Ideas for medical education.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Biomedical subjects
Publications and source records attributed to D M Irby.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The authors surveyed a group of distinguished clinical teachers regarding episodes of failure that had subsequently led to improvements in their teaching. Specifically, they examined how these teachers had used reflection on failed approaches as a tool for experiential learning. The respondents believed that failures were as important as successes in learning to be a good teacher. Using qualitative content analysis of the respondents' comments, the authors identified eight common types of failure associated with each of the three phases of teaching: planning, teaching, and reflection. Common failures associated with the planning stage were misjudging learners, lack of preparation, presenting too much content, lack of purpose, and difficulties with audiovisuals. The primary failure associated with actual teaching was inflexibly using a single teaching method. In the reflection phase, respondents said they most often realized that they had made one of two common errors: selecting the wrong teaching strategy or incorrectly implementing a sound strategy. For each identified failure, the respondents made recommendations for improvement. The deliberative process that had guided planning, teaching, and reflecting had helped all of them transform past failures into successes.
Faculty play an important role in the delivery of quality instruction in the ambulatory setting. As medical schools and residency programs move more clinical training to ambulatory care settings, more faculty must be recruited and trained. Medical educators have attempted to prepare faculty to teach in ambulatory care settings by conducting faculty development programs. This study documents the current practices of a sample of 14 peer-nominated medical educators who conduct this type of faculty development program. The authors conducted telephone interviews to learn what these educators taught, how they conducted and evaluated their programs, and the theoretical framework guiding their selection of program content and format. Results show that these faculty development programs were delivered almost exclusively in the workshop format, and that there was remarkable similarity in the topics and strategies used. Evaluation was generally limited to satisfaction ratings. Based on the results of this study, the authors recommend that faculty development programs that now emphasize the teaching encounter itself should give equal emphasis to (1) the importance of pre-instructional planning; (2) teaching faculty how to employ post-instructional techniques such as reflection; and (3) training learners and clinic staff to collaborate with faculty in the learning process.
PURPOSE: To examine the perceptions of faculty role models to learn whether their perceptions of role models' behaviors are congruent with those of their students. METHOD: In 1996 a survey was mailed to 210 student-identified faculty role models at the University of Washington School of Medicine and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Medicine. The nominees were asked to rate to what extent each of 32 student-identified role model characteristics was representative of their behavior. They were then asked to rank order the characteristics they felt were most important to model for students. The role models were also asked to rate how much influence they perceived themselves to have on their students' specialty choices. A final, open-ended question inquired about the single characteristics they modeled to students that most influenced the students' specialty choices. The role models' specialties were grouped as either primary care (PC) or non-primary care (NPC). Data were analyzed with several statistical methods. RESULTS: Of the 210 mailed surveys, a total of 177 were returned, for a response rate of 84%. The role models perceived their behaviors much like their students did; the role models' self-ratings were generally high for all of the student-defined characteristics. Although clinical reasoning was considered the most important characteristic to model for students, the role models also believed that enthusiasm and love for their work were the characteristics that most influenced their students' specialty choices. Few differences were found between the PC and the NPC role models. CONCLUSION: The role models in this study agreed with their students about what is important to model. They did not intentionally try to recruit students to join their specialties but felt that demonstrating enthusiasm and a sincere love for what they did has a strong influence toward this end.
While ambulatory care education typically does not provide much direct instruction, supervision, or feedback, experiential learning occurs. Using experiential learning theory, the authors describe how this process of learning works. the process is characterized by a cycle of having a concrete experience (e.g., an encounter with a patient), reflecting on that experience as it unfolds, formulating conceptualizations and generalizations from the experience, and testing those generalizations and concepts in other situations. With this model in mind, the authors make four recommendations for improving ambulatory care education for both medical students and residents: (1) plan for experiences in carefully selected ambulatory care settings; (2) facilitate reflective observation; (3) encourage conceptual thinking and inquiry; and (4) promote feedback and testing of insights from experiences. The authors discuss the rationale behind each recommendation and offer guidelines for how each might be implemented.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Based on prior research and current public policy needs, this article identifies five areas that should receive priority in future research on faculty development: 1) To conduct research, greater clarity is needed about the components, competencies, and strategies of faculty development. 2) A stronger link needs to be created between assessment and outcomes of faculty development programs. 3) As faculty roles and career paths change, greater understanding of the nature of professional development is needed. Strategies for promoting teaching, research, and leadership skills require further study. 4) Organizational culture and structure require greater description and illumination as contributors to organizational vitality. 5) Information and instructional technology offer new opportunities for faculty development, but research is needed to determine appropriate uses. Since research takes place in a broader context of societal needs and resources, we conclude with public policy recommendations. We strongly recommend that government, foundations, and universities work together to support fundamental research on faculty development.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
