PubMed Health⌕ Search
Home/Archive/PubMed

PubMed · 10131866

Medical audit: the problem of missing case-notes.

A Yoong·C Hudson·T Chard
View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

This paper reports the results of a case-note audit undertaken to detect the antenatal risk factors found at the initial booking visit, including the subsequent clinical action taken. From a total of 2,139 case-notes of women booked via an obstetric computer system, and delivered between March 1990 and March 1991, 136 (6.4%) were missing. The results showed that these 136 mothers experienced significantly worse delivery outcomes, ie higher incidence of perinatal death; preterm labour; a baby with a low Apgar score and low birth weight. There was also a higher incidence of perinatal death and babies with a low Apgar score for women booked manually compared with those booked via the computer system. These results show that many audit procedures may be the subject of substantial bias due to the problem of missing information. The extended use of a computer-based medical record system should help to resolve this problem, although hybrid information systems can themselves be biased.

Explore related subjects

BiasComputer SystemsDocumentationFemaleHumansLondonMedical AuditMedical RecordsOutcome Assessment, Health CarePregnancyPregnancy ComplicationsPrenatal CareJournal Article

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeXRIS

A Yoong, C Hudson, T Chard. 1993. Medical audit: the problem of missing case-notes.. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10131866/

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related citations

PubMed2026

Assessment of blinding in pharmacotherapy and noninvasive neuromodulation randomized controlled trials for neuropathic pain in adults.

In randomized controlled trials (RCTs), study participants and research personnel are often blinded to minimize biases related to knowing treatment allocation. To determine if blinding was effective, participants may be asked which treatment they believe they received ("treatment guess"). This descriptive review characterized blinding assessment (BA) reporting in pharmacotherapy and neuromodulation neuropathic pain RCTs. Of 288 papers, 36 (12.5%) reported a BA. One paper reported the results of 2 studies, so in total 37 studies with a BA were assessed. Of these, 19 were crossover, 17 parallel, and 1 partial crossover in design. All 37 studies assessed participant blinding, and 10 also assessed investigator blinding. Approximately 27% included an "unsure" answer option for treatment guess, and 38% asked the reason for the guess. There were no clear patterns in BA reporting across time nor based on treatment type. Seventeen trials provided sufficient data to calculate Bang Blinding Index (BI) to determine blinding success. Participants remained blinded (BI = 0 &#xb1; 0.2) in 10/17 placebo and 10/17 treatment arms, 6 placebo and 5 treatment arms had a BI > 0.2 suggesting possible unblinding, whereas 1 placebo and 2 treatment arms had a BI < -0.2 suggesting misinformed guessing. Overall, we found that BAs are done in a minority of published neuropathic pain trials and with variable methodology. Given the importance of minimizing risk of bias because of treatment unblinding, future studies should consider including BAs, and further consensus building is necessary to determine if and how BAs should be conducted and interpreted in analgesic clinical trials.

Bias↗
PubMed2007

A residuals-based transition model for longitudinal analysis with estimation in the presence of missing data.

We propose a transition model for analysing data from complex longitudinal studies. Because missing values are practically unavoidable in large longitudinal studies, we also present a two-stage imputation method for handling general patterns of missing values on both the outcome and the covariates by combining multiple imputation with stochastic regression imputation. Our model is a time-varying auto-regression on the past innovations (residuals), and it can be used in cases where general dynamics must be taken into account, and where the model selection is important. The entire estimation process was carried out using available procedures in statistical packages such as SAS and S-PLUS. To illustrate the viability of the proposed model and the two-stage imputation method, we analyse data collected in an epidemiological study that focused on various factors relating to childhood growth. Finally, we present a simulation study to investigate the behaviour of our two-stage imputation procedure.

Bias↗
PubMed2007

HIV viral dynamic models with dropouts and missing covariates.

In recent years HIV viral dynamic models have received great attention in AIDS studies. Often, subjects in these studies may drop out for various reasons such as drug intolerance or drug resistance, and covariates may also contain missing data. Statistical analyses ignoring informative dropouts and missing covariates may lead to misleading results. We consider appropriate methods for HIV viral dynamic models with informative dropouts and missing covariates and evaluate these methods via simulations. A real data set is analysed, and the results show that the initial viral decay rate, which may reflect the efficacy of the anti-HIV treatment, may be over-estimated if dropout patients are ignored. We also find that the current or immediate previous viral load values may be most predictive for patients' dropout. These results may be important for HIV/AIDS studies.

Bias↗