PubMed Health⌕ Search

Biomedical subjects

D M Irby

Publications and source records attributed to D M Irby.

At least 55 records · Page 3Linked to original sources

The legal context for evaluating and dismissing medical students and residents.

Medical school faculty often cite the fear of litigation as a reason for their reluctance to offer candid evaluations of students' and residents' performances and to dismiss them when necessary. This article is written to reassure faculty that they have nothing to fear from the courts and that they should uphold high academic standards. Three legal issues of concern to faculty are addressed: What does fair and equitable treatment entail? What are the due process requirements for academic dismissals? Are negative performance evaluations libelous and defamatory? Recommendations are made to meet legal requirements and to promote academic excellence.

Clinical Clerkship↗

Factors affecting ratings of clinical teachers by medical students and residents.

Ratings of clinical teachers in a department of medicine by medical students and residents were examined to determine whether the ratings were systematically affected by the teachers' academic rank, the level of the teachers' involvement with the trainees, the educational level of trainees (student versus resident), and the type of clerkship (elective versus required). Using 4,050 ratings of 430 faculty members and residents, the authors found no statistically significant differences among academic ranks, although the faculty members' teaching effectiveness was rated significantly higher than that of residents. Higher ratings of teaching effectiveness were associated with the teachers' greater involvement with the trainees and with teaching in elective versus required clerkships. The residents consistently rated faculty members higher than the students did.

Faculty, Medical↗

Longitudinal analysis of a multisite clerkship.

Monitoring the quality of well-established multisite clerkships can be aided by the use of trend analysis and graphic-oriented presentations. Five years of data on student performance, experience, and perceptions are reported for an obstetrics and gynecology clerkship offered at eight geographically dispersed sites. Of the five measures of student performance, two (final written and oral examinations) showed major changes. Trends also appeared in student participation in deliveries and student ratings of teaching over time. The results of these analyses were communicated to faculty at each site and used to make improvements in the clerkship. The implications and use of these longitudinal evaluation procedures are discussed.

Clinical Clerkship↗

Distorted learning from unusual medical anecdotes.

Doctors are encouraged to look upon each patient as a learning experience ( Wyngaarden , 1979). Case-oriented learning begins in the clinical years of medical school and continues throughout the professional career of the doctor. Clinical cases, or anecdotes, have the potential of producing accurate, relevant and meaningful learning for the clinician even though they are uncontrolled in a scientific sense. However, unusual or atypical cases can also result in erroneous learning which can negatively affect patient care. The purpose of this article is to identify difficulties in this form of subjective learning which can lead to suboptimal doctor practice patterns. Six actual clinical cases are briefly described to illustrate how inaccurate learning distorted subsequent clinical problem-solving by doctors. Suggestions are then made for ameliorating this difficulty.

Anecdotes as Topic↗

Using personality style preferences to enhance teaching in obstetrics and gynecology.

Using personality style preferences as the basis for faculty development workshops, physician educators in several departments of obstetrics and gynecology learned how to use these differences to enhance clinical teaching. Data from five workshops are analyzed to determine the predominant personality styles of 184 department chairmen, faculty, and residents in obstetrics and gynecology. Chairmen had a stronger preference for taking charge than faculty or residents. As a whole, all preferred use of logic and action in pursuit of excellence. These findings are discussed in relation to student ratings of faculty clinical teaching and to faculty development.

Faculty, Medical↗

The use of mental practice in pelvic examination instruction.

The purpose of the research reported in this article was to test the effects of mental practice on clinical skill acquisition. The clinical skill to be acquired was the pelvic examination. Four instructional designs provided learning experiences for 160 second-year medical students at the University of Washington. The usual instructional sequence was the control, and three experimental sequences incorporated mental practice at premotor, postmotor, and combined premotor and postmotor stages of skill acquisition. Mental practice was facilitated by the use by students of audiotapes and headphones. Learner performance measures consisted of the evaluation of student ability to list the examination sequence, evaluations of an actual pelvic examination write-up, including both sequencing and findings, and observation ratings of skill performance. Mental practice produced better performance on the ability to list the examination sequence and the ability to record findings than no mental practice. Methods for providing mental practice created an orderly and efficient learning environment. Students found it helpful.

Clinical Competence↗

Peer review of teaching in medicine.

The design, development, and implementation of procedures for peer review of teaching are described. Peer review is one component of a comprehensive system to evaluate and improve teaching in a school of medicine. Colleague observations and judgments are used to augment student/resident ratings of teaching for purposes of instructional improvement and academic promotions. School policies have standardized evaluation criteria and instrumentation while granting departments flexibility in conducting peer review. Three different departmental peer review committee structures and procedures are reviewed. With the emphasis upon improvement, faculty acceptance of peer review of teaching has been positive. Peer review reports have had a positive impact on academic promotions. The inherent strengths and limitations of peer review of teaching are discussed in relation to the literature and to the medical school environment.

Faculty, Medical↗

Evaluating instruction in medical education.

The component parts and development of a comprehensive system to evaluate and improve teaching in a school of medicine are described by the author in this paper. This system integrates quantitative measures of teaching (student/resident ratings of classroom and clinical teaching), descriptive documentation (faculty teaching load, innovations, and research on teaching), and qualitative judgments (peer review) on the full spectrum of instruction in medicine. Medical school policies have standardized evaluation criteria, instrumentation, and procedures while granting departments flexibility in conducting peer review. The results of two studies indicate that the evaluation system described here has had a positive impact both on the improvement of teaching and on academic promotions.

Education, Medical↗

Evaluation of student performance in a multi-site clinical clerkship.

A method for examining the equivalency of student performance in multi-site clinical clerkships is presented. Six student performance variables within the clerkship are explored: pretest, posttest, oral examination, presentation of a subject review, general clinical performance, and patient write-ups. Student achievement on two external examinations (a University of Washington School of Medicine third-year comprehensive examination and the Part II examination of the National Board of Medical Examiners) is reviewed and compared. This method applied to an obstetrics and gynecology clerkship at the University of Washington reveals no significant differences in student performance among sites on the pretest, oral examination, and both external examinations, but there were differences on four internal measures (posttest, presentations, write-ups, and clinical ratings). The use of this information for clerkship improvement and faculty development is described.

Clinical Competence↗

Impact of family practice residents on obstetrics and gynecology basic clerkship: medical students' perceptions.

Increasing numbers of family practice residents and medical students require training in obstetrics and gynecology. The effect of these residents on medical student learning in a basic obstetrics and gynecology clerkship at the University of Washington was examined. Results of a questionnaire completed by 314 medical students revealed that family practice residents had a positive although highly variable impact on student learning. Individual differences in residents and students seem to account for much of the variability. Suggestions are made for enhancing the learning experience in obstetrics and gynecology for both medical students and family practice residents.

Education, Medical, Undergraduate↗

Clinical teacher effectiveness in medicine.

Characteristics of best and worst clinical teachers in medicine are described by a random sample of medical school faculty, residents, and third- and fourth-year students at the University of Washington. The responses were factor analyzed and examined to determine whether the ratings were systematically influenced by professional role, faculty department, and teaching method. Best clinical teachers are described as being enthusiastic, clear and well organized, and adept at interacting with students and residents. Worst clinical teachers lack these skills and are characterized by negative personal attributes. Using analysis of variance, the investigator found no significant differences in ratings on the three variables examined. Six of the seven hypothesized dimensions of clinical teaching were confirmed by factor analysis. The results are discussed in relation to faculty development and evaluation of clinical teaching.

Evaluation Studies as Topic↗