A thematic review was conducted of the 1980-1994 research literature on teaching and learning in ambulatory care settings for both undergraduate and graduate medical education. Included in the review were 101 data-based research articles, along with other articles containing helpful recommendations for improving ambulatory education. The studies suggest that education in ambulatory care clinics is characterized by variability, unpredictability, immediacy, and lack of continuity. Learners often see a narrow range of patient problems in a single clinic and experience limited continuity of care. Few cases are discussed with attending physicians and even fewer are examined by them. Case discussions are short in duration, involve little teaching, and provide virtually no feedback. Excellent teachers are described as physician role models, effective supervisors, dynamic teachers, and supportive persons. Rather than block rotations, students and residents prefer longitudinal teaching programs, which offer continuity-of-care experiences with patients and preceptors. Although little can be concluded about learning outcomes, the studies indicate that some medical students and residents have deficient skills in interviewing, physical examination, and management of psychosocial issues. Based on the reviewed studies, the author recommends facilitating learning by increasing continuity-of-patient-care experiences and contact with faculty members, encouraging collaborative and self-directed learning, providing faculty development, and strengthening assessment and feedback procedures. The author also recommends further research to learn about medical specialties other than internal medicine and family medicine, to describe the knowledge and reasoning of both teachers and learners, and to assess the influences of various educational programs on learning and satisfaction.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
PURPOSE: To determine the measurement characteristics of a form used to evaluate teaching in outpatient settings, and to compare ratings received by general internists in outpatient and inpatient settings. METHOD: The physicians evaluated were 29 faculty who taught in both outpatient and inpatient settings affiliated with the Department of Medicine, University of Washington School of Medicine, over a five-year period (from 1985-86 through 1989-90). Residents completed 639 evaluations, using a six-point Likert-type scale (from 1, very poor, to 6, excellent) to rate instructors in eight categories and to provide an overall assessment of each instructor's teaching effectiveness. In addition, each evaluation contained an indication of the resident's perceived degree of involvement with the instructor. Statistical analysis involved two-tailed t-tests, analysis of variance and covariance, intraclass correlation coefficients, and the Spearman Brown prophecy formula. RESULTS: When more than ten raters of teaching in outpatient settings were available, the reliabilities ranged from .58 to .81. The outpatient-setting ratings were significantly lower than the inpatient-setting ratings for seven categories, overall teaching effectiveness (5.01 versus 5.35, p < .05), and perceived degree of involvement of the instructor with the resident. When controlled for perceived degree of involvement, differences remained in only two categories: demonstration of clinical skills, rated higher for outpatient settings, and instructor accessibility, rated lower. CONCLUSION: The evaluation form provides reliable ratings of teaching in outpatient settings when more than ten raters are available. The differences found in the ratings between the inpatient and outpatient settings may be explained by the factor of the resident's perceived degree of involvement with the instructor.
In order to identify the components of knowledge that effective clinical teachers of medicine need, the author carried out a qualitative study of six distinguished clinical teachers in general internal medicine in 1991. Using data from interviews, a structured task, and observations of each ward team, he identified six domains of knowledge essential to teaching excellence in the context of teaching rounds: clinical knowledge of medicine, patients, and the context of practice, as well as educational knowledge of learners, general principles of teaching and case-based teaching scripts. When combined, these domains of knowledge allow attending physicians to engage in clinical instructional reasoning and to target their teaching to the specific needs of their learners. The results of this investigation are discussed in relation to both prior research on teacher knowledge, reasoning, and action and faculty development in medicine.
Teaching in response to case presentations is an essential feature of clinical teaching in medicine. Yet, this form of case-based teaching is often done poorly. Using qualitative methods of interviews, observations, and recordings of teaching rounds, the author describes three different yet exemplary pedagogical strategies for organizing teaching rounds in general internal medicine. These include: (1) case-bedside teaching that involves case discussion in a conference room followed by demonstrations at the bedside, (2) case-lecture teaching that blends quick reviews of cases with more formal presentations on relevant topics, and (3) case-iterative teaching that involves discovery-learning using complex cases. From these three case studies, five general principles of experiential learning in clinical settings are derived: anchoring instruction in cases, actively involving learners, modeling professional thinking and action, providing direction and feedback, and creating a collaborative learning environment. These three approaches to teaching rounds overcome common problems associated with learning in clinical settings.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Over the past decade, the evaluation of teaching has increased in importance in US medical schools. In this review, research on student ratings, teaching portfolios, and peer review of teaching is presented in the context of instructional scholarship. Five principles for designing a comprehensive system to evaluate teaching are discussed, along with the impact of such systems on teaching improvement and academic promotions.
When attending physicians are conducting teaching rounds, they rapidly decide what and how much to teach in response to each case presentation. How do they make these instructional decisions? The author performed a qualitative study of the instructional reasoning and actions of six distinguished clinical teachers in general internal medicine to address this question. Four data sources were used: interviews with teachers and learners, a structured task, transcripts of teaching rounds, and week-long observations of each ward team. The teachers in this study engaged in substantial amounts of planning before rounds and reflected on rounds afterwards. When listening to a case presentation during rounds, they quickly diagnosed the patient's problems and simultaneously diagnosed their learners' levels of understanding. These diagnostic assessments were used to tailor content-specific curriculum scripts for instruction. Throughout the rounds, the teachers also engaged in interactive thinking, decision making, and improvisation. The author's findings allowed him to hypothesize a model of clinical instructional reasoning and action; they contribute new insights into the interplay between reasoning in a discipline and pedagogical reasoning. Instructional reasoning and clinical reasoning were found to be closely linked through the use of scripts. The implications of these and other findings for medical faculty development are discussed.
This study identified characteristics of clinical teachers in ambulatory care settings that influenced ratings of overall teaching effectiveness and examined the impacts of selected variables of the clinic environment on teaching effectiveness ratings. A survey instrument derived from prior research and observations of ambulatory care teaching was sent to 165 senior medical students and 60 medicine residents at the University of Washington School of Medicine in 1988. A total of 122 (74%) of the seniors and 60 (71%) of the residents responded. Results indicate that the most important characteristics of the ambulatory care teachers were that they actively involved the learners, promoted learner autonomy, and demonstrated patient care skills. Environmental variables did not have a substantial influence on these ratings.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.