Ethics committees and social issues: potentials and pitfalls.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to D Callahan.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
There is now a great disparity in the United States between resources going to the young, the nation's poorest age group, and to the elderly, the wealthiest age group, who are absorbing a greater and greater share of resources for health care. The author outlines reasons that these imbalances in the groups' access to resources have developed, and then demonstrates that, in the area of health care reform, an entitlement program for the young is not the answer: society must overcome its unwillingness and put into place a universal health care system. Even with such a system, the health care needs of the elderly will continue to grow and absorb more resources, both because the percentage of elderly is rising and because developments in medical technology continue to create new treatment possibilities and expectations. Should the health care needs of the elderly be allowed to absorb a more and more disproportionate share of the nation's resources compared with the resources used for the young? The author answers "No" and explains why he thinks (1) that medicine should become more oriented toward providing care, preventing premature death, and improving the quality of people's lives for a reasonable span of years (for example, until 80) and less toward saving lives of the very old and incurably ill at great cost; (2) that rationing and priority setting are inevitable because of limited resources; and (3) that the claims of children may on occasion need to be placed before those of the elderly. These changes can be made only if Americans change their health care system and some of their present values about the role of medicine.
Proposals to ration health care in the United States meet a number of objections, symbolic and literal. Nonetheless, an acceptance of the idea of rationing is a necessary first step toward universal health insurance. It must be understood that universal health care requires an acceptance of rationing, and that such an acceptance must precede enactment of a program, if it is to be economically sound and politically feasible. Commentators have argued that reform of the health care system should come before any effort to ration. On the contrary, rationing and reform cannot be separated. The former is the key to the latter, just as rationing is the key to universal health insurance.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The Oregon priority plan represents an innovative method of reforming its Medicaid program. It would replace the present system of limiting the number of people in the program with one that would, after setting priorities, limit treatment benefits. The strength of the plan is that it would provide all the poor with health care coverage; its potential drawback is that it might put expectant mothers and children at a disadvantage and possibility make some forms of needed care inaccessible to other groups as well. Despite the drawbacks and uncertainties of the priority plant, it deserves to be given a chance to prove itself.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The number of older persons in our society is increasing as the number of younger persons decreases. Expenditures on the young are decreasing and those on the elderly are increasing. Questions relating to the decisions that may be made in the process of allocation of resources for these competing groups are examined in detail. The goal of meeting all individual needs may well require setting "reasonable" limits and fashioning a broader societal perspective.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Enormous growth of medical activities and issues in the 1960s and 1970s stimulated birth of the field of contemporary biomedical ethics. Nevertheless, when one examines recent trends within the field in the United States, one is struck with how many significant transformations and developments have occurred since that time. This presentation examines recent developments in five areas--those of patient rights and autonomy, termination of life, manipulation of Nature, health care resource allocation, and decision-making by the general public. The author also notes that although bioethical issues have become politicized as major interest groups and the general public have become increasingly involved, the quest for consensus remains a central one for health care ethics in the United States.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
An indirect immunofluorescence procedure was developed for the measurement of cyclobutyl dithymidine dimers in DNA of individual Syrian hamster embryo cells using a specific monoclonal antibody. A fluorescein-labeled secondary antibody and a fluorochrome which binds to DNA were used to measure the photoproduct and total DNA in the same nucleus. Fluorescence intensity was quantitated with a computer-assisted microfluorometric system which was calibrated with a uranyl oxide impregnated glass slide. Similar dose-response curves, i.e. normalized fluorescence intensity plotted as a function of dose of germicidal irradiation, were obtained with two different cell types. Normalized fluorescence intensity per nucleus was related to thymidine dimer content with a competitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay using DNA isolated from cells given doses of germicidal irradiation identical to those used in the immunofluorescence assay. Thymidine dimer levels produced by 10 J/m2 of germicidal irradiation (approximately 8 x 10(5)/nucleus) and which allow for 15-30% cell survival can readily be detected. The specific monoclonal antibody was labeled with tritium and used in the immunofluorescence assay to relate the number of antibodies bound to the number of thymidine dimers per cell. The data revealed that approximately 45% of the thymidine dimers in cells exposed to 100 J/m2 of germicidal irradiation and essentially all the T mean value of T in cells receiving 20 J/m2, were being detected in the indirect immunofluorescence assay. This technique can provide a sensitive means for measuring various types of DNA damage in individual cells given that the appropriate probes are available. It can be especially useful for monitoring occupationally or environmentally exposed populations where usually only small samples of cells or tissues are available.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.