Effect of coronary bypass surgery on longevity in high and low risk patients. Report from the V.A. Cooperative Coronary Surgery Study.

Abstract

There is considerable uncertainty about the effects of bypass surgery on the longevity of patients with coronary-artery disease and angina. The Cleveland Clinic has reported improved survival after surgical treatment; the Duke University study indicated improvement in a high-risk subgroup only. The Veterans Administration (V.A.) randomised study initially reported improved survival only for patients with significant left main artery (L.M.) disease. Further analysis of the V.A. study shows that survival in the high-risk subgroup was 87% for the surgically treated patients and 74% for those treated medically--a highly significant difference after four years of follow-up. However, exclusion of the L.M. group reduced the difference to a non-significant one of 84% versus 79%. For patients not in the high-risk subgroup, survival at four years (with L.M. excluded) was 93% for those treated surgically and 96% for those treated medically. For all patients the rates were 85% and 86%, respectively. These findings indicate that in the evaluation of the effects of bypass surgery on longevity the characteristics of the coronary-artery disease are critical.