome clones derived from 3 independent clinical isolates (TB40/e (TB), TR and Merlin (ME)) display dramatic differences in the abundance of entry-mediating glycoproteins gH/gL/gO and gH/gL/UL128-131, virion infectivity and efficiency of cell-free and cell-to-cell modes of spread. Of these, TB and ME are the most phenotypically different and share only 2 of the 17 allelic genes. A set of recombinant HCMV was generated by coinfecting cells with TB and ME and restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analyses demonstrated complex crossover patterns. Most recombinants were either "TB-like" with much more gH/gL/gO than gH/gL/UL128-131, or "ME-like" with much more gH/gL/UL128-131. This correlated with a TB or ME UL128 sequence, consistent with a G/T polymorphism affecting UL128 pre-mRNA splicing. One recombinant had a gH/gL/gO:gH/gL/UL128-131 ratio of 0.8, suggesting genetic determinants beyond UL128. Virion infectivity correlated with TB versus ME-like glycoprotein display, but intragroup variability indicated additional factors and variability in spread efficiency and the contribution of cell-free and cell-to-cell spread modes indicated an influence of characteristics beyond virion infectivity. Results suggest that the relationships among these three phenotypes are not strictly causal and that all three phenotypes are genetically complex and influenced by epistasis among polymorphic loci across the genome.

Journal Article

Population genetics of multigene family with special reference to decrease of genetic correlation with distance between gene members on a chromosome.

A mathematical method is developed which enables us to treat exactly the process of coincidental evolution under mutation, unequal intrachromosomal crossing-over as well as ordinary crossing-over between homologous chromosomes in a finite population of the effective size N. It makes use of finite difference equations involving two quantities denoted by fi and phi i, in which fi is the identity coefficient of two gene members that are i steps apart on the same chromosome and phi i is that of two members i steps apart on two homologous chromosomes. When the number of genes (n) per family is large, the finite difference equations can be approximately by ordinary second-order differential equations which can then be solved analytically. Results obtained by the present method are compared with the corresponding results previously obtained by one of us (T.O.) using conventional diffusion models of gene frequency changes in population genetics. It is shown that the previous results obtained by T.O. regarding second-order statistics are essentially valid, and they give good approximations particularly when N beta is small, where beta is the rate of ordinary interchromosomal crossing-over within the multigene family.

Base Sequence

Dynamics of correlated genetic systems. IV. Multilocus effects of ethanol stress environments.

Four replicate populations of Drosophila melanogaster, two reared on medium supplemented with ethanol and two reared on standard medium, were electrophoretically monitored for 28 generations. During the first 12 generations, allelic, genotypic and gametic frequencies were determined for eight polymorphic enzymes: GOT, alpha-GPDH, MDH, ADH, TO, E6, Ec and ODH. Samples from generation 18 and 28 were electrophoretically typed for ADH and alpha-GPDH. In addition, samples from generation 27 were analyzed for the presence of inversion heterozygotes. The experimental results showed rapid gene-frequency divergence between control and treatment populations at the Adh locus in a direction consistent with the activity hierarchy of Adh genotypes. Gene-frequency divergence between control and treatment populations also occurred at the alpha-Gpdh locus, although the agreement among replicates appeared to have broken down by generation 28. No differential gene-frequency change occurred at any of the six remaining marker loci. Furthermore, values of linkage disequilibria among all linked pairs of genes were initially small and remained small throughout the course of the experiment. Taking these facts into account, it is argued that the gene-frequency response observed at ADH is most probably caused by selection at the Adh locus. The gene frequency response at alpha-Gpdh can also be be accounted for in terms of the effect of ethanol on energy metabolism, although other explanations cannot be excluded.

Alcohol Oxidoreductases

Dynamics of correlated genetic systems. VI. Variation in recombination rates in experimental populations of Drosophila melanogaster.

Recombination fractions among four chromosome 3 enzyme loci were measured over a 20 generation period in experimental populations of Drosophila melanogaster. The experimental populations were initiated with complete pairwise linkage disequilibria among the marker loci, thereby providing an initial structure favorable to selection for recombination modification. The recombination data show no evidence of directional changes in recombination rates among the marker loci, although variation in estimates, both between families within generations and between generations was large. These materials also yielded much lower estimates for recombination fractions for the centromeric region of the third chromosome than previously reported. Taken in total, the experimental results show no evidence for recombination modification, although the results do indicate ample genetic variance for recombination rates.

Animals

Correlated genetic and EcoRI cleavage map of Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage phi105 DNA.

The seven previously identified EcoRI cleavage fragments of phi 105 DNA were ordered with respect to their sites of origin on the phage genome by marker rescue. One fragment, H, did not carry any determinants essential for replication. This fragment was totally missing in a deletion mutant which exhibited a lysogenization-defective phenotype. There is a nonessential region on the phi 105 genome which begins in fragment B, spans fragment H, and ends in fragment F. The size of the nonessential region, as estimated by alterations observed in the fragmentation patterns of deletion mutant DNAs, is approximately 2.7 X 10(6) daltons. Two new EcoRI cleavage fragments with molecular weights of approximately 0.2 X 10(6) were detected by autoradiography of 32P-labeled DNA. These small fragments were not located on the cleavage map.

Bacillus subtilis

Central core disease. A correlated genetic, histochemical, ultramicroscopic, and biochemical study.

Two patients suffering from central core disease are presented. The condition is associated with musculoskeletal abnormalities which have been traced back over five generations. In addition to the typical histochemical findings, electronmicroscopic study has revealed the presence of both structured and non-structured cores in adjacent areas. The calcium uptake by the sarcoplasmic reticulum was reduced to one-third of normal. Phosphorylase activity was normal in the one case and reduced to 63% in the other. Actomyosin Mg2+-activated ATPase activity was decreased, as was the Ca2+-dependent ATPase of the sarcoplasmic reticulum.

Adenosine Triphosphatases

Robust inference and correlates from genetic associations with personality.

Personality traits describe stable differences in how people think, feel and behave, and how they interact with and experience their social and physical environments1,2. Many questions remain unanswered about associations between DNA and personality traits, such as their robustness, their&#xa0;generalizability and the biological and social pathways through which they act. Here we meta-analyse data across 46 cohorts comprising 611,037 to 1.14&#x2009;million participants with European-like and African-like genomes for genome-wide association studies (GWAS) of the Big Five personality traits (extraversion, agreeableness, conscientiousness, neuroticism and openness to experience), and data from up to 50,725 participants for within-family GWAS. We identify 1,260 lead genetic variants associated with personality, including 824 novel variants3. Common genetic variants explain a moderate 4.8-9.3% of the variance in measures of each trait, and 9.3-13.3% among instruments with typical measurement reliability. Genetic associations with personality are highly consistent but not identical across geography, reporter (self versus close other), age group and measurement instrument, and we find minimal spousal assortment for personality in recent history. In contrast to many other social and behavioural traits4,5, within-family GWAS and polygenic index analyses indicate that genetic associations with personality are minimally confounded by the shared family environment. Polygenic prediction, genetic correlation and Mendelian randomization analyses indicate that personality traits have widespread, potentially causal associations with consequential behaviours and life outcomes. Overall, we find that the genetic architecture of personality is robustly generalizable, minimally confounded and widely relevant to human experience.

Journal Article